A Trip into FreeBSD reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BlatantMediocrity · 2021-02-14 02:48 FreeBSD on a raspberry pi is definitely less than optimal. I’ve had a much better experience setting it up on x86 and x86_64 devices. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-02-14 09:11 Beginning with FreeBSD on exotic devices is perhaps not the best idea to tell how great it is. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ranadoo31 · 2021-02-14 14:52 Overall she likes FreeBSD but I can't help it but to make these comments. >FreeBSD is also fairly weird. It's familiar-ish, but it's a very different experience. Yes, FreeBSD does not work like Linux. Linux does not work like FreeBSD. Does that make Linux weird. Apparently, yes. >It's just a shame that FreeBSD support for programming languages is so poor in general. She only mentions Rust as a problem. I'm pretty sure all other languages are supported just fine. But I can't comment about Rust other than I'm betting the support is there. Her only other dissing is about rc.conf and rc scripts. Most users only have 10 lines in rc.conf, I'd bet, and never mess with rc scripts. I'm a developer and have rarely needed to look at rc scripts except when I had a problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- craftkiller · 2021-02-14 15:14 > using ports/pkg isn't an option because aarch64 is a tier-2 architecture in FreeBSD land which means that it's not guaranteed to have prebuilt binaries for everything I've heard that arm is going to move to tier 1 soon, but even so, the problem here is the raspberry pi, not FreeBSD. You can just set up poudriere to cross-compile your arm packages from a machine with more ram. If the author had managed to get it running on their 4GB raspberry pi 4 instead of the 1GB raspberry pi 3b, that also probably would have been enough ram to just compile from ports on-device. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cacatl · 2021-02-14 16:40 How is the end user supposed to know what is exotic and what is not? I find the overall state of ARM ports on the BSDs to be a bit questionable. They are unfinished ports with limited device support, and clearly the author of this article was deceived. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-02-14 17:02 This quick to google ("freebsd platforms"). You can [clearly see](https://www.freebsd.org/platforms/) that ARM is on tier 2 ("developmental and niche architectures"). Just follow the link and read about what to expect. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-02-14 17:09 At some point FreeBSD ports maintainers decided to eliminate - packages for languages that use their own package managers. There have been always problems when you mix both systems. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cacatl · 2021-02-14 17:13 I still don't think that's visible enough. Most users don't expect their platform to have 'tiers' of support by a project, open source or not. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-02-14 17:30 But this is not a mere project, it's an operating system. Of course you look at the platform support before installing it. It's running bare metal on the target platforms. Porting userland tools is a piece of cake compared to operating systems. You should also be absolutely sure that there are enough users before using an operating system on a platform or, in worst case, it will be only you who is responsible to report bugs and do all work to support it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cacatl · 2021-02-14 17:43 From a developer's shoes this mentality seems acceptable. For the end user reading comments like this, it can be interpreted as 'go away'. If it were me running a BSD derived project, I'd place ARM and other untested architectures under a kind of beta category, to encourage more users to do actual bug reporting, instead of getting frustrated like the one in this blog post. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2021-02-14 18:00 I am myself a user of niche software on FreeBSD. I am fully aware of the risks. I am also aware of the fact that the software survives on FreeBSD, because I have to actively chase people to support it or even commit patches myself. I don't blame anyone for this. I am thankful that people help me when I need help. I don't find the author very frustrated. She rather seems very resistant against frustration, which is a good trait of character. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2021-02-14 19:49 The NetBSD ARM SBC ports seem pretty complete, certainly the RPi one. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RogerLeigh · 2021-02-20 15:26 Do the FreeBSD foundation need some funding to host and build stuff for "tier 2" platforms? I'd happily fund (or host) such things. When Debian manages to autobuild for every supported platforms, I've never seen why FreeBSD needs the hard split wheir "tier 2" users all have to rebuild the entire world. It makes it really painful. I do understand that it takes time and money to do all that, especially within volunteer projects, but other projects have managed to have outstanding support for "minor" platforms.