Looking for computer to try out BSD reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tritonio · 2021-03-29 18:46 Hi all. I'm a long time Linux and Windows user but I've never really tried BSD. Lately I've been disappointed by the progress in both, with Windows becoming too complex to keep track of all the tracking, and most Linux distros using systemd, that I thought I'd try to get a small computer an install some BSD OS to run it in parallel with my Devuan Linux laptop and see which one I like best. I was thinking of trying out something like this: https://www.asus.com/Displays-Desktops/Mini-PCs/All-series/Mini-PC- PN30/ in hopes that I won't have all the compatibility issues that usually come with laptops and all their integrated devices. But I am a bit worried about the compatibility with that chipset, the CPU is something that I've never heard of before and it has Radeon R2 Graphics. I don't expect to play games on this and I don't know if BSDs normally take advantage of acceleration for youtube or for the desktop itself. I also don't know if I should expect the wifi to work but that's a minor issue and I think I can solve it with some USB card that is supported by BSD. Any tips or advice? Cheers! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Blitztide · 2021-03-29 19:10 I would try a VM first to get to grips with the BSD way of doing things, then just try to install on anything that's on the compatibility list. You may need to double check WiFi chipsets and other peripherals, but I've had no problems getting a basic system running out of the box. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crust_cheese · 2021-03-29 19:38 Do you actually *need* a desktop computer or do you just want something to tinker around with? If it's the latter, you can pick up old/refurbished office PCs much cheaper than this and their hardware is usually very, very generic, i.e. probably supported by almost everything ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-29 19:41 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tritonio · 2021-03-29 20:41 I did consider exactly what you said about getting a refurbished since I could get something for about half the price, but I have some space constraints unfortunately and the price of that Asus isn't that bad anyhow. Oh and yeah it's mostly to tinker with, although for me that sometimes end up being my main computer for quite a long time. At some point I ended up using my raspberry 2B+ as my main PC for months. :-) BTW I did consider installing BSD on raspberry but it didn't seem easy enough to want to spend time on it, especially considering how easier it seemed to install BSD on a VM on my other computers, so I stopped trying with the raspberry. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PitifulView · 2021-03-29 20:43 One of the best bare metal experiences you can have might be on an older thinkpad (like a x220 or T61p). I should warn you that there's a good chance you'll need an amdgpu driver for this (so openbsd/freebsd, but not netbsd). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tritonio · 2021-03-29 20:45 > sparc64 sun machines Mmmmmm.... Those seem great, I'd probably get one to play around with if I had some more space in my house! But space is a bit limited, hence the tiny Asus that I linked... :-( I tried a VM a bit, I'll try that some more. My only concern with VM is that they often get me hooked on some OS or distro, I think it's amazing, and then I try it on real hardware and I end up having way more problems than I'm willing to deal with, instead of switching back to Debian or something which happens to just work on the same hardware. So I thought that maybe this time I'd try getting some real hardware and trying out different BSDs until I find one that works well for that hardware and then sticking to it until I learn it very well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tritonio · 2021-03-29 20:48 > just try to install on anything that's on the compatibility list. Is that compatibility list something that a specific BSD publishes or is there a list published in common? With Linux, *usually* the same kernel version has the same support for hardware regardless of the distro; is there some similar concept for BSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-29 20:50 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- laffer1 · 2021-03-29 21:06 Every BSD pretty much has its own kernel. There are distros like ghost bsd, freenas or pfsense but if you are talking about FreeBSD vs openbsd vs netbsd vs dragonfly vs mirbsd vs MidnightBSD, we all have different hardware support, kernel features etc. usually WiFi and video card drivers are where issues come up between PCs supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crust_cheese · 2021-03-29 21:14 Oh, I confused it with the PN50, which is more powerful, but also more expensive series than the P30. Still maybe something you could look at if you want to have the option to comfortably use it as a daily driver, the PN50 uses 4000U-series AMD APUs so both graphics and CPU is pretty snappy. I don't have experience with RPies. From what I can gather it should be pretty easy just to get FreeBSD installed these days, however wifi isn't supported and that just rules FreeBSD out IMO ---------------------------------------------------------------------- laffer1 · 2021-03-29 21:16 Old think pads are a good choice. I bought a new thinkpad for MidnightBSD development and had to change out the WiFi card for an older intel one but they are 15 dollars on Amazon. The onboard amd gpu wasn’t supported but its usable on uefi buffer and that same thing is supported in FreeBSD 13. It’s a a485. For desktops, ryzen systems work pretty well except for early models like the 1700. Anything 2000 series or newer is good. If you are considering FreeBSD, nvidia gpus have binary drivers. Otherwise you can get away with older intel integrated graphics or amd gpus that are a few years old typically. They have a wiki with support and os versions for it. My gaming pc dual boots with MidnightBSD and windows and works great with a 1080ti and ryzen 3950x for instance. Lowered end models would be fine too. I’d you had more space, I’d supports refurbished workstations. I picked up an hp z420 workstation with 24gb ram and a 1tb hard drive along with 8 core Xeon for like 400 a few years ago. It works great with FreeBSD and MidnightBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- laffer1 · 2021-03-29 21:17 Let me also suggest some sites to help you figure out hardware support. These list what people are using and you can tell if a driver attached or not. [http://bsd-hardware.info/](http://bsd-hardware.info/) and [https://bsdstats.org/](https://bsdstats.org/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crust_cheese · 2021-03-29 21:24 Have a look at the Pinebook Pro too - I know some people love their old Thinkpads, but a Pinebook Pro is cheap, you don't have to hunt it down on eBay, and in terms of battery life and performance it's actually an ok device - someone further down recommended a ThinkPad T61p, that thing is ancient and will most definitely not jive well with YouTube or almost any part of the modern web. And it just seems cool to me that you can charge a Pinebook Pro with your run of the mill 5W phone charger. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tritonio · 2021-03-29 22:25 > Pinebook Pro I was looking at it today, I only knew of PinePhone. But it's ARM based so that rules out Dragonfly. :-) Still, I will be keeping the Pinebook in mind for the future. I mean if I settle on NetBSD of FreeBSD I guess it will be a good choice. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- beowuff · 2021-03-30 00:19 I’ve got FreeBSD on a T430 right now. Everything I’ve tried works, even suspend. Intel video with the i915 works great. I picked it up for $100 a few years ago at a pawn shop. It was missing the cdrom and two keys. I maxed the ram to 16g, swapped out for the best Intel wireless card the bios supports, replaced the missing keys and pointer nub, added an ssd, and put the old spinning rust in a bracket made for the cdrom slot. I think I spent a total of about $450 at the time, which was still cheaper than any deal I could find for the same updated specs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crocflamingo · 2021-03-30 00:58 oh btw check out openbsd, when I first got into BSD I ruled it out but now I tried it and I can't GI back to anything else ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ScratchinCommander · 2021-03-30 01:53 Also https://dmesgd.nycbug.org/index.cgi ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-03-30 05:22 You're going in the right direction here IMO: First figure out what OS you actually want to use, then find hardware that it will run on well. When I was an all Linux person, I knew that there were the BSDs. However I made the mistake of thinking of them the Linux way - as distributions. There is this common misconception of a single "BSD kernel" that the various BSD projects use to build an OS on. That's completely wrong: NetBSD's kernel is very much different from OpenBSD's these days which is completely different from FreeBSD's. While all the projects share a common ancestry, they have diverged *a lot*. A couple of years ago I wrote a blog article to give Linux users an overview of the main BSD systems. It's a bit dated now, but will still give the reader an idea of the main goals and characteristics of the projects. If you're interested in that, have a look [here](https://eerielinux.wordpress.com/2016/08/20/how-to-choose-your- bsd-os-to-begin-with/).