Just watched this wonderful talk by Dave Chinner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FegjLbCnoBw It answers an important question that I've wondered about for quite some time: Why don't provide all file systems data integrity? They care about metadata, but why not the actual data? He considers this to be the job of the underlying storage. The file system must be able to trust the data it's getting from the hardware. Alternatively, it's the job of the application. This makes sense if you're dealing with expensive, large hardware. Consumer hardware, on the other hand, rarely cares a lot about integrity. The nice thing about ZFS and btrfs is that you get integrity "for free". These file systems always do that, no matter what hardware you use. For me, as a simple consumer, this is important.