Why so much contempt for Linux and desktop? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 00:41 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2022-04-15 00:52 Didn't read your whole wall of text with no paragraph breaks, but the answer is "there mostly isn't." Most BSD people don't care if you run Linux or anything else that better suits your use case. Desktop usage of BSD is fairly rare (outside of the OpenBSD crowd) but I don't think there's any "contempt" for those people here either. Maybe you just found a weird, vocal minority somewhere. Those exist in every community. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 00:58 I don't think it warrants separate paragraphs really, and I will insist that whenever I see Linux being brought up in this sub and other bsd subs, the comments slowly fill up with people showing contempt or downright disgust towards it, I'm sure there are a lot of people who aren't like that but I think you're downplaying it a fair bit. Also I don't see the point in replying to something you refused to read because it didn't have le reddit spacing :p ---------------------------------------------------------------------- m0llusk · 2022-04-15 01:42 Linux is a kernel and then all the libraries and commands are often referred to as the filesystem or some such. On BSD things are more carefully arranged with system commands built on system libraries and all working together with the kernel. The result is a more cohesive idea of what the whole system is and how it should all work as opposed to Linux having the essentials very slick an everything else being a mass of briars pointing every which way so that mostly everything works but even then it isn't always clear why and then if it stops well golly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2022-04-15 01:54 > whenever I see Linux being brought up in this sub and other bsd subs, the comments slowly fill up with people showing contempt or downright disgust towards it, I haven't seen that. But then why post something about Linux in a BSD discussion forum in the first place? Not long ago there was a big thread called "[Where does Linux outshine BSD?"](https://old.reddit.co m/r/BSD/comments/rvpudm/where_does_linux_outshine_bsd/) that ended up being very civil and a reflection of my original reply. > le reddit spacing :p Man, you're trying way too hard. Someone from 4chan should not be as fragile and whiny as you are. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2022-04-15 01:56 > this hate boner towards Linux systems From what I perceive, the *boner* (?) towards other system is mostly a (macOS and) Linux user thing. There even is an "I use Arch btw" meme. > or more specifically systemd systemd is an awful pile of badly organized sputum, but still I don't *hate* Linux users for voluntarily fighting ("using") it. Not my problem, after all. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 02:00 ????????? dude I was just asking, trying to be as civil as possible too while you're just being dismissive... it's just how I perceived the community and I made it clear it wasn't intended as an attack/bait/provocation :/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 02:06 That's true in principle but... what does it have to do with the question? I didn't ask why use bsd over linux, I asked why a sizable chunk of the community seems to have disdain for it, unless you're telling me that's the only reason, because if it were, I'd raise the objection that it doesn't ultimately matter that it's better designed overall if it doesn't meet half the functionality of the "worse" OS ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 02:10 whether it's for the system or the users the question remains the same. as for systemd... isn't it a bit disingenuous to equate using it with fighting it when most regular users never even interact or are aware of it? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- strawman2511 · 2022-04-15 02:18 People tend to put down other people pride than their pride. Do you know about it? And why do you still care about it? Someone have made our point of view clear. There probably some people in here run NixOS or maybe I just imagine them. :D ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2022-04-15 02:31 > isn't it a bit disingenuous to equate using it with fighting it when most regular users never even interact or are aware of it? I was paid to use it this week (maintaining a server at work). I'm still drinking to wash away the experience, honestly. But again, BSD users don't talk badly about Linux - we are too busy talking badly about other BSDs. :-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 03:15 This paragraph was very hard to read, made me feel like I have dyslexia. Anyways, I haven't seen very many people that hate linux or desktop. There will always be the small entitled group of people In a community. Basically the elitists. You're making it a bigger deal than it seems. I enjoy linux quite a lot and still use it time to time for when I need it and have no hate or contempt towards it, and I use freebsd as a desktop OS and I've been using it exclusively for a week or two now. I'm not planning on looking back. Hell I even "game" on freebsd, I've spent a good few hours just today playing half life and serious sam. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 03:25 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 03:28 I think you're overplaying(?) this way too much. I've only come across 2 or 3 people that have hated linux and for some reason desktop usage. None of it has been on reddit. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reddit_original · 2022-04-15 04:37 As a long time BSD user, I can say that, at one time we considered Linux to be a kissing cousin. We welcomed technical conversations with them and such conversations were always friendly and conversational. But at one point, when Linux started becoming popular with what we now call "script kiddies", you would often find posts by such people attacking the BSD systems as if it were a competition. I distinctly recall such threads being started where the BSD people would, ask them, "Why are you doing this?" and such posters would quickly get banned. Then, of course, some BSD users would get upset and start attacking Linux users as soon as they would appear, often rightly so. Linux also does not defend the Unix way of doing things. The BSDs are staunch supporters of the methodology which is grounded in computer science. While Linux is chasing games and the destruction of Microsoft, the BSDs are chasing technical superiority. And never the twain thinking minds shall meet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 05:44 Yours is the kind of response I was hoping for, because I'd argue it didn't "get popular with skids", it just got popular, overall, that, by definition, will mean more skids, when linux was as inaccessible to inexperienced as bsd is, it wasn't possible for them to get into it, lowering the barrier of entry inevitably causes this to happen, so I find it a bit harsh to somehow point this out as a problem with the thing that happened to get more popular due to better accessibility for desktop use. I also find the "chasing games" bit a little cynical; I like games, I appreciate having an open source platform that can run them and doesn't tie me to a company that I find to be lowkey evil, and "chasing the destruction of microsoft" comes across as disingenous when microsoft is the one that's on the record for trying to destroy the competition... And as much as BSD can conceptually claim technical superiority, can it truly do that if it can't do the basic tasks a user needs it to? You propose sticking to unix as the only correct way of doing computing, and while that's not a debate I'm remotely knowledgeable enough to get into, I've never seen anything in my life where there's a single right way to approach things. Developers and sysadmins aren't the only people that this kind of technology should be useful to imo ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flexibeast · 2022-04-15 05:48 i've been using Linux and OpenBSD systems for a number of years. Currently Gentoo is my daily driver, but in the past i've used Void, Debian, Ubuntu, Mandriva and RedHat (5.2 'Apollo', my first Linux distro). i've seen some of the attitudes and behaviours you describe; here are some of my thoughts, based on my experiences, on what might be contributing to them: * there are a number of Linux users for whom Linux is significantly about trying to signal how superior they are simply by using (not necessarily *understanding*) certain software. The toxic "I'm on Arch btw" crowd is a current manifestation of that; that crowd used to be more Gentoo-oriented. i've seen a number of people coming from Arch to Void and/or Gentoo and commenting how much more friendly and helpful the latter two communities are. Maybe at some point this crowd will generally move to another distro, and Arch will be able to be assessed more on its own merits than on the crowd currently favouring it. * There are significant differences in standards of quality between the Linux worlds and the BSD worlds. The former tends be more focussed on implementing the latest trendiness as quickly as possible, the latter more on taking the time to do things *right* (in terms of design, maintainability and security). As someone passionate about documentation, i really appreciate how seriously OpenBSD takes documentation - man pages in particular - compared to approaches to documentation in the Linux world (which can range from Very Seriously to Somebody Else's Problem). In the Haskell community, there's a slogan, "Avoid success at all costs", which has jokingly been parsed as "(Avoid success)(at all costs)", but which more seriously is intended to mean "(Avoid)(success at all costs)" - e.g. don't implement something which will contribute to popularity in the short terms, at the cost of significant problems ('technical debt') in the medium-to-long term. * Related to the preceding is how so many in the Linux community seem to enthusiastically buy in to the marketing of corporations, and jump onto corporate bandwagons in a way that often involves deriding 'antiquated tech', without apparently having enough knowledge to be able to recognise and appreciate the tradeoffs involved, or how the 'antiquated' way might be the result of hard-earned experience (cf. [Chesterton's fence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Ch esterton's_fence)). i've seen OpenBSD accused of Not Invented Here syndrome, but in practice, OpenBSD seems to reimplement things *in ways that reflects the experiences of existing software*. Yet reinvention of the wheel, possibly badly, is hardly absent from the Linux world, and systemd is one significant example of that. Finally, as for systemd in particular, here's a comment i wrote about my use of alternative init / process supervision / machine management systems on Linux: https://old.reddit.com/r/Gentoo/comments/ttusaj/alte rnate_init_systems/i36ws2h/ (P.S. Even if breaking up text into paragraphs isn't technically *required* in a particular situation, doing so can make it more friendly to many of your potential readers, who after all have no obligation to read your writing or respond to it. When i'm writing, once a section of text becomes 'too long' - and when i write, that happens often - i find a way to break it up into separate paragraphs.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- WikiSummarizerBot · 2022-04-15 05:49 **G. K. Chesterton** [Chesterton's fence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#C hesterton's_fence) >Chesterton's fence is the principle that reforms should not be made until the reasoning behind the existing state of affairs is understood. The quotation is from Chesterton's 1929 book, The Thing: Why I Am a Catholic, in the chapter, "The Drift from Domesticity": In the matter of reforming things, as distinct from deforming them, there is one plain and simple principle; a principle which will probably be called a paradox. There exists in such a case a certain institution or law; let us say, for the sake of simplicity, a fence or gate erected across a road. ^([ )[^(F.A.Q)](https://www.reddit.com/r/WikiSummarizer/wiki/index#wik i_f.a.q)^( | )[^(Opt Out)](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=WikiS ummarizerBot&message=OptOut&subject=OptOut)^( | )[^(Opt Out Of Subreddit)](https://np.reddit.com/r/BSD/about/banned)^( | )[^(GitHub)](https://github.com/Sujal-7/WikiSummarizerBot)^( ] Downvote to remove | v1.5) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 06:25 Yep, sounds like server experience with systemd... but I was talking about individual everyday users ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 06:29 I seriously appreciate the well thought-out response and the suggestion about spacing, even though the third point isn't something I've really found in my experience, especially the bit about corporations, unless you're talking about Ubuntu or Fedora, in that case, yeah, but I don't really use those so I'm not really sure. Point being, thanks for your input, it helped me understand a bit more about BSD as a whole ---------------------------------------------------------------------- -kilix- · 2022-04-15 06:40 I just discovered brutal doom with DoomMetal soundtrack, works well with gzdoom on FreeBSD. I spent many hours playing that in the last few days. It's friggin intense. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- -kilix- · 2022-04-15 07:07 I generally don't know what you are talking about. I read BSD FreeBSD and OpenBSD subreddits for a while, I am also on the FreeBSD forums. There is rarely any discussion about Linux, because--guess what--it's offtopic. Also, you won't find many discussions about Macos or AIX there. I agree though, that there is some poking and joking going around mostly systemd. Which is to be expected, systemd has nothing to do with UNIX. Also, if you are easily triggered by a simple sentence like 'systemd is crapware', uttered by some random dude on the internet, then maybe, just maybe your sensitivity may be too high. If someone comes with a question "why is BSD worse/better than Linux" (which happens at least once a week), he will promptly be encouraged to look into older facsimile threads. He may view this as "dismissive behaviour", but yeah, that's his problem. Whenever you raise a Linux/Macos/Windows question on a BSD subreddit, what kind of response do you honestly expect? I spent a lot of years in Linux and in the Linux communities, even now I try and help people with Linux related questions. (Even though I don't use Linux on a daily basis) What I observed after a year or two in the BSD community is the fact that BSD community tends to be more adult, more to-the-point, more experienced, more factual and less emotional. Some people may view this factual approach as being blunt or elitist. But again, this is not religion, we are talking about software here. Why do you need all the drama, accusations, fanboyism, elitism, short temper and self centeredness? Nobody cares what software you use, use whatever suits you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mwyvr · 2022-04-15 07:22 Perhaps YOU don't think your wall of text would be more readable if it were reformed into distinct paragraphs but hundreds of years of language and reading theory and practice disagree with your opinion. Don't shoot the messenger, they were trying to do you a favour. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2022-04-15 08:08 I have to say, I looked at the title and saw yet another “waaah, why doesn’t everyone love Linux” whinge followed by a wall of unstructured text and it immediately occurred to me: that, right there, is a solid 90% of it. No BSD community I’ve ever taken part in would do that to their fellow members or to others. If they did it unintentionally they’d do something about it if they can, not defend it. It’s just basic respect. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 08:31 Last I checked you separate paragraphs when you change the immediate talking point, though, so that's just reddit spacing, not regular english spacing that you're advocating ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 08:32 ??? What are you even talking about? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2022-04-15 08:44 It very much did get popular with the script kiddies. I’m unfortunately old enough to remember… they’re still very much around - every time someone asks for a YouTube “tutorial“, there they are. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 08:53 but what's the larger point? skids use this therefore bad??? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 09:06 Bud, I Am Asking Just that, is it so hard to not be patronizing over it? And I didn't ask why bsd is better than linux, I asked why you act exactly like I expected you to ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reddit_original · 2022-04-15 09:18 Ubuntu claims their Bug #1 is Microsoft Windows. >And as much as BSD can conceptually claim technical superiority, can it truly do that if it can't do the basic tasks a user needs it to? What basic tasks are you talking about? You wrote that right after talking about playing games so is playing games what you mean? BSD has no control over what platform the game makers write their games for and game makers mostly make their games for Windows, not BSD or even Linux. And game playing is not a "basic task" but are you aware that Playstation runs BSD? How about the Ninetendo Switch? Are you aware that your Netflix video is delivered via FreeBSD? Are you aware that the internet backbone is mostly controlled by routers running FreeBSD? Are those basic tasks significant enough for you? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 09:20 I appreciate the two people that actually added something constructive, everyone else seems to not have bothered reading, I guess I apologize about the lack of reddit spacing, I don't like it and didn't think to use it, guess I'll edit it in now ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 09:37 I am perfectly aware of the examples that you listed, but can you implement that functionality into your own system? didn't think so, and games are only one example of software that's nonexistent in bsd, so, nope, not enough for me And Ubuntu isn't exactly the embodiment of what the larger linux community wants, in fact I'd say most non ubuntu users low key hate canonical and its decisions/objectives It is also blatantly disngenous to claim that the internet is backboned mostly by freebsd when it's also mostly backboned by linux... Maybe I shouldn't have used the expression "basic tasks" and instead said I like it when my computer can do many different things comfortably, and not just a select few things ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reddit_original · 2022-04-15 12:46 >I am perfectly aware of the examples that you listed, but can you implement that functionality into your own system? Of course you can. Netflix contributes their code back to FreeBSD. The source of all the BSDs are open and freely accessible if you wish to modify them yourself. >It is also blatantly disngenous to claim that the internet is backboned mostly by freebsd when it's also mostly backboned by linux... BS. The backbone is mostly run on Junos OS which is FreeBSD. >I like it when my computer can do many different things comfortably, and not just a select few things Such as? I've been using BSD as my desktop for 20 years. What basic tasks can you do that I can't do? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lvlint67 · 2022-04-15 13:19 I'm going to speak hypothetically here, because so far there has been no real evidence that there is widespread hostility from the BSD crowd toward the linux crowd... or at least nothing more serious than the VI vs EMACS holy war which is largely ironic and up to personal preference. **IF**... If there was hostility from the BSD crowd toward linux, it **COULD** be related tot he licensing models. BSD generally has very OPEN licensing. Linux has very "FREE". When we talk about what that actually means, we talk about the GPL specifically. It's not uncommon for folks to take BSD licensed code, make modifications and release the result under the GPL license. Release software like that prevents the BSD authors from using the changes without ALSO converting their own license to GPL. > or more specifically systemd It's a philosophical argument between academics with no bearing on reality. Either you understand the system and the implications, or you're qualified to participate and thusly, should ignore the debate and use what works. No one is personally attacking you for using systemd that is also worth any kind of consideration. > but why the sheer contempt for desktop users half the time There, objectively, is not. > why treat them as lesser just because they're not computer experts The people that get treated poorly are often the ones asking for support with issues that are easily searchable. I will also cling to the idea that if you're going to ask for subject matter experts to spend THEIR TIME to assist you with a problem, you should have taken steps to minimize the effect of the ask on the expert. > If you wanted to hate on a specific kind of system, why target Linux of all systems [citation needed] > Don't take this as an attack, I'm very much enjoying learning about bsd and actually unix like systems, but this is seriously off putting I think it's time for you to come clean on where you specifically have sourced your assumptions from. It feels, very much to an outsider, like you walked into an enthusiast club for a product, started extolling the virtues of a competitor, and were surprised when the club didn't want to hear it... Or perhaps you were asking questions that have easily searchable answers... So lets see some actual instances of the community behaving in the way you are accusing it of before we commit to trying to justify that behavior. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- graemep · 2022-04-15 13:51 I think a lot of this is down to their being more Linux users, and more groups with different priorities. It does happen: I use Manjaro and some Arch users are elitist about it. A lot of Linux users are too prone to want the latest everything, others prefer what is proven. A lot of people dislike systemd and to me its pretty obvious it does too much. That is why there are a number of distros that do not use systemd. The problem is that those have drawbacks too. My ideal OS would be rolling release, prioritise security and reliability over features, work painlessly with my hardware, have the applications I need, be easy (and quick) to install and set up for all my use cases etc. I have to compromise somewhere. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _supert_ · 2022-04-15 13:56 As a practical matter, it's very difficult to scan text quickly for points when not in paragraphs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _supert_ · 2022-04-15 14:00 I'm using nix. A valid and innovative approach IMO. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 14:01 I don't know if it will work on freebsd but check out the mod called "project brutality" it's like brutal doom x20 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaximCapsa · 2022-04-15 14:02 idk what u on about , pretty sure most of the people using linux - love it ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Joe-Asks · 2022-04-15 14:25 As far as I know, it has been Linux users the ones who historically have been arrogant and have belittled Windows and macOS operating systems and users despite the fact that Linux Desktop has never grown beyond the niche status. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- djbelly219 · 2022-04-15 14:50 In all the ways people tell me that Linux is better than BSD, Windows is better than Linux. But I love Linux. If I need it for a commercial app, I use it. If I don’t, I use BSD, because it’s an excellent all around choice for the the things that matter in business: consistency, maintainability, stability, and segregation of functions. And as a personal preference: unixyness. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2022-04-15 15:02 Former penguin here who switched to BSD after about 10 years of using Linux exclusively. The reasons why I switched are more diverse than I can describe here, but let me touch on three of them as the context for my answer to your question: 1. I had started to think that things were not generally going into the right direction. 2. I had been pretty unhappy with the (small but loud) faction of fanatics in the Linux camp who seek to belittle and humiliate users of other systems or heavily engage in infighting ("Use Debian or die!", Arch supremacy, you name it). 3. After what had been meant as a challenge to use a different Unix- like for one month just to see whether I could do it, I had found that I actually liked several aspects better than with Linux and stuck around. As mentioned in 2, I was aware of the hatred going on in the community and I've witnessed things like a fellow Archer mentioning on the forum that he'd go and try out FreeBSD - and one of the replies essentially being: "Sure, do that. You'll come crawling back next week." That arrogance has always made me sad. But when I left, I found myself the target of the same hate: Now I was the *apostate*, the *renegade*, the *heretic*. I have quickly lost any overview of how often I have been accused of "hating Linux" and I've in fact become tired of explaining that this is not the case. But it doesn't matter what I say since I'm guilty of having committed the ultimate sin of abandoning the one true OS (or kernel). The fact that I practice my right of criticizing things that are not ideal with Linux does not exactly help (while I continue to mention the downsides of my new OS of choice as well this does make no difference whatsoever). If I were to decide to leave FreeBSD today and to write a goodbye post stating that I'd be going to illumos for example, I'm dead certain that there will be no such reactions. I have described this as "BSD is for grown-ups". No, I'm fully aware that most Linux users are decent people. But unfortunately there's to many blockheads around that they manage to damage that community and to even make it a refreshing experience to leave! There's difficult and strange people in the BSD community as well, but especially coming to FreeBSD does make so much of a difference. That's for the "human part" of it (which is important IMHO). But there's the technical side, too. And this is where Linux is known to push horrible design decisions to be "de-facto" standards, to act all high and mighty and kill what POSIX once was. This post is becoming too long already, though. Hope that it gave you some insight on why there is some hate but most of it either being a reflection or even a (deliberately) misinterpreted different opinion. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eau-u4f · 2022-04-15 15:09 Contempt you say? The BSDs communities tends to be focussed on effort being made more than efforts being talked. BSDs does not have huge backing from large corporations (despite being used in many products). No full time developers paid by tech companies to upstream their changes to the project, steer it towards their industrial/market interests and avoid having the support weight on them only. The nature of the linux development culture (bazaar) makes it easier to include changes in Linux rather than BSDs (cathedral), which is a choice made by those respective dev communities (nice book about it but you probably know it). These systems were & are developed on spare/free time, it is not designed to necessarily fill a « market share », if you think they should be improved to be more desktop friendly, then pick up the fight and go for it, most of these projects will gladly accept well thought/designs & improvements (which requires ecosystem understanding, the code, the code style and how to fit within the goals of the project and the people running the project). You don’t enter a soccer team and tell them how to play because you think « soccer should more spectacular, it would attract more people. » People are doing that mainly for fun, why would it be expected from them to satisfy a « market share », you are either a « user » or a « contributor » not a « customer », as i said above if there are things you think should be done, start, do, ask for feedback on your progress and if it would fit, contribute and be part to represent the change you want to see, you are part of it, it is not a corp / customer relationship. Now about Linux « hate » well in BSDs you regularly have people coming and talk, propose, suggest, but no code is ever produced, then the easy argument come saying « but in Linux there is… », in a many cases no patch, not even reading docs, but just demand immediate attention to their immediate needs and requests like being utterly important while most of the time people remain civil, it’s energy draining, time consuming. Honestly I often don’t understand why would someone harass with his point of view if it is not shared, why is it so important to impose your views (not you personally!) rather than understand what the people are trying to accomplish and maybe realize it’s not really what you want, or maybe you need to dig deeper to try to change what you think is broken and do the work. I hope i managed to answer some of your comments/questions or at least contribute to an answer. My 2 cents :) Cheers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jols0543 · 2022-04-15 15:10 because it’s so difficult and we don’t understand it so we lash out in anger ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Colonel-EXE · 2022-04-15 15:21 So, I've been quite passionate about linux these last few years... And I've grown to love Slackware due to its simplicity under the hood, making it much easier for me to understand than other OSs I have tried. I have grown to love the focus on stability vs bleeding edge. I've been looking at BSD for some time now, but have been hesitant because I was unsure if it would include the necessary firmware and base applications to run as a desktop workstation. Do you find BSD to be limiting, or should I give it a go? Are freebsd and openbsd the best? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- amnesiac0x07C5 · 2022-04-15 17:02 I have my uses for a linux server but the platform on desktop lacks a lot of software that I need. I dislike how each distro has a different way of doing the same thing. The worst is how I once pointed out on r/linux that software like Proton actually promotes the use of proprietary software. I got banned. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LinuxLeafFan · 2022-04-15 17:29 Of all the operating systems, how could OpenBSD possibly be accused of NIH? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LinuxLeafFan · 2022-04-15 17:36 It all depends on your use case. The asking what is the best BSD isn’t much different from asking what is the best Linux (from a high level, please refrain from rising up with your pitchforks and torches) Each BSD operating system is capable in its own way. For example, OpenBSD (my favourite BSD) focuses on security, simplicity, stability and documentation but as a result, lags behind in features and performance. I’d suggest you read up on NetBSD, OpenBSD, and FreeBSD and make your own decision and if necessary, come back to this subreddit and ask clarifying questions! (And for the two people out there using Dragonfly BSD as their daily driver, sorry) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 18:33 Pretty sure I didn't do that thing you're mentioning, but my impression comes from searching comparisons between the two, and most of the forum based responses coming off as I said, some of the comments in this very post are being quite condescending, not most, and a few are very good and well meaning, but some are basically just, again, being condescending about it ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 18:38 You left out the non netflix stuff... and again with the internet... my point was that large web servers and supercomputers are still using linux anyway, so bsd isn't the sole maintainer of things... Yeah, I can tell you've been using it for a large number of years and have a fundamentally different usage pattern, I give up, since anything I do on my desktop is just gonna be met with cynicism as it already has by other commenters ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 18:40 Reddit mods will be reddit mods :p That's still a weird thing to argue, however, were you referring you the steam client? Or the games themselves? Because if so... well... duh...? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reddit_original · 2022-04-15 18:53 You haven't told us anything you do on the desktop so this whole thread was pointless and I pretty much figured it would end like this. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 19:35 Right, sure, I haven't, I am absolutely not referring to any piece of software that's not available on bsd, and before you go "then go windows lol" I appreciate that the os itself is open source, not tied to a company that's too big for its own good and harvests data and whatnot... software availability is a valid point. I didn't expect a bunch of the majorly grown up userbase here to behave like typical redditors ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mwyvr · 2022-04-15 20:03 >behave like typical redditors You should look in the mirror. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mwyvr · 2022-04-15 20:04 >I asked why a sizable chunk of the community seems to have disdain for it, Someone asked for citations. Show evidence of this. You make a claim without substantiating it. Going on, and on, and on, and on about the claim you've made does not substantiate the claim. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 20:34 I asked a question about how I perceive a portion of this community and got met with condescending people acting the exact way I described :p ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 20:35 So you want me to give you easily searchable information in a silver platter, that's fucking ironic, just look up comparisons in forums and the snobbish attitude presents itself ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mwyvr · 2022-04-15 21:41 You came here with an opinion and presented no facts, and that's a fact, jack. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deafphate · 2022-04-15 22:17 > I asked why a sizable chunk of the community seems to have disdain for it Have any hard numbers to back up the "sizeable chunk" claim? I've been reading the BSD and FreeBSD subreddits for a while and never seen this behavior you're claiming. I've seen annoyance with the weekly "why should I use BSD over Linux" questions. That's it. I've not observed any disdain towards any individuals. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 22:33 Ok, whatsver, replace "sizable" with "small group" and whatever... whenever I look up these places I see people being snobbish and elitist, if you don't see that then just don't chime in, I'm not interested in hearing how wrong I am in how I perceive your colmunity ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lvlint67 · 2022-04-15 22:53 > some of the comments in this very post are being quite condescending You did come in with an accusatory tone. That does tend to put people on the defensive ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 23:19 I EXPLICITLY SAID NOT TO TAKE IT AS AN ATTACK IN THE GODAMN POST JESUS CHRIST ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mwyvr · 2022-04-15 23:23 I used FreeBSD professionally for work (mostly servers and apps on said servers) for many years but at some point changing hardware and needs (virtualization) took me to Linux. I still followed notable BSDrs online in various fora, on Twitter. I see names I recognize from years ago on BSD Reddit and am happy to see that. There are great people in both camps and fanboys in both camps and newbies in all camps. You'll find orders of magnitude more angst in most, but not all, reddit linux groups than you will in the BSD areas. My recollection of the BSD community back when I was quite active is more or less what I perceive it as today - generally very helpful, with a lot less noise than exists (online) in the Linux world. It is a much smaller community to be sure. There may be some - in any camp - who express their preferences with something that looks like contempt for other opinions and design decisions. You need look no further than Linus Torvalds for clear examples of that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lvlint67 · 2022-04-15 23:38 So you can see how the tone can put people on the defensive even if no attack was intended then?... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-15 23:45 I've only learned it's near impossible to accurately convey tone in written message for me, but you're right about that ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flexibeast · 2022-04-16 01:37 > Do you find BSD to be limiting, or should I give it a go? Are freebsd and openbsd the best? In addition to u/LinuxLeafFan's [comment](https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD /comments/u3vrxo/why_so_much_contempt_for_linux_and_desktop/i4uuvuq/), in my own case, i don't use OpenBSD as a 'desktop' system (though a number of the OpenBSD devs do), but as the OS for a couple of servers i run, one of which used to run Debian. i've found running OpenBSD as a server OS (in particular, for NextCloud) to be very pleasant, as someone willing to spend half an hour every six months to undertake the (easy and smooth) OS upgrade process. And maintaining NextCloud, via the OpenBSD package, is also much more pleasant on OpenBSD than it was on Debian. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-16 01:50 This. 100%. Totally agree with you. I used to like Linux back in the 90's - 00's, but I've also started playing with FreeBSD since around the early 00's. I think from back when the 5 release was out. As time went on, I've only grown to appreciate FreeBSD more as an OS. Yeah, Linux in general always felt like it was put together with duct tape and bubblegum, but that part didn't bother me. It was the zealots. The cultists. The real toxic part of the Linux community itself. And of course, the bonehead design choices that seem more like a solution in search of a problem, or that tend to break shit for the sake of change, and the attitude of pushing these choices upon others (systemd) when it was supposed to be about freedom. Basically, the politics that seem to be inherent in Linux itself. Arch users are the worst. Their fanboyism is just incomprehensible to me. Elitists using a shit distro, basically telling others to "git gud." There's certainly a reason why "I use Arch btw" is a meme. Then again, my distros of choice at the time were Slackware, and later on, Gentoo. I never would've taken Arch seriously at that time. Eventually, it got to the point where I needed to be more serious on what I wanted my machines to do, when they need to be servers. I can't be dealing with the politics of Linux, and I can't be wasting hours picking up the pieces when an update badly breaks something. I don't want to be wasting my time reinventing the wheel, trying to do "Linux as a desktop", or trying to make Wine to work, when Windows already works for my purpose as a desktop. Essentially, I don't like drama in my life. Does computing really need to be a source of drama? And when did computers stop being fun to use, or started getting in the way of actually being productive? I don't know, man. I think it all boils down to using the right tool for the job you want done, and as for running a media / file server, and virtual machines, FreeBSD and bhyve are well suited to my needs. Gaming and office productivity? I'm not going to bother with Wine on a Linux distro when Windows already works, and is proven much more stable to me nowadays, than back in the good old 3x / 9x days. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-16 02:45 Definitely this. Thinking back on how some Linux users would be so hostile over Windows, yet try to make Wine run xyz because there's no native Linux program for what they want to do - with lots of frustration bordering on futility. Gee. Why pound rocks together to make jaggedly sharp shards of rock, when you can just use a knife? Just the the right tool for the job! There's nothing '1337' from what I can see, using crude hacks not actually fit for your own use case. And sure, you CAN run Windows in a VM, but when the point was supposed to be about the 'freedom from the tyranny of the M$ monopoly', I don't know, man. I would've bought into that petty little battlecry when I was younger, but times have since changed, and so have I. I can't even be sure they use that battlecry these days. (aren't they trying to play nice with M$, now?) It kind of goes back to trying to shove boneheaded ideas like systemd on people, that feels like such a betrayal from what 'freedom' was supposed to be about, coupled with the arrogance on top of it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Colonel-EXE · 2022-04-16 04:19 Thank you for your input! I could try it as a server... I have been thinking about selfhosting some sort of cloud service(s) for myself for fun & to learn & because I have enough parts for a spare x86 computer laying around, plus a raspberry pi 4 I have started to play with. Do you run your BSD server on x86 or ARM? Or something else? I'm always concerned about software availability on ARMs haha. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- flexibeast · 2022-04-16 06:33 Both my OpenBSD servers are on x86 hardware, but the one on which i run NextCloud is actually a vmd(8) VM provisioned by [openbsd.amsterdam](https://openbsd.amsterdam/) (although its underlying hardware is also x86). i've never tried running on OpenBSD on ARM hardware. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- amnesiac0x07C5 · 2022-04-16 15:24 One of the rules in r/linux is to not promote the use of closed-source software over open-source, yet they promote software that can run applications with closed-source software that is originally meant for Windows. I chimed in on a thread that discussed [bottles](https://usebottles.com/). The use of for-profit video games likely doesn't fall under the philosophy set by their own rules (even though we all know many of them play video games - which are for- profit software and closed source). Why is proton or bottles even mentioned there if the goal is to run such software that is for-profit and closed source? If that is needed, then just use Windows (this is what I suggested hence my ban). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-16 16:33 Bruh, that's just being cynycal, you're blstantly ignoring that the reason people use bottles and proton is because they DON'T WANT TO RUN WINDOWS due to a million valid reasons, so no, it is literally stil promoting open source to a degree, and about the games themselves... read the rule more carefully again, "do not promote closed source over foss" please point me to a single foss game with the same quaity of design, writing, artwork and music as nier automata... o wait it doesn't exist because artists and writers don't work for free and programmers don'thave good game design... You didn't deserve the ban, but for once I understand the mods for feeling that you were trolling or just trying to rile people up with that moot point... Besides, games aren't tools, they're not stuff that needs to be constantly updated and patched for security (at least single player ones) and ultimately they're not just software, they're a collection of assets, writing, voicework, music and game design that's put together with software, they're fundamentally different from something like keepass or obs, which are actual tools you would need to know the inner workings of to trust them and be able to improve them... but that discussion isn't here nor there... again, sorry, but you were just being a dick to them ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-04-16 21:22 I appreciate your response, even though a lot of the others reinforced my perception of there being a degree of contempt and arrogance, which I'm fully aware also exists on Linux side, but what I don't see there is people straight up denying the situation ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Camtaf · 2022-05-05 08:17 The 'unix' philosophy of one program doing one job well, is being lost on Linux systems, unfortunately, & they are tending toward the Corporate way of 'we know best', lets have everything in one place, regardless of its real purpose, (Windows Registry, & now Linux Systemd) - I prefer the 'old way' too. P.S. I'm not against Linux, by the way, but I use Devuan, & when I install BSD, it is most often OpenBSD, but I like NetBSD too.