[FreeBSD-Announce] New FreeBSD code of conduct reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-09 23:27 This is why I don't contribute... I was censored and banned from the FreeBSD Forum by "DutchDaemon" in 2010 for expressing a libertarian opinion in [a thread calling for government intervention](https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/save- mysql-petition.10174/) in Oracle's acquisition of Sun Microsystems. I'm now actually thinking of switching to Oracle (even though I prefer DF BSD & PostgreSQL) just because they don't push left-wing politics, [(at least so far)](http://archive.vn/CKOqi)... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-09 23:34 You were banned for mentioning this thread? I don't understand. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2020-06-10 00:05 Blanket statements which attempt to create divisiveness ("push left- wing politics") speak volumes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 00:06 > You were banned for mentioning this thread? I don't understand. No, I commented on [that "Save MySQL petition" thread](https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/save-mysql-petition.10174/) in 2010. The [site it linked to](https://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.helpmysql.org/*) called for government intervention in Oracle's acquisition. I argued against government intervention. But libertarian (a la Ron Paul) positions and rebuttals are taboo in many open source projects. Even as they push the left-wing socialist politics, we are not allowed to disagree. For this I was banned from FreeBSD, and [all my forum posts had been deleted](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memory_hole). It was a very big blow for me and my life goals at the time... The situation has become increasingly worse with [the "Code of Conduct" movement circa 2018](https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD/comments/7y 347b/freebsd_falls_to_sjws_with_lunatic_ideological/)... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 00:08 > Blanket statements which attempt to create divisiveness ("push left- wing politics") speak volumes. You are blind to your own abuse... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 00:10 I'm very skeptical of these, "I'm so oppressed as a white male libertarian because now I have to be a decent human being in public"-type appeals. It's certainly possible that you said something very anodyne and someone banned you a decade ago but by your own admission, there's no proof. So rather than resort to some decade-old grudge in a different context, what do you have to say about *this* code of conduct that is so bad? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- htnsh · 2020-06-10 00:20 To be fair, "DutchDaemon" isn't a very friendly mod on the forums... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 00:24 Absolute garbage. The only thing that matters is the code, nothing else. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 00:24 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 00:26 McDonald's grease trap dumpster smell in the summer type garbage. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MuffinPimp · 2020-06-10 00:41 Making a statement about George Floyd/BLM/whatever is a reason to dislike a company? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 00:44 ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 00:45 > I'm very skeptical of these, "I'm so oppressed as a white male libertarian because now I have to be a decent human being in public"-type appeals. You are dehumanizing me. I'm also not sure how I fit into your Western "white male" box, being a homeless asexual Russian-Jew with clinical depression, but that's a less relevant point. > It's certainly possible that you said something very anodyne That thread and the site it linked to expressed a political opinion (government should interfere in what Oracle and Sun stockholders are allowed to do). I expressed a different opinion (against the morality and effectiveness of government intervention). It's not a question of what someone thinks is "anodyne" - FreeBSD should have either censored both political opinion (enforced political neutrality) or neither (free speech). Instead it consistently censors the right / pro-capitalist / anti-government-intervention position. > and someone banned you a decade ago but by your own admission, there's no proof. Lack of transparency and a permanent record is itself a problem... (Interestingly my name, AlexLibman, [still appears](http://archive.vn/7Qf3C#selection-1539.0-1539.10) on that thread as "thanks"ing to one of the posts, but all of my posts were deleted.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 00:46 > You are dehumanizing me. ? > I'm also not sure how I fit into your Western "white male" box, being a homeless asexual Russian-Jew with clinical depression, but that's a less relevant point. None of those are not-white or not-male. > It's not a question of what someone thinks is "anodyne" - FreeBSD should have either censored both political opinion (enforced political neutrality) or neither (free speech). Instead it consistently censors the right / pro-capitalist / anti-government-intervention position. Why? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 00:56 > Making a statement about George Floyd/BLM/whatever is a reason to dislike a company? Unless of course that statement is: "Let's wait until the trial, when we'll know all the facts, before jumping to conclusions - calling someone a 'murderer', advocating riots, and insisting everyone who doesn't agree is 'racist'." We live in a time when media and tech companies have immense power over public opinion. Most people live in a bubble of approved political opinions, and everyone outside of it is silenced. Many people I agree with had their lives destroyed by such companies. So where a company (or a FLOSS project) stands politically is crucial - I don't want to build my house on top of quicksand and then lose everything... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2020-06-10 01:04 This does nothing to further any kind of discussion. You've just proved my point. "I have a problem with this specific thing. This is what, and this is why." is a meaningful way to start a dialogue. [the new FreeBSD CoC] "...is why I don't contribute..." without pointing out anything about the CoC is not an invitation to engage. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 01:07 > None of those are not-white or not-male. In your opinion. But "white" "males" also have rights - by what standard of logic do you discriminate against them? Communism has killed tens of millions of "white males" in the country of my birth alone. >> It's not a question of what someone thinks is "anodyne" - FreeBSD should have either censored both political opinion (enforced political neutrality) or neither (free speech). >> Instead it consistently censors the right / pro-capitalist / anti- government-intervention position. > Why? If your "why" is directed at the first sentence you've quoted: because FreeBSD solicits donations and support as a software project, not a left-wing political organization for attacking anyone who's white, male, insufficiently "woke", and/or against unlimited government power. If your "why" is directed at the first sentence you've quoted: I don't know why the FreeBSD project has this bias, I'm just observing that it does. Presumably it's what people who make decisions on behalf of FreeBSD prefer, based on their own agendas. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MuffinPimp · 2020-06-10 01:08 Kinda hard to “wait until the trial” when the cop would have never been charged without pressure from the protests. The companies just like to spin good PR out of things like they do with everything that happens. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 01:09 > But "white" "males" also have rights No one said otherwise. >by what standard of logic do you discriminate against them? ? >Communism has killed tens of millions of "white males" in the country of my birth alone. Okay. Why are you mentioning totally irrelevant things? > If your "why" is directed at the first sentence you've quoted: because FreeBSD solicits donations and support as a software project, not a left-wing political organization for attacking anyone who's white, male, insufficiently "woke", and/or against unlimited government power. lol. Who is attacking anyone? What on Earth are you talking about? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- teksimian · 2020-06-10 01:16 Are virtual IRC hugs still banned? What a way to make yourself a laughingstock Edit: virtual hugs are back on the menu!!! *Hugs everyone* ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 01:17 ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2020-06-10 01:27 Where do we stand with virtual hugs? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- teksimian · 2020-06-10 01:35 What are you new here or something? https://forums.theregister.com/forum/all/2018/02/21/freebsd_code_of_co nduct_controversy/#c_3434048 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 01:38 > Kinda hard to “wait until the trial” when the cop would have never been charged without pressure from the protests. All four cops were fired instantly. Every death in police custody involves serious investigations by default. Plus Trump ordered additional Federal investigation almost immediately. The BLM hysteria has contributed nothing positive. Us libertarians were in the habit of video-recording police arrests long before it was cool. I personally have a lot of Civil Disobedience arrests under my belt... I'm no friend of the police, especially when it comes to victimless crimes (the main reason for Floyd's arrest, more than the fake bill, was that he was driving while very obviously out of his mind on drugs, which the autopsy has confirmed). But that doesn't mean you call someone a "murderer" (this submission technique has been used countless times all over the world) and "racist" without evidence. The accusation of "systemic racism" is directed at everyone who doesn't bow down to BLM's demands. And so I hope this answers your original question of why I avoid [those BLM-signaling companies](http://archive.vn/CKOqi), which is related to my criticism of FreeBSD's hypocritical SJW "Code of Conduct". This is not the place for any further discussion of the Floyd case beyond that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 01:47 I think that a rule that says, "Don't tell someone 'owo *backrubs owo' after that person says to stop" makes someone a laughingstock except among gross trolls. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 01:54 > No one said otherwise. You are absolutely blind to your own injustice... You've [just discriminated against me](http://archive.vn/CLuP1#selection-1649.0-1649.145) because of my (alleged) ethnicity and gender! This illustrates the hypocrisy of the [FreeBSD CoC](https://archive.is/VBC4p) [[2]](http://archive.is/JGrY5). It's like the Soviet constitution under Stalin - it has no connection to reality, and it is used to achieve the very opposite of what it claims! > Okay. Why are you mentioning totally irrelevant things? Why is it supposedly OK to censor, dehumanize, memory-hole, or kill "white males"? Is it because I'm some kind of rich plantation owner who's been enslaving others? BS! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 01:56 > You are absolutely blind to your own injustice... Injustice is when someone does not get what he deserves or gets what he does not deserve. In this case... e.g.? > You've just discriminated against me because of my (alleged) ethnicity and gender! No I didn't. > This illustrates the hypocrisy of the FreeBSD CoC [2]. It's like the Soviet constitution under Stalin - it has no connection to reality, and it is used to achieve the very opposite of what it claims! No, it's not. > Why is it supposedly OK to censor, dehumanize, memory-hole, or kill "white males"? Is it because I'm some kind of rich plantation owner who's been enslaving others? BS! No one said that it's okay to "kill white males". What in the world is wrong with you? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 02:06 > This does nothing to further any kind of discussion. You've just proved my point. No, **YOU are creating divisiveness** - by pushing a political agenda, and [censoring](https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD/comments/822yzv/freebsd_i s_mass_banning_coc_critics_and_opening/) those who disagree. In 2010, FreeBSD promoted the call for government intervention against Oracle, and censored the opposing point of view (mine). In 2020, FreeBSD dictates cultural norms (like anti-scientific gender pronouns), while [discriminating against someone for being "white" and "male"](http://archive.vn/CLuP1#selection-1649.0-1649.146). If you take Political Science 101, that political agenda can be objectively described as "left wing". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- awesomefloss · 2020-06-10 02:16 The announcement makes it obvious that the developers are largely in agreement on the new choice ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 02:31 >> You are absolutely blind to your own injustice... > Injustice is when someone does not get what he deserves or gets what he does not deserve. In this case... e.g.? In the 2010 case I was dehumanized, censored, banned, and my dreams of becoming a FreeBSD contributor came crashing down. All because I expressed a libertarian political opinion on government intervention in Sun-Oracle. I remain quite traumatized by what happened. I've experienced worse injustices in my life, but that one is definitely in the top 10. And here I see how FreeBSD continues to push [their CoC lies](https://archive.is/VBC4p) about how "friendly", "welcoming", "respectful" they are. And I'm not allowed to criticize and tell my story, because, although I was born in a third-world hell-hole, I am supposedly "privileged" for supposedly being a "white male", so I should just shut up... >> You've just discriminated against me because of my (alleged) ethnicity and gender! > No I didn't. Either someone else has made that statement with your Reddit account, or you are experiencing severe cognitive dysfunction. I recommend taking the archives of this conversation to a competent non-SJW psychotherapist to help understand what is wrong. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MuffinPimp · 2020-06-10 02:32 You’re the one that brought up the topic by linking to that google sheets doc, so if you didn’t want to get into the subject why even link to it in the first place? It’s pretty obvious that discussing this topic further with would be a waste of time, so yeah I guess your replies answer my question. As for the topic of the Code of Conduct, idk, I’d say it’s already doing a pretty good job if it’s mere existence is discouraging people like you from contributing. If something that more or less boils down to “be nice to people” is the reason that people avoid participating in a community, then the community is better off without those people. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 02:39 Oh, so you're saying that they shouldn't have a bunch of rules to coddle special snowflakes? Feel free to answer my questions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 02:50 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 02:52 > You’re the one that brought up the topic by linking to that google sheets doc It was relevant to [my original comment](https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD/ comments/gzxx5o/freebsdannounce_new_freebsd_code_of_conduct/ftj386y/) about the CoC lie. I said I don't contribute to FreeBSD, because I was unjustly treated for not being a left-winger and daring to disagree with the left-wing politics being pushed. That left quite a scar in my life, and so now I try to interpret political signals from companies and FLOSS projects, to see if I would be so abused again in the future... > As for the topic of the Code of Conduct, idk, I’d say it’s already doing a pretty good job if it’s mere existence is discouraging people like you from contributing. Only by deception. If that's your desired result, then the Code of Conduct should explicitly state: "FreeBSD is a left-wing socialist project. It [calls for government intervention against businesses](https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/save-mysql- petition.10174/), and anyone who disagrees will be censored and banned. Also anyone who believes there are [two biological genders](h ttps://old.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7xapx2/freebsds_new_geek_femi nismbased_code_of_conduct/) is a nazi. And '[while males](http://archive.vn/CLuP1#selection-1649.0-1649.145)' aren't allowed to have an opinion on anything." ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ctm-8400 · 2020-06-10 03:03 Why not DragonflyBSD then? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 03:12 > Why not DragonflyBSD then? I've continued to use and advocate for BSDs on and off since then, but I didn't contribute any code. That of course is my flaw. But that doesn't make my point about political bias and CoC hypocrisy any less relevant. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2020-06-10 03:31 Wow. Lots of anger here. Settle down. First, you're conflating issues. Second, you still haven't stated your issue or issues about the CoC. Third, you're attempting to be condescending, and that by itself is distracting from any possible civil discussion. If you're here just to complain unconstructively, you've accomplished your goals. If you'd like to actually discuss something which is relevant to the CoC, by all means talk about that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 04:21 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 04:23 > Exactly what did he do that was indecent? I didn't say that he did. >He did nothing wrong yet you're being an asshole. ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 04:28 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 04:29 > You say that his comment is one of those appeals. No, I don't. >"because now I have to be a decent human being in public" Implies that he/she wasn't being a decent human being before. And it also implies that he/she is upset about having to be a decent human being. No, it doesn't. >You're being an asshole by saying "oh, you're one of those people that do X, Y, Z" when he/she never said X, Y, Z. lol@irony ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MuffinPimp · 2020-06-10 04:53 You may need a thicker skin if being banned from the a forum a decade ago has "left quite a scar" in your life. I also fail to see how a petition, a link to a post on the freebsd reddit about the previous CoC, or a comment by OP in this thread would lead you to that conclusion. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 05:03 > You may need a thicker skin if being banned from the a forum a decade ago has "left quite a scar" in your life. Absolutely true. But it's hypocritical and unfair to tell some people to get a "thicker skin", while imposing CoCs to appease others... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MuffinPimp · 2020-06-10 05:15 How so? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- astrange · 2020-06-10 08:00 If your memory goes back to the 90s, I'm pretty sure Lisp lost its popularity entirely because the Usenet group was so rude to newbies everyone abandoned it. Erik Naggum especially was like world-famous because he'd just scream at you and send death threats for asking questions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-10 08:18 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-10 08:18 Good. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- euphraties247 · 2020-06-10 09:57 ((HUGS)) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Axman6 · 2020-06-10 10:41 Dear reader, If you would like to have a good day, do not scroll down and read the comments. Nothing of value will be missed by you, whatever your stance on this issue or political persuasion. Have a great day! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LinuxLeafFan · 2020-06-10 12:49 I did not consent to this ---------------------------------------------------------------------- euphraties247 · 2020-06-10 12:56 Hugs! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xxx4wow · 2020-06-10 13:47 > FreeBSD should have either censored both political opinion (enforced political neutrality) or neither (free speech). Instead it consistently censors the right / pro-capitalist / anti-government- intervention position. You do understand that one of the main inventions that enables capitalism is copyright and the open-source movement is a rejection of it? Now I am not for over-moderation and certainly not for censoring, but you should not be too surprised that an organization that openly challenges capitalism is not happy about pro capitalist comments. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sigzero · 2020-06-10 14:00 Much better than the last one. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pagwin · 2020-06-10 15:43 well now I just want to read the comments even more ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pagwin · 2020-06-10 15:44 > Lisp lost its popularity emacs disagrees ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-10 16:26 A lot better. Actually a reasonable document I can personally accept. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-10 16:28 The old code of conduct says: > Physical contact and simulated physical contact (e.g., textual descriptions like "\*hug\*" or "\*backrub\*") without consent or after a request to stop. It explicitly says that you need to ask before virtually hugging someone which is the most ridiculous thing ever. Stopping with something like that after someone told you to not do it is a common courtesy, but having to ask for permission first is just extremely weird and sounds like the code of conduct was written by people who are deathly afraid of the people around them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-10 19:06 > You do understand that one of the main inventions that enables capitalism is copyright Absolutely false. Read [Stephan Kinsella](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephan_Kinsella). Copyrights and patents (government-enforced artificial monopoly) are statism, the opposite of free market capitalism. > and the open-source movement is a rejection of it? I'm a [copyfree](http://copyfree.org) fanatic. That's the main reason why [I've long advocated](https://forum.freestateproject.org/index.php?topic=19771.0) (and [still advocate](https://www.facebook.com/software.libman.org)) for BSD over Linux. FLOSS is a part of a free market capitalist system. It comes from capitalists (programmers) using their private property (their computers) to produce goods, the price of which has been driven down to zero. The only problem is restrictive licenses like GPL, which do not constitute a valid contract. > Now I am not for over-moderation and certainly not for censoring, but you should not be too surprised that an organization that openly challenges capitalism is not happy about pro capitalist comments. This wide-spread stupidity prevented me from contributing... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PitifulView · 2020-06-10 21:58 Oracle Linux is not too different from a rebranded RHEL, so you could say that Red Hat has shed its left wing cooties on the software. It's ruined now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- astrange · 2020-06-11 00:02 If it had won you'd be using a Lisp machine instead of a text editor pretending to be a Lisp machine on a UNIX OS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-11 05:08 Can you call them an Airbus GPWS system at 20 feet? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xxx4wow · 2020-06-11 10:36 See, this is why I do not believe in censoring or over moderating, you have brought up an interesting view of FLOSS, which I personally highly disagree with, but non the less it helps drive conversation and better understanding of each-other. >>You do understand that one of the main inventions that enables capitalism is copyright >Absolutely false. Read Stephan Kinsella. Copyrights and patents (government-enforced artificial monopoly) are statism, the opposite of free market capitalism. Okay, it might not be the case for Anarcho-Capitalism, but it is the case for the current Capitalist system, so my main point stands as most people will oppose the current capitalist system. Open conversations would leave them open to explore versions of capitalism that dose not rely on copyright tho. >FLOSS is a part of a free market capitalist system. It comes from capitalists (programmers) using their private property (their computers) to produce goods, the price of which has been driven down to zero. The only problem is restrictive licenses like GPL, which do not constitute a valid contract. This is where I disagree with you completely. For one, if your statement is true and FLOSS programmers are Capitalists, but the cost of their end product is driven down to zero, how do they generate profit? Imo, while from one, very limited, aspect they do own the means of production, they still aren't Capitalists and certainly not Bourgeois. Would they be, they would use their capital to invest in the means of production and employ others, whom work from they would generate profit. What they do instead is that they use their capital to buy means of production that allows them to retrieve the full amount of value of their own work, which is the opposite of capitalism. Also I would argue that they do not own the means of production, as you need much more than a PC to recoup the value of your work. You need platforms, where people can find your product and reward you for it, which is almost never in the hand of the programmers. eg:github Often you need giant corporations set up too. eg:RedHat At the end of the day, it seems we agree on copyright is bullshit, but we envision very different markets without it. Good news is we have plenty of time to figure that out as I don't see copyright going away for a very long time. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-11 16:45 >> Lisp lost its popularity > emacs disagrees Lisp was [the #7 most popular high-level programming language in the 60s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Og847HVwRSI), peaking at #3 in the 70s. [TIOBE claims](http://archive.vn/JjKxe#selection-2509.0-2509.4) it was still #2 in 1985 - there are different ways to measure things, but the overall trend is clear. Adding up [all the Lisps](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Lisp- family_programming_languages) **today** would just barely make it into the top 20, with under 1% market share. Same for [GitHub](https://madnight.github.io/githut/#/pushes/2020/1), [search trends](http://pypl.github.io/PYPL.html), etc. Perl and Tcl started to make a dent by 1990. Lisp's lunch was ultimately eaten by dynamic scripting languages like PHP, Ruby, and [especially JavaScript](https: //old.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/b7khq2/i_just_found_out_brenda n_eich_originally_wanted/) (in the Web browser) and [of course Python](https://cemerick.com/2009/03/24/why-mit-now-uses-python- instead-of-scheme-for-its-undergraduate-cs-program/) (automation, math, science), because that's the syntax that most programmers prefer. Emacs now has [<5% market share](https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2019#development- environments-and-tools) among developers, but you can't claim that everyone who uses Emacs is a "Lisp programmer"... So the claim that "Lisp lost its popularity" is entirely correct. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-11 18:00 > Okay, it might not be the case for Anarcho-Capitalism, but it is the case for the current Capitalist system, so my main point stands as most people will oppose the current capitalist system. Open conversations would leave them open to explore versions of capitalism that dose not rely on copyright tho. Free software should be for people who like free software, period. This includes a broad diversity of interest groups: top software companies like Google (and now even Microsoft), small startups like iX Systems and EnterpriseDB, governments (including Cuba and North Korea), right-wing tax resistance zealots like myself (who can't rely on proprietary software due to risk of post-secession sanctions), and billions of individuals in between. Free software creates a common open foundation that everyone can build on. This empowers "the little guy" in the software marketplace to compete with the trillion-dollar giants. It has countless benefits in security, flexibility, and ease of learning. And it ultimately empowers the users, who enjoy a more competitive marketplace with common standards, so they don't have to learn a whole new alphabet (so to speak) to move to a different neighborhood. If the FreeBSD project is anti-capitalist, then it should make that explicit, and be transparent in how it amplifies left-wing / socialist opinions and censors pro-capitalist / conservative / right-libertarian opinions - otherwise it is committing fraud against those who donate their time, code, and funds to the project! This is very sad, because BSD could have been a niche for people to prefer free markets, due to [the license](http://www.softwareliberationfront.org/) and [philosophical differences](https://www.techrepublic.com/blog/it-security/security- tools-should-be-designed-for-security/) from [the Stallman cult](http://archive.vn/pbHSK)... > This is where I disagree with you completely. For one, if your statement is true and FLOSS programmers are Capitalists, but the cost of their end product is driven down to zero, how do they generate profit? [...] [Capitalism](http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/capitalism.html) is defined by private ownership of capital - [your life, liberty, and property](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8GazZBvHhgQ) - including your body, your time, the consequences of your actions, your computer, etc. It's not "profitism", where no one is allowed to do anything unless they make an instant material profit! Capitalist philosophers have the term [Praxeology](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Praxeology), which is the study of "[human action](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Action)", of which Economics is a sub-set. A human being can be motivated by many things, including fame, social standing, respect, ambition, bragging rights ("[egoboo](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egoboo)"), intellectual curiosity, psychological need for achievement, empathy, a sense of moral duty, etc. People learn to use FLOSS software out of their own rational self- interest, and that is also the reason why they contribute work to its development. This increases one's utility, demonstrates one's value to a prospective employer, increases attention and demand (and thus prospective salary for paid work), initiates useful social connections, etc. All those things are perfectly harmonious with the capitalist system! [The only things that aren't](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non- aggression_principle) are theft, violence, and fraud (including collectivist rituals for masking those, like government-imposed regulations, taxation, currency inflation, victimless "crimes", etc.) > [...] Bourgeois [...] The left should have abandoned that word a century ago. It now applies to everyone (even tax resisters living in a tent in the woods like me). Anyone who uses toilet paper is a "bourgeois". 🙀 > At the end of the day, it seems we agree on copyright is bullshit [...] [It's one of the things that libertarians disagree on.](https://en.wik ipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_perspectives_on_intellectual_property) Unless of course it's a voluntary contractual agreement, which would be applicable to business models like Apple and Oracle. But a text file bundled with supposedly "free software" (ex. GPL) is nowhere close to a valid contract! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-11 18:17 > Still can't call people retards, though. It's always better to explain to people specifically which form of intellectual, professional, cultural, technical, economic, or social incompetence they are exhibiting. Except koavf of course, he's a Tard with a capital T. 😈 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-11 18:22 [Hugs](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugs) is still [banned from the ports tree](https://www.freshports.org/lang/hugs). Use [GHC](https://www.freshports.org/lang/ghc). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-11 18:36 >> This is why I don't contribute... >> I was censored and banned from the FreeBSD Forum by "DutchDaemon" in 2010 for expressing a libertarian opinion in [a thread calling for government intervention](https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/save- mysql-petition.10174/) in Oracle's acquisition of Sun Microsystems. >> I'm now actually thinking of switching to Oracle (even though I prefer DF BSD & PostgreSQL) just because they don't push left-wing politics, [(at least so far)](http://archive.vn/CKOqi)... > Oracle Linux is not too different from a rebranded RHEL, so you could say that Red Hat has shed its left wing cooties on the software. It's ruined now. Yes, correct. That was an ironic jab, that even a diehard open source and [copyfree](http://copyfree.org)-dom fanatic like me (who even refuses to touch anything Java or MySQL due to restrictive licenses) would consider Oracle... But I do acknowledge them being the stand-out exception amidst the left-wing derangement that had dominated the rest of the software industry. (Ellison held a fundraiser for Trump, and some employees protested, but the company itself remained refreshingly neutral.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LeftistRebelScum · 2020-06-11 18:39 I am reading this discussion to decide whether to install FreeBSD or OpenBSD. I haven't used either in a decade, so you could say I'm an outsider point of view. I see that FreeBSD is much more feature-rich, and would roll with it, but I don't like this Code of Conduct at all in the context of the deplatforming and banning of people with right-wing political beliefs. I'm transexual, so I'm a member of one of your "protected groups" not that I need your protection; I value freedom of speech much more than my feelings or any other person's feelings because I love liberty. There is no way to limit speech without violating a person's basic human right to self expression. (Hitting "mute" to hide from your own feed or just ignoring the post is not censorship; banning someone or removing their post from public view is.) If you want to misgender me, you're a jerk, but ok. Who cares? Call me names, I'll just ignore them. I don't need "protection". The CoC isn't as bad as some others I've seen on the net, but completely unneeded and just gets in the way. How much time is being wasted talking about not hurting peoples' feels? Not sure which OS I'll choose given the current debate, but if FreeBSD had no code of conduct at all I would immediately install FreeBSD on this laptop and save OpenBSD for an edge router. "Sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me" is a lesson I learned early in life, and it has served me well. Those who advocate for censorship should instead make an effort to not be whiny bitches. If you can't handle life, go hide in a cave somewhere. I'm interested in a secure system that bypasses all identity tracking and attempts at thought control, or I wouldn't even be here; I'd just install Windows or Ubuntu and be done with it. I perceive that people with libertarian to conservative / right wing beliefs are being piled on, and I voted for Jill Stein in 2016 so you can call that a 3rd party point of view on this situation. Censorship is a component of dystopian authority constructs, and a technological group should be focused on the quality of their technology, not the "social credit score" of their political opinions. As a person seeking an operating system that will be a refuge from censorship and deplatforming, you're pushing me toward OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-11 19:27 > Who cares? Any sensible person. Open source/free software projects are by their very nature *collaborative*. Normal human beings will not waste their free time and labor on working with jerks. So if you want the project to be good, you need to not be a jerk. That is actual meritocracy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pagwin · 2020-06-11 19:50 > you can't claim that everyone who uses Emacs I said emacs disagrees not the people who use it as emacs uses lisp for it's editor scripting and I meant this as a joke(not even a good joke) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2020-06-11 20:33 >but if FreeBSD had no code of conduct at all I would immediately install FreeBSD on this laptop and save OpenBSD for an edge router. All the BSD communities (including FreeBSD and OpenBSD) do censorship. If they didn't, then they would get buried in porn and spam. OpenBSD's mailing lists have a code of conduct at [https://www.openbsd .org/mail.html](https://www.openbsd.org/mail.html), with rules like, "Stay on topic", and, "Respect differences in opinion and philosophy". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LeftistRebelScum · 2020-06-11 20:50 I know OpenBSD has that code of conduct, I read it, and it's NONPOLITICAL so it's just fine. The FreeBSD one is political, and not ok. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LeftistRebelScum · 2020-06-11 20:53 I'm not saying people should be jerks. I'm saying to give no quarter to political censorship, which is what this is. I'm seeing people on Fediverse build a huge instance-block wall, and I'm seeing censorship on almost all platforms, including Reddit. This needs to end. If FreeSpeechExtremists on Fediverse wants to run a FreeBSD server and they want to have literal nazis post, is that a violation of the FreeBSD CoC? Could it become a violation in the future? I don't like nazis, but I like freedom of political expression. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-11 21:11 > I'm seeing censorship on almost all platforms, including Reddit. This needs to end. Why? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-11 23:38 LISP lost because it's difficult to program in and has poor engineering properties for large projects, systems programming, and any performance-sensitive applications. It doesn't even have a proper syntax (if you say “but LISP is such that you can easily roll out your own!” you have not understood why this is a problem). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xmjEE · 2020-06-12 06:57 Absolutely. I especially like that the code of conduct starts out by clarifying where it does, and where it doesn't, apply. And that the six general guidelines are rather common sense to polite discourse. Maybe so 'common' they occasionally need reiterating ;-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- xxx4wow · 2020-06-12 08:03 > Free software should be for people who like free software, period. > > This includes a broad diversity of interest groups: top software companies like Google (and now even Microsoft), small startups like iX Systems and EnterpriseDB, governments (including Cuba and North Korea), right-wing tax resistance zealots like myself (who can't rely on proprietary software due to risk of post-secession sanctions), and billions of individuals in between. > > Free software creates a common open foundation that everyone can build on. This empowers "the little guy" in the software marketplace to compete with the trillion-dollar giants. It has countless benefits in security, flexibility, and ease of learning. And it ultimately empowers the users, who enjoy a more competitive marketplace with common standards, so they don't have to learn a whole new alphabet (so to speak) to move to a different neighborhood. The only thing I disagree with here is the: "This empowers "the little guy" in the software marketplace to compete with the trillion-dollar giants.". Realistically that is simply not true, for example the little guy can easily can be forced out of the market if the competition advertises their product so aggressively that nobody even knows about the independent guys product. Or you grab the source code of an independent guy, pay tons of engineers to develop new features and advertise it so the user base migrates. >> [...] Bourgeois [...] >The left should have abandoned that word a century ago. It now applies to everyone (even tax resisters living in a tent in the woods like me). > >Anyone who uses toilet paper is a "bourgeois". 🙀 We wont abandon a term bc you do not understand it or bc opposing political movement tried to steal it and change its meaning. "In Marxist philosophy, the bourgeoisie is the social class that came to own the means of production during modern industrialization and whose societal concerns are the value of property and the preservation of capital to ensure the perpetuation of their economic supremacy in society." How is this apply to everyone? This applies to a very specific group of people and it is quintessential that we can name them as a group in order to fight them. I do not cease them the freedom of anonymity to the point where we can not even name them as a group. You can dance around the question all you want, Capitalism in its essence will always lead to unjust power structures as capital is unevenly distributed. A non governmental capitalism wouldn't address the core issue, it would simply cease even more power to those whom already hold the most power. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PitifulView · 2020-06-12 08:15 You might not know this, but at the end of every BSDCan, there's a charity auction for the men's shelter neighboring the conference venue. Even though the conference this year was virtual, people [didn't forget the auction](https://mwl.io/archives/6754), and still raised what I assume are thousands of dollars for it. Society sees it negatively when someone talks too much about having donated to charity in normal circumstances, so you won't hear too much of it, but it still happens. Every year without fail BSDCan raises funds. We definitely extend our compassion to (mostly white, it's Ottawa) homeless men who are struggling. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-12 09:39 I have one simple question: If the biological sex of another developer is known, can I use the traditionally correct pronoun even if they request that I use something else? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-12 10:19 I think it's almost as good as the original code of conduct. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-12 11:29 I recommend you to avoid unnecessary conflict here. Is this really the hill you want to die on? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-12 17:03 Why would you do this? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-06-12 18:03 > The only thing I disagree with here is the: "This empowers "the little guy" in the software marketplace to compete with the trillion- dollar giants.". Realistically that is simply not true, for example the little guy can easily can be forced out of the market if the competition advertises their product so aggressively that nobody even knows about the independent guys product. Advertising sells sugar-water to low-IQ people with low impulse control - that's on them. Freedom and consequentialism only encourages people to be more skeptical about what they hear. Evolutionary forces of the marketplace reward rationality and frugality. No amount of advertising will erase facts and cause a business to go against their rational self-interest. If EnterpriseDB (which is built on top of PostgreSQL) is better and cheaper, that's what businesses will choose. Getting a list of alternatives and comparing them is not hard. Oracle / IBM / Microsoft cannot erase EnterpriseDB, and a zillion giant billboards claiming that "EnterpriseDB doesn't exist" would only have the opposite effect. > Or you grab the source code of an independent guy, pay tons of engineers to develop new features and advertise it so the user base migrates. So in this scenario they have developed a better product, which is good for the users. Developing this product has been cheaper thanks to the existence of the source code they've grabbed - that means someone else can grab that source code too, and build something even better and cheaper. (Re-implementing a software product based on an existing, successful, battle-tested example is orders of magnitude easier than inventing innovations and experimenting with untried ideas for the first time.) Competition ultimately leads to prices dropping to zero, at which point not-very-new software components compete on the merit of being FLOSS. The marketplace reality confirms this: ever-more products from large software companies are things like Chrome, VS Code, .NET Core, Go, LLVM / Swift, etc. > We wont abandon a term bc you do not understand it or bc opposing political movement tried to steal it and change its meaning. [...] We are not talking about your crazy religion and its made-up definitions. I don't play your games. I deal with reality. The historical [bourgeoisie](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bourgeoisie) were the "[early adopters](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_adopter)" of the urban lifestyle (ex Paris), starting with the Renaissance; with the associated fashion, culture, and gradual embrace of ever-more technological progress. It doesn't matter whether they owned investments or worked in skilled professions and rented an apartment. They were few relatively few, like the "Internet class" was a small exclusive elite [until the early 90s](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September), but progress has spread over time. Everything that Marx predicted has been proven 100% false. The Revolution didn't start in England, wasn't lead by the "working class" (Trotsky, Lenin, Stalin, etc didn't work a day in their lives), didn't quickly lead to peace and prosperity, didn't "abolish the family", etc, etc, etc. These days the bourgeoisie (urban residents) are [overwhelmingly leftist](http://metrocosm.com/election-2016-map-3d/) socialist [thieves](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_as_theft) living through the government, while the proponents of free market capitalism have moved outside those cities. The [most capitalist nations](https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking) (ex Switzerland, Singapore) were the least imperialist and became most prosperous, while the worst aggressors and humanitarian disasters of the past 100 years have all been the socialists. Capitalism has made everyone richer, [including the poor](https://panampost.com/vanesa-vallejo/2016/12/25/marxs- predictions-failed-fewer-fewer-poor-people/?cn-reloaded=1). Pretty much anyone in the world (outside the worst socialist dictatorships like North Korea) can buy a $20 smartphone today, thanks to capitalism, and have access to more information than the richest person in the world just a few decades ago! > You can dance around the question all you want, Capitalism in its essence will always lead to unjust power structures as capital is unevenly distributed. You've been brainwashed to believe that any inequality is "unjust" - that the student who studies 20 hours a day and the pot-head who never opened a book in his life should get the same grade. That is the opposite of justice! The only reason you believe that is because it provides the excuse for the people who manipulate you to steal, and to buy power with the stolen loot! > A non governmental capitalism wouldn't address the core issue, it would simply cease even more power to those whom already hold the most power. You need to differentiate between "power" and creative control over one's own property. The greatest concentrations of power in history have been the socialist dictatorships (and it's doesn't matter if it's one dictator or a million "democratic" "representatives" of the inner Party). Free market capitalism will only take away power from those who acquire it unjustly, including crony government favors like overreaching copyright and patents, regulations that stifle upstart competition, big pharma and prisons with the "war on drugs", limited liabilities for environmental externalities, etc, etc, etc... Under capitalism, everyone is equal in their negative Rights: it is just as wrong to rob or kill a homeless person as a billionaire. If Elon Musk's brain created billions of dollars worth of value, by creating products and services that other people voluntarily choose to pay for, then he should be the one to control it - not the lying government scum who've created nothing and are accountable to no one! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 05:29 I asked a precise question and would be glad to receive a direct answer. Did you just threaten me? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 05:30 That debate would be off-topic. Do you have an answer? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 05:30 No. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 05:37 OK. Do you know where I can get a definitive answer? Do I have to wait for a precedent case? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 05:38 No and no. You could just avoid the topic altogether: that would be my recommendation. Seems like you're intent on dying on this hill tho. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 05:57 I'm not sure what's worse. Is it worse if you're referred to by a polite, generally accepted, but unwanted pronoun, or if you're completely ignored - your name being struck from the conversation? Stop with this "hill to die on" nonsense, please. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 05:58 Hm. Tough to say. I guess you should just stick to calling someone what that person asks to be called. Good thought experiment—lots of fun was had by all. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 06:01 >stick to calling someone what that person asks to be called This is not an option we're willing to give. The reasons are irrelevant at this point. The question seems now to be: Does the FreeBSD community want polite individuals who consistently use traditional language to be able to contribute to the project, or not? It's not like there are no alternatives… ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 06:02 "We"? Alexej, what is the problem here? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 06:05 I'm not alone. Many people refuse to bend the knee. There is no problem. There are two options and I'm curious which of those the FreeBSD project will choose. I'm not even judging those choices. It's just that the consequences are difficult to predict. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 06:06 > Many people refuse to bend the knee. lol. >There is no problem. Well, actually. If you want to contribute to the project, you certainly can. If you want to be "polite-but-not-actually-polite", then you can't. It's very simple. This shouldn't even be something that takes up this much time and effort. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 06:12 You can't claim that I'm not polite. There are rules in societies. Right now, there is a big push to change those rules dramatically, suddenly and unnaturally. The result is that either trans people will be offended because somebody refuses to use their chosen pronouns, or conservatives will be offended by being forced to use newspeak. Tell me, which group is larger? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 06:14 > You can't claim that I'm not polite. I can. I did! > There are rules in societies. Right now, there is a big push to change those rules dramatically, suddenly and unnaturally. "Unnaturally"? Which rules in society change "naturally"? > The result is that either trans people will be offended because somebody refuses to use their chosen pronouns, or conservatives will be offended by being forced to use newspeak. You have no concept of what "Newspeak" is if you're even writing this. > Tell me, which group is larger? This is a false dilemma as there are many persons who are not transgender but would be offended by your behavior. Tell me: which group is larger? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 06:18 >I can. I did! You did, but you were wrong in doing so. >"Unnaturally"? Which rules in society change "naturally"? Naturally, changes are voluntary and not forced by a vocal minority. >You have no concept of what "Newspeak" is if you're even writing this. [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki /Newspeak) >\[…\] not transgender but would be offended by your behavior \[…\] People who are offended on behalf on others are rarely taken seriously. It's strongly associated with virtue signaling. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 06:21 > You did, but you were wrong in doing so. Now who is Newspeaking? > Naturally, changes are voluntarily and not forced by a vocal minority. Yes, we should have waited patiently until the majority just *decided* to give the blacks freedom from slavery. That would be "natural". > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak I know this: I've edited that article. I've also read *Nineteen Eighty-Four*. Since, as you yourself point out, the persons advocating for this change are a minority and therefore not in power, they are completely unlike the programmatic changes to language made by the Party in the book. [You are contradicting yourself by saying the enemy is weak and strong...](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definitions_of_fa scism#Umberto_Eco) > People who are offended on behalf on others are rarely taken seriously. It's strongly associated with virtue signaling. Oh no, not that! (Note that you didn't answer the question—not gonna let you Newspeak your way out of this one.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 06:28 You've skillfully lead the conversation away from the topic to something completely unrelated and started insulting me - the very thing you pretend to oppose so much. Let me give you a few last words of advice: * Re-read 1984. * Read about the civil war. * Look up who voluntarily gave up their slaves. And no, I did not use newspeak. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- koavf · 2020-06-13 06:29 Oh no, I wouldn't want to insult you and hurt your feelings! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2020-06-13 10:29 I believe I have given you a direct answer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _arthur_ · 2020-06-13 12:45 No. Use requested pronouns. It's super simple. The correct pronoun is the one the person in question would like you to use. What's in their pants/shirt/garment or their DNA is utterly irrelevant to anyone but themselves. Your oversimplified understanding of biology doesn't qualify you to be rude to people. For a more in depth answer to why you're oversimplifying I point you to someone with an actual PhD in biology: https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/1271561835800457216 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 21:22 No you didn't. Even a simple "yes" or "no" would be better, than your useless advice or threat. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- alexej_harm · 2020-06-13 21:32 No. The correct pronoun was and still is defined by you being a man, or a woman. If you want to play games and change that, do it. I don't want to be involved. It's not rude to use the correct pronoun. It's rude to demand that others lie about your gender. Again, do whatever you want, but don't involve others in it. I don't care what an ideologue with a PhD spouts on twitter. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _arthur_ · 2020-06-14 06:48 I don't understand why you're so invested in the pronoun other people choose, or why you think you can contradict actual experts, but I'm not particularly interested in that. If you cannot summon the basic politeness of respecting other people's choices and referring to them the way the want, you have no place in the FreeBSD Project. You will not be missed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- octalfallout · 2020-06-14 13:39 I still to this day fail to understand how people can create such a huge amount of drama in a tech community where we should focus on the tech itself. Good to see that this issue found a solution most people can agree on. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- anthk_ · 2020-06-16 04:11 More like the reverse. A Lisp machine trying to be a text editor. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-06-16 11:34 > found a solution most people can agree on. And now shut up about. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nahnah2017 · 2020-06-16 11:35 What's the alternative? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-17 15:55 FREE HUGS! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-17 18:30 OpenBSD is indeed our only line of defense. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fixedfree · 2020-06-21 03:22 If 'be nice to people' is too hard for you, go enjoy OpenBSD alone. And fuck you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-21 20:54 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-06-21 20:56 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2020-06-25 17:10 You just violated your own code of conduct... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PM-TITS-FOR-CODE · 2020-06-26 01:41 > You may need a thicker skin What a moronic and utterly self-unaware thing to say.