Microsoft's war on plain text email in open source reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2020-08-27 02:51 A little context: in OpenBSD, the official rules is that patches have to be submitted as plain-text non-attachment. (I don't believe FreeBSD has such a rule, and I'm not familiar with Linux.) Personally, I've sent most of my attachment as inline, ensuring it's still plain-text, so, the whole email can be saved and passed directly to patch. It's actually a very convenient workflow, because it ensures that each patch has a header documenting what it's for -- you won't have any random patches without the headers if you follow this convention. The header is ignored by [patch(1)](http://mdoc.su/-/patch.1), which probably gives you an idea around how universal and widespread this whole practice has been; then it's hardly a surprise that git's whole workflow is based around it as well. But does GitHub support it? I've never been able to get proper commits with the headers out of it. I stopped trying like a decade ago now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-08-27 03:37 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tim2k_k · 2020-08-27 04:02 Fuck the Microsoft with its opinions about using email. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ImproperGesture · 2020-08-27 04:04 If setting up an email client is a significant barrier for someone then perhaps contributing to the Linux kernel is a bit overly ambitious. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rekabis · 2020-08-27 06:08 Thunderbird does plain-text spectacularly well. In fact, all my eMail is text-only, with no HTML portion whatsoever. I don’t see that “barrier to entry” as anything other than an unqualified positive. That barrier acts as a “minimum technical capabilities filter” that excludes everyone too ignorant and technophobic to effectively contribute in any meaningful manner. In addition to doing purely plain-text eMail, not only do I bottom- post but I also sort in ascending order, with newest eMails at the bottom. It’s the correct way -- the _Unix_ way. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brwendel · 2020-08-27 08:16 They are setting up the path to migrate the kernel develoment to the Microsoft owned Github. Embrace, extend, and extinguish ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xenepa · 2020-08-27 10:46 So someone capable of writing kernel code has problems setting up email client? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-08-27 13:03 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-08-27 14:08 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-08-27 15:03 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MasterOfTheLine · 2020-08-27 15:07 Github does support it by appending a '.patch' to the commit url ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2020-08-27 15:10 Why is there no UI for it? How am I supposed to know this works? I recall in the past it didn’t have the commit message. Looks like it does now. Good to know. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigEnoughRock · 2020-08-27 15:13 Some personal thoughts: \- The title of this post is blowing the problem out of proportion. The linked content alone doesn't spell "Microsoft is waging war on plain-text email". It's just some lady getting a clever idea, because her BF was frustrated with how hard it is to setup an email client to send in plain text instead of HTML. It really isn't though. \- Email is a horrible service that was never meant to be used the way we're using it today and should die a fiery death. Every "improvement" we've had to do to make it more secure, usable and faster is a hack on top of a whole heap of other hacks. Relying on it for sharing patches smells something like clinging a bit too hard to the old ways to me. \- What's a convenient workflow for one isn't necessarily convenient for another. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigEnoughRock · 2020-08-27 15:13 A friendly reminder that Linus considered Debian "too difficult to install" :) Not everyone is a pro at everything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MasterOfTheLine · 2020-08-27 15:14 So that it can be used with curl. I personally never use the github UI and operate solely on Email. When I receive a PR, I just see the patch with curl, apply to the repository and push it. This also closes the pull request automatically. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LukeShu · 2020-08-27 20:14 > in OpenBSD, the official rules is that patches have to be submitted as plain-text non-attachment. (I don't believe FreeBSD has such a rule, and I'm not familiar with Linux.) Linux is the same way; plain text non-attachment emails. `git send- email` can send these; so with Git you don't need to configure your normal email client to successfully submit the patch, which is one of the complaints in the linked openbsd-misc email. Of course, when you respond to comments on the patch with HTML responses, you'll still get yelled at. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deafphate · 2020-08-27 20:37 Right? I exclusively use MS Outlook, and from the format text tab there's an option for Plain Text. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2020-08-27 20:54 Do you really? How you respond usually doesn’t matter, because text- based clients would normally just ignore HTML if the email has plain text version as well. So, it depends on the sending client — many send both — so, you may not even have to select the plain text. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LukeShu · 2020-08-27 20:58 Come to think of it, I'm not sure I distinctly remember seeing HTML emails on the Linux mailing lists. I've definitely seen people reply to HTML emails with "please only send plain-text email to this mailing list" on other dev lists with the same procedures though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2020-08-28 01:28 It's installer sucks, that's the problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ctisred · 2020-08-28 02:11 >just some lady "Sarah Novotny, Microsoft's representative on the Linux Foundation board." ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigEnoughRock · 2020-08-28 06:47 I read the linked email. What's your point? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2020-09-01 15:40 It's not that setting up an email client is difficult, it's that it's pointless in today's development ecosystem. E-mail is a terrible, slow, inefficient way to do development. Most modern programmers expect to use faster, better tools than e-mail. If your development model depends on e-mail, then it is going to discourage talented programmers who don't want to put up with that work flow. Since Linus Torvalds has pointed out it's getting hard to find people to help maintain the kernel, it might be worth considering that a large part of that is likely not a lack of talent, but rather than Linux (and OpenBSD) use 1990s era workflows while anyone graduating after 2000 is used to issue trackers, GitHub, etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- glamdivitionen · 2020-09-03 08:13 Yeah, I hate debian installer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UrpleEeple · 2020-09-22 16:58 Yep, exactly this.