Not trying to troll or start a flamewar, but why is there some weird amount of hate around BSD systems, specifically OpenBSD? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 09:58 I'm talking about sites like www.isopenbsdsecu.re and others. I'm migrating from Windows to a more free operating system, but I don't know what to believe. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reddit_original · 2021-12-29 10:40 Any hate you hear is from clueless people trying to feel good about themselves, have never used a BSD system, and are only displaying their lack of knowledge due to their incessant game play which distracts them from learning anything about life. Ignore them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- asymptotically508 · 2021-12-29 10:57 I don't think [isopenbsdsecu.re](https://isopenbsdsecu.re) is hate, it seems quite honest and objective. See the [page on fuzzing](https://isopenbsdsecu.re/mitigations/fuzzing/) which discusses how OpenBSD is catching up and fuzzing syscalls. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 11:23 Theo de Raadt is known to be somewhat difficult to work with and has beef with half the people in the BSD world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-12-29 11:33 [removed] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 11:55 So is OpenBSD not as secure as it claims to be? Should I just stick with NetBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 12:08 I recommend FreeBSD to be honest. NetBSD is a bit outdated and OpenBSD is so single mindedly focused on security that everything else suffers significantly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 12:12 I get that, but I kinda want a fully 'libre' operating system. I'm going to be learning how to program and I will try to make my own bluetooth firmware (eventually). So I won't really mind missing functionality, I don't mind getting it from other packages or just making it myself as a self programming exercise. I mainly worry about security and documentation because I worry a lot about my stuff getting compromised, and I refer to documentation and wikis a lot for help. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Pollu_X · 2021-12-29 12:27 FreeBSD is an OS that is meant to be used and useful. OpenBSD is mostly a research OS ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bashbeeb · 2021-12-29 12:51 Can you give an example of where openbsd suffers due to security? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 12:55 For example, it has limited support for file systems (e.g. no ZFS) due to complexity involved in auditing them. X11 performance is poor and as far as I know there is no support for any 3D acceleration at all. As far as I know OpenBSD has no support for compartmentalisation of the system like with FreeBSD jails. But mostly the thing is that the OpenBSD people neglected to modernise their system. FreeBSD has moved on and introduced lots of quality of life improvements as well as new design ideas into the system whereas OpenBSD still feels like a late 90s UNIX system. I mean if you like that kind of vintage, by all means go for it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 13:00 So is my only real choice as far as BSD's go is FreeBSD? I kinda wanted to weigh in my choices first before I hop onto a BSD os. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 13:01 That's not what I said. You do have the free choice. But FreeBSD is by far the most modern one of these. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 13:05 I'm not criticizing what you said, I just meant is it the most 'usable' one out the box. I asked around in OpenBSD communties amd they said theirs was easy. Almost everyone keeps telling me to try this and that so I'm kinda lost haha. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- su_root_ · 2021-12-29 13:18 With such a questions all you really get are people preaching their "religion". Try the bsd's and pick the one that best suits you. All BSD's have their dis/advantages. Only you know what will work best for you and your requirements/needs ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 13:20 You should just give each of them a try. Read the handbooks, install the systems to a VM, try to get a usable environment up and running. The proof is in the pudding. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sam0016 · 2021-12-29 14:25 I think you should give OpenBSD and FreeBSD a try everyone likes different things also documentation wise FreeBSD has the best documentation out of any operating system I've ever used and I have used quite a lot over the years. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mike_elapid · 2021-12-29 14:51 You are using a crap definition of modernise for your argument. The fact that new releases happen and things are added and taken away from the distribution means it is being modernised, the fact that it is not shiny and does not have the improvements you want does not mean its not being modernised. OpenBSD is used in the main for networking (security and routing) and as a server OS. The majority of people/organisations that use it in production dont run X11 on it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2021-12-29 14:58 there are so many bad and inaccurate replies in this thread that i'd probably just nuke it if i was a mod ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 15:04 So... what parts were modernised in OpenBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 15:04 Could you elaborate? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2021-12-29 15:15 I think OpenBSD is hated online by a few small, vocal groups: - GNU/FSF fans, because it uses a truly free license, not the GPL (the majority of 4chan people fall into this category) - A small subset of passionate Linux users, because it's not Linux - A small subset of passionate FreeBSD users, because OpenBSD outpaces it in all areas of security (see the comments in this thread) - grsecurity and their crowd, because it offers comparable modern exploit mitigations to their paid product (but for free) The website you link has had outdated and outright wrong information on it since its inception, along with the original conference presentation that was given alongside it. The best advice I can give you is to do your own research, asking people familiar with the source code for specific questions that you can't find yourself after searching. This talk is also pretty good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRg2vuwF1hY ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwbowen · 2021-12-29 15:15 It depends on the perspective of the user. OpenBSD is straightforward to use if you share a similar mindset to the developers. If you're a person who doesn't care a ton about having a system with secure defaults at the expense of performance or features, then you may find it frustrating to use. I really like NetBSD. I care a lot about about portable code and (in my personal opinion and experience) the community is the most laid back and friendly of the BSDs. But NetBSD's documentation isn't very good and that makes it difficult to approach for newcomers. FreeBSD is the most widely used BSD, so you're more likely to be able to Google a problem and find an answer. They also have good documentation and a wider array of features, so some find that to be more aprochable. Just try them all for a bit and see which one resonates with you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sehnsuchtbsd · 2021-12-29 15:54 In which ways is NetBSD to be considered outdated? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sehnsuchtbsd · 2021-12-29 16:16 I suggest to take this with a grain of salt. Emphasized and out of context statements are more likely to paint a distorted reality and sound alarming. This is not to say that any of what you read is wrong. It is likely true, though I lack the kind of knowledge to truly interpret such content. My question is: what if a comparable in-depth analysis were to be carried out on other BSDs? What about the merits, the wise development choices, and the good ideas attributable to the OpenBSD project: have they been covered thoroughly and with comparable emphasis? There's some general hostility BSD in the GNU/FSF/GPL ecosystem and also significant fragmentation within the BSD community itself. Not seldom will you come across *BSD zealots heavily criticizing and downplaying other BSDs just for the sake of elitism (i.e. bragging about their OS of choice and blindly repeating some cookie cutter nonsense they read somewhere, be it an old blog post or video from another proselyte). Clueless newcomers tend to be the loudest. Worth noticing nobody here came up with any useful technical observation concerning the statements made in the link you posted above. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-12-29 16:22 FreeBSD user here. No one hates OpenBSD. There are useful features exchanged within the BSD ecosystems. As a user I need functionality first. Secure development is an approach to deliver functionality. Implementing a feature is a goal. Security is not a feature, but one quality criterion like performance or usability, but not a goal. That said, FreeBSD is a general purpose operating system. It is loaded with features for all kinds of users. OpenBSD has a special target user group and does not have many things. Because of this, I (personally) had to go back to FreeBSD after having tried to cope with OpenBSD for a while. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brynet · 2021-12-29 16:29 > X11 performance is poor and as far as I know there is no support for any 3D acceleration at all. This is not true, at all. In fact, OpenBSD includes more recent drm drivers (inteldrm/radeondrm/amdgpu) than any of the other *BSDs, based on Linux 5.10.65 "LTS" branch, with a WIP update to 5.15x in the pipeline. The rest of your comment is pure FUD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2021-12-29 16:33 > FreeBSD user here. No one hates OpenBSD. Glad that you don't, but I said a small subset of users. There's a fairly obvious one in this same thread. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thawkth · 2021-12-29 16:35 I’m very unclear on why you have goals that involve significant learning and effort and yet seem less than willing to just install and try the operating systems you are asking about. When it comes to time and effort required your actual project is an order of magnitude more than simply reading some documentation and installing them. No matter what you choose you’ll gain knowledge and experience. For the record OpenBSD is a solid system with fantastic documentation and FreeBSD will almost surely handle whatever you need to do. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2021-12-29 16:35 OpenBSD a research OS ? I find OpenBSD to be more usable than FreeBSD honestly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-29 16:39 If i got better from the last time I checked it out, that's great to hear! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2021-12-29 16:40 I am an OpenBSD user and I can tell : it is easy. It is the most secure of the three and comes directly out of the box with most things you'd need with clean configuration. But indeed, it is a bit dusty on the side. All the same, FreeBSD still has sendmail in its base where OpenBSD has opensmtpd natively, with fairly easy conf. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2021-12-29 16:41 This is a good answer. There is no point searching "the best BSD" for it depends a lot on what you look for. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2021-12-29 16:44 Security, straightforward. For example, they don't have sendmail in base, they have the latest pf version (of course...). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- loudle · 2021-12-29 16:48 they're all good, try everything. don't listen to anyone who says one or the other is better, it's just a matter of how you like to use your computer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brynet · 2021-12-29 17:01 So before 2013? Because that's when the drm drivers with KMS (Kernel Modesetting) were integrated into the tree, including proper console integration, which we had even before FreeBSD. Also on OpenBSD, GPU drivers w/ full acceleration are included OOTB, not delegated to the ports tree like FreeBSD. Again your post demonstrates nothing but outdated and opinionated FUD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vext01 · 2021-12-29 17:10 I just see a navidrome instance... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- asymptotically508 · 2021-12-29 17:30 OP's link (to www.) is broken, the link in my comment should work. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2021-12-29 17:35 Because I don't want the bulk of my effort to be based around switching from variant to variant until I find the one that just works. I know that's the most logical way to come to that conclusion, you're not wrong though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2021-12-29 17:46 "More secure" can mean completely different things to different people without any of them being necessarily wrong. The point is that all of the BSDs are secure enough for most applications. Unlike Windows, which can't be on a public network at all without protections, BSDs are generally clean and don't start listening on random ports without being explicitly told to. That said, the findings in that web site are not illegitimate, aren't FUD, and aren't "hate" - they're observations. Some people take jabs at OpenBSD because they tout security so heavily, when really they have many of the same issues as the other BSDs. Any time anyone makes claims like those in the site you reference, they can be checked, verified, refuted, whatever. Read up on others' responses to them if you want to learn more. But really, if you're not that familiar with the BSDs, then just take as given the fact that the difference in security features is not going to affect most BSD users, nor is it likely to affect you, unless you are doing out of the ordinary things that would require more security knowledge, anyway, at which point you'd already have enough information to make an informed choice. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mhd · 2021-12-29 18:20 This might be a Theo-logical question. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thawkth · 2021-12-29 18:32 Hopefully you get whatever answers you seek here but I doubt you will. Trying three related operating systems pales in comparison to your stated goals but either way, I hope you find the answer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-12-29 18:58 I think you're missing a couple other groups: * People annoyed with OpenBSD zealots. (No where near as bad as GPL zealots, but they exist.) * People who do not like Theo for whatever reason. OpenBSD is great for a few select niches, and I would use it if I needed a system in those niches. In my opinion, other BSDs are better in other niches. But the only thing that matters is what works for you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-12-29 19:06 Depending on what you're trying to do, NetBSD can be the best choice. Or OpenBSD might be the best choice. Or FreeBSD might be the best choice. Heck, maybe even DragonflyBSD... The best choice depends on what you want to do and if the OS you're using has a limitation you can't live with. I will say, considering your initial post, you're over thinking "security." All BSD's used for Desktop computing are significantly more secure than Windows. Be that from design, or obscurity. When folks worry about security in this realm of computing, they're mostly thinking about securing transactions and PII on servers or public net connections. Personally I use FreeBSD for desktop and server. I use NetBSD non-x86_64 machines (looking at my desk, a growing amount of them.), and when Hammer2 comes out, I'll probably give Dragonfly a spin again and compare it to some of my FreeBSD server to take over some compute workloads I have. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PunishedRaion · 2021-12-29 19:18 Lemme preface with: I don't hate OpenBSD, I respect the project despite my gripes with it and criticisms I will mention here. I respectfully ask that the OpenBSD guys reading this do not take this personally, I am not against or attacking you. OpenBSD is a controversial system because it makes claims that while "freestanding" are correct, bring criticism because academics, users and sysadmins all cannot agree on what's the best model. OpenBSD is a "No compromise, simplicity is security." OpenBSD is the same level of sophistication as the AK-M or M1 Garand. It's robust, simple and derives its reliability and security solely from its ability to exist and operate in harsh conditions. An AK-M (erroneously called the AK-47) will operate in conditions that more sophisticated weapons will not because it's not delicate, it's not precision, and it was designed to be operated by uneducated Soviet peasants who were illiterate, much less unable to understand maintenance unless it was shoved down their throats. By comparison, I'd compare FreeBSD and GNU/Linux's models to be more akin to say, an AR-15/M-16 or even the FN F2000. They're smooth, complex, have sophisticated mandatory access controls (i.e. Apparmor or SELinux, or TrustedBSD), and lots and lots of features that OpenBSD does not. They're equally capable of being reliable, but you cannot throw an F2000 or M-16 into the dirt, out of moving vehicles or other things the same way. They're precision weapons, and similarly, FreeBSD and Linux are more intolerant of neglect and incompetency. Following me? The specifics I see that cause OpenBSD to get ridicule include: * A removal of many useful features because of nebulous security reasons. SMT, loadable kernel mods, linux emulation etc. * Giant locking in the kernel which hurts bottom line performance, especially for network usage. * lack of mandatory access controls or other sophisticated trusted features. Pledge() and unveil() are useful though. * Community elitism. OpenBSD devs and users, including honcho Theo, are really elitist, intolerant of differing opinions, and often include abusive language that wouldn't be tolerated in other projects. I'm not saying it's right or wrong, but I'm just saying that it can be intimidating to be a new OpenBSD user and be a total fish out of water. It took me years to work up the courage to talk to the users regularly. * Refusal to adopt a journaling FS. Everyone else agrees soft dependencies don't offer useful performance or simplicity over journaling FS, and every incarnation of UFS is dreadfully slow compared to even the heavyweight ZFS. Compared to the awful ext4 in GNU/Linux, it's no contest (ext is a bad filesystem though), and to the rather good XFS, it gets wiped every time. NetBSD is the only one with any kind of sane implementation, and it's still quite a bit slower. In any case, I know that some people are gonna take this the wrong way, so let me conclude: It doesn't matter the OS you use. Any can be insecure if used correctly. Security is a process, and as someone who spends a lot of time on obsolete systems, sometimes inferior security doesn't matter if nobody's actually poking your server for the right exploits. OpenBSD has a purpose, and has been instrumental in bringing good projects out. Everyone benefits from OpenBSD. Let's not drag such an important group through the mud. OpenBSD ain't for me, but it's not an unusable pile of trash. Just a rather limited, and primitive, OS that makes some dubious claims according to academics and sysadmins who probably could do with shaving a bit of their beards off. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- some_nihilistic_Cunt · 2021-12-29 19:22 Most eloquently stated dude! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- desal · 2021-12-29 20:07 true. love both myself but yeah people jealously put openbsd down . less handholding than freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- desal · 2021-12-29 20:08 netbsd isn't outdated, but they do support a lot of outdated devices ---------------------------------------------------------------------- desal · 2021-12-29 20:09 oh shit legend in the flesh ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nu0or · 2021-12-29 20:22 this ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nu0or · 2021-12-29 20:24 ufs is slow compared to zfs? really? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rdcldrmr · 2021-12-29 20:30 > I think you're missing a couple other groups And I think you missed that I'm more or less directly referring to you and your other comments here in my third bulletpoint... > OpenBSD is great for a few select niches Let's be real: this is a roundabout way of saying OpenBSD has very limited usefulness, which is not true. Maybe it doesn't fit your needs and that's alright. Take a step back and enjoy your choice of FreeBSD, but don't be the very zealout you're complaining about just to self- validate that choice. > People annoyed with OpenBSD zealots > People who do not like Theo for whatever reason. You can use any software without ever interacting with the people who make or use it if you're so inclined. If you **hate** a software project because you just don't like one of the developers... I don't know what to tell you. That's a special level of immaturity. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-12-29 21:14 > > I think you're missing a couple other groups > And I think you missed that I'm more or less directly referring to you and your other comments here in my third bulletpoint... You're referring to me? You don't even know me. Per your third bullet point: > A small subset of passionate FreeBSD users, because OpenBSD outpaces it in all areas of security (see the comments in this thread) I'm not a passionate FreeBSD user. I use FreeBSD equally with NetBSD, Mageia Linux, and Slackware. Of the BSD's, I am most familiar with it because of ZFS support and Bhyve, both of which I need for my job, hence my flare. Secondly, I don't give a rats ass about security in most situations. (Since folks will nitpick, I said most, not all. Public facing services should be secured based on what they host.) So the third bullet point doesn't apply to me in that regard either. But nice try saying "you". > > OpenBSD is great for a few select niches > Let's be real: this is a roundabout way of saying OpenBSD has very limited usefulness, which is not true. Maybe it doesn't fit your needs and that's alright. Again, bullshit. OpenBSD excels at what they designed it for, security. It lags behind in some other things, some of which it's not designed for. 3d Acceleration with Nvidia drivers? Nope, because it requires non-free driver blobs (Which it's not designed for, and nVidia won't provide). Virtualization? Various filesystems? Compatibility Layers? No because it's not designed for it. Can you use it as a typical desktop? Sure, you can. And you can be perfectly happy with it. I never said otherwise. However, if you're trying to use the best tool for the job, OpenBSD is a good choice for some jobs, and not a good choice for others. Anyway, your comments don't address my two bullet points, which leads me to believe you're just trying to argue and project for the sake of arguing. Some folks are annoyed by Zealots who proclaim theirs is the best above all. Some folks are put off by Theo. The later of which is the entire reason OpenBSD came to be in the first place. As for me? Despite what you may have warped in your head, I have no hatred of OpenBSD, and would totally consider it as my first choice for a gateway, firewall, thinkpad, or router OS. So no point in calling me "a passionate FreeBSD user who hates OpenBSD because it's better than FreeBSD at security..." If anything, you sound like you're falling into one of my bullet points. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- loudle · 2021-12-29 21:35 what's up with hammer2? it's the default rootfs in dragonfly, so i assumed it was stable lol ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-12-29 21:40 It's stable, but as far as I know, not feature complete. It should eventually become a feature competitive copyfree replacement for ZFS. And with it being designed specifically for DBSD's and DBSD's core scalability, I think it might end up a good OS for heavy compute/data workloads. (Something I will be dipping my toes into in the next couple of years.) I used DBSD before in the past for a basic desktop machine and it was enjoyable, but nothing special compared to the other BSDs. I think Hammer 2 + Epyc machines could bring them a new found audience. Matt Dillon is pretty heavy into Threadripper workstations if I recall mailing list comments. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- loudle · 2021-12-29 21:40 oh wow, that's all quite exciting! i'll have to keep an eye out, thanks :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-12-29 21:49 Here you go: https://gitweb.dragonflybsd.org/dragonfly.git/blob/HEAD:/sys/vfs/hamme r2/DESIGN ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koldkalamity · 2021-12-30 00:09 Avoid all scourge telling you BSD/Linux is insecure or inefficient or whatever. The tech runs the internet for good reason. That it's free is a bonus some pricks choose to get rustled over. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- SoCZ6L5g · 2021-12-30 00:53 Right on, it'sall about goals amd use case. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- distark · 2021-12-30 01:35 I love them all, freebsd is arguably the easiest starting point as (much like the Linux ecosystem) it's got allot of compatibility available to it.. this can be daunting however and maybe you'd like to learn something simpler? Really depends on your goals... I've never been hacked by running any of them (20+ years) so don't stress and play it sensible, pf for example is fantastic to learn. Either way, they're all fun (cause I love UNIX per-se) and I enjoy running them when I can find an excuse to do so. (Sadly less and less in this cloud era) I'd even think about kicking my Linux desktop habit if any of them had Bluetooth, but meh... Don't worry about the FUD.. spend time getting your hands dirty instead, I really enjoy aspects of all of them and have no time for flinging poop at my friends. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- feversurvival · 2021-12-30 03:33 It seems to me that he enjoys music very much ;) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- feversurvival · 2021-12-30 03:34 Btw, the correct link is https://isopenbsdsecu.re/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mynis · 2021-12-30 05:33 I'm a sysadmin of sorts who tries to avoid reading or writing code when I can. I've dabbled with freebsd and openbsd a bit. My findings more or less were that it's easier to get a lot of things working in freebsd, and a lot of things just aren't even possible to get working in openbsd. But openbsd is still easy enough to get working if you're good at following documentation, and depending on who you ask, it's more secure. The fact that the whole entire tech industry has standardized around openssh for shell access makes me inclined to agree that the devs probably are correct about at least some of their perspectives on security. I realized too while running openbsd that these days, I mostly use a workstation just to run a web browser and an ssh client from. So I probably don't need any of the unique features that come with freebsd. If I was maintaining web servers, I'd probably run debian or openbsd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _w62_ · 2021-12-30 06:32 If you want to go for NetBSD, you may want to check out [CS631](https://youtube.com/c/cs631apue) . Jan Schaumann is a current NetBSD developer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-12-30 11:25 Anything besides a single minded focus on security? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2021-12-30 11:30 Cleanless, easiness of configuration and general simplicity. Being security minded makes you also work more efficiently. Your build tend to be more reliable. Look at the configuration of opensmtpd and tell me it's not cool... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VoidDuck · 2021-12-30 13:46 In my experience, which is for desktop use on FreeBSD: definitely. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mike_elapid · 2021-12-30 16:09 Clean implementation of PPPoE the same as other interfaces. In FreeBSD it is still the old method of using files in /etc/ppp like it was back in actual dialup days. In addition, OpenBSD supports native 1500 mtu over PPPoE via jumbo frames, this is not possible without using an external PPP client in FreeBSD. It has rewritten service daemons for more secure simpler versions that cater for the majority of cases, eg OpenSMTPD, OpenNTPD, ldapd, OpenSSH, OpenBGPD, LibreSSL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-12-30 18:39 There is no way that is right. UFS far out performs ZFS in almost every possible scenario. If you're finding UFS slow you're probably facing disk failure. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nu0or · 2021-12-30 18:44 well, when you make stuff up everything is right.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VoidDuck · 2022-01-02 20:28 >If you're finding UFS slow you're probably facing disk failure. What? No. I did try both filesystems on various machines, with various disks, and FreeBSD was always faster on ZFS than on UFS. I'm not saying ZFS is particularly fast, but UFS (be it with soft updates and/or journaling or not) is definitely slow by modern standards, slower than ZFS and most common Linux filesystems. Of course your mileage may vary depending on the usecase, you probably have some specific usecases where UFS is faster, but that's not the case for an average desktop computer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paspie · 2022-01-06 18:18 OpenBSD is somewhat a polar-opposite of the FSF as far as licenses are concerned (within the realm of open source software), and both sides aim for their approach to be broadly accepted, hence tension. Most operating system projects, including Windows nowadays, make more compromises as license types are inconvenient to bicker over. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Current_Hearing_6138 · 2022-01-06 21:14 Or maybe a Theo-sophical question ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pramsky · 2022-01-12 18:41 Well said. Though this is not limited to the BSD community. There has always been that elitism within the BSD & Linux communities since I started using both in the mid to late 90s. While I have always considered the availability of all these operating systems as choice and love using all of them, some people prefer to spread FUD and start drama. More recently the systemd vs sysvinit vs rc vs . Haiku is in beta now, so maybe the Haiku community will be able to send a representative to the flamewar ring in the near future. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditor66583 · 2022-01-26 04:30 And what does that have to do with security? Openbsd does what it does well, it's not suppost to be modern, it's suppose to function well and it does. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditor66583 · 2022-01-26 04:34 So you wanna criticize operating systems knowing nothing about what your talking about? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2022-01-26 09:14 The OpenBSD developers have specifically decided not to implement these features because of the complexity (and thus chance for security problems) involved in implementing them. It's all about security. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditor66583 · 2022-01-26 14:30 What features? And if something is improved for security, wouldn't that be a good thing? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2022-01-26 19:19 What compelled you to reply to a month old thread with a reply completely pointless on top of that? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditor66583 · 2022-01-26 19:19 Scrolling and wanting to put my 2 cents in ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brickdoge · 2022-01-26 19:27 Well try reading further than that cause nowhere did I criticised any of the BSD's. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditor66583 · 2022-01-26 19:28 What ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brogus_amogus · 2022-01-27 07:45 Old thread I know, but that hasn't been my experience beyond a few people who *really* love systemd for some reason, almost like Lennart Poettering is personally holding them hostage. This "hate" you speak of is definitely the minority and I'm not even sure if you can really call them vocal. So since you're looking for a free OS, allow me to espouse the merits of both Linux and BSD: - Linux has the largest community and the most software support, since it got a bit of a jump start on its life compared to BSD. This means your games are more likely to run on Linux, albeit with some difficulty depending on the distribution and specific game. - If you need to run containers, use Linux (containers exist to solve a problem that the Linux ecosystem itself created, namely getting apps to work consistently on any one of 1,000 unique distributions, but at this point they've become entrenched and there's nothing we can do). - Virtualization: I dare say it's a draw, at least on x86. Linux has KVM, FreeBSD has bhyve and supports Xen. Unfortunately bhyve is not available for my PowerPC-based development workstation, but that is to be expected as it is fairly new. - If you are going to be running non-containerized server applications, FreeBSD wins hands down. Some of the largest websites are backed by FreeBSD, touting its performance and robustness. If you must isolate your applications from each other, jails provide equivalent functionality to containers on Linux - and no need to package an entire OS image with each program, since there's only one FreeBSD. - If you don't mind a lack of (non-free) games and just want a development or multimedia workstation, BSD is pretty similar to Arch Linux in terms of what it can do, although setting it up is generally easier compared to Arch. It really just depends on whether you specifically want systemd, notably absent in all BSD's in favor of simpler solutions. - In general, Linux is somewhat more flexible thanks to a vast library of software, while BSD has a more robust foundation and tends to break less when you install things. Most Linux software that isn't super obscure should also be available for at least FreeBSD. If you're new to the land of UNIX-like systems, I would honestly start with Linux, even if I prefer BSD for my purposes. BSD's hardware support can also apparently be a mixed bag, although it's good enough in my experience. Actually, OpenBSD's hardware support is *great* as long as you don't have an Nvidia graphics card. Software support, though... let's just say it's fine if you don't mind building and running a slightly buggy Common Desktop Environment as your DE.