Wanting to install Trident to boot from my USB stick (64GB), run live on RAMdisk (my laptop has 16GB), and save all progress (RAM&RAMdisk) upon hibernation or shutdown reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RetroZvoc · 2019-08-03 15:32 Hello. I'm interested in using Trident as my USB stick live OS akin to PuppyLinux and Tails. My idea is to have the OS bootable from my USB stick whether as a VM (if I'm multitasking with Windows) or from my laptop's BIOS (which is good if my Windows installation gets busted or if there isn't enough RAM). The OS would unpack its snapshot into a RAMdisk and not require the USB stick to be plugged in after that is finished. It wouldn't install onto my harddrive either. I should be able to install more stuff onto the OS (RAMdisk) and put stuff there. And when I'm finished, I'd like to either shut down or hibernate the whole thing back onto the USB stick for the next bootup. And if I messed something up, I'd like to just shut off my laptop and boot from the USB stick again. That's the behavior I saw of PuppyLinux, but that OS is very weak for what I'd like to do. My USB stick has 64GB of storage and I'd like to have at least 32GB free for my own stuff that can be easily visible to a Windows XP/7/10 PC, Android with USB-OTG and other embedded devices (radio stereo player, MIDI synthesizer keyboard with USB slot for music recording, DVD players with USB slots) under some standard partition like FAT32. I don't know would two partitions work with all of those devices in case I want the second partition to be the bootable one with all of the necessary boot doohickey thingamajigs for Trident OS. My laptop specs are this: Laptop: HP Elitebook G1 840 Refurbished CPU: Intel Core i7-4600U @ 2.10GHz (with turbo up to 3.1GHz) GPU: Intel HD Graphics Family & AMD Radeon HD 8750M RAM: 16GB Storage: 512GB SSD OS: Windows 10 Pro with MAR license (for refurbished computers) Thank you for your help and time and patience and understanding as I can ramble all day long, lol. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-08-06 14:23 Why not using Nomad instead? http://nomadbsd.org/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RetroZvoc · 2019-08-07 00:11 Wow, didn't know about that one. You sure it could work? Does it allow for storing FAT32 files onto the same USB stick along side the OS? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- q5sys · 2019-08-07 01:04 Ex PuppyDev and current Trident Dev here... (this is the perfect question for me) The problem is that FreeBSD does not have anything remotely capable to do what AUFS does on the Linux side of the isle. FreeBSD does have UnionFS, but its MAJORLY limited in what it can do. As for why no one has ported AUFS to FreeBSD, my understanding from talking with Kernel Devs is that due to very fundamental decisions in how the Kernel was written with respect to how it works with filesystems, its not possible without major work. And as it stands, no one is interested in doing the work, and it's questionable that even if someone did... that i'd be merged into the kernel. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RetroZvoc · 2019-08-07 01:08 So, what are the potentials of this what FreeBSD has already available? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-08-07 06:47 Sorry, missed the FAT32 thing and, other "details"... I was just thinking about having the OS on the USB-stick. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- q5sys · 2019-08-08 01:16 That I have been able to figure out... no potential... which is why I haven't done it. Maybe someone far smarter than I could figure it out, but I've unable to see a path forward to the end goal of this capability. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RetroZvoc · 2019-08-08 02:21 Btw, don't get me wrong. The only reason I'm into this \*nix stuff is due to my escapism from politics and copyright EULA rightism and copyleft GPL leftism. So, is there anything usable in the spectrum of MIT/BSD/Apache2.0/zlibpng licensed material? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- q5sys · 2019-08-13 01:24 Nope, not until someone write something and licenses it under one of those options. Keep in mind the GPL doesn't really affect you unless you're sharing your binaries. It's fully legal for you to take whatever GPL code you want and do your own personal thing with it. You just cant share your creation without abiding by the license.