Let's talk about licenses reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcpower03 · 2021-03-14 02:20 So GPL vs BSD, the eternal question. Well I wanted to hear the arguments from both sides, so I'm posting here and on r/linux. ([Link] (https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/m4lkm8/lets_talk_about_licens es/)) I want to hear why you love or hate the GPL and why you love or hate the BSD license (any revision, but please specify). I also encourage you to comment on the Linux post, but please be civil. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pfak · 2021-03-14 02:32 They're both good licenses 🤷‍♂️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcpower03 · 2021-03-14 02:34 Thats fair, I agree thats why I'm looking for some good/bad about both. I'm pretty sure there are some people who feel very strongly for one or for the other, so what I'm hoping is that one of them comments on either post ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-14 02:38 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcpower03 · 2021-03-14 02:42 I like how simple the BSD license is. I can read it in like 30 seconds and I know what permissions it does and does not grant. Probably not the best way to pick a license, but its still nice. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-14 03:17 I just use the unlicense for everything, which is mostly(??) synonymous with the bsd zero clause. unless I was going to do something that'd be useful for like law enforcement or something somehow (like facial recognition), then I'd do gpl ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fnoyanisi · 2021-03-14 03:46 Neither love nor hate towards either of the licenses.... being in such a position is...well childish I think. I am a FreeBSD user and favour the BSD license over GPL. The main reason being its simplicity (especially the 2-clause one). Although I like the idea behind the GPL family licenses, i.e. strictly encouraging free & open source software, I always find myself reading about corner cases of GPL. Projects like LLVM (and many other using the Apache or MIT licenses) show these BSD style permissive licenses still help the widespread use of open source software. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2021-03-14 03:49 ISC ftw ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcpower03 · 2021-03-14 03:50 I agree with you on both GPL and BSD. While I haven't written any public software projects as of yet (we're getting there), I think if and when I do I'll use a BSD license just because of how easy it is to understand. I also on a moral level believe the BSD is more free, you licensed a piece of software from me (whether payed or free) and yoy can do anything you want with it because its yours now ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gumnos · 2021-03-14 03:51 Everything has its own purpose. The choice of license reflects the creator's wishes. Do they want BSD- like freedom for their code to just get it out there; it serves their purpose and they don't care if others take it proprietary downstream and only give credit? Then BSD/MIT/Apache it is. If they want to ensure that nobody can take it proprietary ever? Then a GPL variant. As a user, you have a choice to accept or decline the creator's wishes, take-it-or-leave it. It's a personal line. Corporations tend to prefer BSD-like licenses to mitigate risk, but for personal use, while I lean BSD/MIT/Apache these days, I'm fine with both. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Red_Spork · 2021-03-14 04:29 As a proprietary software developer, I am a big fan of BSD. The GPL is cancer and, as such, it's easiest to just ignore things licensed under it rather than use them and hope that you're using the code in the right way. BSD gives me the freedom to modify and adapt things to my own uses, push changes upstream if I want and if it makes sense, and not be restricted in how I can use the actual open source portion of the code. I don't have to ever worry about the BSD license or MIT license being used against me or my company. All open source code I write gets licensed BSD, or in a couple of cases, public domain, because ultimately I put it out there for the benefit of others and I really don't care what they do with it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2021-03-14 05:21 What I dislike most about the GPL is that the more radical folks that embrace it like it was a religion (and the one true religion of course). So it's mostly a cultural thing. Second is complexity, third the idea of "freedom" for source code over freedom for actual beings. And then I don't like acting as if you were "the chosen one" all that much (e.g. almost hostile towards other Copyleft licenses). It's ok if people like and use the GPL, everyone gets to decide. But the attacks on people who don't embrace it are grotesque. I've written a whole article about that topic [here](https://eerielinux.wordpress.com/2018/01/25/permissive- licensing-is-wrong-no-its-not-2-2/). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bumblebritches57 · 2021-03-14 07:04 My open source (BSD) projects are the basis of my proprietary project. All the gpl FUD is pure propaganda. Frankly, if there was a license that was permissive and was incompatible with copyleft, I’d use it. Fuck their lies, they don’t get to use my work while spreading nonsense about me and my goals and motivation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- OsrsNeedsF2P · 2021-03-14 07:15 I love the GPL license because it breeds open source. Honestly, I'm up for changing my mind but the BSD license just seems like another way to get adoption or another edge over a GPL project. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BadDadBot · 2021-03-14 07:15 Hi up for changing my mind but the bsd license just seems like another way to get adoption or another edge over a gpl project, I'm dad. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- showcontroller · 2021-03-14 07:59 Could always use the original/4 clause BSD license. It has the advertising clause which makes it GPL incompatible. I’ve considered it for projects before, but I usually end up going with the 3 clause. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JamesT868 · 2021-03-14 08:10 Forced freedom isn’t freedom. Therefore GPL isn’t freedom. BSD/MIT is. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bluecliff93 · 2021-03-14 08:19 \> Noooo the *GPL is evil because it wont let me leech on something and take away other users' freedom!!1!!1!!!1!11 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lightray22 · 2021-03-14 11:10 >As a proprietary software developer, I am a big fan of BSD. Pretty much sums up the case for GPL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lightray22 · 2021-03-14 11:13 I disagree. GPL is like a free society with laws protecting it, BSD is like anarchism. BSD gives you the freedom to remove freedom, which is inevitably what happens. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- SoCZ6L5g · 2021-03-14 11:23 Also a proprietary software developer. The GPL saves the company a huge amount of money. If you don't link to any GPL-based libraries, the GCC gives you a complete compilation suite for free. And because it's open source, we can inspect it for back doors and weird behaviour. Why should we, as a company, pay someone else rent to use a compiler with fewer features, that we legally can't take apart to inspect and fix? We can even (and do) make our own additions to GPL projects for our own in-house tools. As long as we don't distribute it, it's explicitly not a GPL violation. So our trade secrets and patents testing methods are safe. No rent owed to anybody. "GPL = communist mind virus" is a ridiculous idea that should have died in the 90s. If you want to build a house and charge people rent, fine. Go ahead! But you don't get to charge rent for access to someone else's house. That's what the GPL prevents. BSD licenses are also cool but the projects I'm aware of seem to be smaller. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xmidnightdreamer · 2021-03-14 11:44 From the user perspective, it’s a great point. I’ve read alot of licenses but the GPL is way too long ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JamesT868 · 2021-03-14 12:08 But you chose to give the software away with the BSD license. Both licenses exist for a reason. Both have their use. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lightray22 · 2021-03-14 12:41 Of course. I'm not saying the proprietary developer should avoid using BSD - just that the open source developer should avoid giving away under BSD. You shouldn't release your open source stuff under BSD if you want to avoid the possibility of subsidizing corporations that don't give back. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gsdhewr · 2021-03-14 14:04 Person A: creates a library, licenses it as BSD so that other people would use it everywhere, they want people to just use it Person B: uses the lib Linux zealot: NOOOOOOO PERSON B IS A LEEEEEEEEEEEEEECH REEEEEE Get out. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gsdhewr · 2021-03-14 14:09 You seems to think that MIT or BSD are not open source, and somehow Rust/clang/go/whatever compilers are not open source and you can't inspect it for back doors and weird behaviour and that you as a company should pay someone else rent to use a compiler. What?????? \> BSD licenses are also cool but the projects I'm aware of seem to be smaller. What???? Have you ever taken a look at any programming language's package manager and what licenses are packages using???? GPL is literally the exception, not the norm. Same with compilers. What the hell?? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AskJeevesIsBest · 2021-03-14 14:11 I don't have any preference one way or the other. I think both help the adoption of free and open source software. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- slewp · 2021-03-14 14:31 They are different and serve somewhat different purposes. This is like asking what are the pros of a rake vs. shovel ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bumblebritches57 · 2021-03-14 16:34 Hmm interesting idea, thanks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwbowen · 2021-03-14 16:40 Bad bot ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2021-03-14 17:17 From a developer’s perspective, I would not touch the GPL with a ten- foot pole. It would restrict my freedoms and the freedoms of anyone interested in contributing to or using my code. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jhonnylanz · 2021-03-14 18:42 I believe it all boils down to this: Do you consider the act of taking away someone else's freedom allowable? If you, like myself, do not, then the GPL is the natural choice. If, on the other hand, you do consider it allowable then any less restrictive license is the natural choice. I don't see any way they could compete, for they serve different purposes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcpower03 · 2021-03-14 19:07 I guess what a lot of people are misunderstanding of my question is that I'm not asking which is 'better' or 'worse', but rather do you value copyleft or not and why. Granted, its probably the way I asked the question however thats really what I want to know, not necessarily which is better or worse ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gumnos · 2021-03-14 19:56 "But all gardening must be done with a rake! If you're not using a rake to dig your holes, the holes aren't truly free!" ;-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bluecliff93 · 2021-03-14 21:02 Let me fix for you Person A: Creates good libre library Persom B: Uses library in evil proprietary software GNU/linux "zealot": Person B is a leech Why get out ? im just saying my opinion, which is you shouldnt have freedom to take away other peoples freedom ---------------------------------------------------------------------- SoCZ6L5g · 2021-03-14 23:13 Of course MIT and BSD are open source! Where did I say they weren't? Nice assumptions, jeez. Clang is also a great project and of course you can inspect it and fork it etc. I didn't write about it because we don't currently use it. It lacks some features of GCC, which is the only reason we don't use it. If it overtakes GCC one day, good! We'll switch to it. Why not. >What???? Have you ever taken a look at any programming language's package manager and what licenses are packages using???? No. :) But my impression from the dependencies on the projects *that I have personally worked on* is GPL licensing is very common on older, larger projects, and MIT and BSD licensing is much more common on newer projects. These tend to be smaller projects, because they are newer. Again, if they overtake the older GPL projects, fine. It's all open source, and it's all cool. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gsdhewr · 2021-03-14 23:31 Yes, Person A creates a library for using, Person B uses it, Linux "What you're referring to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX. Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called "Linux", and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project. There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called "Linux" distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux." zealot goes "Person B IS A LEEECH REEEEEE". Person B would be a leech if he had used GPL and didn't open source his work (if needed be, GPL is so stupid - your software must be GPL, but you can totally take away freedom if you're running your software as a service or internally like NSA, retarded license is retarded, unlike AGPL which at least tried to fix this). No, Person B uses the software as Person A intended and doesn't break the law, get out. It's like condemning someone for sexual assault if he chokes a woman.. during sex... because his wife enjoys it... Get out. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- euphraties247 · 2021-03-15 02:17 I find the larger 'issue' is that it's the people. there is nothing inherently 'wrong' with BSD the issue is you have people using it for massive stuff, and they contribute nothing back in even patches let alone even funding to a slight degree (Yes SONY!). I know they don't *have* to, but it'd be nice if they were actually involved with stuff that didn't involve their "trade secrets". Oh well. Linux won out by sticking with GPLv2 for a reason. The rising tide of the death of SGI ended up raising the entire sphere of Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bluecliff93 · 2021-03-15 05:55 Well i agree that GPL has the problem with software as a service, and AGPL is alot better. But just GPL is still better than MIT/BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RyzenRaider · 2021-03-15 14:23 In my opinion, both licenses are acceptable. It'd be like arguing between whether Pacino or De Niro is the better actor. Regardless of preference, they're both still great. Personally, I lean toward permissive licenses. On social issues, I'm generally libertarian, so I appreciate the extra freedom - and less complication - that permissive licenses offer in that regard. It's generous to offer something to the world with no demand of it being paid back. I have huge respect for sqlite, which goes a step further and is public domain, literally owned by the people. They wrote a great project, and they want anyone and everyone who might find it useful to use it. FreeBSD uses it in pkg, companies have installed it in proprietary/trade secret systems. Call me a hippy, but I like that they want everyone to be better. By contrast, GPL/copyleft generally only wants to share with like-minded projects. If you don't share their beliefs, then you can't play with their stuff. I'm exaggerating the language, but I'd rather that limitation didn't exist. While I understand the GPL intent to ensure free software remains free, I think it kinda misses the point. FreeBSD is free and open source. Apple's Mac OS isn't (although they do release the source for Darwin) and neither is Sony's Playstation OS. Despite this, FreeBSD itself remains free. Apple and Sony even contribute code to FreeBSD without attempting to encroach on the license. FreeBSD would remain free unless the project decided to change their license. And hell, it's their project, it's their right to change their license if they want to. The other aspect about GPL is whether violators are even successfully punished. I know one of the busybox developers (GPL) decided to start his own parallel project of toybox with a BSD license, because busybox was spending lots of resources pursuing violators. Lots of noise, but no results. He just thought to start over with a permissive license and worry less about who used the code. Is the GPL license worth anything if it doesn't stop the violations it was specifically designed to prevent? If there is one thing I like about GPL, it's the ingenious design of using copyright law to protect against code concealed by copyright. That's like digital guerilla warfare. The idea is awesome, I just have doubts about how it's applied/enforced. I know I praised permissive and criticised copyleft. But I'm splitting hairs here - mostly based on preference - and happily install projects using both licenses. Again, in a race with all licenses, proprietary is a distant third, with copyleft and permissive duking it out for first and second. But that's just my ~~asshole~~ opinion. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-19 11:07 Comparing the GPL to the BSD is like comparing apples to pears; they're similar, but they're not the same. They fulfill completely different things; the GPL is a restrictive license that attempts to ensure the user's freedom by making sure that the source code is available and redistributable, whilst the (2-clause, because we don't talk about the 3-clause or the 4-clause license) BSD license is more of a "do whatever you want with it, just credit me" license. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-03-19 11:10 > I have huge respect for sqlite, which goes a step further and is public domain, literally owned by the people. SQLite is only in the public domain in countries that allow you to place things under the public domain; in countries where you can't, it's copyrighted. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RyzenRaider · 2021-03-19 11:41 Is there an example of this? What copyright would apply when the author has basically declared no copyright? Who would own the copyright? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Yubao-Liu · 2021-04-01 14:13 https://choosealicense.com https://choosealicense.com/licenses/ Seems they don’t recommend BSDL, I guess as a permissive license it’s very confusing to find there are four versions of BSDL: one BSD-2, two BSD-3, one BSD-4. Actually there is another BSD-0 which isn’t well known. https://choosealicense.com/appendix/ The second link above gives a very good order of licenses from the most restrictive to the most permissive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- crocflamingo · 2021-04-24 19:06 I mostly use isc but i totally get why one would wanna use gpl