Rubenerd: I’m not sure that UNIX won reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LousyMeatStew · 2021-08-30 16:32 My two questions are probably the same as anytime these sorts of discussions crop up: 1) What is UNIX? 2) What is winning? When it comes to what UNIX is, remember that UNIX is essentially [just a trademark](https://www.opengroup.org/membership/forums/platform/unix). It's relevance as a *product* is really only for legacy applications. macOS seems to be the sole exception. I thought that Apple stopped certifying it but it looks like macOS is still registered as part of SUS on both x86 and ARM. But aside from that, you're talking about systems like HP-UX, z/OS, AIX, etc. So based on that definition of UNIX, it's hard to think of a way in which UNIX "won". I'm sure HP, IBM and the like get lots of money in support contracts for their longtime enterprise customers but I don't think that's what anyone had in mind when they set out to "win". Of course, you can extend UNIX to mean "UNIX-like" but I don't know that this means anything, either. Sure, you can include Linux - thereby including most of the web plus devices like Android. And BSD to include all your various routers and consoles. Plus Minix if you want to include every implementation of Intel's Management Engine. And iOS to include all iPhones and iPads while we're at it. I'm not sure what this really gets you, though. Given the breadth of devices, this definition of "UNIX" is fractured enough that it doesn't really mean anything anymore. Do we consider someone a "UNIX user" just because they're using a Samsung Galaxy, Apple iPad or Sony Playstation? All that said, the one way in which I think UNIX has decisively won is in terms of the development philosophy, the New Jersey style derided as [Worse is Better](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worse_is_better). And in this respect, nearly all technology today adheres to that philosophy - including Windows. Of course, this is a double-edged sword because it encourages fundamental flaws to become entrenched over time and make it very difficult to fix those - in a way, I see Wayland, SystemD, and other projects as being a resurrection of the MIT style. And the fact that both are fighting difficult uphill battles to gain acceptance really just hammers home how much UNIX's original design philosophy has won. To be clear, I know that I'm perhaps framing it as a negative but on the flip side, technology wouldn't have advanced at the pace that it did were it not for Unix and the Unix philosophy winning out. Edit: formatting issue ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nukem996 · 2021-08-30 17:16 GNU's not Unix because the FSF knew that while Unix is a great starting point OSes need to evolve to survive. The creators of Unix knew this which is why they started to create plan9. So a strict definition of Unix didn't win but no one ever thought it would. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-30 17:43 If unix won then my sun microsystems stock must be doing great! I probably should go check on it... IMHO the challenge now is to keep FreeBSD and other BSDs from being a second class citizen in ports and obviously part of the issue is that many Linux developers see themselves as, well Linux developers, rather than Unix developers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2021-08-30 21:04 Too late, that’s already happened. There are already quite a few packages that will not run properly outside of Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-30 21:10 I'm glad you mentioned this because BSD is pretty cool as well but like everyone else I am more familiar with Linux. If I may ask a question. What do you think hinders BSD from being as popular if not more popular then Linux. How might this be able to change? I would idealistically LOVE to see solid BSD counterparts to other Linux systems. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-30 21:23 If I understand you correctly then you feel BSD has already fallen irreversibly behind Linux? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-30 21:45 Having lived through the tail end of the Unix wars, I think the reason that Linux is successful is that the major Unix system vendors, Sun, IBM, DEC, SGI, NeXT I guess, were greedy and incompetent, and just imploded. And at that exact instant, Linux was just somewhat ahead of BSD, not by a lot but by enough to make a difference and gain some traction by getting some big names behind it early. Actually if that doesn't keep Torvalds up at night it probably should LOL because if things were just a little different it could have gone the other way. If you look at the advantages that Linux has, it's really just mindshare since Unix is basically a finished product and there is nothing stopping anyone else from making another unix- variants (as Apple demonstrated with Darwin / OSX). And I don't think that Unix is the end-point of computing evolution either - there has to be something great on the other side, and it's probably already being worked on. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-30 21:56 .So do you think BSD could mount a Unix comeback so to speak? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-30 22:16 I program in Ruby on FreeBSD so I know the feeling - finding libraries that work only with Python or Java and then ports and packages that work only on Linux. But even so I still have a lot to work with and it's a great and productive environment. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2021-08-30 22:26 No, not at all. What you’re arguing is that web browser makers have failed because those building web apps and sites build content that only work in google chrome. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-30 22:29 I'm not sure I'm understanding you on this one. 😶 could you please clarify for me? Thank you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-30 22:34 I'm not very good at predictions, but just going by where we are right now, I think Linux has a serious "package hell" and general inconsistency problem that makes BSD look really good by comparison. I would argue today that if FreeBSD (or OpenBSD or whatever) has the ports / packages you need and supports your hardware well, then you're better off using it. So sure, I think that leaves BSD in a pretty good position - just keep extending hardware support and making sure the important packages get ported and theoretically it could surpass Linux at some point. Or maybe something comes out of left field and surpasses them both - tech is always interesting and entertaining. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2021-08-30 22:54 What part are you unclear on? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-31 00:03 We were talking about Linux and BSD not web dev and Chrome. We're you comparing I discussion using that as the analogy? If so I'm not getting it. Sorry 🤦‍♂️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2021-08-31 00:23 Yes, it’s an analogy. You attempted to argue that application developers using linux-only options is somehow a failing in BSD. It is not. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-31 00:30 Ok. understood. I guess that wasn't my take away from that though. There's plenty of Linux devs that are able to work with BSD. I think it was just meant that focus went to Linux and not Unix. That's all. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- stacker9 · 2021-08-31 01:42 I agree on the "inconsistency hell" point. BSD has the advantage of being simpler as far as packages go and more consistent in the way things are done overall. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-31 02:46 You haven't run into the "package hell" issue? I installed KDE Neon a while ago while I liked it, at a certain point I just had to back up my data, nuke the OS and start over. And now barely six months later it seems like I'm headed to that point again - I already have some packages that won't install and don't have a clear idea why or how to fix it, something that basically never happens on FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Chousuke · 2021-08-31 07:57 What Linux distro do you run that has sych problems? As far as I can tell (having used it), the FreeBSD package manager is similar enough to Linux package managers that it would be susceptible to the exact same issues you might have with bad packages on any Linux distribution. That said, I've run Linux for well over a decade and the package manager has very rarely been a problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Vladimir_Chrootin · 2021-08-31 09:42 > at a certain point I just had to back up my data, nuke the OS and start over. Without knowing the specifics of this, I would tend towards classifying this as user error rather than a distro problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-08-31 09:59 I use Kde neon. Well other Linux users have told me that package hell / dependency hell is fairly common and I've read a lot of discussion on it but if you have a different experience that's good. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motific · 2021-08-31 10:27 The focus absolutely does go to linux and not unix, and that extends beyond the OS and through to application development. All developers could write for linux and unix derivatives, the number who do are becoming fewer. I don’t really know what can be done to limit the damage being done by linux’s dominance to other communities. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nerdguy_87 · 2021-08-31 13:27 Thank you for this great comment. I understand the economics in coding is you go where the highest demand is. I guess my feeling is wishful. To much time is spend coding for Microsoft and Apple because of their market shares but in a perfect world both Linux AND BSD could crush both if coders weren't drawn by the need to code for the major platforms for the sake of profit. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- oxamide96 · 2021-09-03 01:31 (asking as a junior developer) what does a developer have to do to make sure their software does not neglect BSD? Is it mostly about compiling and providing binaries for them? Or is it more than that? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-09-03 05:35 That's a good question and I don't know if I have the exact answer. Personally though think it should be much easier for a developer to target a monoithic system like FreeBSD than deal with Linux's innumerable variants, repositories, etc. FreeBSD just has one single ports system, and every port in the system and even the kernel and OS itself is expected to compile cleanly from source. There is also a package system, but I believe it is simply a pre-compiled binary of a port with the default options. I think that gives you a simplicity and longevity as a developer that you wouldn't have on Linux - like a ten year old port should work just fine on every single FreeBSD system in existence (as long is nothing is architecture specific and your dependencies are stable - which they usually are). That sounds great, but in practice, a lot of unix deveopers don't know how to make a FreeBSD port, so what happens is that someone who is comfortable with FreeBSD finds the Linux port, figures out how to compile it for FreebSD (which could be really easy or really difficult), and then creates a port / package for everyone else to use. Then they find something else to do with their time (which is perfectly reasonable), the original developer makes some updates, enhancements, etc and the port / package never picks it the changes. So people end up installing the six month old version of your software. So ideally the developer themselves would create the FreeBSD port and maintain it, but it's certainly understandable that they may not have the skills or incentives. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deojfj · 2021-09-05 19:08 > And I don't think that Unix is the end-point of computing evolution either - there has to be something great on the other side, and it's probably already being worked on. What do you think of [Plan 9](https://www.operating- system.org/betriebssystem/_english/bs-plan9.htm) and [Inferno OS](https://www.operating-system.org/betriebssystem/_english/bs- inferno.htm)? As research OSes go, of course. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- IanArcad · 2021-09-06 06:46 I was really impressed by the ideas in the OS. This is why I love technology - there's always new and better solutions. Unfortunately there's a lot of inertia too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- smorrow · 2021-09-09 11:38 Not the end of the line; see Clive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deojfj · 2021-09-12 15:00 If I'm not mistaken, [Clive has been abandoned since 2016](https://github.com/fjballest/clive), and it hasn't had much community support. What design decisions are interesting in Clive? (I like that it was written in Go.) Also, as a general rule, I'm wary of one-man projects, because even if the man is a genious, more minds (properly aligned) looking at the same problem may produce a more fleshed-out product; also, there are more chances of becoming abandon-ware. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Power-Direct · 2021-09-21 02:01 >GNU is not UNIX Well.. yeah. That's quite literally what GNU stands for, **G** NU's **N** ot **U** nix. RMS's thoughts on UNIX: >I never used Unix (not even for a minute) until after I decided to develop a free replacement for it (the GNU system). I chose that design to follow because it was portable and seemed fairly clean. I was never a fan of Unix; I had some criticisms of it too. But it was OK overall as a model. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vvelox · 2021-09-28 06:29 Most of those don't even work well on Linux. I've often found once brain dead Linux specific stuff starts seeping in, it tends to be very distro dependent and very fragile.