Is there any REAL advantage of BSD over GNU/Linux? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 10:26 Ok now I feel like these windows users that come to r/linuxquestions and ask if they should change to Linux and what are the advantages over Windows blah blah blah. Let's be more specific. I'm a programmer (or that's what I like to believe), I'm using Qtile (a tilling window manager) and have a pretty minimal and basic setup. I don't use anything fansy and I don't play video games (tho planning to create some when Godot 4.0 releases). So here are some questions: 1. Are there any TRUE advantages over GNU/Linux? Like better performance, smaller system size, more organized directories or even anything else that I'm not aware of? 2. How software on BSD work? First I know that some software are available only for Linux. I heard that BSD have a software that is similar to Wine for Linux and let's you run Linux software. How well it behaves? Also can a program made for let's say freebsd run on other BSD distros like dragonflybsd for example? 3. Which BSD should I use? I care about having tons of packages and as much up to date as possible. Also I want something that will set me started with a minimal setup and I can build my way the way I want! Thanks a lot in advance and sorry If I piss some people off... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unexportedID · 2021-02-15 10:52 Why don‘t you just setup a VM and try out major BSDs to see whether you like them? Should be a piece of cake for a programmer. If you care a lot about Linux-only software that cannot be ported over, then I suggest NetBSD out of all options, or FreeBSD as a second choice, as they have binary compatibility layers for Linux in a somewhat maintained state. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-02-15 11:09 BSDs offers more stability and better structured system. There is no messing around with folder location for some binaries. If you want the newest binaries, you will prefer Linux. But if you are okay to have well tested packages, than BSD will be your OS. I never messed around with the Linux compatibility layer, but should work fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 11:17 Thanks a lot! I don't want to start trying each one in a VM cause my time is really really limited so I want to know some stuff before starting out! Have a nice day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 11:19 What about compiling from source? Will I have at least the latest dependencies so I can compile from source? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ranadoo31 · 2021-02-15 11:20 1. Networking is faster on BSD. It's why Netflix uses it among other companies. Another thread here on reddit from a new user remarked how shocked she was at the smaller install size of FreeBSD. Installation files are in paths that make sense. Documentation is better than anything else. 2. Probably all the software you run also runs on BSD and it's up-to- date. You can use Wine or the Linuxulator which is FreeBSD's Linux emulator and Phoronix claims it runs Linux programs faster than Linux can. (Note: there is no such thing as a "distro" in BSD. One BSD is not the same kernel or anything else as the other. That is a Linux term.) 3. FreeBSD. It's far more widely used and supported. It starts you with a complete, working operating system but doesn't make installation decisions for you or force anything on you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-02-15 11:21 What do you want to compile from sources ? Basically the dependencies needed for a port are also on the ports. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 11:30 I mostly care about libraries like gtkmm. Most Linux distros (including Void Linux which I'm currently in) don't have the latest version (version 4) and neither two dependencies it needs. So yeah, I really care about stuff like that and I'm sure I'll care for a lot of things in the future. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 11:33 Thanks a lot! For the term "distro", I mean DSB distribution. Isn't this a thing? I know BSDs are fully OS but I heard people referring to different BSDs as distributions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-02-15 11:36 If even Linux does not have the packages you want, it will be difficult to find them on BSD: the focus of BSD is stability, so untested packages (newest one without feedback from community) will not be present in the ports or as binary. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2021-02-15 11:51 They're all separate, really. OpenBSD was a fork of NetBSD in...1994? 1996? DragonflyBSD forked from FreeBSD 4.x. But they are all different. I have preferred using OpenBSD as my desktop/daily driver for 15+ years and have used net and free in production through out. I understand time is limited but no one can digest summarize and transmit all the information you would get from a few hours with one or a few in a VM ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ranadoo31 · 2021-02-15 12:00 The term "distro" was created for Linux to describe their method which uses the same kernel but built by cobbling together third party software to create a system. The word "distribution", in BSD, comes from the fact that it was the original copy of UNIX code that was distributed--passed around--to universities for their use but it was all the same copy of UNIX. Do not call them distros. You will rub people the wrong way. Anyone who calls it that is a rank amateur. (Watch as they all pile on here in a few minutes or hours.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reditanian · 2021-02-15 12:02 Look up linux.conf.au on youtube. There have been a couple of FreeBSD talks aimed at a Linux enthusiast audience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- moboforro · 2021-02-15 12:28 Uhm unless you have nostalgic feelings about using UNIX no or want to run a modern operating system on legacy exotic hardware (sparc,alpha,power,mips etc) no, there are no reasons to NOT use linux instead of BSDs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- necro168 · 2021-02-15 12:46 In reality, Network latency fbsd > Linux. Application speed Linux is better than bsd Overall performance Linux beats bsd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unexportedID · 2021-02-15 12:54 For your specific use case (no gaming), any BSD will do great and be probably very similar to others in terms of performance. However, I wouldn't say that is the reason to switch from Linux, especially if you don't have time to explore the possibilities. BSDs are about different culture and philosophy, primarily - more internally consistent (as a whole system), less hacky, less chaotic. There are technically two BSD family trees, in broad terms of internal system similarities, as the second one for each row (OpenBSD, DFBSD) forked from their respective parent at some point: \- NetBSD / OpenBSD \- FreeBSD / DragonFlyBSD My personal preference goes with NetBSD, as the one that resonates with me the most, in terms of system layout, package management (pkgsrc), general philosophy and aesthetics, but this is a matter of taste. As I mentioned before - any BSD should work great for your specific use case. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:01 Thanks a lot, I will do! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:10 I'm not saying that I'm not happy with Linux but I'm open to anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:11 Thanks a lot! I may try them all over time idk. Have a nice day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:12 Makes sense. I will try them all out probably but it will take me some time till I choose. Thanks a lot for everything and have a nice day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:12 I understand, thanks a lot and have a nice day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 13:13 Ok, I'll keep that in mind! Thanks a lot! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- goldfluss · 2021-02-15 13:22 You too! Have a good day, I hope you will try a BSD one day :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vext01 · 2021-02-15 14:48 I disagree. Some parts of Linux are horrible. Some parts of BSD are horrible. For example, iptables makes me cry. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LiberalMasochist · 2021-02-15 16:20 You can always compile the library from source and make install of not in ports. And you could make a port if you want to learn more. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 16:33 Thanks a lot for your time! I'll check that out! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anonymocities · 2021-02-15 16:53 From experience I can recommend freebsd, I've only tried openbsd on tilde.institute but some things I have been unable to compile and other things behave strangely (cpu spikes). [fbsd handbook](https://docs.freebsd.org/en/books/handbook/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 16:54 Thank a lot for your time! Have an amazing day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ranadoo31 · 2021-02-15 17:25 With the next release of FreeBSD 13, we'll have to see about that application speed as Phoronix has shown FreeBSD performance has nearly doubled in a number of their benchmarks. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- teksimian · 2021-02-15 17:35 a sane userland. I hate how no distro makes distinction between packages and base system. freebsd installs everything to /usr/local ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tonedeath · 2021-02-15 17:38 From what I can ascertain and from the few times I've installed a BSD either in a VM or on bare metal, there's no real advantage to using BSD for a desktop computer user. And, I think it's a classic "dog chasing it's own tail" problem- not enough users to get the same level of driver and application support as Linux (similarly, think about how Linux still lags behind macOS & Windows for application support) and users won't come until there's more driver and application support. But, this post has me thinking... do I have a machine that would be good to do a 30 day desktop BSD challenge with? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-02-15 18:40 First, keep in mind there isn't one BSD. Each BSD is quite different. This isn't like GNU/Linux where you have a bunch of operating systems in the same close family mostly using the same upstream software. Each BSD is a distinct operating system with its own in-house development. Answers you get will vary a lot depending on which BSD you are talking about. In my case I'm mostly going to talk about FreeBSD (and its derivatives). Better performance? Yes, usually. Smaller system size? Yes, typically. More organized directories? Yes. Better advanced filesystem support is a big one. Software on the BSDs work the same as on Linux. You download packages from repositories. The BSDs mostly run the same software Linux does, with a few rare exceptions. FreeBSD has a compatibility layer which allows it to run some Linux software. It's a pain to use and rarely works as expected in my experience. No, software built on one BSD does not work on others, they are completely different operating systems. The only exception might be if you try to build something on GhostBSD it might work on another FreeBSD-based system. You probably want GhostBSD for a first go. It's pretty much automatically set up for you so you don't need to configure the desktop from the command line. It has up to date packages and a fairly large collection of software. However, if you want minimal, then install FreeBSD and you'll get started with a command line only. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- SoCZ6L5g · 2021-02-15 20:02 pf and the whole BSD network stack just blows iptables out of the water. It's not even funny. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 20:07 Makes sense to me. Organization in general is something that I care about a lot! Thanks a lot for your time and have an amazing day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 20:10 Yep! The classic problem! That's also the reason that if there's one thing I don't want to do is create another OS. Sucks but it's the truth... Have an amazing day my friend! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 20:12 FreeBSD is my way to go then! Also I heard about DragonFlyBSD. Have you tried it? What got my interest is that it uses a hybrid kernel which got my attention! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- m1k3e · 2021-02-15 20:49 Different tools for different jobs. To wholly write off the BSDs is wrong IMO. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- carliker · 2021-02-15 21:47 Architecturally a microkernel is more reliable. In a monolithic kernel, if a wlan driver has some major crash, you may need a system reboot to recover. I believe for BSD, in this same event, the whole driver chain can be brought down and recovered without rebooting. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 23:48 Linux is not a microkernel though and will go down all the same. Only (certain versions of) Windows could recover from some driver crashes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-15 23:53 Audio is vastly superior on *BSD than on Linux. ALSA and PulseAudio suck. NetBSD's sunaudio based system and OpenBSD's sndio (also available on Void and Alpine Linux, although those only use the sndio server and still the underlying ALSA kernel interface) and probably also FreeBSD's OSS4 based system (and whatever DragonFly has) are actually quality audio subsystems. I hate ALSA and PulseAudio with a passion. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Whoa_throwaway · 2021-02-16 00:52 you can always look at https://www.freshports.org/ to see the version that is in ports. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2021-02-16 02:07 0 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:36 I heard about that and I really wonder cause in so many Linux distros, I never had a major crash for almost the 2 years I'm using Linux ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:36 Don't compare Windows. They crash for no reason LMAO! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- carliker · 2021-02-16 07:37 Really depends on the hardware and maturity of the driver. Using well supported hardware you may never see this. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:38 That's really really interesting! I use never able to make sound work without pulseaudio! Can you please tell me more about that! I'm really interesting for deep information! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:39 Yes probably! Thanks for your time and have a great day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:39 Understandable, have a nice day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 07:40 Thanks a lot, I'll keep that in mind! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 08:28 Basically, PulseAudio has had a lot of issues since the beginning, although people are claiming that they are pretty rare now. But it is still a bloated and annoying piece of software. On the BSD's the audio system is integrated (there is no separate audio server at all, or it was at least designed together with the kernel API, and is as simple as possible) rather than a huge piece of bloat built on top of a mediocre kernel API. There are a lot of things to dislike about PulseAudio, you will have to do some searching if you want to know more. One thing that I will never forget is reading how someone got permanent hearing damage as a result of PulseAudio's idiotic default behavior. The developer of PulseAudio (also the developer of systemd) furthermore has a reputation of being arrogant and simply ignoring and downplaying bug reports. But, again, if you want to know more you will really have to do some research and maybe ask people who are an expert on audio subsystems and the various Linux and *BSD ones in particular. I am just an average user with bad experiences with PulseAudio and ALSA (and good experiences with OpenBSD and NetBSD audio) and who has read quite some negative stuff about PulseAudio. I do know that some of the OpenBSD developers are also musicians who actually use sndio with MIDI instruments. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 09:17 PERMANENT EAR DAMAGE??? WTF???? Could you link about that? It's not that I don't believe you of course, I just want to read about it. > The developer of PulseAudio (also the developer of systemd) Oh I see what you did there ;) Thanks a lot, there got my attention even more! Have an amazing day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 19:02 I can't find the post of the person who claimed that they had actually sustained permanent hearing damage, but it is almost certainly related to [this](https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/2rjiaa/horrible_deci sions_flat_volumes_in_pulseaudio_a/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-16 19:12 Thanks a lot for everything man! I wish you to have an amazing day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RegretComfortable317 · 2021-02-17 10:04 We advantages are minimal at best. It's all about the dialect you wish to speak. For me if I want a desktop system, the tools are the most important thing. For me that is Logic Pro, therefore I use MacOS. If games were your focus you might choose Windows. For the server, I don't need cutting edge tools. I prefer consistency, coherence, and I prefer \*BSD over any Linux as the dialect I want to speak. So in my world, it's Windows/MacOS (desktop) and BSD on servers or VMs. And Linux is the odd one out. If I didn't need Logic Pro X. I would personally switch to BSD as it has more than everything I need to be productive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-17 10:05 I understand! Thanks a lot for your time and have a nice day!