Revive PacBSD? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thefriedel · 2021-11-16 12:07 I heard of PacBSD (ArchBSD) which is Arch Linux but based on the BSD Kernel. But sadly it's dead. Would it be a good idea to revive PacBSD (more as a hobby project) or will it be a time-waste? (If somebody also wants to maintain/contribute, feel free to comment/send a pm!) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2021-11-16 14:04 Just my opinion, but, I don't see much value in it. I switched from Arch Linux to OpenBSD years ago and today I'm convinced that OpenBSD (the BSDs in general) is a superior system and I don't really miss anything from Arch Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thefriedel · 2021-11-16 14:42 That's the reason, I like Arch (like the pacman, the rolling releasing, the minimalism) and BSD, but so far I saw isn't there an OS which has both ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2021-11-16 15:11 While it is achieved in quite a different way, OpenBSD (for example) has a rolling release like model in the form of daily snapshots. Whenever it's convenient for you just run sysupgrade(8) and press enter a few times. Within 10 minutes you'll be up and running with the current version. OpenBSD's snapshots have proven to be more reliable and convenient than Arch's ad-hoc approach (which, at least back in the day, broke things.) OpenBSD is ideal for me :-). Your mileage may vary. used to be, before Arch adopted systemd. It's a very simple and consistent system, which is easily configured through a few plain text configuration files. The one minor downside I can think of -- and why I sometimes end up running Linux -- is that packages aren't always bleeding edge. Personally, these days I'm fine with that. I don't need (or want) a computer that I need to spend hours maintaining or fixing when something goes wrong. OpenBSD is ideal for me :-). Your milage may vary. Pacman/ABS is nice and all but, for me, not worth the effort of maintaining a separate BSD distribution. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nsp0323 · 2021-11-16 15:11 Personally, I run NetBSD-HEAD with pkgsrc-current, as close as you can get to rolling. Some packages are even newer than on Void Linux, which I use on another machine. I guess you can do the same on _the other BSDs_ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-11-16 16:54 Considering ArchBSD (and I assume PacBSD) were based off FreeBSD, your comments are a bit odd to me. * Pacman => pkg practically the same thing. * Rolling Release => FreeBSD -Current (a couple extra steps required to build and merge of course.) * Minimalism => All the main BSDs are minimal installs. FreeBSD is practically the same thing you're asking for. The other three major BSDs can be operated the same. This is why these ~~Linux/BSD~~ BSD/Linux and GNU/BSDs OSs never get off the ground. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-11-16 16:54 Im Arch user but also FreeBSD user and i would switch to BSD full on if nvidia played nicely ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thefriedel · 2021-11-16 20:25 Thanks! I didn't thought OpenBSD is that 'rolling release'd, I'll give it a try ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crocflamingo · 2021-11-16 21:03 I'm more curious about reviving gentoo/kopenbsd there really just isn't all that much to arch linux, the main thing that separates it from other distros is pacman (which really isn't a special package manager), and I don't see any benefit in it being on BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GreenSage13 · 2021-11-17 00:32 Most projects truthfully die because of the kernel. It's usually when something gets dropped or added in support that the project eventually dies. I've seen this in multiple distros across many platforms. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GreenSage13 · 2021-11-17 00:34 For example there's thousands of folk who left Ubuntu and its flavors because of the various kernel headers that they like to play around with and the big sweeps like that from one patch to the next invalidates a lot of hardware and software installs. All because of the damn headers haha. For example in Xubuntu and often Ubuntu MATE (my preferred Ubuntu) you can't use Wine to its fullest potential because of SSAO and SS3 and other things that the custom/modified kernel headers that come with the distro. I know of course you can compile but the target market folks for Ubuntu, rough estimate about 60% of its base, wouldn't be comfortable enough with the CLI to redo their kernel headers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jeetelongname · 2021-11-17 04:28 What makes you say that? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RandomXUsr · 2021-11-17 08:57 Confused. What is meant by Linux/BSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RandomXUsr · 2021-11-17 09:04 There are so many things to unpack (no pun) with this request. The BSD's are generally not as cutting Edge; which I would argue, makes them more stable. What would a modern Arch style BSD consist of? Forgive my ignorance, but are snaps/flatpaks a thing on BSD? I'm aware of ports, but where would this go? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2021-11-17 10:33 Presumably a Linux Kernel with BSD userland, in contrast to the more commonly discussed BSD Kernel with a GNU userland. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-11-17 13:24 You are correct, sorry, I should have typed it BSD/Linux. My brain doesn't function when writing sometimes. :) I also vaguely recall an attempt at BSD/GNU (BSD userland, Gnu Hurd Kernel), but a quick search doesn't turn up results. That one always befuddled me. I'm not one to dictate, but the things people choose to spend their free time on is curious. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2021-11-17 16:59 Minix 3 is an interesting case of a Minux 3 Micro-kernel paired with a NetBSD userland. I haven't paid much attention to Hurd over the years but I would expect, as the GNU Kernel, a GNU userland would just work better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-11-17 23:01 > Minix 3 is an interesting case of a Minux 3 Micro-kernel paired with a NetBSD userland. With Minux it makes sense, they need a userland and they're BSD licensed. Ditto with everyone else who uses BSD userlands. Where it doesn't make sense to me is trying to make a GNU/BSD. Particularly because they often use FreeBSD as a base, and FreeBSD has much of the GNU userland in ports already. Then there is always the, " *Linux distro* does X arguments", even though pretty much all the main BSD already do X. Case in point, the above 3 points made by the OP. BSD/Linux makes a little more sense to me, but people interested in that path are mainly pissed off about BSD hardware support. So they run off to try to make entire OS's rather than just buy what works or implement/port drivers. It's nearly as much work to make an OS. And that's why, in my opinion, we rarely see those "distros" getting beyond forum posts. (Not to mention, it's just plain easier to GNU/Linux Linux From Scratch distro than try to shoehorn BSD userland from scratch.) Just my two cents. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- -kilix- · 2021-11-18 11:14 Exactly, moving from arch to FreeBSD is very easy and hassle-free. Once FreeBSD is installed, you disable quarterly and you have a rolling-release-like OS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Few_Diamond5020 · 2022-04-18 17:46 dont forget about Gentoo/FreeBSD