FreeNAS web interface on FreeBSD reddit / freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 11:20 I've been running FreeBSD as a server since before FreeNAS was an option. But I will admit that the web interface they use looks pretty nice. Is there any way to run that (or something like it) on FreeBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- InternalMulberry · 2020-08-13 11:28 Why not run FreeNAS directly? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 11:30 I've thought about that, but I'd prefer not to change my system much. For one thing, wouldn't I then become dependent on FreeNAS for updates? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- InternalMulberry · 2020-08-13 12:17 Yes, you would. FreeNAS is still on the 11.x releases (but with some stuff backported I read). I run FreeNAS as my home server, but when I upgrade my server I'm going with plain FreeBSD. A gui is nice, but makes it difficult to document what changes you made and automate changes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 12:19 Right. I just think the web UI would be nice for viewing the state of things at a glance, like disk usage, snapshots, etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mrelcee · 2020-08-13 12:59 Have done both. Started my current server on a custom built box, installed FreeBSD 11. Got er all going. Fast forward 18 months, I became enamored with freenas and wanted that webgui. So I installed FN on a usb stick and booted my server on that, imported my Zfs pool to it and moved my FreeBSD apps to a jail under freenas. This was a plex server and file server. It was fun at first and i managed to get it going fairly well. Had some annoyances getting the webui to do some tasks. I made mistakes of trying things the FreeBSD way, when one would be well advised to stay within the lines and do things how freenas wants it done. Thing is you can only really do what freenas developers allow you too when adding features into the webui. And they do take their sweet time adding features. Don’t get me wrong, freenas is quite impressive. It IS FreeBSD underneath, but it isn’t really as flexible as FreeBSD. I ended up yanking my freenas boot stick and rolling back to just FreeBSD after about six months. After having experienced how green the grass was on the other side, I discovered i was happier before. I would use freenas again, but I would do it as a dedicated file server machine with perhaps a lite jail or bhyve vm or two. Not a complex server. It did provide me with motivation to switch to jails for a lot of my server processes. I’m not disparaging freenas one bit. Just discovered i liked the idea of the webui a lot more in theory than in practice. So my bottom line recommendation is get another server and give it a shot. Leave your existing server alone and try it before spending the time on changing the server you have. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- spanctimony · 2020-08-13 14:11 FreeNAS is pretty awful IMO. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 14:13 Any particular reason? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 14:14 Thanks. I think that's a good recommendation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- spanctimony · 2020-08-13 14:20 Primary issue is lack of project stability and scope creep. Years and years ago when it was just a GUI for ZFS and file sharing, it worked pretty well. Then somewhere along the line they decided it needed to be a hypervisor. WTF? And they just kept throwing shit at it, and changing the interface, and changing their minds, and reversing course. The final straw for me was when I was trying to integrate a customer’s FreeNAS box with their AD only to find out FreeNAS had major show stopping bugs in their current production release, with some developer engaging with people on a thread on their forum to keep releasing patches for people to try. It made a simple process take hours culminating with the decision to downgrade the FreeNAS server to a previous major revision just to get it functioning. This is garbage, and I will never suggest FreeNAS or TrueNAS to anybody. People either need a real platform with a real admin, or a synology. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 14:22 Fair enough. Thanks for the details. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- InternalMulberry · 2020-08-13 16:12 Webmin is available on FreeBSD. Haven’t used it though ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 17:24 True, but there's no built-in support for ZFS. The best I could find was an unfinished third-party project that hasn't been updated in years. I'm betting the situation is similar, if not worse, for jails. Also, to be shallow, Webmin isn't nearly as nice as the UI FreeNAS has made. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flaming_m0e · 2020-08-13 20:17 Perhaps when TrueNAS SCALE is finalized it can be used on FreeBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-13 20:37 This is the first I've heard of it, but it looks interesting. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ZarK-eh · 2020-08-13 21:03 ... A freenas gui while at first seems like a good idea, issues can arise (see other posts). ... yet, to run client side apps like kodi would be advantageous tho dangerous. ... Maybe a free/truenas gui plugin or vm when bhyve matures? Or a webgui addon? All while considering the presentation of the console menu for newbs to still use if the video port is the only presentation device. Like, invade the living room by having a box there! Anyway, dreamy dreams of future feature creep... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- WesleysHuman · 2020-08-13 21:20 Try Webmin. It has a decent interface for most common services and is cross platform. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cbunn81 · 2020-08-14 12:59 I'll mention what I put in another comment: There's no built-in support for ZFS. The best I could find was an unfinished third-party project that hasn't been updated in years. I'm betting the situation is similar, if not worse, for jails. Also, to be shallow, Webmin isn't nearly as nice as the UI FreeNAS has made. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- InternalMulberry · 2020-08-15 06:29 To bad. Personally, I'm not fond of the tools for administrating jails or zpools in FreeNAS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- edthesmokebeard · 2020-08-16 12:38 What benefit did the jails provide? Ease of backup? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mrelcee · 2020-08-17 05:38 Backing up, simplification of configurations. More lightweight than VMs. If an app or config change goes haywire it is limited to destroying what is in the jail not the entire system. And with ZFS i can roll back that jail and recover. Have had some apps that had trouble with newer kernel versions so i was able to run an older OS version until that was sorted out. In my case, plex runs in its own jail. I run UniFi controller in its own jail for configuration and control of my ubiquiti WiFi devices, switches and gateway instead of dedicating a whole computer or paying for a UniFi key. Other applications i run are in their own jail. My actual FreeBSD install has a very simple rc.conf because of this. Only thing extra i run is samba, and a couple other, packages.