reveddit.com: improving online discourse with transparent moderation
reddit / freebsd
----------------------------------------------------------------------
grahamperrin · 2022-11-09 00:06
Not related to FreeBSD, but maybe of interest to members of the
FreeBSD subreddit.
I have not yet listened to the video, but I **am** a fan of the
[reveddit](https://www.reveddit.com/) extension for Firefox. A few
minutes ago, the extension alerted me to automated removal of one of
my comments.
Not only for your own content: reveddit is also useful for finding
*other* people's comments that were automatically removed. I'm
reminded of
by
/u/vermaden, and so on.
----
For general discussion of reveddit, please aim for
(the origin of
this cross-post) and
Thanks
----------------------------------------------------------------------
rhaksw · 2022-11-09 03:40
Thank you for sharing it!
I'd be interested to hear why you feel FreeBSD is a good place for the
content. Does it have to do with the ethos or origins of FreeBSD?
The video is worth your time, I promise! See also this discussion on
Hacker News:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33475391
Hopefully there will be more such conversations in the future, either
based on this video or just on the general topic of *shadow*
moderation, which is a distinct concept from moderation itself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
grahamperrin · 2022-11-09 06:48
> … why you feel FreeBSD is a good place for the content. …
A few weeks ago, there was some **group interest in perceived
deletions**, with a mod hat on I found it necessary to post what's
below. At the time, I had forgotten the value of reveddit …
----
September 2019:
* [New comments not showing up (not removed) What is going on? : help]
(https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/davv5u/new_comments_not_showin
g_up_not_removed_what_is/)
October 2019:
* [Are new comments not showing up for anyone else? : help](https://ol
d.reddit.com/r/help/comments/dnyhsp/are_new_comments_not_showing_up_fo
r_anyone_else/)
I have no idea whether the causes nowadays are the same as causes
around three years ago, but recently, again, I found the same type of
issue.
**Essentially**:
* a comment visible on the timeline of the person who made the comment
* the comment **not yet visible** in the context of the post under
which it was submitted.
To anyone else who finds this peculiarity: sorry, I can't explain it.
/r/help offers help with Reddit.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
rhaksw · 2022-11-09 10:16
> * a comment visible on the timeline of the person who made the
comment
> * the comment not yet visible in the context of the post under which
it was submitted.
This might be what I call "[missing comments](https://www.reddit.com/r
/reveddit/comments/gwzbxp/tracking_missing_comments/)"
I track this on Reveddit under [/r/all/missing-
comments](https://www.reveddit.com/v/all/missing-comments/). Here is a
recent example where you can see the child comment on old Reddit, but
not on new Reddit:
* [old Reddit](https://old.reddit.com/r/de/comments/ypdlve/katar_schwu
ler_berichtet_von/ivizing/) (child appears)
* [new
Reddit](https://new.reddit.com/r/de/comments/ypdlve/comment/ivizing/)
(child does not appear)
The behavior [appeared to change](https://www.reddit.com/r/bugs/commen
ts/tyvt4r/update_comments_can_go_missing_from_new_reddit/) at some
point such that only new Reddit isn't showing those comments, although
I can't be certain.
As far as I know, Reddit never acknowledged it as a bug.