[NetBSD] pkgchkxx: a complete reimplementation of pkg_chk and pkg_rolling-replace reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2023-07-23 06:06 Nice.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PunishedRaion · 2023-07-23 13:08 It's an interesting tool but I think that my biggest criticism here is that the developer of it has no understanding of C++ versions. He claims that C++17 was the first version that had shared pointer code. [This is untrue](https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/memory/shared_ptr) Going with something that new is going to hamper portability and adoption. I almost guarantee that someone could probably rewrite it in C++11 and it would be just as useful. Other than that I do respect his contribution and am impressed at how fast it runs. My main complaint is people complaining about how low level C is. The only people who actually make this as a problem are people who have not coded a lot in it. He admits he's a Haskell user. On total I think that this is an interesting implementation but I think it could use a lot of improvement and he probably could get wider adoption if it used C++11. C++03 would be very nice but that would require using the boost library which might make things more painful for some people.