Linux user here. Why should I switch to BSD? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- S-A-R · 2020-09-04 00:28 Unless you have a problem to solve, you shouldn't switch. If you want to learn more about BSD, install it in a VM on Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deafphate · 2020-09-04 00:30 That's a vague question. As a server platform or as a desktop? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pm-me-ur-cattos · 2020-09-04 00:49 You could try it out in a VM. Especially with Open bad, you can administrate your system and read the docs without the internet :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ChamberMySecrets · 2020-09-04 01:06 It's well designed and won't change randomly to follow new fads. Also no ~~cancerd~~ systemd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- toastmaster124 · 2020-09-04 01:10 I find it funny when my phone corrects openbsd with openbad ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pm-me-ur-cattos · 2020-09-04 01:34 Noooooo I can't believe it happened to me too!!!!!!! :( ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pagwin · 2020-09-04 02:43 > Also no ~~cancerd~~ systemd. you can run linux without systemd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kyleW_ne · 2020-09-04 05:12 In one word: stability. I mean that in several senses of the word. Stability as in a package update won't break the base OS (freeBSD example) and that the OS is long term stable (FreeBSD doesn't break compatibility between point releases 12.0, 12.1, and this year 12.2). Security is also a big bonus both from obscurity and by design especially on OpenBSD. Performance is at worst about the same as Linux on FreeBSD and in some cases is a little better or a little worse so you aren't making any huge sacrifices in performance. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kchoudhury · 2020-09-04 06:00 They're broadly similar in ability. If you current ship isn't broken, don't sink it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-09-04 06:45 The trouble you will spend learning a new version of Linux, might as well spend it learning FreeBSD. The Linux kernel is bloated, bugs are maintained to keep backwards compatibility, and now comes with DRM! Encryption keys that you dont control. That's the GPL ethos right? I would like to see more mindshare move to the BSDs. \- Recent convert to FreeBSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-09-04 06:45 Yes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-09-04 07:51 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- achauv1 · 2020-09-04 08:11 Only difference is the kernel. You have Gnome, KDE, Firefox, Chromium, htop, tmux, zsh, etc There is no systemd, lxc, ip, usermod, adduser : those are Linux-only tooling but there are equivalent tools. Both belong to the UNIX family but it seems BSD's kernels have better code quality than Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- arnulfslayer · 2020-09-04 08:22 "Windows user here. Why should I switch to Linux?" Not trying to be a smartass here. What made you switch to Linux? Those reasons/feelings are the same ones that will make you switch to BSD. PS. You can use it without "switching". My daily driver is still Linux, but my "weekends laptop" uses OpenBSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- andregarzia · 2020-09-04 09:15 mostly because you want it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kormoraan · 2020-09-04 09:24 unless you have a problem on Linux you can only solve with BSD, you shouldn't. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- StephaneiAarhus · 2020-09-04 09:53 Easyness of admin' and conf'. The firewall is a breeze. Notice there are challenges too, like BSD tends to be more conservative and runs less software. It has pro and cons. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- WalkingOnFire · 2020-09-04 10:29 NO. Do your own research. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-09-04 11:05 There are many reasons, but the only one that matters is that you decide for yourself that you want to use a BSD variant over Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Ozymandias2112 · 2020-09-04 12:48 This is a good point, and in addition you don’t need to have one size fits all when it comes to operating systems. My servers run FreeBSD, my personal machine runs macOS and my work machine runs Linux. The context switch between them isn’t really bad at all. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-09-04 13:37 For the same reasons every Linux user asks this same question here over and over and over again. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pm-me-ur-cattos · 2020-09-04 14:15 Wait what DRM? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- frankev · 2020-09-04 14:42 Or if you have spare hardware--I run OpenBSD on an old Mac Mini that could no longer reliably run OS X. You can also pick up a used Dell OptiPlex for dirt cheap these days--lots of fun for experimentation purposes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-09-04 14:43 As a desktop platform, though given all the replies here I suppose I should play with it in a VM before making any decisions ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-09-04 14:43 Alright time to go get an open bad VM ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pm-me-ur-cattos · 2020-09-04 14:45 I had a typo in the earlier comment. OpenBSD* ---------------------------------------------------------------------- TheRealLazloFalconi · 2020-09-04 16:02 The only reason to switch is because you want to. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-09-04 17:19 Digital "rights" management. Encryption keys of media giants (like Netflix), embedded in the kernel. It encrypts the video feed to try and prevent people from ripping it. Gets decrypted at the display. You don't control those keys, and without them, you can't watch the content. It's disgusting. It's antithetical to everything Linux is supposed to stand for. Hurd is rolling in the grave that it will inhabit after Stallman stops trying to CPR a 20 year dead baby ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deafphate · 2020-09-04 17:19 I think you'd see the biggest difference running it as a server than a desktop. The package system is different (Gentoo's ports system is similar to FreeBSD's though), and not as bleeding edge as you'd find on many Linux distributions. That aside, I think you'd find most of the software you use available on FreeBSD. Your workflow probably won't change. I personally changed to FreeBSD because the documentation is more complete. I'm getting myself back into C programming, so the documentation is very important to me. Running it as a VM first would be a good idea :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vvelox · 2020-09-04 17:36 So you don't have to spend time de-fucking "helpful" half assed drek. No systemd. This makes administration massively easier. Don't have to check multiple locations for logs... no having to check syslog and systemd like on Linux as stuff gets logged to both and it is incredible inconsistent as to which it is going to be. The audio system actually work. Ports are kept up to date than better than packages on many Linux distros. It is easy to maintain your own package repo. Jails are massively cleaner in design than containers. All relevant base systems utilities are jail aware. Ifconfig was actually maintained and expanded upon. It is not a sprawling mess of a bunch of different badly maintained utilities, some of which just have terrible syntax and readability(i.e. ip). Easier to maintain and work with multiple routing tables. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reebs12 · 2020-09-04 17:38 What kind of problem could be solved only using BSD and not GNU/Linux? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reebs12 · 2020-09-04 17:47 "Gets decrypted at the display." ​ can u not capture it using vokoscreen? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-09-04 18:38 I have no doubt there are work arounds. But that's irrelevant. What is relevant, is that the most popular open source x86 OS, who's license contains a lengthy pre-ramble about user freedom and humanity, who's community ethos is supposed to be of a certain ideology, is now embedding encryption keys that the user doesn't control, as an attempt to maintain control of speech on behalf of the behemoths it's license was created to challenge (the GPL, that is). But that's a predictable outcome of communism. Yes the GPL is communism. It uses the power and threat of daddy govt, to force you to share your toys with everyone. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 101fulminations · 2020-09-04 19:03 Besides in-tree ZFS? Having a fully integrated single source user space has its advantages, like much less potential for update breakage. Things like legacy init systems and filesystem hierarchy compliance make BSD seem simpler and refreshing compared to linux. Don't get me wrong, what linux communities do with maintaining their respective userlands is truly remarkable, but it's also chaotic and, well... wild. Sometimes it's nice to get away from that, and BSD provides an escape. Aside, apart from my FreeNAS I don't have a home for BSD so recently I began playing with NomadBSD (live usb stick) and I quite like it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nukem996 · 2020-09-04 19:19 > Digital "rights" management. Encryption keys of media giants (like Netflix), embedded in the kernel. Can you provide any evidence of that? AFAIK there is no DRM in the Linux kernel. Linux does allow you to only load signed kernel modules. You can use a vendor key for ease or setup your own. This is a requirement for UEFI Secure Boot which is increasingly becoming a requirement in corporate environments. Does BSD not support UEFI Secure Boot? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- droso_ · 2020-09-04 20:24 e.g. really open license or zfs ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reinoudz · 2020-09-04 20:30 If you don't want any fuss with automatic updates (or dislike doing things without a gui) like its easily done with the Xubuntu linux distribution then maybe linux is more suited. I installed that one for my mom :) As for normal working desktop, i like that the BSDs are much cleaner, more complete and less crippled with systemd etc and also have good documentation. I can also run my NetBSD on all kinds of systems from really old hardware (used to use it on mips, arm6, alpha, sparc etc), small RPi's, my Pinebook to my big i7 and use the same settings, the same configuration, the same package system etc. without the need to remember what flavour of what distro is on it and if its still updated. For compatibility sake, NetBSD is able to run programs from ages ago, even from NetBSD 0.8 IIRC and they are now nearly at NetBSD 10. Next to running linux and freebsd (and openbsd?) programs as well. As for speed, NetBSD/aarch64 outperforms the linux distro on my Pinebook and with NetBSD I at least know it will be around for years and years whereas i am not sure the particular linux for the Pinebook will even be around in a few years or updated even. I might be biassed, but then I've a NetBSD developer for a very long time now already... ugh.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Tireseas · 2020-09-04 23:00 Sensible answers like this from the community would be high up on my list. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- S-A-R · 2020-09-05 04:32 OpenBSD is secure by default. NetBSD is portable to more CPUs. There are advantages to the other BSDs, but I'm less familiar with those. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dadbot_2 · 2020-09-05 04:32 Hi less familiar with those, I'm Dad👨 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- reebs12 · 2020-09-05 06:12 Thanks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- u2706988 · 2020-09-05 06:22 The only reason the BSDs are free of the shitty DRM is because they're far less popular as end user systems. As much as I dislike the lengthy and super verbose GPL license, I don't think it is responsible for the DRM implementation. But I agree with you: this situation is sad and annoying. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bawdyanarchist · 2020-09-05 09:09 I can see how it might be difficult to make the connection, but it's there. I very much doubt the mainline BSDs would ever put something like that in the system. That's totally specificity of end user kind of stuff, which they are loathe to do, esp FreeBSD. Maybe one of the GUI desktop derivatives like Ghost or something. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CanadiansAreEvil · 2020-09-05 16:26 I just made the switch and I am happy with it. I used linux for years, now I am using freebsd. I really like it ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-09-07 02:06 [Quare FreeBSD?](https://vermaden.wordpress.com/2020/09/07/quare- freebsd/) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- opseceu · 2020-09-08 07:39 Using other variants helps to understand general concepts vrs. implementations. The concept is similar across platforms, the implementation might differ. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- finderxxx · 2020-09-08 08:19 And what do you expect to see in a VM? How the power management or Wifi works maybe? Or how tear-free and hw accelerated your graphics is? As someone already told, there should be a problem to solve. Learning a real UNIX is a good example of such a problem. Getting familiar with the current state of truly free software - yeah. Making a low-effort "review" on youtube using a VM... well... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- finderxxx · 2020-09-08 08:23 Bullshit, it's the other way round :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- finderxxx · 2020-09-08 08:36 Crippled? I wish there'd be something half as performant as systemd on BSDs. Also, systemd is a huge step towards making Linux a "much cleaner, more complete" system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freepackets · 2020-09-13 13:54 Probably [this](https://mobile.twitter.com/jschauma/status/13031586080 42098688?s=21)? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RedDima100 · 2020-09-27 08:12 It is just interesting to know why do you use bsd systems? On linux(i think you know about it) we have just one kernel and usally we see it in every linux distribution, just package managers, gui interfaces and some small peaces of code can be different in every distribution. On bsd systems we can look for open, free, net, dragon fly bsds and every bsd system have it's own idea, own kernel and own parts of system ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-09-27 10:38 I don't understand your question. Each BSD system has their own kernel, too, but BSD systems are complete systems by themselves. They do not rely on some other entity to piece them together to create an operating system. The BSDs do not decide what software you will run. You choose your desktop if you want one. You choose all your software. You configure as you please. And, when you do, you don't concern yourself that it is incompatible with the OS. In addition, FreeBSD's documentation is superior in every way. Directory organization makes sense. Everything is where you expect it to be. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- waspentalive · 2020-10-04 12:14 Wasn't open bad the guy from homestar runner? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Isaac2737 · 2020-10-08 18:58 What if our problem is that we're bored ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Isaac2737 · 2020-10-08 19:02 Why? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- S-A-R · 2020-10-08 19:26 That's a good problem to have, and a good reason to learn new things. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Isaac2737 · 2020-10-08 19:34 The only problem to which the solution is more problems ---------------------------------------------------------------------- S-A-R · 2020-10-08 19:37 That, and regular expressions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-10-15 17:51 Depends. Do you like a meritocracy where code correctness, security, minimalism, and quality are emphasized - no, strictly required? Go with OpenBSD, git gud, and thank me later by contributing to the project. Do you like the way flocks of uh... “confused” losers in thigh high socks flood a community, demanding that a set of inane rules be implemented which enables them to have their piss-poor code included in the OS over the hard work of those who have actually earned that honor? Do you think that a handful of delusional lolcows should demand that organizations formed around a project which has no relation to social issues must suddenly and explicitly broadcast it’s “support“ (at gunpoint anything looks supportive, I suppose) for certain societally-harmful social issues? Do you support these mentally subnormal individuals flocking to a community en mass and being obnoxiously loud and outspoken in order to create the illusion of an outraged majority opinion? Do you believe that if you haven’t earned recognition and representation it’s not indicative of your own faults as a programmer but instead that it’s evident of some kind of illogical, unprovable *-isms or *-phobias? Would you be comfortable moving goalposts and redefining the english language in order to gaslight others into believing they have some inherent and unspoken bias against you? Then good news, comrade! FreeBSD is the OS for you! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- __TBD · 2020-10-30 19:08 Flame Linus to a crisp! [https://lwn.net/Articles/30048/](https://lwn.net/Articles/30048/) check [https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/intel-gfx/2017- November/148897.html](https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/intel- gfx/2017-November/148897.html) and source are here [https://github.co m/torvalds/linux/tree/master/drivers/gpu/drm](https://github.com/torva lds/linux/tree/master/drivers/gpu/drm)