Does the overall BSD community have any opinion at all about the Common Development and Distribution License (CDDL)? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- demetrioussharpe · 2021-07-30 11:47 This license was accepted as a free software license, but was deemed by the Free Software Foundation as being incompatible with the Gnu General Purpose License. I found this incompatibility to be extremely appealing. I would like to hear the community’s opinion on this license. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gondur · 2021-07-30 12:04 Ubuntu found it in an audit compatible. They included zfs. The fsf threatend court cases but nothing happend. So we can assume they are indeed compatible in spirit (while maybe not in letter). That the cddl was rated so harshly by the fsf had most likly more to do with their will to keep any competitor against the gpl down, using any fud available. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-07-30 12:07 The CDDL is a fairly reasonable license. It is pretty much identical to the MPL (Mozilla Public License). The reasons for rejecting it are all about politics, there is nothing technically wrong with it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2021-07-30 14:06 Wasn't it specifically designed to be incompatible with GPL? To prohibit a downstream from GPL'ing their changes? It's basically the same as GPL, except that it applies on a per-file, instead of per-project, basis. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-07-30 14:48 There's also a patent trap clause making it GPL2 incompatible. Ironically a similar clause was added to the GPL3, making it GPL2 incompatible, too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thesleepyadmin · 2021-07-30 15:17 FreeBSD includes CDDL code in its kernel source tree in the form of the ZFS filesystem, dtrace, and a few other supporting tools. So I guess as far as the FreeBSD developers go, they have no issue with it. The CDDL license is not controversial, and is similar in many ways to the Mozilla Public License. It is only incompatible with the GPL because the CDDL states that files cannot be relicensed as something else and must stay as CDDL, whereas the GPL *requires* that files that are part of combined works are relicensed under the GPL. CDDL also applies to files only, but the GPL applies to “combined” and “derived” works (which are defined as part of the license text). BSD/MIT/Apache do not require derived works to be relicensed, and generally only apply to individual files so there is no concept of combined works, and thus they do not conflict with CDDL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Anopheli · 2021-07-30 16:36 No. That claim was put forth by Danese Cooper in 2006. She is incredibly wrong. It has been refuted by basically anyone of significance who was at Sun at the time and involved. Sun management wanted a strong copyleft license for compatibility with the GPL ecosystem. Solaris engineers however mostly had their roots in the BSD community and wanted a permissive license for compatibility with that ecosystem. CDDL was a mediocre compromise in the middle. It was intended by Sun for CDDL to be GPL compatible, and they fully believed it was they released it. The FSF saw it as a competing license and declared it incompatible over contrived technicalities, which they would not fully explain for over a decade. Remember, this is just a few years after Ballmer declared Linux to be a cancer that would force your company’s secrets into the public. SCO vs IBM was in full swing and still scary. There was a general perception at this time (and there still is) that large commercial software companies were trying to strangle Linux, or subvert the open source movement to their profit. I think it’s reasonable to infer that the FSF saw Sun establishing its own license as a threat. So we got a license holy war instead of a powerful, universal file system across all Unixlike operating systems. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- system-user · 2021-07-30 23:56 My general concern with the CDDL and BSD licenses is that they are aligned with a healthy software development life cycle that benefits all, where as GPL v3 is a ridiculous land grab for code which requires developers to allow their works to be re-licensed into the socially toxic FSF ecosystem and its often pedantic political bullshit. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PunishedRaion · 2021-07-31 03:20 The CDDL is fantastic for what it is. Its a file-based copyleft that was made to screw over the GNU GPL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- distark · 2021-07-31 13:00 CDDL was used by sun in a last minute "hail Mary" to preserve all their awesome work and to make it open when oracle was looming to acquire them.. I was a bsd+Linux and sun sysadmin at the time and I was extremely happy to see stuff like zfs saved (for the rest of us) when this happened. CDDL is generally well thought of and respected in my experience and I'm very glad that Ubuntu feels the same. I'm not much of a fan of GPLv2