FreeBSD core team appoints a WG to explore transitioning from Subversion to Git reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mcandre · 2019-09-01 23:37 lit ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2019-09-02 02:03 Ah, didn't realize this wasn't public yet. It was announced internally back in May (and obviously bikeshedded to death). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- masta · 2019-09-02 03:37 Weird. Well i believe netbsd moved their commit history to git a few years ago, or at least tried. I believe Eric Raymond himself was leading the efforts, and probably a good chunk of the early history would be the same for both projects. That is assuming the history goes back far enough, and the svn/cvs/rcs heritage did not have anything too terribly crazy happen. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2019-09-02 03:41 Does anyone seriously prefer SVN to Git?! Where were they when the CVS to Git transition was taking place?! I'd vote anyday against SVN and for Git. SVN has the worst of CVS and Git, there's absolutely no reason anyone should ever use Subversion. BTW, what happened with Perforce? I've noticed it's not online anymore, yet I couldn't find any announcement about its impeding shutdown. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2019-09-02 04:56 Nah, we still use CVS at NetBSD; although we do have an official export from CSV to Fossil to GitHub. * http://mail-index.netbsd.org/tech- repository/2017/06/10/msg000637.html I've seen ESR contemplating on various things in our mailing lists, but I'm not sure of the exact involvement, as the things he was proposing didn't seem very realistic (e.g., like modifying the past commit messages by hand to accommodate the conventions in Git and things). * http://wiki.NetBSD.org/gitsofar/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2019-09-02 08:01 I prefer SVN, but I am insufferable, and don't work well with other programmers... I can use either just fine though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2019-09-02 08:30 I'm under the impression that [transitioning to Mercurial](http://www.netbsd.org/~dholland/notes/hg- migration/usage.html) has turned out more feasible so far http://anonhg.netbsd.org/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mercurysquad · 2019-09-02 09:42 Aw man, 10 years ago when I was working on an experimental patch I had to use Perforce. Perforce! That said, Subversion is probably just fine for a centrally managed project like FreeBSD. But why does it take so much discussion to switch? Any BSD developer (if they don't already know it), can pick up Git usage in a day. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- egrek · 2019-09-02 13:10 The issues are not only with git usage (which takes more than a day if you can't afford mistakes cluttering the tree, and git documentation is poor). Since git provides mechanisms, but not structure, the organization must make many decisions about how to manage pull requests, branches, etc. Also, in a hash based dvcs, permanent removal from the tree (e.g. in response to legal threat or court order) is problematic. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mercurysquad · 2019-09-02 15:48 I see. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mcnst · 2019-09-03 01:23 We do have it on Bitbucket, but with them shutting down `hg` now (just announced a few days ago), I don't think that'd be a preferred option over Fossil or Git. We've had the CVS to Fossil to GitHub conversion since 2011, apparently: * http://wiki.NetBSD.org/github/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- efxhoy · 2019-09-07 01:54 >Also, in a hash based dvcs, permanent removal from the tree (e.g. in response to legal threat or court order) is problematic. ​ Are there any examples of projects having to permanently delete code for this reason? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- egrek · 2019-09-07 16:24 I know of at least two firsthand, but don't want too get into details because... Legal threats. I'm sure there are some other public documented instances. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unixygirl · 2019-09-22 06:05 wish they’d use git with github ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ray_juped · 2019-09-23 15:53 If you need a third-party host, https://sourcehut.org/blog/2019-08-21-sourcehut-welcomes-bitbucket- refugees/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- drewdevault · 2019-09-23 16:02 Sourcehut founder here. Some NetBSD devs have experimented with bringing ports over to hg.sr.ht, which has proven that it can handle repositories of this volume: https://hg.sr.ht/~joerg/src Large git repos also work well: https://git.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/linux https://git.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/aports/ FreeBSD is [also available](https://man.sr.ht/builds.sr.ht/compatibility.md#freebsd) as a platform on our CI service, [which has been used by many projects](https://sourcehut.org/blog/2019-09-12-sourcehut-makes-bsd- software-better/) to improve their BSD support. Feel free to reach out if you have questions, /u/Mcnst.