Project Trident VS GhostBSD reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- horizonrave · 2019-06-10 07:09 Hi, I understand both are targeting desktop users and are based off FreeBSD . Any other difference I should be aware please? Cheers ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Anonymous_Mentat · 2019-06-10 08:21 GhostBSD Is based on Trident. Think like this: FreeBSD is Debian (solid base) Trident is Ubuntu (light-fork mostly desktop oriented) GhostBSD is Linux Mint. (customized distro with some extra tools) Not 100% accurate, but close enough. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2019-06-10 12:45 Both GhostBSD and Project Trident are based on TrueOS. TrueOS is, in turn, based on the development branch of FreeBSD. Trident is basically a development testing grounds for desktop features and the Lumina desktop. It's more geared towards experimental people and developers. GhostBSD ships with MATE (and Xfce) and offers a more polished, end- user experience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gnemmi · 2019-06-13 16:14 You forgot TrueOS (being an upstream fork from FreeBSD -CURRENT) ... It is actually more like this ... : FreeBSD -> TrueOS -> Project Trident FreeBSD- > TrueOS -> GhostBSD Debian -> Ubuntu -> Linux Mint ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Anonymous_Mentat · 2019-06-13 16:15 Isn't TrueOS the main distro of Trident? Is it the other way around? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gnemmi · 2019-06-13 16:18 TrueOS is an upstream fork from FreeBSD. Project Trident builds upon TrueOS. Is the desktop oriented version of TrueOS. Project Trident uses the infrastructure and development resources that TrueOS provides. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Anonymous_Mentat · 2019-06-13 16:18 Ah ok, I was sure it was the other way around. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gnemmi · 2019-06-13 16:26 Just in case you, or anyone for that matter, should ever need more info or help about Project Trident or GhostBSD, let it be know that both projects have really friendly, resourceful, active and helpful communities over at Telegram which can be found at @ProjectTrident and @ghostbsd respectively. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jsalpha2 · 2019-07-05 14:17 Mainly the difference is the desktop. I am a fan of Xfce and while you can change Trident to Xfce, Ghost comes with it. I would recommend trying Ghost first. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jdrch · 2019-07-08 17:36 >really friendly, resourceful, active and helpful communities I can vouch for this. Unlike many other communities they're not dogmatic, either. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jdrch · 2019-07-08 17:53 > based off FreeBSD Close. They're based on TrueOS, which is great because TrueOS has features that make it better for desktop users than FreeBSD. That said, TrueOS has, IMO, suffered from horrible mismanagement of late. First of all, they (iX Systems) dumped their desktop development altogether to prioritize server dev. Not a bad thing for them, but pretty crappy for everyone who'd bought into their previous vision of an easily usable BSD desktop. As if that wasn't enough, they then proceeded to nuke their own Discourse forum (lmao wat), which contained most of knowledge about the OS since TrueOS still lacks anything close to FreeBSD's documentation. The result of this is a huge chunk of TrueOS' functionality is poorly documented, if at all. This is pretty important as TrueOS has some significant differences from FreeBSD, such as the use of OpenRC. > Any other difference I should be aware please? * (AFAIK) GhostBSD has 1 dev, while Project Trident has 2. You could therefore argue that Trident has more manpower * GhostBSD's DE (Gnome) has its own dev team, leaving GhostBSD's dev to focus on integrating the DE with the rest of the OS. OTOH Trident's DE (Lumina) is developed by 1 of Trident's devs. I'd therefore argue that Lumina is more dedicated to BSD and therefore more likely to not have bugs/issues with it * Obviously from the above, they use different DEs. Lumina's state of development is impressive considering it's basically a one man show. For example, it supports Windows 10 windowing over SSH better than Gnome does * Following from the above, Trident has a bigger workload than GhostBSD * From my own personal experience, Trident's installer is more robust; I couldn't get GhostBSD's installer to boot on 2nd or 3rd Gen Intel Core CPUs * GhostBSD has better security. For the longest time Trident's ISO download wasn't even delivered via HTTPS (I filed the bug to fix this), while GhostBSD's was * IIRC GhostBSD has a torrent download option, while Trident doesn't That said, *if your aim is to run desktop BSD or Unix or ZFS*, you won't be disappointed with either. If your aim is something else, I must admit there are better options out there. I run all 3 major OS paradigms (Windows 10, Trident (BSD), Ubuntu (Linux)) on their own machines so I've been able to evaluate each on its own merits. Hope this helps. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jdrch · 2019-07-08 18:06 > uses the infrastructure and development resources This used to be the case. iX Systems quite literally pulled the rug out from under Trident recently and have actually tried to distance themselves from both it and GhostBSD. While I can understand the financial motivation for the former, I don't understand the motivation for the latter. More people using your product can only be a good thing 🤷‍♂️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2019-07-30 14:15 Just use GhostBSD. Project Trident is generally unusable and ugly.