I recently watched a video of a talk given by Richard Stallman (rms) a
few days ago. After some time to think about it, I'm not sure how to
feel.
You can get the video to watch for yourself:
(HTM) rms' talk
The talk is rms' usual speech concerning free (as in freedom) software
and the evils of proprietary software. While he makes a lot of good
points, and a lot of what he says makes sense, his zealotry in the
matter makes it difficult to subscribe to, or even accept, his ideals
which, at the very least, can be considered extremist.
At its very core, his message is correct and palatable. Unless
software is free (not necessarily gratis), there's no way for its
users to be in control of their digital workings. We can't know if
something is spying on us or hurting us or our data unless we have
access to the source. We have to, instead, rely on trust, something
which is becoming more and more rare in the digital world in which we
live.
Yet, unfortunately, there's a day-to-day practicality in surrendering
our digital freedom for the sake of convenient software and
services. Even if I can't prove what all the software I use is or is
not doing, I'm able to conveniently get my work and personal business
done. At what cost? It's hard to quantify. However, it is a sacrifice
I have chosen to make. A sacrifice I find myself questioning and
second guessing after hearing talks such as the one in this video.
As I write this on my MacBook running OS X, sitting next to my iPhone
while my iPad charges and my AppleTV awaits my return to "The Clone
Wars" on Netflix, I fully realize and admit my current dependence upon
Apple: their software, their services, their world, their rules, their
sandbox, their jail. I also understand that Apple is not the only
proprietary digital dependence I have. I get it. I understand the
extreme lack of freedom I have. Yet, I also have to admit: I enjoy the
Apple products. They work well. They tend to be intuitive. They rarely
require much maintenance or change. They are practical by means of
being convenient. Yes, I've put my trust in a company that could, at
any time, screw us all over. Some would say they already have, time
and again. This is a sacrifice I've chosen, and (at least for the
moment) is a sacrifice I will continue to make.
However, there will always be a nagging little voice in my head,
whispering things like "GNU"[1] and "FSF"[2]. There will always be a
bit of doubt and a bit of concern about my lack of freedom over the
software I use. While it is unlikely I will ever reach a point where I
use nothing but free (as in freedom) software, there may come a time
when I choose the sacrifices required to be as free as I can over the
sacrifices of proprietary convenience. Today just isn't that day,
though even now the silent mental debate continues in my head.
(HTM) [1] GNU
(HTM) [2] FSF