How can I make my own operating system from FreeBSD source code reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eliot3451 · 2020-11-08 09:15 Hello, I am an open source software follower and I noticed that there is a lack of custom operating system for gamers and I found the FreeBSD very promising despite the little popularity besides Linux and there are issues about game compability. I know console firmwares and apple operating systems are based on FreeBSD and I would like to make my own for fun. Any thoughts of this? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kraileth · 2020-11-08 09:42 That's certainly possible - the question is however: Is it feasible? My advice here would be to go to a planning phase first. Write down (as concrete as possible) exactly what you want to accomplish. Then put some thought into *how* you think to best accomplish it. There will probably be either a lack of answers here because some people won't take a project like this seriously. Others will likely advise you to do something else because there's little likelihood of actually finishing something like that. My recommendation would be a different one: If you are interested in a project like this, go ahead. It has a lot of potential for you to learn how operating systems work. If you are ok with the project as a whole "failing" in the end but yourself having built up a fair bit of valuable insights and knowledge, then it might be worth it. If you share at least a scratch of what you want to do here, it will be easier to comment. I've in fact also thought about forking FreeBSD, just for educational reasons. So far I haven't had the time to mess with the innards of the OS but I'd still like to do this at some point. If you decide to attempt something like that - how about teaming up for thoughts and trying to get a few other people in so we can tinker together? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- redditnemo · 2020-11-08 09:55 So you have some time to spare and want to tinker. I would suggest that you investigate the following key points first: - what is working right now on FreeBSD - what could be better - what needs to be done to do this For example: - the most popular game platform right now is Steam - does it work without much hassle? - 3D acceleration is key for games to work properly, does it work out of the box with nvidia and AMD cards? - the selection of linux games is sparse and freebsd is even sparser, how well do linux games work on freebsd, how much trouble is it to set them up? (take a look at what is necessary to run chrome on freebsd, as an example) - for the reason above wine is absolutely crucial to have for more games and there are a lot of features that make wine perform well, namely: vulkan support and f/esync - are these features supported under freebsd? When you have done that you know what needs to be done before starting to fork FreeBSD. By fixing issues with the points above (or the points you identify) you help everyone including your effort to create a gaming OS and, this is the most important point, by integrating these fixes you will hopefully not have to support it alone. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2020-11-08 12:30 I see you're inspired to do great things. That's a nice feeling and I wished there would be more people who think like you and begin to create big things. FreeBSD is already a great system. With nVidia support there is an opportunity to make an OpenSource gaming system. Unfortunately, it's often not enough to make an attractive gaming system. It is more important to attract creators who will make content available for your gaming system. First thing, I would suggest is find others who join your cause. You need more talented people who care about different fields of gaming. The tech side is not the only side. And you cannot care about everything while developing the core system. Marketing, management, finance, design, artists... you need so many different kinds of people. It's hard to lure them with a vision. It needs to be something that has a good plan. The plan will already take at least a year to be created. Many people need to be talked to. From the technical side, you can start with some attractive prototypes and provide evidence that your system is a good way to entertain people. You need to think how you and others get money of this thing. Money is the only thing that counts, especially for game publishers. Go on and do your thing, but many people are going to discourage you, because you try to do "impossible" things that many others have dreamt about. Why should you be the special guy? It's up to you to prove that you're able to do this. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eliot3451 · 2020-11-08 13:05 There was an attempt like this before with steam os but it flopped. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xplosm · 2020-11-08 19:31 This makes a lot of sense. Perhaps after this, the next step would be to build on top of FreeBSD what is needed like FuryBSD and initially GhostBSD did (distribuiting a base, stable and official BSD with a GUI on top,) then when things work to a reasonable degree think what needs to be changed and the main trunk would never change or would be unfeasible in the short/medium run. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kormoraan · 2020-11-08 19:39 you have the wrong idea if you need to ask this question on reddit... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ScrambledAuroras · 2020-11-08 21:13 I have done a teeny tiny bit of FreeBSD but more Linux. Here are some tips: 1. BSDs are, including FreeBSD, structured around a more tight knit userland-kernel integration ([the kernel comes with the userland](https://github.com/freebsd/freebsd)) than Linux (the userland is your own choice, but you need to bring an `init` daemon). 2. The vanilla, official [FreeBSD](https://www.freebsd.org/) and unofficial [FreeBSDDesktop](https://github.com/FreeBSDDesktop) projects also use `drm-kmod` components for GPU side. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GafiQ · 2020-11-25 21:27 Hi! Not a FreeBSD user here. I just like to go over this sub BC I like learning about FreeBSD and I think you might be looking for this: http s://docs.freebsd.org/doc/6.1- RELEASE/usr/share/doc/handbook/kernelconfig-building.html And you could use: https://www.freebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?release(7)