BSD on BayTrail ? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-23 11:00 How is BSD support on Intel BayTrail (Z3735F) netbooks with EMMC storage and a 32 bit UEFI ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- notaplumber · 2021-05-23 14:46 OpenBSD will probably be your best bet, a 32-bit EFI bootloader is provided that is able boot amd64 kernels. Remember to use the USB install69.img media and not the .iso. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-23 15:11 Thanks mate ❤️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-05-23 18:10 Any 32-bit OS should boot fine on it. That will skip the whole mess of a UEFI system on these chips. In BSD world, that would leave you with NetBSD, OpenBSD, or FreeBSD. Of those, I believe only NetBSD has tier 1 32-bit support. Although OpenBSD and FreeBSD still work with 32-bit. The low amount of ram these things have, you're better off on 32-bit anyway. I have a BayTrail Z3735G tablet and it just barely works with Linux. Right now I am using Mageia 8 with it. It'll properly boot about 50% of the time. They're about the only distro out there that can install without fuss on these wintabs. Almost all the distros have dropped support for 32-bit, they have no support for 32-bit UEFI on their 64-bit builds, and the few distros that offer 32-bit either have no non-firmware (debian), won't install if you have less than 1.2GB of ram (Debian-nonfree), or are just way out of date (Slackware). I can't imagine BSD support is much better in terms of stability, wifi, touchscreen, etc. But do let us know. I'd much rather run BSDs when possible. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-24 01:10 >Any 32-bit OS should boot fine on it. That will skip the whole mess of a UEFI system on these chips. In BSD world, that would leave you with NetBSD, OpenBSD, or FreeBSD. Of those, I believe only NetBSD has tier 1 32-bit support. Although OpenBSD and FreeBSD still work with 32-bit. >The low amount of ram these things have, you're better off on 32-bit anyway. Thanks alot ❤️ >I have a BayTrail Z3735G tablet and it just barely works with Linux. Right now I am using Mageia 8 with it. It'll properly boot about 50% of the time. They're about the only distro out there that can install without fuss on these wintabs. Almost all the distros have dropped support for 32-bit, they have no support for 32-bit UEFI on their 64-bit builds, and the few distros that offer 32-bit either have no non-firmware (debian), won't install if you have less than 1.2GB of ram (Debian-nonfree), or are just way out of date (Slackware). The condition of Baytrail with a 32 bit Uefi has changed tremendously over the years . Almost all Linux distributions can be booted (+bootia32.efi) in it and everything works just fine . This is more true when it comes to rolling releases . Latest Linux kernel has the best support . Fedora is the out-of-the-box supported distro for 32 bit Uefis . I was using Linuxium's custom Ubuntu in Baytrail until official Ubuntu (19 or previous ) when things went in track with the addition of a bootia32.efi into installation media. At that point only Bluetooth was the issue . In the next release , with a new kernel even Bluetooth started working . For obvious reasons I moved to openSUSE TW minimal kde plasma , which doesn't have support for installing on 32 bit uefi , but the existing Ubuntu's grub was capable of installing openSUSE and later I was able to install package for grub 32 bit and now openSUSE have its own grub . Everything is working now man 😂 and with kde it's smooth for day to day work . You can even play Minecraft on it . For more : https://linux32bituefi.blogspot.com/?m=1 Linuxium : https://linuxiumcomau.blogspot.com/2021/04/canonical-have- announced-release-of.html?m=1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-05-24 02:05 > Almost all Linux distributions can be booted (+bootia32.efi) in it and everything works just fine . I did say: "without fuss" I would say having to edit install images with boot loader files to be a little bit of a fuss I don't want to deal with. Similar to not wanting to fuck around with non-free firmware on debian installs... (And yes, I know they have non-free firmware installs too, I've been around for 20+ years now.) But yes, I know you can boot a 64-bit os with a 32-bit efi file. Hell, you wouldn't even have to do that if you did a netinstall. Yes, I know a whole host of distros would work if you modify /boot/ to include the 32-bit efi file. At that level, all the linuxes are pretty close to the same. No need to raddled through them. My point was 32-bit builds are better suited for devices with 1GB of ram, and you don't have to worry about UEFI issues. As for stability, the Z3735G occasionally runs into kernel panic when booting, sometimes systemd hangs the boot, and occasionally the wifi is spotty. Touch screen works, but userland software (touchegg) is still a bit behind. (The later issue might be better resolved by rolling with a mobile friendly dristro, like postmarketos.) DE's like Xfce have window management issues, DE's like Gnome are too heavy. Wayland is busted. And for the aforementioned touch-egg issues, you can't get a good WM like Fluxbox working since right click doesn't work half the time... Since you have a netbook, your mileage may vary. Anyway, I've rolled a few different distros on the device, they're all not in what I would call usable tablet state. Then again, it's about as good as when Windows 8.1 was on it. I could live with it with a mouse and keyboard, but that sorta defeats the purpose of my device. And FYI, Mageia 8 Kernel 5.10, so a bit newer than the Ubuntu blog you linked. (I'd never touch Ubuntu outside of customer support.) Good luck! Let me know if you get NetBSD or OpenBSD to work on it. I'll be interested to hear its status. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-24 02:14 >I did say: "without fuss" Oh my bad . Thought adding a bootia32.efi file was not a big thing in a BSD subreddit lol . You can try Fedora then , it has out-of-the-box support . No need of going through any fuss . >As for stability, the Z3735G occasionally runs into kernel panic when booting, sometimes systemd hangs, and occasionally wifi is spotty. This can happen when booting some distro's installation medium , especially openSUSE installation media which only supports iso9660 filesystems which is write protected . Booting from an existing grub is the solution here . With Z3735F (Not G) , If you are referring to Regular booting , I have never encountered any major issue after 2018 ( C state bug was a thing in LTS kernels until 20) . With latest Linux kernel and a non-ancient (Debian ) base , there can be no problem at all . Don't know about touch support tho . KDE plasma minimal , XFCE and other lighter gang works just fine ( far more usable than windows 10 ) . This is my main machine . I will give BSD a try when I'm mentally and physically ready for it 😂 . Thanks for your support 😅 Mageia looks cool BTW . Don't know why stability issues happening , may be you can try openSUSE TW or Gecko KDE . ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-05-24 02:27 > > I did say: "without fuss" > Oh my bad . Thought adding a bootia32.efi file was not a big thing in a BSD subreddit lol . Pick and choose what you waste time on. For me, a wintel hobby tablet isn't worth 5 minutes getting a 64-bit distro working on it, when resource wise, it makes significantly more sense to use a 32-bit distro. I mean if this is your only computer, I can see it being worth the time for you. > You can try Fedora then , it has out-of-the-box support . No need of going through any fuss . Why would I need Fedora? It won't work any better or worse on the device than Mageia 8. Not to mention, Fedora is a 64-bit OS, you get minimal CPU performance gain with more ram usage on an already ram depleted device. As I suggested before, if your device has 1GB of ram, such as mine, you'll be better off running a 32-bit. Otherwise you run into ram exhaustion sooner. My mentioning of DE's primary is concerned with touch screen support. Again, I am talking about a tablet. If you have a mouse or fiddle with onscreen-keyboard settings, XFCE works fine on said device. However, using it without a mouse, and not using long-press-click, the mainstream DE's have issues on a 1GB tablet. Again, YMMV since you have a netbook, and we might have differences in what we find acceptable. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-24 02:33 You have 1 GB of ram ? My bad now I can see from where the major performance issues are coming . Z3735f is not that bad with a 64 bit OS with 2gb ram for day to day tasks BTW . The problem with 32 bit OS is that the absence of many programs and packages in Linux (by default ofc). If mageia still panics , freezes and have stability issues on your system , there is something wrong with mageia which is not present in fedora , openSUSE TW and Ubuntu . ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-05-24 02:38 > The problem with 32 bit OS is that the absence of many programs and packages in Linux (by default ofc). That is distro dependent. Unless you're talking about proprietary stuff. Slackware, Mageia, and Debian (the only three Linux I bother to touch on a regular basis) all support 32-bit as tier 1 and should have approximately the same number of packages for both arches. Anyhoo, we're well off topic. You install a BSD yet? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Randa_Rason · 2021-05-24 02:40 >Unless you're talking about proprietary stuff. Mostly Yes . >Anyhoo, we're well off topic. You install a BSD yet? Lol😂 . Nope , will try and give an update here .