netBSD vs openBSD which is better for someone new BSD? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- paranoidandtired6554 路 2023-08-08 02:36 or would a different BSD os be better suited for me? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gumnos 路 2023-08-08 02:43 There's little harm in trying both (or even including FreeBSD or Dragonfly if you want) to see how they feel. You're the only one who can determine what "better suited to me" means *to you*. Do you intend to run on more obscure or low-end hardware? NetBSD might suit you better. Do you happen to think the way OpenBSD devs do? There's a lot to be said for their out-of-box experience. Do you need to protect your data with the assurances of ZFS and you favor performance on common/modern amd64 machines? Then FreeBSD might be your schtick. I run FreeBSD on my daily driver, but have several OpenBSD laptops around, and VPS instances running a mix of OpenBSD & FreeBSD. But only **you** can determine the best fit for you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- paranoidandtired6554 路 2023-08-08 02:58 noted. thank you ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k3nrap 路 2023-08-08 03:48 I'm in agreement with you, I just want to make a funny joke about the following: >Do you intend to run on more obscure or low-end hardware? NetBSD might suit you better. Oh yeah? Well. Toasters can also run on FreeBSD too. If they run on an embedded raspiberry pi that's powered by FreeBSD. 馃槢 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AxeyEndres 路 2023-08-08 04:48 Are you serious that's a joke? :| ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AxeyEndres 路 2023-08-08 04:50 Ooh hahaha wait wait My wall clock can run freebsd, if it has an rpi, hahahahhaahha soo funny ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AxeyEndres 路 2023-08-08 04:50 Stupid ---------------------------------------------------------------------- desnudopenguino 路 2023-08-08 05:15 I prefer openbsd for my personal daily driver. And for smaller single purpose hardware. And I use freebsd servers for running different local services like web servers and apps. For some reason netbsd never really clicked for me. But I'm not you. Test drive them all and see what they can do for you. I really like freebsd jails and zfs for managing/separating services and experimenting with things, instead of hosting a whole OS system occasionally. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Few_Detail_3988 路 2023-08-08 05:35 I just installed nomadBSD on an old eeepc x101, Just because it's so easy. OpenBSD wouldn't let me log into my DE (lxqt) and freebsd didn't find my WLAN, although my wifi adapter was recognised. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k3nrap 路 2023-08-08 07:01 Alright, I've removed my comment. However, I didn't need any harassment for it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl 路 2023-08-08 10:45 I recommend FreeBSD as it's the most production-ready. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- InformationWorking71 路 2023-08-08 10:55 Would you recommend trying netbsd, I mainly use freebsd and have used openbsd alot in the past, but I have never properly tried netbsd. Could it be used as a desktop and would it be worth it over freebsd? I don't have any special use cases for an os, as I only code write documents and browse the web. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EnigmaticHam 路 2023-08-08 12:14 OpenBSD has a truly painless installer. If you are new to BSD, I鈥檇 try that. It is slower, yes, but it鈥檚 worth it in my opinion. NetBSD is really neat, but if you鈥檙e new it can be a little more complicated to get up and running than OpenBSD in my opinion. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gumnos 路 2023-08-08 13:00 I'm afraid I'm in the same boat as you鈥攐nly having dabbled with a NetBSD install to kick the tires before returning to FreeBSD & OpenBSD. I don't remember any particular negatives to NetBSD as it worked much like any other Unix-like. I just preferred features the others offered that NetBSD didn't (though now that [NetBSD also supports ZFS](https://wiki.netbsd.org/zfs/), it comes a lot closer to FreeBSD for me). If I wanted to run some ancient or obscure hardware (such as for [Sol猫ne's Old Computer Challenge](https://dataswamp.org/~solene/2023-06-04-old-computer- challenge-v3.html) recently), I suspect I'd have better luck with NetBSD. A perfectly cromulent project, it just happens not to scratch any of my current itches. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- the_humeister 路 2023-08-08 13:11 What is your goal and computing background? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Trick-Apple1289 路 2023-08-08 14:03 NetBSD is better for old, obscure hardware and it is bit more lightweight (altough openBSD is still pretty damn fast). Lack of some drivers in openBSD might be the issue for some. Also openBSD is only good if you agree with the projects philosophy (wich i personally do), also installation of openBSD is stupid simple. Overall both are amazing, stable and secure os鈥檈s. For me openBSD has an advantage but that鈥檚 just my opinion. Check both for yourself thats the only way for you to truly know. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AxeyEndres 路 2023-08-08 14:32 Sorry man, I was having a bad day. I apologize ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k3nrap 路 2023-08-08 15:10 Apology accepted. I hope your day today will be awesome! 馃槑 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- paprok 路 2023-08-08 18:02 maybe Free? i've feeling that it's most widespread out of The Holy Trinity ^^tm - and this translates into wider knowledge base on the Internet. so if you'll have any trouble, it'll be easier to find answers/solutions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- paranoidandtired6554 路 2023-08-08 19:04 elaborate on "computing background"? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherealN 路 2023-08-08 19:12 I intended FreeBSD to be my first BSD, but hardware dictated OpenBSD was what I ended up using. By quirk of timing, Open was the first to support my 11th gen laptop hardware fully with no special maneuvers needed. And I happened to like it. So I stuck around. I would suggest that, unless there's a specific feature you want where one has a known advantage, just pick something that you have good reason to expect to work well with the hardware you intend to use. If you have problems, or end up disliking it, you can always switch later. Aside from that, my personal motivations (in case this helps you decide) for staying with OpenBSD aside of the whole "it just installed and everything worked fine with no kmods or building drivers from ports", was: their somewhat extreme "if this code is not actively maintained, we will delete it". So, that's why OpenBSD has no bluetooth support. And while I (sometimes) do enjoy bluetooth for my headset while on the day job, as a Test Engineer there's something really nice with retiring at 5pm to an OS that ACTIVELY ensures there's no unmaintained garbage littering the codebase. For me, with my dayjob in the hyper-agile web services kind of stuff, this alone is just so "zen" that it's worth it. Your motivations may be different, and in that case what is suitable for you might be different, and that's fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherealN 路 2023-08-08 19:19 Most widespread how? Deployed silicon? Yeah, probably, because all the appliances etc. But I have access to the visitor numbers on my employer's (non-tech) website, offering consumer services completely unrelated to anything tech to a global audience, and last time I checked we actually had roughly equal traffic to our site from FreeBSD, OpenBSD and NetBSD. They were basically equal. (I didn't check for Dragonfly, nomad, Midnight, etc.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- the_humeister 路 2023-08-08 21:01 How well versed are you in installing an OS? There's no GUI installer on NetBSD or OpenBSD like there is in the Linux world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- paranoidandtired6554 路 2023-08-08 21:10 oh okay. this clarifies it better, thank you. ive installed various linux OSes in the past and BSD is new to me and its community is smaller. right now i dont have any real plans for using BSD, i only use my pc for browsing and writing i simply want to mess with a different os and get the feel of something new. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kyleW_ne 路 2023-08-08 22:40 You ask this question at an interesting moment in time. Right now the most recent version of NetBSD 9.3 doesn't support the latest and greatest hardware, but version 10.0 should finally come out soon. I personally don't like the way NetBSD is updated compared to Free or Open but that is just me! FreeBSD 14.0 with a much newer software stack come out in October after some delays. Right now oddly enough OpenBSD supports the most hardware (this could change with FreeBSD 14.0 though!) iwx WIFI is only supported on OpenBSD 7.3, the latest 13th Gen Intel graphics, only on OpenBSD if I recall, FreeBSD does new graphics support in a port so it may have been updated to support 12th and 13th Gen graphics. OpenBSD system updates are easy with one command syspatch and upgrades aren't much more painful with sysupgrade. FreeBSD patching and upgrading is super easy too! I Would say the installers for all three are about on par with Debian's old installer that was ncurses based. Nothing a seasoned Linux user can't get past. Net and Free use a Ncurses based installer and OpenBSD is even simpler with a plain text installer. We could better help you if you told us what hardware you want to run on and how new it is also if you wait till the end of year holiday when new versions of all three will be out that have better newer hardware support that would be great too but I don't want to dissuade you from trying them out today, just wanted to point out that new editions of all three will be out probably by end of year! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bmeling95 路 2023-08-08 23:42 Choose OpenBSD for your Unix needs. OpenBSD -- the world's simplest and most secure Unix-like OS. A safe alternatve to the frequent vulnerabilities and overengineering of Linux and related software like NGiNX & Apache ([httpd- asiabsdcon2015.pdf](https://openbsd.org/papers/httpd- asiabsdcon2015.pdf)), OpenSSL, iptables/nftables, systemd, BIND, Postfix, Docker and so on. OpenBSD -- the cleanest kernel, the cleanest userland and the cleanest configuration syntax. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- SaturnFive 路 2023-08-09 02:17 FYI cap the first letter, FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- steverikli 路 2023-08-09 02:34 Echo this. I ran NetBSD for years when I was rescuing old non-PC hardware, mostly Sun SPARCs, a DEC Alpha, and SGI. I ran my home domain on a matched pair of SPARC20 with NetBSD for quite a while. Eventually the power bill took priority over my fun :-) , so I donated all the old Unix metal to other hobbyists and I switched to lower- power PCs and FreeBSD. Now, there's no reason you couldn't run NetBSD on PC's too -- that works a treat also. I went to FreeBSD back then because there was some overlap with my job at the time, so it made sense for me. Really, in my experience you can use any of {Free,Net,Open}BSD for similar duties, each has their own specialties and a few differences here and there, e.g. the mechanism for installing extra packages, how to upgrade, etc. But the basic config methods -- /etc/rc.conf and related -- will be at least familiar. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Playful-Hat3710 路 2023-08-09 04:18 depends on the hardware and what you want to do with it imo ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani 路 2023-08-10 08:40 Go for NetBSD 馃毄 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jmcunx 路 2023-08-10 17:47 If you have a nVidia GPU, OpenBSD is really out of the question, there is a good chance it will not work. NetBSD may support nVidia with nouveau, if you grab 10-BETA you have a better chance. 10-BETA is quite stable. FreeBSD, maybe a better chance with nVidia because I think you can still use the proprietary driver. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] 路 2023-08-15 04:43 [removed] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Wood_Work16666 路 2023-08-21 15:26 Decide on the basis of how accessible the documentation included on the system is to you and not necessarily what is served to you on the openweb as polluted as it may be; I started on nbsd, experimented with obsd, have both available but just use nbsd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- passthejoe 路 2023-08-22 00:59 I've had the most success with OpenBSD, but I still recommend trying everything. One I'm looking at is GhostBSD, which is FreeBSD with a Mate desktop in the default install. I wish there were more desktop projects built on the BSDs. I've just gotten back into OpenBSD after a long spell of Linux only, and my Xfce desktop n 7.3 is doing really well. I'd say that setting up OpenBSD gets easier every year. I never had to do so little to get Xfce running, and now full disk encryption is an easy installer choice. There are packages for just about everything, and I've found quite a few tutorials and issue-specific help when I needed it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- passthejoe 路 2023-08-22 01:03 I forgot to say that suspend/resume and hibernate worked out of the box, and I wasn't expecting that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- watasiwakamisama 路 2023-08-26 17:11 i recommend you to freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- iCe_CoLd_FuRy 路 2023-10-03 13:44 Is you鈥檙e completely new to BSD you might as well try something like ghostBSD