[HN Gopher] The Case for Never Reading the Book Jacket
___________________________________________________________________
The Case for Never Reading the Book Jacket
Author : pseudolus
Score : 15 points
Date : 2023-11-28 21:25 UTC (1 hours ago)
(HTM) web link (thewalrus.ca)
(TXT) w3m dump (thewalrus.ca)
| jjgreen wrote:
| French novels quite often have just the first paragraph of the
| book on the (back) cover, I think that works rather well (and I
| have bought books by unknown authors on the strength of that).
| jowea wrote:
| That might indicate if you like the prose, but that only really
| works if the author makes 100% sure to indicate what's the
| genre and theme of the novel already on the first paragraph?
| jjgreen wrote:
| Just my personal view, but I do think that French writers put
| a lot of effort into the first paragraph (for just that
| reason I guess).
| bwb wrote:
| The article makes the point that I also agree with, most people
| buy books because someone loved it and told them about it with
| passion.
|
| And then a small number of "book people" actively seek out books
| like it is an adventure, and then filter the winners out to
| friends, family, community, and net...
| crthpl wrote:
| The idiom "Don't judge a book by its cover" applies to many
| situations, but books are not one of them.
| maxwell wrote:
| http://www.paulgraham.com/javacover.html#:~:text=book%20by%2...
| lmm wrote:
| Meh. Many of the greatest works open by explaining themselves in
| miniature (to the extent that it's probably a named literary
| technique). If you let your engagement with a work be
| circumscribed by what you're told about it beforehand, that seems
| more like a you problem.
| Wowfunhappy wrote:
| I have had so many books ruined by the summary. They will
| regularly include details about what happens in even the latter
| half of the story.
|
| I never read them anymore. It's harder to find books, but at
| least I don't see literal spoilers.
| climb_stealth wrote:
| Same. It's also quite a different experience reading a book
| without having any idea what it is about. Mostly Sci-Fi and
| Fantasy in my case.
|
| These days I ask my partner to check for other books in a
| series. Even just trying to look up the sequels online can
| spoil quite a lot. This may sound like a hassle but it's
| actually not.
| megmogandog wrote:
| My personal worst experience of this was Philip K. Dick's _Time
| out of Joint_ ; since then I only read the blurbs after I'm
| finished.
| andy99 wrote:
| I'll usually look when I'm buying the book to see if I might like
| it. But then I won't look when I actually pick it up go read it.
| I'm pretty sure summaries on the back are designed to be used
| that way, to help with selection and then be promptly forgotten
| to not interfere with reading.
| NoMoreNicksLeft wrote:
| Maybe it marks me semi-literate, but I've always liked the cover
| art. I know that it's absolutely unconnected to the work itself,
| but it shows an effort on the part of the publisher that lately
| has been sadly lacking, and they're pretty incentivized to hint
| at the nature of the story in a way that matters to me. They are
| seeking readers for that kind of fiction, after all.
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2023-11-28 23:00 UTC)