Subj : FTS-5001
To   : mark lewis
From : Markus Reschke
Date : Sun Dec 09 2018 07:49 pm

Hello Mark!

Dec 09 11:57 2018, mark lewis wrote to Michiel van der Vlist:

 ml> i don't understand what conflicting interpretations of which flag 
 ml> there are...

Let's try some example. ;) Carol's nodelist entry includes:

  INA:shenks.synchro.net,IBN:shenks.dyndns.org

Carol has explained that in Z1's view both FQDNs should be used for binkp. 

Based on the FTSC doc multiple addresses should be listed either as

  INA:shenks.synchro.net,INA:shenks.dyndns.org,IBN

or as

  IBN:shenks.synchro.net,IBN:shenks.dyndns.org

The INA flag is meant to list a common FQDN for all protocols/services. If the 
IBN flag carries an address it should be used for binkp. It prevails any common 
address(es) from the INA flag(s) because it's specific to binkp. But this 
contradicts the method Carol has explained.

A nodelist converter for binkd following FTSC-5001 would extract just 
shenks.dyndns.org since it's the binkp specific address. And based on the 
undocumented way the tool would extract shenks.dyndns.org and 
shenks.synchro.net. Maybe you'll understand the problem now.

ciao,
Markus

--- 
 * Origin: *** theca tabellaria *** (2:240/1661)

.