What does BSD have against the GPL? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- WoodpeckerNo1 · 2021-01-18 08:15 Just read that the FreeBSD team is working on removing as much GPL based software from the OS as they can, and the users seem happy about it. Then there's obviously the whole BSD license all BSDs share, but... why? What's wrong with the GPL? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dudinax · 2021-01-18 08:34 My guess is the GPL's requirement that if you use GPL'd code in your code, your code also needs to be GPL. BSD license doesn't say that. You can reuse BSD code in proprietary code. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thisisaiken · 2021-01-18 08:37 gpl have clauses that are aimed to corporations, like the fact that any upgrade have to be released with the same licence so it can be integrated into the original project So nobody can download the code, invest a ton of money and sell it as own, or creating a commercial version that actual destroy the original team purpose. but for an os, this is a problem because every change made for their system have to be send back and stick with two licence that you have to include everytime your project use one of them ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-01-18 12:02 The GPL is infectious and makes it hard to use GPL code in a project mainly licensed under a different license. It is questionable if it's even legal to link GPL and BSD licensed code together as the BSD license does not permit relicensing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-01-18 12:14 The GPL is much more restrictive and this makes it cumbersome for developers, especially if they are using different pieces of code under other licenses. Look at ZFS for example. You can't merge ZFS (licensed under the CDDL) into the Linux kernel (GPL). Merging ZFS into FreeBSD was easy because of the license and it meant FreeBSD became _the_ choice for large data storage projects and NAS platforms. The GPL also makes it harder to share code back and forth. A GPL project can accept BSD-licensed code, but the reverse is not true. This means GPLed projects can take code from MIT/BSD licensed projects, but you can't then take their improvements and merge them back into the BSD/MIT licensed projects. It's a royal pain. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2021-01-18 12:16 The BSD license does permit relicensing, at least additive licensing. You can _add_ more restrictions to BSD-licensed code, you just can't remove the original restrictions. This allows you to merge BSD code into GPL projects using the GPL as an additive restriction. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2021-01-18 12:42 The BSD license does not permit you to distribute the BSD licensed work under a different license. To do so, it would have to give you explicit permission but it doesn't. Each BSD license is given directly from the author to the end user. Yes, it is possible to tack additional restrictions on top, but what some people like to do is change the BSD license to a GPL one in a derived work. This is not permitted. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2021-01-18 18:26 You can read about Copyfree here: http://copyfree.org/ Why use Copyfree: http://copyfree.org/policy/why General idea why Copyleft is bad: http://copyfree.org/policy/copyleft And why GPL is not free: http://copyfree.org/standard/rejected (No anchors, so you'll have to scroll.) > GNU General Public License > > Explaining all the reasons this copyleft license has been rejected could fill a book. Start with the fact it is a strongly copyleft license, violating points 2. Free Distribution and 4. Free Combination of the Copyfree Standard Definition. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Seriqolm · 2021-01-24 00:41 Simply the GPL is the software equivalent of The Borg, it assimilates all it touches. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2021-02-03 19:18 They like to be big companies free labor ---------------------------------------------------------------------- demetrioussharpe · 2021-03-06 19:20 BSD-licensed projects already have a license that does exactly what they need it to do. Why would any BSD-licensed project want to keep around software with some other license that does something other than what their own license does? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- yo_99 · 2022-07-19 14:16 more like copycenter