I'm just gonna say it- BSD sucks as a desktop OS, especially on laptops reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 16:52 Here I sit, watching Ubuntu install on the Asus Zenbook UX31E that I bought specifically because it was listed at the FreeBSD wiki as a laptop where everything works. Well, that might be true as far as drivers are concerned but, it was not a nice experience. I followed the install guide and got as far as setting up Gnome and Gnome session manager for graphical logins. Every login, the GUI crapped out and I had to login again. It's a known issue that people discuss on the forums. This is pretty pathetic and a sign that FreeBSD devs don't eat their own dog food. Ok, I'll instead try Window Maker as a desktop environment and I won't do a graphical login. I kinda like the old school look anyway. Cool. Plug in a USB keychain drive? Automount? Nope. More slogging through documentation if you just want USB keychain drives to automount. I could do that, but since I learn how to manually mount drives, let's plug in a drive formatted in EXFAT. After it mounts, FreeBSD can't even read it. Ok. I'll search for how to install EXFAT support in FreeBSD. It can't be that difficult, right? Adding it to most Linux distros I've used was a one line package install. Did I find an easy answer that wouldn't have me slogging through more documentation? Nope. Alright, what about TrueOS. That was looking promising as a desktop BSD. Oh, it's been abandoned. But, it lives on in a fork called GhostBSD. This is the polished BSD for desktop users... Install went great. I'm booted right into the Mate desktop and the network manager is already there (unlike FreeBSD where it has to be manually installed). Automount is even there too. And... it mounts my FAT32 USB keychain drive read only. No problem, someone at the forums will probably help me out... 4 days later and no response to my request so I inquire again only to be told that it should work. Yeah, great. Thanks. It should. It doesn't. There's actually more (like the network manager can't connect to WiFi that requires Captive Portal and also acts like it is connecting to my personal hotspot but, doesn't) but, that's enough for now. So, here I sit, watching Ubuntu install on the laptop I searched out specifically to try FreeBSD (or any BSD for that matter) on. But, see, I'm sure some BSD neckbeard is already typing a response telling me how BSD is for people who like to learn how their computers work and that I should just go back to Linux, Windows, or macOS if I want a system that just works. Ok. Fair enough. But, this is why BSD will never make any inroads onto the desktop. BSD sucks as a desktop OS, especially on laptops. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gojirabsd · 2021-03-04 17:16 You can submit your patches via (bugs|reviews).freebsd.org. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deux3xmachina · 2021-03-04 17:16 I don't have time to type out a detailed response, but it sounds like BSD just "sucks" at meeting your expectations of what a "desktop OS" is. A key example here is that NetworkManager is a huge amalgam of roughly half a million lines of code including JS just to hopefully make connecting to networks easier. (I say hopefully because I find NetworkManager just gets in the way of what I want.) Maybe it's not what you need/want to be a daily driver, but you're clearly interested in using a BSD, so I recommend using one in a VM and taking your time getting to know it and configuring it in a low- stakes environment to do the things you're interested in. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-04 17:51 FWIW even Linux sometimes has trouble on *laptops*, despite being pretty darn good on the desktop side of things. And stuff like wifi and graphics cards tend to be a bit thorny outside of common, well supported models. OS dev is *hard*. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 17:52 I'm clearly venting here a little bit about how poorly things went with FreeBSD & GhostBSD. And, it's probably a little unfair of me to post that here in r/BSD. I did read one person's experience with using OpenBSD on his laptop and from what he wrote, he is convinced that the OpenBSD devs "dogfood" whereas it's becoming pretty obvious that the FreeBSD devs don't. EDIT: I forgot to say, I may try a crack at OpenBSD to see if it's a better laptop experience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-04 17:53 I think OP is after a working out-of-box install first. Problems with the graphical desktop, network/wifi, amd removable media kinda make it hard to do work... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 18:28 I've run a lot of Linux on a lot of laptops and the problems (especially in the last 5 years) are minor compared to what I've experienced with FreeBSD/GhostBSD. BSD clearly has earned its place as a server OS but, still needs some interest and development before it is ready to for the desktop/laptop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unix_hacker · 2021-03-04 19:00 Well, despite slowly adding support for such devices, I don't think OpenBSD or FreeBSD actually wants to gain casual laptop or desktop market share. So your impression is correct. OpenBSD is a research OS for devs and by devs, attempting to please no one else, which is really awesome if you want to participate in the research. FreeBSD is largely a server OS (and I say this as someone who dual boots my GeForce gaming Windows desktop with FreeBSD). As you've mentioned, there have been some distros that have tried to bring a desktop experience to BSD. But if the average \*nix user is running KDE or GNOME... I wonder how much the OS underneath really matters all that much. Might as well stick with Linux with its superior device support and speed. Don't select a worse version of your desktop environment just because you prefer BSD coreutils to GNU coreutils. Not all OSs exist for everyone and every purpose. I'm a big fan of the 9front OS (which doesn't even have a real web browser), and what they say in their FQA may apply here: What do you use Plan 9 for? if you dont know what this is usefull then its not for you ---------------------------------------------------------------------- yourhelpfulfriend · 2021-03-04 20:45 I quite enjoy OpenBSD on my laptops. It's not as automated as Linux, sure, but the payoff is that there are fewer moving parts. I have some sense of what's going on and some trust that stuff won't break. fwiw, gnome 3.38 works well on OpenBSD. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nsp0323 · 2021-03-04 22:22 >Plug in a USB keychain drive? Automount? Nope. Just the way it should be. Please, don't ever change this. Disclaimer: I use NetBSD on my laptop and I won't use anything else. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- woogeroo · 2021-03-04 22:31 The expectations of everyone who wants a desktop OS. Things have moved on since the 90s, battery life and performance make FreeBSD awful for any desktop use. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PDXubaru · 2021-03-04 23:04 “BSD SUCKS! Gnome desktop didn’t work” Wait... does BSD suck or is it the port of gnome that sucks? You do know the BSD team does not actually make Gnome? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PDXubaru · 2021-03-04 23:06 Thank god my desktop isn’t reliant on a battery for power. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jmcunx · 2021-03-04 23:21 I was thinking the same thing. Is is not that difficult setting up sudo (or doas) to allow a specific user to mount/umound USB flash drives without a password. It is a bit of reading, but far safer than using automount. IIRC, automounts is one of the reason Linux ended up with all the freedesktop.org crazyness. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 23:29 Did I say BSD sucks? Or did I say it sucks as a desktop? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PDXubaru · 2021-03-04 23:43 I have no problem with BSD as a desktop, but my desktop is literally the terminal so... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 23:44 So... you wouldn’t know. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PDXubaru · 2021-03-04 23:46 I actually love gnome. I find the paradigm to fit my usage- Little to no mouse. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-04 23:47 To be fair, your experience is likely of a handful of Linux distributions, specifically and the last five years doesn't nearly tell the whole story. I'm not sure *any* BSD has been meant for the Desktop to the degree that mac os/Windows are ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-04 23:51 You don’t know how much I’ve distro hopped (it’s a lot) and I’ve been using Linux since 1997. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- demetrioussharpe · 2021-03-05 00:36 Myself & many others have brought this up & the general FreeBSD community simply doesn’t give a shit about it. You might get a much better experience with GhostBSD. FreeBSD isn’t good for much more than being an ingredient in something else that’s better than itself. And you’re right, they don’t eat their own dog food, as far as using it as their primary desktop OS. From what I understand, many actually run macOS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 03:29 I had high hopes for GhostBSD. It was only slightly better than FreeBSD. I'm guessing it's miles better on a desktop but, as I pointed out in my post, it had some insane issues on a laptop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- demetrioussharpe · 2021-03-05 03:32 GhostBSD is very much a work in progress. However, they’re one of the few groups in the FreeBSD community that’s even working on improving the desktop experience in the BSD world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anthk_ · 2021-03-05 10:00 hotplug and specially hotplug-diskmount works perfectly under OpenBSD. You seem unknowledged by dealing with all BSD's as if they were the same. Learn the manuals again and stop generalizing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anthk_ · 2021-03-05 10:02 Hotplug-diskmount or just bare hotplugd works perfectly under OpenBSD. You can still use the old method, ofc, but if you know your external media is totally realiable, just do it. No freedesktop.org, no dbus, no bullshit. It just works with hotplugd and hotplug-diskmount if you want as quick helper. With Linux udev and such are crazily restarded on design. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anthk_ · 2021-03-05 10:06 >BSD sucks as a desktop OS, especially on laptops. Ah, yes, it sucks: https://sohcahtoa.org.uk/openbsd.html Powersaving: rcctl set apmd flags -A rcctl enable apmd rcctl start apmd Suspend: zzz Hibernate: ZZZ Automount: pkg_add hotplug-diskmount less /usr/local/share/doc/pkg-readmes/hotplug-diskmount Easy audio mixer: pkg_add cmixer cmixer (as a user) Wireless: ifconfig -a echo "join essid wpakey password" >> /etc/hostname.run0 #(my wifi if) echo "dhcp" >> /etc/hostname.run0 sh /etc/netstart # No wpa-supplicant neede except for eduroam, no bullshit. Linux needs so many layers to do the same which is totally ridiculous. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 15:25 >I'm clearly venting here a little bit about how poorly things went with FreeBSD & GhostBSD. And, it's probably a little unfair of me to post that here in r/BSD > >. I did write that in my first reply (and it was in reply to someone else's comments). But, yeah, you're right I am unfamiliar with all BSDs and I was unfairly generalizing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 15:28 Point taken. I was venting and I was unfairly generalizing about BSD when my bad experiences were with FreeBSD / GhostBSD. I did mention in some comments to someone else that I'd read a web page of an individual who wrote about how much better their laptop ran with OpenBSD and I even speculated that I may try and go down that road. But, I do apologize for painting all BSDs as sucky desktop / laptop OSes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 15:30 >but my desktop is literally the terminal so... If you're not running Gnome on FreeBSD then you wouldn't know about the issues that I (and others, go check out the forums) have run into using Gnome and the Gnome session manager. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anthk_ · 2021-03-05 15:42 Yeah. TBH, FreeBSD look and still looks a bit overcomplicated to me as a OpenBSD user, where everything is dumbed down (not idiot proof), but at least you will know in a easier way how something works. The inners are much simple than Linux and FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PDXubaru · 2021-03-05 15:43 For the best experience with gnome I would recommend Debian or Fedora ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 16:00 Fedora's pretty darn good. Not been as impressed with Debian. I know that they are going for stability but, you're left running a lot of old software which can suck in some instances. But, the point was, I was led to believe that if I purchased the right hardware, FreeBSD would be a usable alternative and I wanted the experience and the learning. I was sold a false bill of goods. That remains. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Unredditer · 2021-03-05 16:01 Whenever I've tried using any BSD as a desktop, it has always been one problem after another so I've given up on it and will only use it on servers from now on. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- truupe · 2021-03-05 16:18 Disregarding desktop platforms, I think there's a way too much emphasis on getting linux (and to a much lesser extent, on xBSD) to "seemlessly" work on a laptop. Frankly, the obsession to do so, predominately amongst linux distros, is making linux damn near unusable in it's more traditional server role. Fortunately, I don't see that level of compulsion in the xBSD. But that lesser emphasis results in a less featured desktop/laptop OS. My usual response to most criticisms (in many cases, valid criticisms) of linux/BSD on the laptop is...well, use a Macbook if you want quasi unix functionality on a robust and flexible GUI. Obviously, my argument appears to lend more fire to your claim that BSD sucks as a daily driver. But really the problem is one of expectation. While people much smarter than I can easily get OpenBSD or NetBSD running on a laptop (with all the features one expects of a laptop), I myself wouldn't ever pick either of them as my daily driver. That's not a criticism of Open/NetBSD, but a recognition that neither of them work for me as a "full-featured" laptop or perhaps even a desktop OS. By a similar token, I would never advocate FreeBSD to, say, my technically challenged family members. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-03-05 16:40 BTW- it just occurred to me that you covered everyone of my gripes except for getting EXFAT support. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 18:50 With Debian, if you want newer software you need to change your repos to testing. That stays fairly current. Otherwise, Debian running old software is not understanding the use case. Debian stable is meant to be a rock solid distribution for servers, and environment where you don't want the latest but instead battle tested LTS packages that just get security updates and patches. Edit: Debian testing branch is also fairly stable as in, Ive ran it for a few years and maybe had 1 package break on me? But it goes back to use case. One package breaking isnt optimal for stable because its not optimal for a server environment. Its also an issue we've had in what I have noticed is the past 5 or 6 years. The term stable seems to have changed meaning, while Debian is still standing on what originally was considered stable. I hear Arch users talk about how stable it is. Compared to what it was 10 years ago, yea sure. But to say it is a stable distro? A Stable distro used to mean, I can throw it on the server and run it without having to worry that an update would break anything. That is Debian's definition of stable. At the end of the day, it comes down to a discussion of something I dont see a lot in the Linux community. That is understanding packaging and release engineering. Who care how good KDE feels on manjaro? That is a small part in the greater idea of how a distro manages releases. What is it they define as stable or good enough. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 19:06 Not so much a reply, but an add on. Looking at where funding for both Linux and xBSD projects come from, the majority of funding tends to come from server usage and not users who want a Desktop. Sure, some do donate. I've given a few bucks to Elementary OS (to support development for family members who need a non-technical distro) and NetBSD. But this is not a majority for most of these systems except for niche Linux distros like Elementary, where they are specifically targeting desktop. For those of us who do use them as daily driver (as I have Gentoo, NetBSD, and OpenBSD on my machines), it is very much still a hobbyist thing because that has been the majority of the users for this. A clean, polished feel hasn't been required in the past. It has just always been a bit of a pipe dream. Then we compare that to Windows and Apple. Consumer desktops/laptops are money makers for them. In addition to the above, something I used to hear, but don't anymore. People forget, regardless of how polished Linux and xBSD are, we all know what is "under the hood" is really powerful. And in respect to MacOS and Windows, more freedom. With more freedom comes responsibility. As I tell people who are fairly newish, Linux and BSDs give you the power to do a lot of cooling things, but it comes with consequences. Those consequences are, they will let you bork your system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 19:21 An issue here is the drivers. Its not a linux/BSD problem or a OS dev problem. It is a problem with hardware vendors. Reverse engineering drivers from nothing is extremely difficult, costs a lot of money in equipment (oscilloscopes are not cheap), time and talent. When Nvidia releases a new card and doesnt provide at the very least a specification to use, that is not Linux or xBSD's problem. That is the hardware vendor. So instead, don't buy Nvidia. Buy AMD, who literally goes out of their way to get their drivers in the Kernel. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- truupe · 2021-03-05 19:53 Your point about sources of funding is particularly telling because if you look at the major backers both in terms of straight up donations to the Linux Foundation and direct coding resources, you can see a corporate influence on the direction of linux and that direction is in desktop/laptop (while maintaining a dominant position in the linux side of the server market). Such a push into the desktop/laptop market (to leverage IBM/RedHat's cloud offerings) gives linux a huge edge over the BSDs thus creating the impression (perhaps falsely) that BSD sucks on the desktop/laptop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 21:13 I think you missed the point. FOSS is community driven, instead of writing "bsd sucks on the desktop," take an active role in the development by submitting bug reports and contributing code. After all,it's the only way things YOU want get better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-05 21:16 Sorry? If you want to criticize **OP** for wanting things to *just work*, feel free. But don't trash talk me simply for pointing out the facts. Also, "taking an active role in development" requires a **functional** dev machine... Bugs that break your ability to use the machine are too severe for justing a bug report and going back to what you were doing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-05 21:22 Pardon, but show me anyboy using an *oscilloscope* for this. They might be using a *logic analyzer*, but idk if either are particularly helpful in this context. I agree that a lack of documentation *can* be a legitimate issue, but so is no developer having the actual hardware to test. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 21:26 If you can install and get booted to a terminal environment, congrats, you have a functional dev machine. Not to mention, you don't need bare metal installs for everything. I'm pretty sure most devs use a VM or some QEMU environment for testing fixes to bug in *whatever you want* window manager/desktop environment. As an example. And BSDs have no issue installing I'm Virtual box or QEMU ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-05 21:28 That might be technically true, but I dare you to find me a serious developer on a mainstream project that does *most* of their work in the CLI. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 21:32 But if that's the only workable state your FOSS OS gets you to, then someone does have to start from there. Example, Hector Martin and his M1 Linux port. Granted he has build tools to cross compile and work from his Gentoo machine and control the M1 ihe is working on. But it's not impossible to set up this kind of environment for someone who is serious. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2021-03-05 21:37 That's technically true, but that's highly unusual for an established platform. What we're talking about is standard x86 hardware, not brand new ARM silicon. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 21:47 Yea it is. There was a post earlier that I think sums up FreeBSD a lot. A lot of FreeBSD users are mostly interested in Server use and use MacOS as their daily driver. It's a matter of where developer interests lie. On all the BSDs, it seems the biggest interest is the server. If you want to make it competitive on the Desktop, people need to become developers who want to see that come true. As an example, NetBSD is geared a lot toward research of OS design. Because of this, there may not be a lot of work getting done centered on a stable clean desktop. But that is the priority of the developers and people who are contributing code. Don't take it too much as critisiscm of you or the OP. But if the OP is serious about making a BSD their preferred desktop, it takes people like OP to get in there and make those changes. This is true for me to. If I want to see tool get better, I need to be apart of that change. I would love to see a competitive BSD on the desktop. And I think a lot of us feel the way the OP does, we just maybe need to do the Linux thing and find a way to get together and tackle desktop BSD. Maybe it is getting more people in on GhostBSD to help. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-05 22:02 I've seen oscilloscopes used a lot, but I didn't think about most of them having logic analyzers built into them. So I guess the times I've seen it, people have the oscilloscope because they can have more purpose rather just a logic analyzer. And yea, having the actual hardware is an issue to. Having all possible chipsetas for wifi can start to become a huge expense. Here I think the BSDs do need better channels to ask for hardware donations. I'm sure there are quiet a few people who wouldn't mind donating cards to get them supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BrickFan2020 · 2021-03-07 11:59 Agreed. I use OpenBSD on my Thinkpad as my daily driver. It does everything I need. Granted, hardware support is more limited compared to Linux. However, for any well-supported hardware (I recommend doing some research getting a laptop which is used by the developers), I find it rock solid. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _supert_ · 2021-03-15 10:45 > With Debian, if you want newer software you need to change your repos to testing. If something didn't exist then something would have changed, perhaps everything. stable + backports. . Some people believe that the future is merely hypothetical; its very definition, as hard as it is to understand, bears all the signs of impossible logical fallacies and conceptual idiocy.. Items and phenomenon which defy description have long been described as being "all that." Despite this, many uninformed people insist on "having none of that.". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tcmart14 · 2021-03-15 14:26 Completely forgot about backports. Good mention since Testing branch doesnt really get security updates as stable does. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Nx0Sec · 2021-03-22 04:06 The ONLY gripe I have with Free or any other BSD is the lack of 802.11ac.. I know, I KNOW they're working on it, but I mean, shit.. 802.11ac came and went and now wifi 6 is here. FreeBSD isn't like Linux where you install it and "oh look, everything works" it's an OS where you put in the work to make it work, and sometimes it takes quite awhile to learn how to do it correctly. Also, USB automounting is a huge security risk. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DoNotAgreeToDisagree · 2021-04-08 09:30 I think it makes a huge difference between OpenBSD and FreeBSD that if you say "Yes" to install the X Windows System during install on OpenBSD you're automatically logged into X on boot. FreeBSD sends you into the XFree86 rabbit hole if you want an X session. So contrary to popular belief OpenBSD is often the best OS for newcomers to the BSD family. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-05 20:06 Yeah I am currently making my foray into BSD operating systems. I installed FreeBSD and Gnome on my Thinkpad x230 last night, but I couldn't make anything work. I just installed OpenBSD on that computer and I am installing XFCE. It seems like there are more tutorials and more stuff already works out of the box. I am excited to give this a try! I probably should have tried Arch though instead of going straight from Fedora to BSD! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-05 20:08 Yeah my noob ass couldn't get anything in FreeBSD working on my Thinkpad. Just installed OpenBSD and I am already having much more luck getting stuff working. The screen brightness controls actually work! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Nx0Sec · 2021-06-05 20:08 Arch isn’t all it’s cracked up to be… if you want a good midway between Linux and BSD try Void Linux ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-05 20:12 Well I will take that recommendation to heart. I am kind of a distro hopper so I will probably try that one when I get bored with OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Nx0Sec · 2021-06-05 20:15 Only two operating systems stopped my 8+ years of hopping … void and macOS. I’m sure you’ll like it if you like openbsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-05 20:17 I'm kind of surprised to hear someone openly support Mac OS on a BSD or Linux forum. I love Mac OS but if I say that I tend to get swarmed a bit. As far as mainstream OSes go, it's great if you want stuff like the Adobe Suite, but also a native shell environment that's not powershell. And Spotlight is leagues ahead of windows search. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Nx0Sec · 2021-06-05 20:21 Yeah, you’ll get flamed for it for sure, but I’ve ran Linux as my main OS for well over 20 years now, I could give a shit what some kid that installed it 2 weeks ago and now has a superiority complex thinks. macOS is POSIX compliant, super secure, I can run all my favorite Linux apps AND top tier music production apps not to mention all the apps my work requires me to run. Granted, Big Sur is a little more locked down than I like but it’s not a deal breaker. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-05 20:25 Big Sur was definitely a bit of a step backwards in my opinion. I think that a lot of people just can't understand that it isn't important to everyone that they can swap their laptops ram. Upgradability isn't always the top priority for people and that is okay. People might say that Macs are overpriced but overall for computers of that fit and finish, the comparable Windows-based product will be about the same price. A lot of my bad opinions of Mac OS come from when I had hardly used it and it just seemed different than the Windows 10 that I was used to. The window management is really different from most other operating systems I have used. I think it is great for laptop use and I can be really productive with it, but I didn't learn to appreciate it until I started daily driving it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- leiu6 · 2021-06-09 03:04 I think BSD is definitely more server oriented. Most people who want to run it on their desktop or laptop should probably just install a minimal distro of linux. I personally installed it on my Thinkpad for fun. It is definitely a bit of a learning curve and there are a lot of things that don't work out of the box. But it is fun to learn about.