Subj : Nothing in Outbound Area ?
To   : Peter Knapper
From : Mvan Le
Date : Wed Sep 13 2006 06:07 am

 ML> So how do I send netmail (to my NC) if I haven't 
 ML> got a FidoNet address ?

 PK> If you don't have a Fidonet address then you don't have 
 PK> an NC, because you do not have a Nodelisting. When you 
 PK> wish to apply for a Node number, then your have 2 main 
 PK> methods you can follow -
 PK>   1. Follow the method described in the Fidonet Policy4 
 PK> document (this method ensurs that you HAVE read P4).

The last time I read P4 10 years ago it said send a netmail to the NC with 
name, number, location, software details and wait 2 weeks for further 
instructions.

The last time I did that I used FrontDoor 2.12 which had no problems polling 
other systems using a 0:0/0 origin.

Policy 4, Section 2.2 - "How to Obtain a node number" does not require a valid 
node address to send netmail to the NC for a FidoNet application.

 PK> The entire process is designed to demonstrate that you 
 PK> know HOW to use your Software and follow instructions.

I'm at the stage where I have everything configured, but BinkleyTerm refuses 
to work with an unlisted address and there isn't a configuration option to   
turn this restriction off, which seems counter productive to me.             
                                                                             
 ML> Impersonating an existing address works.

 PK> That is considered extremely bad and could trigger 
 PK> alarms of malicious intent, and preclude the issuing of 
 PK> a Node address. It is not recommended.

0:0/0 or -1/-1 shouldn't / can't be routed as echomail anyway so I don't know
what the fuss is about.                                                      

 ML> When not specifying an "Address" statement in 
 ML> Binkley.cfg the default node is Node: 1:65535/65535. 

 PK> That is a "default" settng that does not allow you to 
 PK> do much other than at least see if Binkley runs. When 
 PK> that no. is used Binkley ignores anything in your 
 PK> Outbound because it knows you should have a valid 
 PK> address.

I might look into BinkD and bypass BinkleyTerm altogether.                 

Nobody uses dialup anymore.
                                  
I just waned BinkleyTerm to show me what's waiting in the outbound area so I
could verify the packing process, and study how BSO worked. I don't really need 
it to send mail. It just looks good. I'll just use BinkD.       

 ML> And if I use an unlisted address BinkleyTerm exits with 
 ML> "System misconfigured or no entry in Nodelist":

 PK> Because you need to work out how to create a Nodelist 
 PK> that is VALID for the purposes you need.

That seems strange to me because that sounds like the NC's job. 

The applicant shouldn't be tampering with the nodelist.

:)

--- Maximus/2 3.01
 * Origin: Top Hat 2 BBS (1:343/41)

.