Why use freeBSD and not a Linux distro? Or over another bsd like openBSD? reddit / freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GafiQ · 2020-07-11 13:49 Why? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Fastidius · 2020-07-11 13:56 Matter of taste? On a whim to try something different? 🤷🏻‍♂️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Max-Normal-88 · 2020-07-11 13:59 Because of SystemD, hierarchy making little sense and finally undocumented stuff, for me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jurrehart · 2020-07-11 14:22 BSD over linux : BSD is a complete OS kernel + userland all managed by the same team this gives a well orchestrated and functioning OS , wheras Linux is actualy just the kernel and each Distro will bundle userland packages to it to have the OS, thus every Linux distro uses it's own packaging & config methods. IMHO Also because "Systemd" eventhough systemd has it's positive ease of use for some things, it has too much scope creep to it and goes against the UNIX mentality of "a program does 1 thing but does it good" ​ FreeBSD over OpenBSD/NetNSD: Depends on what you're looking for/ taste every BSD has it's priorities OpenBSD prioritises security , Freebsd will prioritise speed & features, NetBSD if I remeber correctly aims to support as much platforms as possible. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-07-11 14:31 [Why FreeBSD?](https://www.adminbyaccident.com/freebsd/why-freebsd/) [Why Should You Choose It over Linux?](https://www.fossmint.com/what- is-freebsd-why-should-you-choose-it-over-linux/#:~:text=FreeBSD%20is%2 0much%20easier%20to,is%20the%20case%20with%20Linux). [FreeBSD is an amazing operating system](https://www.unixsheikh.com/articles/freebsd-is-an-amazing- operating-system.html) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-11 14:45 I started using FreeBSD because it has so much better performance on an old PC compared to GNU/Linux. But basically for me it's just a matter of taste. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lumberjackninja · 2020-07-11 15:42 I am a long-time Linux user. I started playing around with FreeBSD at the beginning of this year; it currently runs my home server (NAS + Emby, and eventually a few VMs via Bhyve). I would now say that, at least a server OS goes, I prefer FreeBSD over Linux. * As others have mentioned, FreeBSD is a cohesive, monolithic project. The userland is maintained by the same people as the kernel. This is noticeable in how well integrated everything is. As an example, for a long time I had a mirrored ZFS setup running off of an external USB drive enclosure; this filesystem hosted my jails which contain the various services I have setup. So, before the system can auto-start the jails, it has to wait for the ZFS volume to be mounted, which means it needs to wait for geom to enumerate the USB drives. This was straightforward in FreeBSD; I'd never attempt anything like that in Linux, because I've never been comfortable with udev (and now systemd). I know it's possible in Linux, but in FreeBSD it's an anticipated setup and the documentation made it very straightforward. * Documentation. Thus far, it has been very rare that I've needed anything other than the FreeBSD Handbook to configure the system the way I want. * Jails. I know Linux has containers/cgroups, but jails just seem better; they're explicitly marketed as something that you should definitely use in FreeBSD, whereas in Linux cgroups come across as a "developer feature" that you should never touch directly, and instead rely on Docker to do it for you. * Heritage. FreeBSD tries very hard to maintain the "old" ways of doing things as long as possible (e.g., \`ifconfig\` is still the way to manage your network). On Linux, that's not the case. I guess I'm just an old man now at the ate of 32, but a lot of the stuff I learned about Linux internals when I was younger now no longer applies, even though I thought it worked pretty well. I know there are good arguments for it, but at the end of the day I prefer the FreeBSD way of doing things (usually). * Expanding on the above, the lack of systemd. I actually think the \*idea\* of systemd is decent, I'm just not impressed with the execution. The \`rc\` system in FreeBSD works really well and (so far) has not been the maintenance nightmare that systemd proponents complain about. * Less bloat. Most Linux distros are still pretty trim compared to Windows 10, but running \`top\` under a fresh FreeBSD installation really reminds you of how much bloat modern software has. FreeBSD is extremely tuneable, and jails allow you to compartmentalize "functional sets" so you can enable or disable them without affecting anything else. To be fair, I'll give you a list of things that I think Linux is better at: * Hardware compatibility. I think this is a pretty un-controversial position; Linux has a much larger group of people working on it, and is largely paid for by hardware companies that want to avoid lock-in with Microsoft. FreeBSD seems to lag behind in a lot of hardware areas (e.g., sleep support on laptops; wireless protocol support). * Application support. This isn't really a fault of FreeBSD, but as the less-popular OS, application developers are going to prioritize Linux over FreeBSD. In my experience, it hasn't been too bad; I'm comfortable compiling software myself, and unless you're using something that is very closely coupled to a non-POSIX kernel interface, most things cross-compile just fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-11 16:25 [Jails](https://www.freebsd.org/doc/handbook/jails.html) Linux has LXC/LXD, but they’re not for the faint of heart. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- asveikau · 2020-07-11 16:40 Since you asked, I'll say I really like OpenBSD. FreeBSD is also good. Right now, the best reason I can think of to pick FreeBSD over OpenBSD would be ZFS. OpenBSD has nothing like ZFS. FreeBSD makes a really good disk server for this reason. From what I understand OpenBSD has better power management and wifi performance. So it might be nice on a laptop. In the past it had more up to date intel graphics drivers, but I don't think that's true anymore. In the past, I chose FreeBSD on some machines because `freebsd-update` is simpler than the old way to patch and upgrade OpenBSD. But OpenBSD has gotten *much better* at this in recent years, with `syspatch`, `sysupgrade`, and `pkg_add` getting stable branch packages. It's now pretty easy to keep OpenBSD up to date. I also used to like that FreeBSD could be a VM host, but now OpenBSD has `vmd(8)` for this purpose. I haven't had a chance to play with it yet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dadrought3 · 2020-07-11 16:56 (Not trying to start a flamewar) Playing devils advocate but I think on the desktop Linux is a little better, only because there’s more availability with software and support. Wine/Lutris comes to mind. I like Linux on the desktop but have slowly been moving from Debian to FreeBSD on my servers. I’ve been into FreeBSD since early 2000s. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- overkill · 2020-07-11 17:13 I agree with everything you said. I use FreeBSD on my servers, pfSense as a firewall, and Linux on my laptops. My games machine is, sadly, Windows, but it's only games. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- keybwarrior · 2020-07-11 17:24 Netbsd kinda sucks for new hardware tho ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-11 17:25 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- keybwarrior · 2020-07-11 17:26 I wish i could boot freebsd or openbsd on my new asus laptop...but like with many linux distro i tried, its a blank screen once the install reboot is done. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MrRichBOB · 2020-07-11 17:57 It depends on your mentality. I am gonna guess by your question that you are most kinda move-y-sway-y. You don't, at the end of the day, have to use any one tool for the job. To a large extent, you can do the same things on any \*NIX "distro." Why Linux? 1. For 99% of distros, the License, as they are using mostly GNU utils. The GPL ensures that any changes to their source must be open 2. "Ease of use;" by this, I don't mean consistency; most Linux distros force you to use more modern of software (which means they are easier to get going faster *securely*¹,) and tutorials are a dime a dozen, and it is nothing to find a *sage* to teach you how to find your browser cache in `~/.cache/firefox`. Why not? 1. There is too much choice and you worry you can't do the same thing on all distros 2. You hate that GNU forces all forks of its software to be open, because you want to spy on people. 3. Often GNU software is not as stream-lined as BSD software, or as secure. But, you can install a lot of this software yourself, separately. Under the hood, you may see one program use 8 different config files all in 8 different, unpredictable locations. 4. The Community, with the exception of Gentoo and a lot of the Arch community, is very, very nice, and eager to help you find that clear history button in Firefox, before your parents do a nightly check of your history. 5. Many Linux users that have come about since Windows 10 have brought about their Windows elitism to Linux as well. Therefore, they foolishly slander, mar, and deride other OS's, thus kinda making relations with BSD and Linux a bit hard, as some say. Why BSD? 1. The license; you want a good, strong base that you can add to, but don't have to reveal those changes or write separate programs to interface with the software, adding more overhead and headache, etc. Your incentive to give back any changes is to make it easier to move over to another release of your BSD. 2. Very mature code, and "just works." BSD's use older code than Linux does, it has had more time to develop, thus being more secure. Plus, at least FBSD, they ensure that all programs on a given release just work. They are willing to go through the trouble of putting all those 8 random configs from Linux into one, logical place (`/usr/local/etc`, I believe.) 3. Where Linux is just a Kernel, thus it is good because you can use it anywhere, FreeBSD is a kernel, an init system, and all the tools you need to expand on the system. 4. With OpenBSD, they are VERY security oriented, and many privacy- focused Linux users use their software. Why not? 1. Again, with FBSD for sure, there tends to be elitism for one reason or another... 2. Again, with FBSD, the community is not always the nicest 3. The License. 4. If you are looking for bleeding-edge utils and software... you won't find that here. 5. With FBSD, it is a bit of work to get it set up more securely. I am not good in this area, but there is an article: [https://vez.mrsk.me/freebsd- defaults.html](https://vez.mrsk.me/freebsd-defaults.html) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 18:03 I think any BSD sucks for new hardware.. Linux too. Sure they're faster than BSD (because of the bigger userbase) and sometimes a Linux driver is actually provided by the manufacturer but 99% of the time, new hardware works on Windows. Everything else comes later. And I get it. It's the biggest market. I can't blame them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 18:06 Yup, server on FreeBSD and windows for games and graphics-software. When it comes to gaming, you really only have one option and it's windows. Either that or get a console. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 18:13 Will yes and no. Jails may technically be better. Linux makes much better user of the entire container technology with stuff like docker. It's the lack of stuff like this that keeps users away from BSD, sadly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- overkill · 2020-07-11 18:26 Weirdly though I mainly play Cataclysm: DDA which requires nothing in the graphics department. Dwarf Fortress, while similar in graphics, requires more RAM than Half Life 2 while it works out the social ramifications of losing a sock... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-11 19:16 Docker is a steaming pile of brown stuff. In its relatively short lifetime it has had lots and lots of privilege escalation exploits, container escape exploits and more. It is (probably) great for development purposes, but I wouldn’t touch it in production. The last critical vulnerability was <8 months ago. Btrfs has had a much longer stretch (5 +years) since it’s last serious data eating bug, and people still don’t trust it. Jails have had fewer bugs, though it has had its share of critical vulnerabilities as well. It is by comparison much more mature. LXC/LXD appears to be solid, and supports unprivileged root in containers, which by itself goes a long way in reducing criticality of container escape vulnerabilities. Of course, like jails, LXC requires people to setup a complete environment, which is not the “easy way”. Jails management is a breeze with the mature tools that exists on FreeBSD. Linux will get there eventually if LXC can get enough traction over the docker hype. Personally I run FreeBSD, but I’ve worked enough with Docker to understand it, and form an opinion based on understanding and experience. I’ve considered using Linux with LXC instead, but as I have little to gain and a lot to lose, I really don’t see the point. The main problem with Docker is people trying to “cut out” the middle parts by using prebuilt images. Each layer of a Docker image may contain vulnerabilities, but short of rebuilding the whole thing from scratch there is no easy way of spotting those vulnerabilities. That’s why companies sell expensive products to scan Docker images for vulnerabilities. At work we run OpenShift, which is RHEL, and using only a curated selection of base images, and whenever a vulnerability is discovered, everything is rebuilt. Docker solves nothing (for me) that cannot be accomplished by Jails and Ansible. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-11 20:11 > `ifconfig` is still the way to manage your network Removing ifconfig, netstat and the rest of the standard tools still does my head in. I’ve heard reason why, but the new tools are foreign, and not at all on feature parity with the old ones. Using `lsof` to check for listening sockets is counter intuitive to me, where `netstat -an` just feels natural. Then again, I’m an old fart that has been a sysadm since around 1990. I don’t really give a hoot about the whole systemd debate. Systemd is intuitive enough to not get in my way, but don’t start replacing everyday tools... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 20:25 While I wrote "better use" I should've written "more use". I never used docker but I do hear and read it mentioned in so many places. It is one of the things that makes Linux popular. It at least more popular than BSD. I've used jails and I agree they're pretty easy to setup with one of the many available tools (although I have a slight problem with them all needing an IP address) but somehow docker (with Linux) is so popular that they even made a windows version for it (imagine that).. If I'm correct the popularity of docker is slowly moving towards kubernetes. I know absolutely 0 about kubernetes though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 20:30 You might be able to manage with Wine and whatever that Steam project is then. I prefer the more AAA games. And my graphics suit from Affinity is only for Windows and Mac. And while MacOS originated from the BSD kernel, its software won't run on BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-11 20:38 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rm_-r_star · 2020-07-11 20:42 That's the one real challenge, hardware support. But for everything else it's just so well designed. Specialized software can be a problem too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rm_-r_star · 2020-07-11 20:46 There's a lot of stuff that can run on Steam's fork of WINE which they call Proton. Not sure how well FreeBSD can do with it, haven't tried, but might work pretty much the same. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- waitman · 2020-07-11 20:47 I use FreeBSD and Linux for my laptop/desktop and servers. In my opinion FreeBSD has better documentation. Installed software on a FreeBSD system is kept separate from the operating system where on Linux systems is co-mingled. Software packages are kept up-to-date and the FreeBSD ports system is transparent, accessible and comprehensible. Maybe that's true with Linux distributions but I've not felt it. I'm currently switching out my Debian systems replacing with Alpine Linux. It's only a short matter of time before systemd v 246 is released. Actually, a compelling reason to use FreeBSD, I think. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-11 20:58 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- snogbat · 2020-07-11 21:00 The lack of a real "/usr/local/" separation on Linux just really gets me. I don't know how people that use it full time deal with that. The concept of "base OS" and "additional software" to me feels very sane and correct. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- snogbat · 2020-07-11 21:03 Also the MWL book on Jails is fantastic. I learned so much... I think Docker is a steaming pile, but it's great for people that don't want to have a sysadmin on staff, nor care about doing things "correctly". Startup culture gives Linux life. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rm_-r_star · 2020-07-11 21:08 GNU/Linux never really stayed the course like FreeBSD has. They get directed easily by sometimes contradicting political influences. For a lot of years since its inception GNU/Linux was pretty consistent in conforming to the Unix standard, but for me it went off on a weird tangent with systemd. FreeBSD has always been FreeBSD and always will be FreeBSD. They won't make huge non Unix-like changes to the system just out of the blue. There are some things GNU/Linux can do over FreeBSD, but that's the case with Windows over Linux as well. Pretty much if FreeBSD can do it, the user or admin experience is better than other systems. The main reason I like FreeBSD over the other BSDs is it has the biggest community. That's an advantage for me in terms of support. If I post a question more eyes will see it. Also software gets more attention with more developers working on it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 21:39 Oh don't get me wrong, I love FreeBSD! But it's important to know its limitations. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-11 21:48 Proton, that's what its name was. Oh I'm sure it's pretty good but I'm too lazy to go through all that trouble. I want to install and run. Not having to worry about the game being on a "working games" list, which I'm sure 70% of my games are not. Not having to worry if my controller or my joystick and throttle are supported. But who knows, some day.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-11 22:36 Not having a a sysadm on staff is a recipe for disaster If you’re hosting stuff. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jdrch · 2020-07-11 22:54 https://unixsheikh.com/articles/technical-reasons-to-choose-freebsd- over-linux.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-07-12 01:00 vnet (with allow raw sockets) is a good option for managing jails networking. Each jail gets its own networking stack, you can set up their networks normally, and you avoid the weirdness of sharing localhost. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-07-12 01:02 Yeah, I wouldn't recommend FreeBSD to a normie, non sysadmin type, as a starting point for Unix and terminal, unless they were preparing to straight up deep dive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BitingChaos · 2020-07-12 03:10 I went with FreeBSD over Linux because the FreeBSD version of Samba worked perfectly with NFSv4 ACLs on ZFS. It was the most "Windows-like" file server I had tested, while still having full NFS compatibility for our Linux clients. Samba on FreeBSD worked better with a wider range of clients than trying to go with a Windows server, and it supported ACLs better than trying to go with Linux server. It wasn't working on Linux when I needed to replace our legacy file servers in 2012, and as of 2020 it's still not working in Linux. https://github.com/openzfs/zfs/issues/4966 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2020-07-12 03:56 Well written & I agree 100%. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vvelox · 2020-07-12 04:28 I can answer the why not Linux easily. * We have working software RAID. RAID1 does what one expects it to do. We don't have any half assed partial mirroring etc that require designing tooling around the a broken RAID implementation. * GEOM makes all disk related tasks real smooth. * I don't have to fight the init system like with systemd. * Packages actually get updated(does not fucking happen on many common Linux distros where they do very questionable jobs back porting stuff, so it may be fixed or it may not and their work may have introduced new bugs or security issues that were not there before) * To expand upon the last item, I can actually use rust with out having to rely on rustup. The package version of rust is useless on many common Linux distros. * The system does not turn on security features that you need to turn off because of half assed packaging... apparmor is so fucking broken for many packages it is depressing. * poudriere makes it trivial to maintain my own package repo. * The ports system makes it very easy to write up custom ports for my own stuff for systems I maintain. * I don't have to fight any auto-config stuff for setting up X. * UFS through all iterations have been way more rock solid than any of the ext* FSes. I've never seen it shit it's self and want to move everything to lost+found. * Easy to control CPU throttling on laptops as well as servers when desired. The only draw back I've found is it lags slightly behind Linux in terms of X drivers. That said the gap has been shrinking more and more over the last few years and lately becoming incredibly competitive unless you are looking to use Intel procs aimed at the tablet market. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bro_can_u_even_carve · 2020-07-12 05:30 `lsof` tells you the owning process, though. And there's nothing Linux-only about it... it's available in FreeBSD ports & packages. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-12 05:50 Hmm, I should look into that. Thanks for the advice. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xplosm · 2020-07-12 06:22 >This is noticeable in how well integrated everything is. How does one perceive level of integration? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chesheersmile · 2020-07-12 06:23 As much as I'd like to use OpenBSD instead of FreeBSD, the former still has huge problems with amdgpu driver. X randomly freezes all the time. Looks like it's a longstanding bug (I tested on 6.6 and 6.7). There are many bug reports about this in OpenBSD mailing lists. Devs are aware about this, but for now there's no hints as when it might be fixed. FreeBSD, on the other hand, works just fine with my AMD card. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chesheersmile · 2020-07-12 06:32 I remember that some long time ago I've read in an article for newbie programmers that FreeBSD would be better for them because FreeBSD is actually **harder to install**. Here we are now: people install Arch and Gentoo from command line following 1 hour long videos on YouTube, doing by hand things which should've been handled by script, while FreeBSD takes \~7 minutes to install with full disk encryption. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- snogbat · 2020-07-12 06:34 Just destroy the VM and start over! :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sunjay140 · 2020-07-12 07:02 Is there anything like a rolling release for FreeBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sunjay140 · 2020-07-12 07:10 Are you saying that the article is wrong? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chesheersmile · 2020-07-12 08:03 Well, these days it is certainly wrong. I don't know how hard it was to install FreeBSD 10-15 years ago, but these days default FreeBSD installation is a breeze comparing to some popular Linux distros (no offense, though!). I was amazed how simple and sane it is to get a fully encrypted desktop FreeBSD system in practically no time. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-12 08:15 And what about that production database I just lifted from the VM before it was destroyed ? I mean, it does contain customer information like name, address, credit card information, etc. Enough that when I leak it, there’s going to be a GDPR incident. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-07-12 11:00 netstat is built in to Freebsd since 4.2BSD. lsof is a foreign port, though the author of lsof is a FreeBSD user. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-12 11:59 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-12 12:13 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-07-12 12:15 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- hackersmacker · 2020-07-12 12:52 Meanwhile on Arch, /bin is a symlink to /usr/bin for some unknown reason ---------------------------------------------------------------------- hackersmacker · 2020-07-12 12:53 That's how I see it too. Linux has taken too many rabbit trails while BSD has, more or less, stuck on the same path. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-12 13:01 Most startups I know use “cloud” services (not just VPS), and as such are probably fine without a sysadm. Those that insist on running their own servers (VPS or not) are the ones facing trouble without a sysadm. Previously i have no doubt many got away with it (with a lot of data leaks in the process), but in these GDPR times, where failure to maintain (patch, audit, whatever) your setup is considered “gross negligence”, things get expensive real quick. > There are two tiers of administrative fine for non-compliance with the GDPR: > Up to €10 million, or, in the case of an undertaking, 2% of annual global turnover – whichever is greater; or Up to €20 million, or, in the case of an undertaking, 4% of annual global turnover – whichever is greater. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 13:49 Seems pretty well supported to me, among the cloud host providers. https://console.cloud.google.com/marketplace/details/freebsd- cloud/freebsd-11?pli=1 https://aws.amazon.com/marketplace/pp/FreeBSD-FreeBSD-12/B07L6QV354 https://www.linode.com/docs/tools-reference/custom-kernels- distros/install-freebsd-on-linode/ https://www.vultr.com/servers/freebsd https://www.digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/how-to-get-started- with-freebsd https://www.freebsd.org/commercial/isp.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 13:57 Try disabling secure boot or UEFI. And or both. Not all support one or both of those boot features. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 14:24 No real desktop software? XFCE, CDE, KDE, GNOME, MATE, Cinnamon, etc... are not real desktops? https://www.freebsd.org/doc/handbook/x11-wm.html https://www.2daygeek.com/install-xfce-mate-kde-gnome-cinnamon-desktop- environment-on-freebsd/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- carwash2016 · 2020-07-12 14:29 You cannot count gnome as the last development update was 14th February 2016 so its not the latest and that link is 4 years old - hence my statement no real desktop ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 14:55 Are you mixing up GNOME or GNOME 2 with GNOME 3? Or running an old release of FreeBSD? Also you only consider GNOME to be a real DE? Others are non- existent, doesn’t matter? Video made in 2018 installing GNOME 3.28.2. Which was current then. A 2018 release of GNOME, not a 4 yr old 2016 release. The GNOME team maintains the GNOME pkg for FreeBSD. https://youtu.be/hosgv06V7Kg ---------------------------------------------------------------------- asveikau · 2020-07-12 16:08 Thanks for that. I don't have any hardware that needs amdgpu. I will also say FreeBSD has a propriatary nvidia driver in ports. I am using that on one machine. And I forgot to mention one more FreeBSD plus: running Linux binaries via emulation is still a thing. OpenBSD removed that some time back, so you would need a VM to do something like that if you need to. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lumberjackninja · 2020-07-12 16:14 Like in the example I gave, where the \`rc\` mechanism has options for waiting on ZFS mounts before starting certain jails. Or, again with jails, the ability to specify an \`fstab\` for each one so that you can specify \`nullfs\` mounts that need to be created/destroyed on jail start/stop. Things like that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 8fingerlouie · 2020-07-12 16:17 Not to mention the Unix philosophy of doing one thing well is being tossed out the door with all these new “improved” tools. Where netstat was a simple tool, it’s being replaced by iproute2, which more or less looks like the systemd of network tools. Not saying change is bad, but change for the sake of change is not what anybody wants. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- carwash2016 · 2020-07-12 17:23 According to there web site GNOME, MATE, and Cinnamon for FreeBSD are currently fully supported on 11.1, 11-STABLE, and 10.4, while support for 12.0-CURRENT is provided on a best effort basis. So the word is best effort so not fully supported ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 17:36 Where are you getting this info? Sources? You’ve yet to prove your point and I’ve shown multiple of you’re statements aren’t correct with citation to sources of information that negate what you’re trying to say. Is this your opinion? 12-RELEASE and 12-CURRENT use the same pkg repo. What I described in my last comment was 12-RELEASE. Which would also apply to 12-CURRENT. So 12 any branch of FreeBSD runs newer version of GNOME than a 2014 (6 yr old) version. Also if the pkg repo and ports aren’t to your liking, you can always grab the source code from the developer and compile yourself. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- carwash2016 · 2020-07-12 17:37 From the freebsd website https://www.freebsd.org/gnome/ I’m just reading what the freebsd site is saying about how they do or don’t on this case support gnome ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smileymattj · 2020-07-12 18:06 GNOME runs and runs well on FreeBSD. That statement means there is no expectation that they will fix all bugs reported. They’re not leaving it broken. Chances of it not working for you or running into a bug is very slim. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bro_can_u_even_carve · 2020-07-12 19:44 To be frank, showing me open sockets without the PID that owns them is doing one thing not-well-at-all. `lsof` isn't a new tool, either. It's been around for over 20 years. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- snogbat · 2020-07-12 21:20 EMBRACE CHAOS! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- snogbat · 2020-07-12 21:21 I mean, I'm not arguing FOR this style of "administration" mind you, but it certainly exists out there and has been made worse by The Cloud and stuff like Docker and of course by developers who think they are sysadmins. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- hackersmacker · 2020-07-12 21:46 Sounds good to me ---------------------------------------------------------------------- moon-chilled · 2020-07-15 00:12 Freebsd with the 'latest' package repository is more-or-less rolling release. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jclocks · 2020-07-20 02:00 I just made the switch myself! So far, several reasons: A very solid core system I know is going to work that is centrally managed by the FreeBSD team for good compatability. Ease of managing packages and ports. Better relationship with ZFS. Free and not copyleft. Probably my biggest reason, something new to learn and play with, as I'm a professional Linux user. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- throwaway997918 · 2020-07-28 22:14 Consumer hardware that is... The server manufacturers cannot sell their wares to hosting centers, telcos and cloud providers, which are now their biggest market, without functioning and stable drivers in the Linux kernel (and maybe even *BSD). Embedded/USB hardware must be compatible with the Linux/Android ecosystem already and nobody cares about Windows on ARM. I wouldn't be the least surprised if the server hardware manufacturers are going to put driver development for Windows as their 2nd or 3rd priority in the coming years. Half the world's Windows servers are going to be running on a Xen or VMWare hypervisor in the future and Azure is already stuffed with Linux VMs. I just hope FreeBSD will manage to keep up and keep a presence, as I personally find FreeBSD far superior to Linux in so many ways. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- throwaway997918 · 2020-07-28 22:22 Aren't you supposed to use the ip-command solely in Linux-land by now? I mean netstat and ifconfig are not even present in the base system of distributions such as Ubuntu and CentOS anymore. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xzenor · 2020-07-29 07:17 > I just hope FreeBSD will manage to keep up and keep a presence, as I personally find FreeBSD far superior to Linux in so many ways. I agree. Especially for a server.