I have a dillema reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2019-05-18 13:04 I don't know if I should install FreeBSD, or choose OpenBSD. I don't care about small differences like ls --color=auto. I will install BSD on my laptop, ThinkPad T400. And as it will be carried in several different locations almost everyday, encryption is a must-have. Performance should be enough to run web browser. Disk I/O isn't a problem because it has SSD. Battery life is important to me. Nice to have would be to volume keys and Fn+Key combinations to work. It has 4GB of RAM, Core2 Duo P8600, 250GB SSD, 900p screen, Intel GPU and fingerprint reader. I plan on flashing Coreboot/Libreboot on it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GSlayerBrian · 2019-05-18 14:27 If you're planning on going Libreboot, I recommend OpenBSD. I don't know for sure, but I think OpenBSD has no or fewer proprietary binary blobs in its kernel than FreeBSD. (Or if you want to be sure, go LibertyBSD, but it lags behind OpenBSD by quite a bit.) For what it's worth unless you're planning on running a 100% Libre system, Libreboot will be nothing but a hindrance. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2019-05-18 14:29 What I want, isn't fully libre laptop, what I want is almost- unhackable computer and I know that LenovoBIOS has vulnerabilities ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-05-18 14:37 OpenBSD runs smooth as butter on a T400, and fits your requirements. I recommend it over FreeBSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2019-05-18 14:58 No matter what I choose, it runs smooth ---------------------------------------------------------------------- choombak · 2019-05-18 15:42 Why not give both a try, and keep what you like? Best way to get educated about strong points of both operating systems (and don't forget to take notes). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GSlayerBrian · 2019-05-18 15:53 Having no binary blobs is a requirement to having an almost-unhackable computer, so Libreboot is more or less a requirement (and thus so is an operating system which doesn't contain un-auditable blobs). Maintaining such a system is a tedious but rewarding challenge. ----- Note: Since you seem more interested in security than in licensing/software ethics, you could probably still run Coreboot, but just make a conscious effort not to load any proprietary firmware into it. Same idea with the OS kernel. While as far as I know LibertyBSD won't *let* you load any nonfree firmware into the kernel or installing nonfree software, I think OpenBSD won't prevent you from doing so, so it's up to your own diligence in that case. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sehnsuchtbsd · 2019-05-18 17:20 > If you're planning on going Libreboot, I recommend OpenBSD. I don't know for sure, but I think OpenBSD has no or fewer proprietary binary blobs in its kernel than FreeBSD no binary blob in FreeBSD kernel too, nvidia-driver is kept in ports, together with optional firmware; I really wonder whether OpenBSD comes with less firmware in base, as, for instance, it's not like it supports less wireless NICs than FreeBSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2019-05-18 18:10 i915kms driver uses blobs? iwn driver uses blobs? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- techsnapp · 2019-05-19 05:08 Choose the one that you plan on learning about. No sense and asking opinions from people who are already running either operating system. They're already aware of the strengths and weaknesses and have been willing to learn about the OS to be a better user of it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sehnsuchtbsd · 2019-05-19 09:14 i915kms does not, iwn may require loading firmware in order to work (depending on device and regardless of OS), see [iwn(4)](https://www.f reebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?query=iwn&apropos=0&sektion=4&manpath=FreeBSD+1 2.0-RELEASE&arch=default&format=html) on FreeBSD man pages ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ben_bai · 2019-05-19 21:49 And by blobs you mean binary-only divers in kernel? No, blobs. If by blobs you mean firmware-binaries that run on the hardware (NIC, ...) good luck finding hardware from this millennia without. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2019-05-20 05:42 Even if the kernel doesn't load a firmware blob, the device may already contain such a blob. When OpenBSD's kernel sees an Intel gpu, the kernel might try to load the blob file from /etc/firmware. This might fail, because OpenBSD doesn't provide the blob. The device might still work, because Intel might have loaded the blob at the factory. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- stillcantpickaname · 2019-05-23 05:01 for the extended keys, on freebsd at least you can use ports/uhidd to gain access to non-standard keys assuming the thinkpad keyboard is usb.