Best BBS for files? reddit / bbs ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-25 20:40 Hi all! Used to run a WWIV board back in the early 1990s, and its claim to fame was files. I had a *lot* of files. I’ve been thinking about reviving this idea to share things among a community of friends, but I’d like to know which BBS you think has the best file management system? Something that’s make it easy-ish to on-board hundreds, if not thousands, of files. Thank you! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- opicron · 2021-04-25 21:33 I wrote my own file inplementation for Mystic BBS. The default file browsing is really subpar imho. Forze.opicron.eu:23 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-25 21:46 I kinda thought about doing something like that. But I’m just good enough at writing code that my first thought is always “Has anyone smarter than me done this already?” ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NuSkooler · 2021-04-25 22:37 Check out ENiGMA 1/2 - the default file base is designed to handle large file bases. Easy filtering, full text search, exporting, and web based batched downloads to name a few. You can check out an example setup on Xibalba @ xibalba.l33t.codes 44510 or 44511 ssh. There are a LOT of files :D ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-25 22:41 I will do that! ENiGMA was on my shortlist for “Well this looks promising,” so I’ll give it a go! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dmine45 · 2021-04-26 08:43 I always thought Synchronet did a good job of file management? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-26 11:46 I can look at Synchronet too! I've got a Pi to try ENiGMA 1/2, and I can throw Windows onto a VM. (I know that you can run Synchronet on Linux and such, but it seems geared more towards Windows.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- opicron · 2021-04-26 16:17 I got my inspiration from Xqtr sysop and his bbs, cant recall the name atm. I did not release it yet, if you want I will put it online. It is 100% configurable with an seperate config file. Its all python so you can adjust it where you want if it is missing something. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-27 12:29 That'd be fantastic, not just for me, but for anyone else looking for something like this! I started fiddling with Mystic a while ago because it's got a similar look and feel to WWIV. But I was quickly reminded of how time-consuming it is to get files into the system, especially with decent descriptions. I know just enough Python to be dangerous, so this wouldn't be a bad thing to see, just so I can learn something! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-28 20:30 Curious what you think is subpar about it so I can consider changes? I've frequently had people praise Mystic over its file bases over the course of Mystic's history so this is surprising to me. It visually configurable, mouse active file list which you can freely scroll around in, supports long file names on all platforms, built in protocols, a second-to-none archive viewer that allows you to scroll around in archives and view files from within it, access to download files you've queued by FTP or HTTP, real-time file list downloads, file echo with automatic creation of areas and file hatching, slow media support, the index reader to scroll through areas and see file stats at glance, boolean file searches, ANSI .DIZ support, text file DIZ support, SAUCE support, etc. Its got various import functions for PCBoard, FILES.BBS, the list kind of goes on lol! What did I miss?! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-28 20:32 What challenges did you have? All you should have to do is copy the files into their directories and Mystic will mass upload them and import any descriptions they have for you. Now actually creating all of the file bases can be a task though but its hard for Mystic to automate that because it doesn't know how you want to categorize your files. But it will even do that for you for networked file bases. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-28 20:38 There is a MPL mod done by Gyphon for a file list that might be what xqrt based his off of not really sure. But that code is out there somewhere. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-28 21:20 I dug around in the Mystic documentation, but I couldn't find how to do that! Totally possible I missed it, but I'm looking for something that'll allow for fairly decent descriptions. (Not novel length or anything, but at least a few sentences here and there.) I can work on creating the file bases, and seriously, I'm willing to try any software that'll make this work. How do you add the descriptions and what would be the limitations (like description length, etc)? I know this is an odd thing because, from what I've seen, most BBSes are all about the door games and such. I figure to let others do that, because they're better at it than I am. But I'd love to run an old school file focused BBS again! Also, freakin' love Mystic. Of all the boards I've tried, it's the one that makes the most sense to my brain. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-29 16:09 Yeah the documentation is probably not clear at all, unfortunately. Sorry about that! Its meant to work similar to how Renegade BBS worked. The general process is to create your file bases, and then copy the files you want listed into that file base into its directory. After that you execute "Mass upload" which will import the file into the file listing. Thats it. Now I'll go into more detail about those things: During this mass upload import, Mystic will look inside the file archive for "FILE\_ID.DIZ" which is a BBS standard for file descriptions (basically a text file that contains the file description). If it finds one, it will import the description from this file during the mass upload. There are two ways to do the "mass upload" after copying the files into their directories: The first is the offline mass upload. If you set "MassUpload=true" in your mutil.ini file then every time you run "MUTIL" it will look in all directories and add any new files it finds with their descriptions into your BBS listing automatically. You can set this to run on its own every day and then simply copy files to their directories and Mystic will do the rest. "Set it and forget it" mode. The second option is to use the "online" mass upload feature, which is basically an interactive version of what MUTIL does that you can run while logged into your BBS. By default this command is /U on the file menu if you have SysOp access. The online mass upload will present you with each file it finds, and allow you to confirm if you want to add it. If it doesn't find a description, then it will ask you to provide one (for files that do not have a FILE\_ID.DIZ). In terms of descriptions Mystic allows 99 lines per file up to 50 characters in length per line (the default standard for FILE\_ID.DIZ is 10 lines and 45 characters per line). Mystic also supports FILE\_ID.ANS which is similar but supports colors and ANSI graphics in the descriptions. Now what happens if files do not contain a description in them and they're in your file listing? You can edit descriptions yourself directly from the file listing. If you have SysOp access to a file base you can press "E" in the file listing to Edit the current selected file. From there you can edit the file description using Mystic's message editor. Mystic will also optionally generate the missing FILE\_ID.DIZ file which caused it to not have a description to begin with, and then add it into the archive for you. Sorry for the really long response but I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any other questions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sonorandragon · 2021-04-29 16:22 This helps a *lot!* And thank you so much! And it makes me feel better that I didn't miss something in the docs. I hate it when I ask a question and the answer is "have you read page six?" 😅 Mystic was the first BBS I started fiddling with recently, and I've got it up and running on Pi. I'll definitely try this out sometime in the next day or so! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-29 16:53 Glad it was helpful. I've used this interaction to add to the Frequently Asked Questions on the Mystic BBS Wiki as well so thank you for that! [http://wiki.mysticbbs.com/doku.php?id=faq](http://wiki.mysticbbs.com/ doku.php?id=faq) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- opicron · 2021-04-29 18:00 I love this comment, thanks! Let me get back on this when Im home :). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mysticbbs · 2021-04-29 23:57 Awesome thanks I would appreciate the feedback! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- digitlman · 2021-05-01 07:25 I'd say Synchronet is equally "geared" towards UNIX-like OSes and Windows. Although it Windows was supported before \*nix (and DOS and OS/2 before that), it's been 20 years now and it's very "at home" there now too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- opicron · 2021-05-03 09:00 I see that I was not subtle with my remark, the file implementation of Mystic is perfect. What I meant whas that viewing (browsing) the files on the front end of the board could be, in my opinion, better. I found it counter intuitive and the fact that sometimes descriptions were cut due the the continued screen list type view. Which meant to scroll up to flag the file again. I understand that it needs to be compatible with a lot of technical debt. One thing that would really help me would be the option to automatically include files in subfolders of a certain file area. That way I can keep things organized in the backend (file system) and just show all files on the front end as a colletion of one file area. Thank you for your consideration.