Are the BSDs dying? Some security researchers think so reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2020-05-08 16:04 Nope. This question is as old as "are there aliens out somewhere?" ---------------------------------------------------------------------- merdely · 2020-05-08 16:12 Definitely dying: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7tvI6JCXD0](https: //www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7tvI6JCXD0) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-05-08 19:30 BSDs are doing great. Linux is doing better, for now. The competition between the two is only just beginning. BSDs are genuine free software, and their code is shared between many different operating systems. Linux is crippled by a restrictive communist license, and always will be. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NitroNilz · 2020-05-08 22:07 I read it as well and got worried... a few years later and I'm not. BSD is older, but also more stable and better engineered. Linux is trendy. BSD is thorough and more traditional with direct connections to real Unix. __More eyes__ does does not mean __better eyes__. I'm tired. Tired of this article too. I ♥ UNIX - tired of Linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NitroNilz · 2020-05-08 22:08 👀🤣 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-05-09 14:38 You summarized it beautifully. I like the idea of more eyes if it means asking more questions of the development team and helping them to revisit things, but what is needed is people that know what they are doing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2020-05-10 11:12 >Linux is crippled by a restrictive communist license, and always will be. lol. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- le_funny_yellow_dog · 2020-05-13 07:50 > Linux is doing better, for now. Preaching to the choir, but high disagreement; if Linux was "doing better" I'd be using it for... anything. It garnered popularity, but popularity doesn't mean it's "doing better"; a bunch of people using a software doesn't automagically make it good in quality or design, despite what some might say. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-05-13 12:43 Popularity is important. Linux has dozens of billion-dollar corporations, countless smaller businesses, and government departments using it in the workplace, so you have a chance of actually getting a job with it. Linux runs on virtually every "cloud" / VPS / shared hosting provider, so you get better performance per dollar with a Linux container rather than full system virtualization (BSD on top of KVM on top of Linux). I am yet to find a cost-effective way of running a BSD server short of bare metal. But even on bare metal, as confirmed by every benchmark [**(ex. Phoron ix)**](https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=dfly58- freebsd121-ubuntu2004&num=9), all BSDs' performance is lacking... You can get Linux pre-installed and fully supported on a laptop. That isn't the case with any BSD. I occasionally try to get back to one of the BSDs on my laptop, and begrudgingly always end up returning to Linux, because things are horribly slow or just don't work... 😢 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- le_funny_yellow_dog · 2020-05-13 18:24 > Popularity is important. Linux has dozens of billion-dollar corporations, countless smaller businesses, and government departments using it in the workplace, so you have a chance of actually getting a job with it. Sure you can get a job with it, but it doesn't speak anything to Linux' quality. > Linux runs on virtually every "cloud" / VPS / shared hosting provider, so you get better performance per dollar with a Linux container rather than full system virtualization (BSD on top of KVM on top of Linux). I am yet to find a cost-effective way of running a BSD server short of bare metal. Unsure if this helps you in any way, but check out [vultr](https://www.vultr.com/products/cloud-compute/); they offer virtual instances for as low as $2.50 a month and can be preinstalled with OpenBSD or FreeBSD. > But even on bare metal, as confirmed by every benchmark (ex. Phoronix), all BSDs' performance is lacking... Fast != Well-made, if you've ever dug through the Linux kernel configuration, you'd know there are plenty of options like "Enabling this makes X class of exploit easier, but also improves performance. Say yes.", and while I have no objective measure of how much these things actually affect performance, if that's the magic of making Linux faster then I want no part of it. > You can get Linux pre-installed and fully supported on a laptop. That isn't the case with any BSD. Does this actually matter? Installing any BSD isn't that hard; and computers that come pre-installed with Linux aren't particularly common either; nor do I suspect they ship the specific distribution you'd want. >I occasionally try to get back to one of the BSDs on my laptop, and begrudgingly always end up returning to Linux, because things are horribly slow or just don't work... 😢 OpenBSD is quite snappy for me for regular desktop and server usage; it's notably slower at some things, but nothing deal breaking. I don't know your usecase though so I won't assume anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2020-05-13 23:49 I'm a BSD fan (first of all for license reasons), and I want the BSDs to succeed, but my "first duty" is to the Truth... > Unsure if this helps you in any way, but check out vultr [...] I think they are running Linux, same as 99.9% other VPS providers. That means a Linux container would be additionally a lot faster due to less kernel/fs/etc virtualization overhead. There are thousands of VPS providers that offer competitive pricing. > if you've ever dug through the Linux kernel configuration, you'd know there are plenty of options like "Enabling this makes X class of exploit easier, but also improves performance. Say yes.", and while I have no objective measure of how much these things actually affect performance, if that's the magic of making Linux faster then I want no part of it. Then why doesn't a BSD offer the same configurability so it could compete with Linux on a level playing field (even if those optimizations are not recommended)? I don't find Linux (Ubuntu or Arch) any less stable than FreeBSD. > Does this actually matter? Installing any BSD isn't that hard [...] It's easy on a server or desktop, but not a laptop (much less tablet or phone). Last time I installed FreeBSD on my 2-year-old Dell Inspiron 7773, it required a lot of tinkering, but I still couldn't get sound and GPU working right. With Linux everything works automatically after the install. Still can't do any OpenGL (ex. `glxgears` gives an error message), which makes the browsing the modern Web especially slow and painful. No speaker sound. And the battery life is a lot worse, which is very important for me. I'm no noob, and I've spent many hours RTFMing and searching for solutions... > computers that come pre-installed with Linux aren't particularly common either; nor do I suspect they ship the specific distribution you'd want. System76 is awesome. And now Dell ships Linux on some models as well. > I don't know your usecase though so I won't assume anything. Unfortunately I live "off the grid", with electrical power from very limited solar or presently a gasoline generator, so battery life / energy efficiency is more important for me than 99% other users... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- le_funny_yellow_dog · 2020-05-14 00:27 Sounds like the reasons you don't like FreeBSD are the same reasons I don't. OpenBSD addresses all of these issues, besides the performance, where it's likely a worse experience. OpenBSD ships X by default; and usually you won't have to do any tinkering to get it up and running regarding > Then why doesn't a BSD offer the same configurability so it could compete with Linux on a level playing field (even if those optimizations are not recommended)? BSD, or at least OpenBSD shys away from user kernel configuration because it damages system consistency, making life harder for developers. Take the system as packaged or you're on your own. That being said, OpenBSD's kernel is still just as modifiable as linux, it just doesn't have easy toggle switches everywhere because that goes against the design of the system. > System76 is awesome. System76 is overpriced. I'd rather just buy a thinkpad that's known to work with the software (using an E585 right now, vega 8 igpu and ryzen 2500U); rather than pay out the ass for something meant to run an operating system I don't like or use. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bsdlinuxnerd · 2020-05-15 07:12 bSd iS DyInG! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Ironfist · 2020-06-11 03:10 FreeBSD is dying. Netcraft confirms it.