For all the people using FreeBSD as their primary desktop. reddit / freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 01:41 I love FreeBSD, really I do. I love its rock solid stability (my Linux installations seem to always have weird quirks from time to time), performance, directory consistency, relatively simple setup, and of course The BSD Handbook. ​ I've dabbled with it off and on for years, but have never really made the complete plunge for my daily driver machine mostly for two reasons, which are either drivers or lack of a certain software that I need (Signal, Slack, Bitwarden, Discord, Chrome (for Netflix, and Spotify), etc.). The Linux compatibility layer helps, but it's often a hit or miss, especially on packages that require systemd and that still doesn't solve the drivers issue. Also, this one has really stumped me. Why is FreeBSD still stuck with the grossly outdated and insecure mount.smbfs instead of mount.cifs like what Linux has, which supports SMB version 2+? How do you guys solve this problem? Am I missing some secret sauce or BSD-fu? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-04-29 01:58 GhostBSD makes it easy to maintain a desktop. For me, the big failings of BSD as a desktop are games (though Linux isn’t the best either) and DRM (though I hear Firefox in a Linux jail can get around this). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 02:10 Exactly, and while I can kinda' live with the lack of games (I just dual boot Windows for it). It's really the lack of software that is otherwise typically available on Linux that isn't available on FreeBSD. Especially for things that only give you an option to install through snapd (Slack), which you guessed it, requires systemd to run correctly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-29 03:38 For your SMB problem, the man page for mount_smbfs directs you to use the ports tree for newer versions, and you’ll find fuse_smbnetfs in there. In general, the Linux community is turning into the new Windows with their rampant change for changes sake and the incompatibilities that come from that and its just not worth chasing. FreeBSD is fairly close to Unix (POSIX) and Linux used to be close but it seems they’ve given up on that now. I now just treat Linux the same way as I used to treat Windows, I run it in a VM. Some applications I try to get working on FreeBSD if they have a source build (I can usually patch it and submit a github issue), but you’ll notice that much of the Linux community has given up trying to support Linux with the rise of Docker and Snapd. If a developer cannot get their product to compile cleanly on a subset of Linux systems and has to distribute essential a packaged VM there’s no hope in getting it to compile anywhere else. I guess the hope for the future would be that once these packaging things stabilise someone might choose to develop a shim layer to get them to work on FreeBSD, but I don’t think we’re there yet. I stick with FreeBSD because it doesn’t change much. I want stability in my computer systems because I want to control them without having to learn a whole new suite of things every 6-12 months. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letstrythisagain12xx · 2022-04-29 03:41 FreeBSD is a professional operating system. If you are looking for game play or Windows or other general user type software, which is what you list, you're looking in the wrong place. That said, I've been using FreeBSD as my daily driver since the late 1990s for both professional programming and regular desktop usage. The only thing I wish worked better was Chrome but that's on Google for not supporting FreeBSD (but there are ways around the Netflix issue). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UnusualRelative8251 · 2022-04-29 03:49 I think using FreeBSD for any Linux destroyed as a desktop is ridiculous. I can understand people wanting to avoid windows, it's terrible operating system and pretty much always has been. But given the stability and overall usability of Apple desktops and laptops why wouldn't you go there? I'm typing this on a seven year old iMac. Still works perfectly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-29 03:57 Actually, now that I think about it, it’s kind of funny that Linux which is supposed the be the bastion of GPL and “it’s only open-source if I can compile it myself” is leading, by design, to a situation where you cannot reliably compile applications anymore Reminds me of dealing with Linux supported embedded systems decades ago which were supposedly GPL but the build toolchain was so full of bugs they were impossible to use. The BSDs and Gentoo/Funtoo are the only operating systems that I’ve been able to reliably compile everything from scratch, but I’ve had Funtoo/Gentoo systems brick themselves during updates if something I compiled was different to what they expected. The BSDs are the only systems that I’ve found to be reliable in this regards. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 05:34 Lol, I can tell you don't use Macbooks for intensive things like Xcode. It's far from the stability level you implied. Even the new M1 Macs had a huge memory bug (early on before they patched it) where it was hogging 20GB/32GB of the system RAM. Also, every once in a while, they'll push a software update that just mysteriously saps your battery life. Apple QA lately hasn't been as stellar. I'd argue my windows machine is actually more reliable. I usually only find problems with Chrome or Firefox using a lot of memory, but that is more really issues with the browsers themselves. Disclaimer note, I only ever build my own systems so YMMV. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 05:37 I'm a software developer, so not sure if that's not professional enough. When I want to game, I boot up my Windows machine. I just want my work machine to also happen to be used for other more leisurely things. And Slack is also basically a requirement as pretty much any recent modern tech company uses it as the primary mode of communication. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 05:42 Oh, thanks for that. I missed that on the man page. I agree with you on Linux turning into the new Windows. I think the original thinking with the container is the whole sandboxing thing seems to be the new "hip" thing to do. The tech world these days seem to be more driven on the current new hot trend like functional everywhere vs OOP, Electron, React everywhere, etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jlnxr · 2022-04-29 09:15 Apple hardware is nice (if often difficult to repair/upgrade) but I'll take Linux, an open platform, over a closed one like Mac OS any day of the week. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jlnxr · 2022-04-29 09:31 The Linux community is far more committed to flatpak than snap, although that has many of the same issues. Personally I agree this change for changes sake is harmful, but it's far from the "new Windows" yet; my Debian stable install doesn't use flatpak or snap at all, all the Linux stuff that doesn't work on FreeBSD works great, and I've never had any stability issues and certainly no broken installs on it (YMMV). It also doesn't change every 6months, which is exactly why I picked it, each stable release is out for like two years or so before there is a new stable. If you dislike systemd (I'm more or less indifferent) there is also Devuan, which is essentially Debian but without systemd. I've got FreeBSD on my backup/spare computer at the moment and I've really been enjoying it, but issues like proper support for NTFS and FAT are major limitations even for basic productivity usage. Forget games. I've used it for work (data work mostly) in that past and it's been great for that. But struggling to format/mount/use FAT SD cards is a pretty big negative for everyday usage, at least for my use case. Obviously it must work for you, so that's great. But it's really not in a "works for any use case" on the desktop yet, whereas Linux is damm near pretty close. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2022-04-29 10:36 The games thing isn’t a BSD failing, it’s a decision on the part of the makers. When there’s a will to develop for the platform it is vastly capable. Just look at Sony’s fork of FreeBSD for the PlayStation - most would agree that it is a more than capable gaming platform. Same goes for widevine drm, if google wants to get it onto BSD then we’ll have it. I’m not holding my breath there… ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 11B_Geek_with_gun · 2022-04-29 10:42 Agreed. When introducing FreeBSD to other, non-techies, one of my first mentions is that OSX, PS 3-5, and the Nintendo Switch have BSD under the hood. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xerxero · 2022-04-29 10:45 Same here OS X is perfect for my needs. Got freebsd on all my servers and have Linux on my old laptop ( freebsd runs but for some reason the intel card runs subpar). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xerxero · 2022-04-29 10:46 That bug is solved like 2 release ago. Other than that the new m1pro work so well ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 12:03 Well, the whole point of the post is about me trying to transition to FreeBSD full-time so using Debian/Devuan kinda defeats that purpose. I don't need the NTFS/FAT support for my use case as I more rely on thr network file sharing protocols over USB storage, hence the SMB question. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jlnxr · 2022-04-29 13:17 I was more countering the "Linux is the new Windows" argument expressed by the user I replied to directly and not your initial post. I hope you find the solutions you're looking for. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 404-does-not-exist · 2022-04-29 14:08 Slack and discord both run fine within the browser. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Daedalus312 · 2022-04-29 14:26 What's wrong here? Linux has a lot of free software with different free licenses. If you can't compile this software for FreeBSD because of dependency problems, then whose problems are these? Figure out how to make these dependencies work on FreeBSD or redo the source code of the software. It's still free software. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crest_ · 2022-04-29 14:33 The FreeBSD SMBv1 in-kernel client is very old and shouldn't be used because SMBv1 shouldn't be used (anymore). There are SMB v2 and v3 clients available in the ports tree including fusefs-smbnetfs, the GNOME VFS mounting daemon should be able to mount all its backends including SMB via FUSE as well (iirc both wrap the Samba client code). While fuse(4) adds noticeable overhead it's still fast enough to saturate 1Gb/s Ethernet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-29 14:35 My reference was to dockerized or snap/flatpack applications that no longer come with build tools so you cannot compile them reliably even on Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-29 14:48 I’ve never had any difficulty using FAT on FreeBSD during my work with embedded systems, but necessarily I was only using it in a basic way so didn’t really push the limits. In truth, so long as the source code stays open Linux will never be the “new Windows”, but I more often find myself being frustrated by the same sorts of issues that bug me about Windows when dealing with Linux now: out of date documentation, unexpected changes in behaviour after updates, random compatibility problems, things only really working if you use the “right” programs the “right” way. To be fair I’m turned off by these issues so I don’t spend much time with Linux anymore. Maybe if I found the right distro and dug a little deeper I’d be able to get past them, but that feels like a young man’s game. I worry that I’d spend the time getting it sorted and things would just change again. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-29 18:39 > … Why is FreeBSD still stuck with the grossly outdated and insecure mount.smbfs … Under : >> smbfs in base: support SMBv2 and SMBv3 … ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-29 19:14 Docker itself is a build tool, with Dockerfile acting as source code. It is very much possible to rebuild dockerized applications. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-29 19:19 This hip trend leads to the fact that you can now update your Ubuntu daily, without being afraid to brick it. The desktop experience is still pretty poor compared to Windows or OS X, but at least it doesn’t require reinstalling the operating system every year or two, like it was ten years ago. I hate Electron and dislike snapd, but at least they allow to run those programs _at all_. Otherwise many people who use Linux desktop at work nowadays, would be tied to Windows. Another way to look at it — mainstream desktop OS should be able to run Microsoft Teams. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-29 19:36 I have the word “professional” in my job title, and no, FreeBSD doesn’t support half of the software which I need for work. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letstrythisagain12xx · 2022-04-29 19:45 FreeBSD supports ALL the software my company and I use so there! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-29 20:57 Well, the title says "desktop" -- can you give an example where FreeBSD desktop is used in some *professional* context? CAD? Accounting? Programming? Medical devices? SCADA? Scientific tools?.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 21:28 Got it. Makes sense. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letstrythisagain12xx · 2022-04-29 21:57 Is Gnome a good example? How about KDE? Any number of cAD tools are available. I program in C, PHP, Python, assembly and so on. Is that good enough? All the others are available, too, including any number of editors. What, do you think FreeBSD was born yesterday? Are you just here to bitch and moan to make yourself feel better or are you trying to accomplish something else? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-29 22:03 While that’s a cute analogy it doesn’t get me any closer to being able to modify the actual program and recompile it. Often dockerized applications set up a VM and install precompiled binary blobs into it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-29 22:47 I agree with you. I don't particularly like Electron because it tends to make the apps rather heavy especially in size and snapd requiring systemd to install sucks but the apps wouldn't be available otherwise (can't see any other way to install Slack and thats a requirement for the last 3 jobs i had). So I'll take what I can get. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-30 06:02 Cross-reference: * [For all the people using FreeBSD as their primary desktop. | The FreeBSD Forums](https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/for-all-the-people- using-freebsd-as-their-primary-desktop.84983/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-30 06:23 > … Another way to look at it — mainstream desktop OS should be able to run Microsoft Teams. 👍 Mozilla bug [1623340 - Microsoft Teams: video not supported in Firefox](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1623340) * priority: P1 * severity: critical * [webcompat:site-wait](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/buglist.cgi?keywo rds=webcompat:site-wait&resolution=---) – and discussion, whilst the bug is in that waiting state: * [(1623340) Firefox compatibility with Microsoft Teams and Teams for friends and family - Firefox Development - Mozilla Discourse](https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/1623340-firefox- compatibility-with-microsoft-teams-and-teams-for-friends-and- family/67381) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-30 07:24 /u/letstrythisagain12xx [wrote](https://old.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comme nts/ueas25/for_all_the_people_using_freebsd_as_their_primary/i6pwf4d/? context=4): >>>>> FreeBSD is a professional operating system. … ---- > …do you think FreeBSD was born yesterday? Are you just here to bitch and moan to make yourself feel better … Such rudeness is **instantly** recognisable: * /u/letstrythisagain12xx sounds remarkably like * /u/reddit_original sounds remarkably like * [drhowarddrfine](https://forums.freebsd.org/members/drhowarddrfine.7 84/) in FreeBSD Forums – all three in the same area of the United States, all three with a bad attitude. It's [OK to create multiple accounts](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/204535759-Is- it-ok-to-create-multiple-accounts-). Rudeness is [less welcome](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en- us/articles/205926439). Some context: * in 2021, I blocked /u/reddit_original for unnecessary rudeness * in 2022, a public drive-by comment from a stranger alerted me to multiple identities, after which the bad attitude from drhowarddrfine became recognisable – and no longer of interest (immediate addition to my ignore list) * 28th April: /u/letstrythisagain12xx begins posting to Reddit * 29th April: rudeness. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 07:29 I’m fine with FreeBSD limitations, and I understand why they are there. It is because there’s not enough developers, and they cannot keep up with the mainstream operating systems anymore. I have huge respect for their underdog effort. At the same time I find it very lame to use “professional” as a justification for the inability to run, ironically, professional mainstream software like CAD (Autodesk, Creo, Solidworks, you name it) or even modern programming IDEs like IntelliJ. Following this logic, ReactOS is also a professional OS, because it runs Vim, a similarly professional IDE. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 07:35 While that’s a cute analogy with VM, those binary blobs are just Linux packages, which you can recompile to your heart’s content, just need to take an extra step to update the Dockerfile to pick your custom version. There’s no proprietary magic or conspiracy in it — the code running in those containers is still open source, and you can modify and recompile anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-30 07:38 My point is that you can’t always recompile those packages because you don’t get the build scripts/tools for them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 07:48 Very interesting read, thanks. Teams is a monster of a product, with all those network protocols and hacks. Cannot imagine how much development effort was put into it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 07:52 It applies to non-dockerized packages to the same extent. Would be easier to look at an example. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-30 07:59 Yes, that’s true, but before the availability of dockerization/snap/flatpack if you distributed your app as a precompiled binary it would likely only work on a single distro, so open source projects didn’t do it. This has always been a problem with closed source Linux applications which would only run on a single distro (usually either RedHat or Ubuntu). For open source developers however it was worth the effort to make the program buildable by toolchain and then have porters collaborate to add your program to each distro. That incentive is dimished/gone now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 08:09 Removing this incentive was the whole intent of that. It allows developers to focus on quality, security, features, performance and backwards compatibility, instead of working around intricacies of individual distros. It ultimately allows to shorten the release cycles to the point where the rolling releases can be considered for production workloads. And you can still rebuild a flatpack or a Docker image. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- parakleta · 2022-04-30 08:28 I hadn’t considered those advantages, and I can see how they’re appealing, but it does come back to the fact that there are nominally open-source projects that may not be compilable. For an old curmudgeon like me it just makes me long for the days when I could download a source tarball and type `make` and either have a working program or at least some errors I could work with to repair it and get it working. Now I basically just don’t bother looking at any programs that install by docker since I figure I’m not going to be able to modify it and so I move on and look for an alternative. I know I’m in the minority in this case, but I am comfortable editing code and absolutely hate being trapped by software that doesn’t work in some weird edge case that I always seem to stumble upon, so I’ll only use things I can hack. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- setwindowtext · 2022-04-30 08:38 We’re in the same boat, I run FreeBSD and Slackware at home. But it’s a different thing — I just don’t need the latest features, top performance and even the highest security. I associate it with some sort of software consumerism, even if it’s free software. However, my opinion doesn’t matter in the working environment, with its infinite struggle to get the latest and greatest — there containers are pretty much a prerequisite already. For work nowadays I have to use either Windows, OS X or Ubuntu, with anything else I just can’t keep up with the business pace. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-04-30 08:56 Haha. You caught me. I'm just trying to solicit the largest audience to get the highest chance of people's ingenuity and their creative solutions. I'm sure there has to be some people out there with similar desire and concerns as me. That being said. Aside from the user you brought up, I find this community in general bit better and less passive aggressive/rude/elitist on the discussions instead of saying things like just don't use them or just being plain rude and unhelpful like the user sko and drhowarddrfine on the FreeBSD forums. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letstrythisagain12xx · 2022-04-30 09:36 Now you prove you are totally clueless and have no understanding of the subject so no point in continuing with you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-30 10:58 > Haha. You caught me. Cross-posts are fine :-) (A cross-reference can help the audiences to not duplicate effort.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lenzo1337 · 2022-04-30 21:40 I mean I run Discord and any other things like that in my web browser. No way I'm trusting discord on my system. Your right about the SMB thing being super annoying. I run my stuff with NFS for my little network and all my machines can access it just fine. But it would be nice not to have too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-05-02 01:06 I'm guessing that could be resolved in a linux jail, but that might be a pain. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-05 08:43 Have you tried helloSystem yet? Supposed to be pretty good I hear. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-05-05 22:28 I considered it, but the lead dev apparently posted some weird stuff online, and so I didn’t really bother. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-06 21:32 Right, but that doesn't mean new ones don't pop up. Like this one for example as recent as 15.4. Battery drain problem, in particular, is a recurring problem every few releases it seems. [https://5gmobilephone.net/ios-15-problems-bug- fixes/](https://5gmobilephone.net/ios-15-problems-bug-fixes/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-07 10:45 I'd just like to thank everyone who participated and gave suggestions. Ironically, this community is a lot more helpful and constructive than the actual official FreeBSD forums who has a very elitist attitude and apparently don't even care that they're going against the very philosophy of the FreeBSD Foundation itself. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-07 23:25 I didn't know jails could be non FreeBSD jail. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-05-08 00:14 Sorta. It’s a Linux user land, and still uses the FreeBSD kernel with Linux compatibility layer. Check out the wiki. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-08 02:32 Are you talking about the ***chroot*** ***debootstrap*** environment with ***Ubuntu*** ***bionic*** userland? I wouldn't exactly call a chroot environment a jail, but I tried that. It's definitely not perfect. Especially for things that have direct dependencies to ***systemd***. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-05-08 03:19 You don’t have to use a jail, but I definitely would. https://wiki.freebsd.org/LinuxJails ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-08 03:57 I just looked at it. It's exactly what I mentioned above. I think the term jail is a misnomer there cause you usually use jexec for jails whereas this one is just a regular chroot. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theSarif · 2022-05-08 05:04 You should look at it again. It references doing it as a jail as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-08 10:18 Oh you're right. I missed that part. Thanks! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-05-28 18:08 > … official FreeBSD forums who has a very elitist attitude … Don't let the (very) few bad actors spoil the experience. For what it's worth, the *ignore* feature can be positively transformative. It's generally a very good place. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-05-28 20:03 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whattteva · 2022-05-28 20:03 I did not know about that feature. Thanks!