Recommended micro-ATX motherboard? reddit / freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mcur · 2020-07-29 22:52 I'm looking to do a small system build for FreeBSD, and I want to hear what worked well for you. I'd like to get a micro-ATX motherboard that is pretty compatible with 12.1. Wifi, ethernet, sound, etc., etc. Bonus if it has 4xSATA or more, NVMe slots, some more advanced USB (USB-C, USB-3), or other things I'm not thinking of! Edit: Those bonus things really aren't required at all. If you know of a uATX board that works 100%, I'd love to hear it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DigitalBoffin · 2020-07-30 01:14 Your best bet is to look at the [HCL][hcl] or [Hardware Compatibility List][hcl]. It's found in the Handbook and as part of the release notes for each version of FreeBSD. [12.1-RELEASE Hardware notes][hwnotes] What you need to do is find a board you think you like and compare the components to the HCL. [hcl]: https://www.freebsd.org/doc/en/books/faq/hardware.html [hwnotes]: https://www.freebsd.org/releases/12.1R/hardware.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mcur · 2020-07-30 02:31 I had already done that for a couple of motherboards, which both had basically all of the components supported, but in the end something strange ended up making them hard to use. (One example I found was a broken BIOS that didn't manage C-states correctly, causing the machine to be unusably slow.) I seem to remember way back in the early Linux days that there was basically a list of SKUs that were "known good." You had users that had tested on those boards, and had found everything worked (or everything except XYZ). Even though there wasn't a ton of stuff on the list, and many more things would likely work well, you were at least assured to have a good out-of-the-box experience with the stuff on that list. I was hoping to get something like that here -- I'll really take any board, any CPU, whatever, so long as it works correctly, and fits in my micro-ATX case. I've probably muddied the waters with all those nice-to-haves, but really I don't need them... Just want a board to get me on-board (ha!) with FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DigitalBoffin · 2020-07-30 02:57 You can have a "known good" motherboard and then the mfg. release an update, but broken BIOS. Something like that isn't going to show up on an HCL radar because components aren't continually tested. That would be a user submission and it still wouldn't take it off the HCL. It would include a note re: the BIOS rev level. I've gotten FreeBSD to work on virtually every machine I've tried. Then again, I don't use no-name components. I have it working on VMs, Dell Precision workstations and laptops, Dell Optiplex, HP's, Lenovo and even a white MacBook. Chances are, it will work on your mobo just fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- linuxbuild · 2020-07-30 03:22 Check the list of **tested** BSD-compatible desktops ([https://bsd- hardware.info/?view=computers&type=Desktop](https://bsd- hardware.info/?view=computers&type=Desktop)) and find out what works and what doesn't. For example, Gigabyte B450M S2H works fine: [https://bsd- hardware.info/?probe=6baf39851a](https://bsd- hardware.info/?probe=6baf39851a) In case you can't find the board you want in the list of tested boards, please refer to this article: [https://www.reddit.com/r/freebs d/comments/hrhfe3/how\_it\_fits\_bsd/](https://www.reddit.com/r/freebs d/comments/hrhfe3/how_it_fits_bsd/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avgapon · 2020-07-30 10:52 Pretty much any consumer motherboard. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cvnmjs · 2020-07-30 18:17 Are you planning on using the integrated graphics chip❓ That has been the only pain point for me so far. Some of the AMD CPUS are said not to have an on-die gfx chip. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mcur · 2020-07-30 18:30 If it has one, then yes. But I'm not opposed to putting in a cheap NVIDIA card or something. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cvnmjs · 2020-07-31 00:11 running -current didn't result in a great experience w/ the integrated gfx chip. so i ended up doing just that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flatland_spider · 2020-08-03 18:17 Generally server/workstation level boards work better then consumer boards. Those boards are incredibly picky about RAM though, so stick to DIMMs on the tested/approved list. I've installed FreeBSD on the ASRock X470D4U with a Ryzen 7 2700, and it was fine. The NVMe slots are laid out in a quirky manner, so spending lots of money on highend NVMe drives would be a waste. https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=X470D4U#Spe cifications You might think about getting a home router/gateway which can be repurposed into a Wifi bridge if Wifi is needed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flatland_spider · 2020-08-03 18:22 I like Dell Precisions and the top 2 Optiplex lines. Dell supports alternative OSes fairly well on those. Mainly Linux, but whatever. Depending on the age of the system, the UEFI implementation could be quirky though. The early stuff sometimes needs to be set to legacy BIOS mode to boot. This is more pronounced with FreeBSD then Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flatland_spider · 2020-08-03 18:24 Most AMD CPUs don't have integrated graphics. Only those with a G suffix have an integrated GPU, and those are lower end parts. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flatland_spider · 2020-08-03 18:29 I'd probably look at AMD for a discrete card. They have a FOSS driver unlike Nvidia. https://wiki.freebsd.org/Graphics https://wiki.freebsd.org/Graphics/AMD-GPU-Matrix ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cvnmjs · 2020-08-05 19:41 Interesting that Nvidia take the trouble to release an official driver. Must have some big customer requesting FBSD support❓ I do like the Nvidia control panel tho. Takes me back ten years or so. When I had time to play video games lol ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flatland_spider · 2020-08-06 17:40 > Interesting that Nvidia take the trouble to release an official driver. Must have some big customer requesting FBSD support❓ Yeah, it's an oddity, and I'm not sure why it exists. CUDA isn't supported with the FreeBSD driver, so your guess is as good as mine as to why they do it. If they would release FreeBSD CUDA support, that would change my life.