What are your experiences with VPS providers using *BSD? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-07-26 22:04 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mrdeworde · 2021-07-27 04:30 I used Francisco's - BuyVM. It was my first VPS and had the 3 main flavours represented IIR (definitely NetBSD and FreeBSD, not 100% sure if it had OpenBSD). They were pretty good about having the ISOs available and up to date, and they had an easy deployment (click to deploy) set up for some of them. Overall, not a bad experience by any means. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Grimm665 · 2021-07-27 04:33 OpenBSD on Vultr has been a good experience for me so far. I'm running my email server on one of their $6/mo high-frequency instances. Their virtual environment seems fine with it, no device issues or anything like that, and no fussing with custom ISOs, they let you select OpenBSD right from the start. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-27 06:59 I assume two out of 7 threads being cross-posted here (because they are both relevant to general BSD discussion *and* the project) is too much for your liking? I can assure you that the majority of topics (which have a scope limited to the project) are only being discussed there and are not being spammed all over the place. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-27 07:03 Hadn't heard of that provider, yet! Good to hear that there's some smaller ones out there that are actually doing pretty well. Thanks for sharing! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-27 07:07 No customized installations with additional drivers and nontransparent changes to the system? That's how it's done! Looks like most people who use Vultr have only good things to say about them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Grimm665 · 2021-07-27 11:54 ya they're good. Only thing I had to do was open a support ticket to request port 25 to be opened, they block it by default for all new instances. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dr_cheese_stick · 2021-07-27 12:29 I use prgmr. It was stupid easy to install OpenBSD, and they're very transparent in their blog posts (https://prgmr.com/blog/). I've been happy with them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- craftkiller · 2021-07-27 15:19 I use vultr with FreeBSD. They let you upload ISOs and boot into the installer with KVM access through the web, so you can install pretty much any OS you want and end up with a stock system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- QGRr2t · 2021-07-27 17:14 Hetzner have the BSDs in their custom ISO selection, but not as one of the four 'instant on' VPS creation images (Debian, CentOS, Ubuntu and Fedora). I've used FreeBSD and OpenBSD. I originally spawned a FreeBSD 13 VPS on Hetzner to use as a Signal proxy (to replace a CentOS/AlmaLinux image on DO), but couldn't get throughput over 1Gbps. Their Linux images hit multi-gigabit out of the box, so I posted here to ask whether this was a Hetzner limitation or something I can tweak/fix (FreeBSD can go way faster than that ime). I just got a somewhat sarcastic analogy in reply insinuating that FreeBSD can't carry traffic that fast compared to Linux. I guess I dreamt the whole Netflix 100Gbps thing. :p I just went back to Linux, and it's serving traffic at 10Gbps no sweat now on a new server. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-28 06:18 This one looks pretty nice, didn't know it before. I really like the "we don't assume you are stupid" slogan! :) Took a look at the blog, too, and must say that such a level of transparency is indeed nice. Seems to be tailored for a more technical audience rather than the mass market. Hats off for that! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-28 06:22 Yes, the ISO upload seems to be a killer feature in their portfolio. And really it is awesome if you're looking for something that doesn't fit into the "off-the-shelf" category. Guess this is why quite some of the illumos guys use vultr, too. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-28 06:34 Oh yes, I remember the topic. Wasn't it somebody replying about different car brands? It also made me shake my head over that ignorance. However I admit that I've struggled with throughput issues and FreeBSD even on bare metal as well. We've still got a considerable fleet of FreeBSD servers at work (decreasing in numbers sadly as the focus is Linux these days) and they all do 1Gbps. Attempts to use FreeBSD for an internal backup storage (for the love of ZFS) were eventually canceled because of bad performance. The colleagues in the DC tested two or three different 10Gbps network cards, I think. With each of them Linux saturated the connection out of the box while FreeBSD barely managed to get half as much data through the wire. Ironically FreeBSD-based FreeNAS was mostly up to match with Linux - also out of the box. We did quite a bit of reading and with some tuning could get FreeBSD to improve performance somewhat. But it ended up being considerably worse in comparison with either Linux or FreeNAS. Eventually we had to move on. This pretty much sucks but what can you do? Netflix does some insane optimizations as far as I know. And while they generally try to give their improvements back to upstream FreeBSD, their version is still heavily tuned. So even if stock FreeBSD won't be able to serve 100Gbps I would still think that 40Gbps (or at least 10Gbps!) really should be no problem. Obviously however it is. :( ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dholdrums · 2021-07-28 08:55 I think I've used all the major BSD VPS providers over the years: * RootBSD * John Companies * ARP Networks * Digital Ocean * Amazon EC2 * Vultr * RamNode I'm sure I'm forgetting a few as well. They've all worked fine and I've never had any major problems with any of them (but see my comment below about mounting ISOs on DO). I've now consolidated on Digital Ocean and Vultr, mostly because of price -- 95% of my stuff can be run on the cheap $5 instances, and also their interfaces to deploy droplets are simple and easy to use, I really appreciate that. (I have kept my original RootBSD VPS around for the last 13 years because mail deliverability from their networks is good, the rest of the providers are *somewhat* spotty in this regard.) I should mention that the one thing I absolutely don't like about DO is the fact that their FreeBSD machines cannot mount an ISO, this bit me hard when I missed the `zpool upgrade` part of freebsd-update when going from 12.x to 13.0, so I definitely prefer Vultr for that reason. (Also, DO FreeBSD machines install a bunch of "Digital Ocean FreeBSD cloud management" garbage that I immediately remove with Ansible. It's a minor annoyance.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-29 03:15 Interesting, thanks for sharing! If you have only one VPS on RootBSD, it might have been by random chance that you've got an IP that worked well for mail, I think. Might also be due to it be a less well-known provider. The big ones are often used for spam attempts and thus a lot of IPs get a bad reputation regarding mail pretty quickly. Agree that consolidation makes sense and that low price is a pretty compelling reason to chose one provider over another. What did you have to do with DO after the incomplete upgrade to 13.0? It sounds that recovery is more complicated than with Vultr where you can boot a live system from an ISO if I understood correctly? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dholdrums · 2021-07-29 03:35 > What did you have to do with DO after the incomplete upgrade to 13.0? I keep frequent backups, so I had to wipe the system (re-installed the OS from their interface) and restored from the last snapshot. I didn't lose any data or anything, but it was a major pain to do this. > It sounds that recovery is more complicated than with Vultr where you can boot a live system from an ISO if I understood correctly? Yup. I had the same exact problem on one of my Vultr instances, and the fix was a simple as booting off the ISO, opening up a shell, and running `gpart bootcode -b /boot/pmbr -p /boot/gptzfsboot -i1 vtbd0` on the disk. Took less than 2 minutes to fix. > Interesting, thanks for sharing! If you have only one VPS on RootBSD, it might have been by random chance that you've got an IP that worked well for mail While that's possible, I believe larger ISPs who block mail start with /24 or larger subnets as opposed to individual IPs. I think RootBSD was aggressive about keeping spammers away and kept their netblocks clean from the start. I hope the new owners (NetActuate) do the same. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-07-29 12:24 I've used both Vultr and Contabo for low-resource BSD hosting. FreeBSD, in both cases. No problems to report in either case, it was smooth sailing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-30 06:11 Do you know if the FreeBSD instances that Contabo offer are stock FreeBSD or are in some way customized? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-07-30 14:27 They are very slightly customized. I believe the Contabo instances, at least the Storage instances, ship with ZFS by default. And I think sshd is enabled, which is typical of VPS deployments. Otherwise it appears to be entirely vanilla FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-07-31 05:33 Thanks! But isn't SSH enabled by default unless you select it in the installer? Anyway, going with ZFS makes a lot of sense especially for storage, so I cannot blame them for making that selection either. And with 13.0 it's also the new default. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-08-02 13:53 SSH is, as you said, an installer choice, so I think it's worth noting which services they enable and which ones they don't. At any rate, Contabo offers a really good, pretty much vanilla, FreeBSD experience. Plus the were super inexpensive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- karr0n · 2021-08-08 14:52 I can recommend Contabo as well. Good support, surprisingly good performamce for a rather small price tag and a very smooth sail