Help me decide: which BSD for a first tryout? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goodbyclunky · 2021-06-13 10:50 I'm itching to try out BSD but can't decide whether I should go OpenBSD or FreeBSD. There more I read the more each seems to have its own pro's and cons. I want to learn from the ground up, so OpenBSD seems to have a bit of an edge in therms of sane defaults, simplicity and straightforward documentation, but with FreeBSD a more complete desktop setup seems easier achievable (that's my two cents from what I gather so far). The machine I would dedicate to the project is a Thinkpad X200 that needs a new task. But I have corebooted it and someone told me that OpenBSD has issues with Coreboot. Is that correct? Since I guess that would be something difficult to troubleshoot and fix for a newbie like me, I should maybe avoid this extra problem and go with FreeBSD? Update: thank you everyone for taking the time and effort and provide so much useful information! I believe this will be also useful for others that come after me and find this thread, so it's really great. Thanks a ton! For those who come after me and are interested in my conclusions: My requirements are not extensive, I won't need wine (have no personal use case for Windows, if the requirement should ever arise again, I will employ a dedicated machine). I don't need virtualization, Netflix or docker or anything else fancy for that matter (for that I have my Linux machines). But, the goal is to have working and stable desktop that can be used seamlessly for most standard office tasks, communication, writing, research. And learn the BSD way of things. So, I think I will take the FreeBSD route. The big community and good documentation are a strong argument for me in favor. There also seem to be more tutorials online on how to build a working desktop and configure things in that respect. That might come in handy for me if I hit the wall with the documentation. I'm not inept, but I appreciate the occasional tutorial taking the reader by the hand. I'm attracted by the simplicity of the OpenBSD documentation argument and might try out OpenBSD as well on the side just to have a look, but it may be more something for later, as a side project or for even more specialist tasks or enhanced security at the expense of features, or a server, or to get further down the rabbit hole once I got my feet wet. In the same vein, I will try NetBSD on just to see how that goes in comparison. The route I will take is to start by trying out GhostBSD, just to see what already works on the desktop, to see where are possible, machine related problems and limitations, and to have a general look around :) But then I will switch to vanilla FreeBSD to build from the ground up for the learning experience. Also, the rc init system is an argument for me, so I won't stick with GhostBSD even if it runs well. But that's just idiosyncratic, I'm not knocking OpenRC or anything. Again thanks everyone, I wish everybody a good time! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- truupe · 2021-06-13 11:10 Why not both via Vbox VMs? That way you can try them and compare them side-by-side. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-06-13 11:12 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goodbyclunky · 2021-06-13 11:20 I want to make a serious attempt at running it on bare metal and getting to the level of at least a backup machine I can use for most tasks. May be just me, but virtual machine installs always have this unreal try to play a bit feel to it and I lose interest more quickly. If it runs on bare metal, I somehow have more motivation to fix issues and get it to run as I want. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goodbyclunky · 2021-06-13 11:21 OK...and why is that? Would you mind to elaborate a bit, it's the first time I hear that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-06-13 11:24 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2021-06-13 11:44 It works mostly like that: *the first BSD you will try this is the BSD that you will probably use.* **OpenBSD:** \- slow WiFi \- no Bluetooth at all \- no Netflix \- no WINE \- no serious virtualization (no Windows for example) \- no Linux compat (if you need that) \- slow USB \- no Docker or other container technology \- no Nvidia driver \- old slow FS \+ suspend/resume works \- generally slower in everything **FreeBSD:** \- Bluetooth mostly works for keyboard and mouse only \+ Netflix works but only on Linux browsers in Ubuntu chroot \+ WINE works but lacks comparing to Linux \- WiFi faster then OpenBSD but still slower then Linux \+ good virtualization options (Bhyve/XEN/Virtualbox) \- no Docker \+ great Jails containers (especially with BastilleBSD) \+ binary Nvidia driver \+ ZFS and UFS with Soft Updates Journaling \+ suspend/resume works \+ mostly as fast as Linux (or faster) in most tasks **NetBSD:** \* do not know about WiFi - probably somewhere between OpenBSD and FreeBSD \+ has ZFS \+ very UNIX like \+ smallest memory footprint \- no Netflix \+ WINE works but lacks comparing to Linux and is 64bit only \+ good virtualization options \- no Linux compat (if you need that) \- no Docker or other container technology \- no Nvidia driver \+ supports hardware that you thought does not exist anymore \+ suspend/resume probably works Hope that helps. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xMrIs · 2021-06-13 12:17 >NetBSD: wine is 64bit only , just a notice.. and **there** is linux\_compat on the level of SUSE 13.1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xMrIs · 2021-06-13 12:22 I would say FreeBSD, depends how compatible is your machine there, eg brightness etc. It's my main OS but on my desktop PC only. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- demetrioussharpe · 2021-06-13 12:53 Honestly, you should try GhostBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-06-13 14:49 Not so much a reply, but an extension of your post for OP. Wifi is slower typically due to b/g/n modes being the main modes aviable. AX support for many cards is either there, early days, or none existent. An example I am more familiar with is with FreeBSD in this case. Adrian Chadd has been the main dev handling wifi support for years, took a break off and no one took lead on it. However, Adrian came back last year and looks like has been a slow march towards AX support. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-06-13 14:56 I would say NetBSD may be a good option since the drivers are more readily available built-in to the system. So there is less fussing with not having the drive loaded and then loading it in. Otherwise it would be best to look at the cultures and aspirations of each BSD and evaluate from there. NetBSD wants to be portable, clean, and adhere to the 4.4 BSD design in a modern sense the most. They also are not afraid to experiment with new things in the kernel, such as lua. FreeBSD is geared towards performance and trying to be as general as possible. It also has the largest user base and most developer support. OpenBSD is geared towards security even at the risk of performance loss, breaking configs, and deprecating code believe to be unused. OpenBSD in my opinion though is the simplest in tool set, also a heavy focus on clean code. They are also a little more militant on GPL v BSD licensing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-06-13 15:00 I'd say there is still some value in a VM. Mostly, to see what toolset they offer and which you like most. Also as a dry run through the documentation to see which BSD offers the best documentation that suites you in whatever level of understanding you are at. So that if something goes wrong on a bare metal machine, your working on a BSD with documentation you like the best and are more familiar with. Big thing would be, just do a dry run install and basic tasks in a VM. I won't advise trying to "live in the VM," since I hat doing this myself. But do it just enough to get a taste of documentation and toolset. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Embridioum · 2021-06-13 15:52 That was my first pick as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DoNotAgreeToDisagree · 2021-06-13 18:12 Not sure why "a more complete desktop setup seems easier achievable" on FreeBSD. When you've installed FreeBSD and reboots you land in the shell. Happy XF86ing! (If you're new it'll probably take quite a while before you get a stable GUI running.) When you've installed OpenBSD (and chosen "I want to use X Windows" during install) and reboots, you land in a graphical login manager that brings you to a working FVWM2 after logging in. You're much closer to a working GUI desktop experience after installing OpenBSD than FreeBSD. Provided, of course, that your HW is supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-06-13 18:20 It's a few years old now, but I wrote [an article](https://eerielinux.wordpress.com/2016/08/20/how-to-choose- your-bsd-os-to-begin-with/) about this topic to help newcomers make an informed decision. While a lot has happened since then, the projects of course maintained their identity, so you can still chose based on that information. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- greatwhisper · 2021-06-13 19:57 I would say FreeBSD. I've run FreeBSD for years, and its always my go- to. I've tinkered with OpenBSD, Net BSD, Dragonfly, DesktopBSD (RIP). I always come back to FreeBSD. Relevant: https://distrowatch.com/search-mobile.php?ostype=BSD#simple Also, FWIW, I'm ashamed to admit it, but I've recently been favoring Arch Linux, because of Docker. Docker is broken on BSD and I've become a heavy enough user of Docker that it's hard to live without. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2021-06-13 21:09 Thanks for clarification. I really wanted to use NetBSD about 13 years ago because of if XEN support but something else stopped me ... I do not remember what now :( ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mtemmerm · 2021-06-13 21:40 OpenBSD runs like a charm on my corebooted T500. I would try them all out, having done that - I chose OpenBSD for its cohesiveness. Free and Net are both excellent as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- truupe · 2021-06-13 22:26 I hear you. Running on real hardware is more interesting and obviously a better test of "real-world" environment. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Itchy-Suggestion · 2021-06-13 23:30 Great summary its pretty much my own experience. If you need Windows Virtualization or GUI-Linux OpenBSD is gone right away, Freebsd works if you have the right hardware but sooner or later you will notice lacking software from Linux (some Electron apps might be uff..) that you might need in a business environment. BSDS have their usecases, but they are not general purpose, rather security (openbsd) or network stack & bhyve (freebsd). Are they worth diving into, yes, because it makes you a better Unixer. Edit: My particular problem with Freebsd was that I got into building and compiling lots of third party code to get stuff working that was no hassle on Linux, that made me feel extremely unconfortable in terms of security, importing lots of libraries of npm, entirely losing trust. \+my Wifi Drives (that ran first of all, is already win\^) were like 1/8th of the speed of my normal ones, something that is well known, nothing I can do something about before learning kernel development and learning/reading wifi specs ---------------------------------------------------------------------- --aspergers-- · 2021-06-14 05:43 Seconding this. If OP wants to know more about Ghost BSD in detail: Its FreeBSD made easy, the installer take no time at all, it comes with MATE but you can install KDE, Xfce, ect, common open environments, it has an application GUI in case you find using pkg a new experience, it uses OpenRC making it boot really fast. You can't really go wrong with GhostBSD for an introduction to BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-06-14 09:42 Perhaps you could add DragonflyBSD ? I know that it works the best with a full AMD configuration. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reviewmynotes · 2021-06-14 09:49 Back in the late 90s, I was using FreeBSD as my main desktop system at home. I had it set up to go to a GUI login screen on reboot. So your claim that it can't do that is not only wrong, but was wrong more than 20 years ago. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reviewmynotes · 2021-06-14 09:53 I haven't used it read about NetBSD or OpenBSD recently enough to give a valid impression of those. However, one of my favorite things about FreeBSD is how well documented it is. The FreeBSD Handbook is an excellent source of official advice on how to do things like seeing up printing, performing software updates, managing accounts, etc. I recommend taking a look at it (freebsd.org/handbook) before making your choice. It may be useful enough to influence your decision. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2021-06-14 10:31 There is also NomadBSD. The 'minus' (for me) is that GhostBSD uses OpenRC instead of FreeBSD rc(8) init system. But that may be 'plus' for some Linux users that prefer OpenRC instead. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2021-06-14 10:41 I have recently tried DragonflyBSD in a VM but not much more. I will try to add info about it but not sure how much accurate it will be. **DragonflyBSD:** \* WiFi - probably somewhere between OpenBSD and FreeBSD \- feels like FreeBSD 4.x \- lacks FreeBSD GEOM Storage Framework \+ good SMP code \- Bluetooth mostly works for keyboard and mouse only \- no Netflix \+ WINE works but lacks comparing to Linux (and probably FreeBSD) \- some virtualization options (Virtualbox in DPorts) \- X11 graphics drivers older then on FreeBSD \- no Docker \- no Nvidia driver \- no ZFS \+ has HAMMER/HAMMER2 filesystems \+ suspend/resume probably works \+ mostly faster then Linux and FreeBSD \+ has SWAPCACHE \+ has DNTPD (Network Time Daemon) and DMA (Mail Agent) \- has Jails containers (but without VNET from FreeBSD) \- no Linux compat (if you need that) \- documentation is kinda outdated Hope that helps. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-06-14 10:59 Thanks for the reply, I appreciate that ! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xMrIs · 2021-06-14 13:57 >Edit: My particular problem with Freebsd was that I got into building and compiling lots of third party code to get stuff working that was no hassle on Linux, that made me feel extremely unconfortable in terms of security, importing lots of libraries of npm, entirely losing trust. yes same issue with me I am just using the FreeBSD as main OS but surfing on web etc not office apps, biggest f up there is the issues with the scanner and I f need to scan documents, - xsane on FreeBSD is without a f maintainer , figure it out... no problems for someone that don't rely on printer/scanner/wifi etc , hell we are in the f 2021 but the FreeBSD logic is stuck past 2 decades... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DoNotAgreeToDisagree · 2021-06-14 14:58 Of course you can setup FreeBSD with a GUI. I've made no claim to the contrary. But FreeBSD does not boot into a GUI after install. OpenBSD does, if you chose so during install. Therefore, the statement "It is easier to get a GUI in FreeBSD" is plainly wrong, which is really all I said. I didn't say it was impossible. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- knightjp · 2021-06-15 11:59 GhostBSD is a great project if you don't want to tinker with everything too much and just want a good stable system. Think of it like a Linux distro. Basically the Ubuntu of the BSD world. Personally, if I was moving over to BSD, I would go with vanilla FreeBSD because it is the more popular one and will have the most support. Going Vanilla, will help me setup the system exactly the way I want it and learn while I am doing so. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chrisfrompatra · 2021-06-16 20:57 Just go with FreeBSD but if you are new to freebsd just go with ghostbsd or nomadbsd OpenBSD is somewhat slower unfortunately and has less packages available . ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NitroNilz · 2021-06-17 21:23 I was once like you sitting on the fence gazing over to BSD-Land after getting weary hopping about in the quasi-UNIX Linux plains... My first attempt was NetBSD on a IBM T42 (Thinkpad), but ended up in a boot loop. OpenBSD just worked. I quickly fell in love - at first by the atmosphere, but later in the straight forward- and correctness of things. Docs are awesome, and it's usually not too hard to find guides or good company (Telegram, IRC, mailing lists...) for hand holding. I went on to try ready-for-desktop-FreeBSDs on my more modern laptops (not very much more modern). They worked well, but I seem to have more trouble with them. Especially upgrading between releases. Two completely different laptops and Nomad-/GhostBSD both gave the same error and X wouldn't start after going 13. Also other stuff. All in all they worked well, both have been main systems. Now, though, I am releived after deciding to focus on OpenBSD for a while. Never had upgrading problems (since 6.7). Now I run -CURRENT and upgrade several times a week (in germany a guy runs his big ISP on -CURRENT; Henning Brauer)! I will eventually learn ZFS and vanilla FreeBSD, perhaps even convert some of my Windows refugees I help over to this side (since Netflix and such now is quite easy to set up)? What got me back into OpenBSD was coming across a guide to calibrate the touch screen, and I had a weak machine with Linux Mint on already. I cleared a partition and got OpenBSD installed (according to their FAQ it sounded like a bit of a daunting task, but not at all, eeven for a noob like me!). Touch screen worked out of the box. Some cool things with OpenBSD: * Plug in an Android phone and turn on USB tethering and the correct driver is initiated (IIRC). * CWM is so fun when one gets to know it! * The devs really seem to focus on having their laptop work so details like brightness/volume keys work OOTB. Webcam and sound was just a config away (for security) * Easy to understand what's going on - minimal and lightweight. * Of course: security. No compromise. At the cost of performance, yes. Firefox takes forever to launch. Running basic Xorg and CWM in around 50-70 megs of RAM! * It's late, bed is calling... I fall deeper in love every time! FreeBSD seems more clunky, but with right setup it will be a dream system too! Like Vermadan said: I think the first BSD will be the favorite xD In the end just jump into it, not so important what you go for first. They are all "better" than Linux/Windoze for Unix Lovers.) After conquering BSD-Land I will expand to the Solaris systems and explore illumos-based enterprise Unixen, but that is a story for another thread... ed(it): * s/dan/den * . * wq * % ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goodbyclunky · 2021-06-17 21:50 aw man, you are making this hard again :) :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- probonopd · 2021-06-19 13:59 ...and don't forget to say "hello" to helloSystem :) A FreeBSD based system for "mere mortals" with a focus on simplicity and elegance. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goodbyclunky · 2021-06-19 16:11 Actually, I'm monitoring this! But it's too early stage still for me. I think it's better for me to cut my teeth in a mature system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bgpepi · 2021-06-20 23:47 Not only OpenBSD.... NetBSD also has option from install program sysinst to boot direct to "xdm", and you need user and pass to start X, if you have proper video support :-). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bgpepi · 2021-06-20 23:54 It depends what you need... FreeBSD is a large project more then 9 million lines of code... NetBSD is 7.3 million lines of code... OpenBSD is only 2.7 million lines of code(info from 2018) So OpenBSD is easy to understand and compact with the best documentation from all BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chrisfrompatra · 2021-06-21 06:24 Thats why i like it. Netbsd is better but it doesnt support any of your gpus anyway except you have q vintage pc which i think it would be great for netbsd. On graphics support netbsd is awful even openbsd supports my amd gpu. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kyleW_ne · 2021-06-25 05:45 Sadly the feature to install xorg from the installer in FreeBSD was removed in 5.something. I remember those days too. FreeBSD was easier than some Linux distros to get a desktop going, but nowadays in 11.x, 12.x, 13.x you have to install Xorg with pkg and then your desktop or wm of choice.