Why Do I Keep Coming Back to BSD? reddit / freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Then-Face-6004 · 2022-04-28 14:47 This is a bit long and navel-gazel-y. I wrote up a quick trip through my personal computing history to figure out why I keep returning to the BSDs. TLDR; I've spent a lot of time in Solaris. [https://jrgsystems.com/posts/2022-04-28-why-i-keep-coming-back-to- bsd/](https://jrgsystems.com/posts/2022-04-28-why-i-keep-coming-back- to-bsd/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AJCxZ0 · 2022-04-28 15:35 Interesting read, with more than a couple of me-toos. Thanks for sharing it. As a fellow SunOS and Solaris veteran who mostly uses Linux platforms for work and home, I always have at least one FreeBSD host on my network running a world, custom kernel and ports built from source with options and configurations which I chose. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-28 17:11 > Interesting read, with more than a couple of me-toos. Thanks for sharing it. True, and me too, and thanks, /u/Then-Face-6004 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- QGRr2t · 2022-04-28 17:17 I also enjoyed reading, and can relate. I've used Linux, BSD and macOS in one form or another on desktop for about 20 years now, but this year I moved all but one of my servers over from Linux to FreeBSD or OpenBSD (mostly Free). It was such a relief, as I posted recently, to rediscover Free on server and adapt my configs to run under Free instead of in Docker or on native Linux. I felt like all my recent (~7 year?) Linux headaches just melted away, and I was back to running a 'pure', simple and solid system again. I assume most of that boils down to systemd stuff, if I'm honest, but I haven't really given it much thought. The sheer simplicity and power in knowing that everything I need lives in `/etc` or `/usr/local/etc`, and any changes I need to make to my programs are a $(program).conf away is a huge time saver. No more editing `/etc/systemd/system/unit.file` **and** `/etc/app/app.conf` **and** whatever else. It felt like spinning plates. If Widevine ran nicely on BSD I'd be using it on my desktop more, too, but alas. We can't have everything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-28 19:59 On FreeBSD you can give [this](https://github.com/mrclksr/linux- browser-installer) a try. It gives you a Linux browser with Widevine support. I have used Brave for some udemy courses in the past that required it and it worked well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-28 20:08 I started using OpenBSD on routers around 4.1 and then FreeBSD on my desk around 7 something. Ran it for a long time as a desktop and enjoyed it. I then ended back on Linux for a while probably sometime after FreeBSD 9. No particular reason I just felt the need to play with Linux again I think. When FreeBSD 11 came out I went back to it and I been there again since. I really missed the concept of getting a complete operating system out of the box that is cohesive. Jails rock, bhyve is getting better all the time. I still find myself running Linux in some cases where docker makes sense. Sadly dotnet support in FreeBSD isn't great and at home I use certain programs that require it and I have had to do some Linux containerization to keep using those programs. I'm considering putting FreeBSD back on that box now though and just running a bhyve VM with alpine and docker to get those apps going that way. Not sure if that's really worth the work though. I also have been experimenting with OpenBSD on my desktop on another nvme since the 7.1 release. It now supports my amd gpu (RX 580) and that's been working better than ever as far as OpenBSD on a desktop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UnusualRelative8251 · 2022-04-28 21:58 FreeBSD has been my server platform of choice since 1999. For the same reason I choose Toyota cars and Kubota Tractors, when your reputation relies on providing a reliable service you go for robustness. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- QGRr2t · 2022-04-28 22:08 Handy! Thanks so much for this. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jacksonbenete · 2022-04-28 23:43 Let me ask you something if you don't mind. Why do you think that SunOS and Solaris lost market but BSD keep going? There is something that you miss about those two that you haven't found in other OS? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zachsandberg · 2022-04-29 00:02 Treadle pedal = Systemd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AJCxZ0 · 2022-04-29 00:03 SunOS was a BSD platform which hardware vendor Sun replaced with a SVR4 UNIX platform and called it Solaris, with the base OS being called SunOS 5. Oracle purchased Sun. Folks who pay Oracle can run Solaris on their hardware. Some hobbyists run older versions of Solaris on old Sun hardware, but get no updates. BSD is a family of platforms with a common ancestor which include several free and open source software projects and many closed ones. There have also been commercial BSD platforms. I offer that extremely simplified summary to illustrate that the market for current Solaris use is practically limited to folks who like giving money to Oracle and anyone can use BSD code for anything so there is no way to keep track of them all. I have a TV which runs FreeBSD. Sony Playstations and Apple devices run FreeBSD-derived BSD platforms. ​ There is nothing I miss from the time when I both used and managed Solaris because any unix (i.e. BSD, Linux, [UNIX®](https://www.opengroup.org/unix-systems) or similar platform) platform can be made to do what I want it to do, albeit with varying degrees of difficulty, and I choose platforms which I find best suit my needs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- m0llusk · 2022-04-29 00:42 Hard to describe but to me it seems like the system and the core libraries of BSD all fit well together while Linux is great chaotic mess. Mostly I use Linux, but BSD never fails to impress. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bmyatt99 · 2022-04-29 01:57 I wanted to come back, been using BSD since the late 90s, but .net framework 6 support sucks, and I dislike mono. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NominallyMusing · 2022-04-29 04:21 Given your Solaris background have you tried any of the illumos distros? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-29 18:34 > … I offer that extremely simplified summary to illustrate … Also oversimplified (misleading): > … I have a TV which runs FreeBSD. Sony Playstations and Apple devices run FreeBSD-derived BSD platforms. … ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AJCxZ0 · 2022-04-29 21:13 Yes that is also oversimplified, but if misleading, then I don't know where it leads other than a discovery that there have been and still are lot of BSD platforms on a lot of things. While a less superficial response may have been interesting, I was only trying to answer u/jacksonbenete's question. By way of compensation, I direct anyone interested in unix platform history to Éric Lévénez's legendary [Unix History](https://www.levenez.com/unix/). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- secahtah · 2022-04-29 22:29 I read that post. It’s almost my exact story. The progression and timeframe and everything. I do stuff in containers so I have to use Linux, but I work on a Mac and I do most other things in FreeBSD, and I honestly crave the old UNIX world. I have a Sun Ultra 5 on top of my server cabinet, and it still runs perfectly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-04-29 22:55 Thanks, my concern with misleading (in general) is the leading to questions such as "[is there any way to natively run macos applications on freebsd since macos is just a freebsd fork?](https://o ld.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/u6chcw/is_there_any_way_to_natively_r un_macos/i58azpz/?context=3)" It's fair to say that distros such as GhostBSD are [derived from FreeB SD](https://www.freebsd.org/projects/newbies/#_learning_about_freebsd_ derived_projects). IMHO it's a stretch of the imagination to describe any Apple device (with an Apple-provided OS) as being derivative of FreeBSD. The proper distinctions have been too many times … ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-05-01 10:16 > Sony PlayStations 👍 [Details about Playstation 4 OS development](https://vgleaks.com/some- details-about-playstation-4-os-development/) (2013-06-20) [Sony's PlayStation 4 Is Running Modified FreeBSD 9 - Phoronix](https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=mtm5ndi) (2013-06-23) [Playstation 4 uses FreeBSD 9.0 | FreeBSD Foundation](https://freebsdfoundation.org/blog/playstation-4-uses- freebsd-9-0/) (2013-06-25) > The operating system powering the Playstation 4 is [Orbis OS](http:/ /games.slashdot.org/story/13/06/24/000250/playstation-4-will-be- running-modified-freebsd), which is a Sony spin of FreeBSD 9.0. [Why did Sony choose FreeBSD over Linux to build the PS3/PS4/Vita OS? : PS4](https://old.reddit.com/r/PS4/comments/2pk4dv/why_did_sony_choos e_freebsd_over_linux_to_build/) (2014) [Open Source Software used in PlayStation®4](https://doc.dl.playstation.net/doc/ps4-oss/index.html) (©2019 Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc.) FreeBSD Journal DE July/August 2020: * [FreeBSD Friday](https://issue.freebsdfoundation.org/publication/?m= 33057&i=673890&p=12&ver=html5) | [PDF](https://freebsdfoundation.org/wp- content/uploads/2020/09/FreeBSD-Friday.pdf) * [Building and Running an Open-Source Community—The FreeBSD Project]( https://issue.freebsdfoundation.org/publication/?m=33057&i=673890&p=25 &ver=html5) | [PDF](https://freebsdfoundation.org/wp- content/uploads/2020/09/Building-and-Running.pdf) Sony's representation of licencing information is slightly messy. Under [FreeBSD's fsck/newfs commands](https://doc.dl.playstation.net/d oc/ps4-oss/freebsd_fsck.html): * information for *fsck_ufs* is difficult to untangle, the second chunk might relate to [sbin/fsck_ffs/ea.c](https://github.com/freebsd/freebsd- src/blob/main/sbin/fsck_ffs/ea.c) * *newfs_msdoc* is non-existent, this should probably be *newfs_msdos* e.g. [sbin/newfs_msdos/newfs_msdos.c](https://github.com/freebsd/freebsd- src/blob/main/sbin/newfs_msdos/newfs_msdos.c). (©2019 Sony …) is slightly odd in that it does not mention *The FreeBSD Foundation*, copyright information for which [was added in April 2012](https://github.com/freebsd/freebsd-src/commit/e35497f13b3b6cf343 0f91aaaf3bfedf4eb85a0f#diff- 5482d00c6aa59cb1c33f7850da8ec2c6fb1a1380d2ad7179d247a0666f5e3f9cR4) – around eighteen months before the launch of PS4. It would have been true when FreeBSD 9.0 was released (January 2012), but I wonder: * does Sony **truly** still use decade-old versions of software such as this? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-05-01 10:50 > IMHO it's a stretch of the imagination to describe any Apple device (with an Apple-provided OS) as being derivative of FreeBSD. … Contrary to my humble opinion :-) the second of the two FreeBSD Journal items mentioned at states: >> … Apple’s Darwin, the base operating system in Mac OS X, is directly derived from FreeBSD. … The first of the two is closer to how I view things: >> … Apple originally used components of BSD and that there is a lot of FreeBSD that was or is in those operating systems. … ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FreeBSDfan · 2022-05-01 23:24 I know the PS5 runs FreeBSD 11, which reached EOL only a few months after the PS5 launch. For the PS4, it isn't really easy to suddenly upgrade to FreeBSD 11-13 without possibly breaking games people bought, whereas with the PS5 its a clean state. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- grahamperrin · 2022-05-02 07:18 Thanks! Interesting. > I know the PS5 runs FreeBSD 11, … [Source Code for OSS Used in PS5](https://doc.dl.playstation.net/doc/ps5-oss/index.html) – I guess that FreeBSD is not listed because there's no *requirement* to do so in that context. > there's a lot more than that, which you can only see in the ps5 itself. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tambow44 · 2022-05-10 11:43 Solaris was one of the best (if not the best) UNIX system, imo. Oracle did a real disservice to it.