which computer should i buy with which bsd? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localhostdotdev · 2019-05-17 13:25 (sry for what i guess is a frequent post but i prefer people's opinions than lists and comparison tables) history: - i used windows in my early teenage years, started programming in c++ and python - then switched to linux (ubuntu and derivatives) for like 10 years - also android when it came out - then switched to macos since like 6 years - then switched from android to iphone like 4 years ago - all my servers are linux (except one i just bought that has bsd on it) (ok i know macos/darwin is bsd, but not really what i imagine when i talk about bsd) hardware: - has the longest battery that possibly exist :) - a keyboard and trackpack the most similar possible to pre-butterfly macbook keyboards - a 15 inches or less screen size - a laptop - i don't care about all the ports (even usb), just charging would be nice, especially if it's an easy to find cable - keyboard should be available in "no writing on it" or us qwerty (not international qwerty) - if it's cheap it's better so i can buy multiple ones :D (e.g. a $50 one would be the perfect price point even if i know it's unlikely) - some kind of wifi card would be nice :D - gpu, cpu, memory, hard drive i don't care about that, let's say a minimum is no gpu, 1GHz, 500MB, 5GB :D (actually the less the better :), i haven't gotten around to doing programming stuff with 0GHz yet :) ) software: - can run ruby, node, and bash (hard i know :) ) - can run any kind of visual web browser (not lynx) except firefox (and derivatives), ideally chromium or better - by default will have some strong security protections where it's even hard to shoot myself in the foot (but i still can if i reeeeally want to) - is minimal, simple and easy to learn ideally everything "works out of box"™️ i will probably start by ssh-ing into the bsd server and setting up everything there then move that setup offline on a computer running bsd natively. thanks xxx ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2019-05-17 13:56 Are you planning to use BSD on a workstation or is it going to be just a server? For a beginner, you might want to use TrueOS which is a more user friendly FreeBSD variant. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localhostdotdev · 2019-05-17 15:59 on a "workstation", e.g. my personal and work computer thanks, will definitely try TrueOS if FreeBSD is too complicated or doesn't work ---------------------------------------------------------------------- istarian · 2019-05-17 16:07 I feel like you're describing diametrically opposed things. Are you looking for something you can use daily or something really low end that might be borderline obsolete for experimentation? I have no idea how anyone could guarantee everything works right out of the box unless it's very specific hardware combination that has actually been tested... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2019-05-17 16:18 TrueOS is just FreeBSD with a different installer and a slightly different base configuration. It's just a little bit more user friendly, especially in the set up (graphical instead of text based installer). That's all there is to it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2019-05-17 16:23 For a workstation, there are two major points to watch out for: * the graphics card * the wifi card For these two, make sure to buy something that is supported by FreeBSD. Perhaps check out the [hardware compatibility list](https://www.freebsd.org/releases/12.0R/hardware.html). Everything else should work just fine. In general, I recommend you to by a professional workstation or tower server as these devices just work better in general. It should be no problem to get FreeBSD working on any normal tower though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- woogeroo · 2019-05-17 17:32 Thinkpad, X, X1 or T series depending on budget. Keyboards are great, better than Mac keyboards for sure, but similar enough to the old model MacBook to feel at home. They’re not cheap new, but are available with very good deals from Lenovo sometimes. Also, to really save money you can buy a used model (many available from Enterprise businesses) in perfect condition for very little money. Swap in a bigger SSD / RAM and you have an amazing machine. FreeBSD devs (those that actually use FreeBSD anyway) tend to use them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- plhk · 2019-05-17 20:02 Agreed. X230 goes for about $200 on ebay and is a good enough machine for most uses. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2019-05-17 20:06 TrueOS is based on FreeBSD's -current branch so will have different drivers and it uses a different package manager for the base OS. It also uses LibreSSL instead of OpenSSL. There are other differences, but it's a bit more complex than just having a graphical package manager. If the OP wants a user friendly experience they should use GhostBSD. It's TrueOS at its core, but with a more beginner-friendly approach. TrueOS is experimental and designed with more technical people in mind. GhostBSD is more beginner friendly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localhostdotdev · 2019-05-17 20:50 looked at them, also tried a few thinkpads previously keyboards are good, just not as great as macbook's (pre-2016) ones, also has too many ports, and i don't want mate display, it's not made in metal, i don't like the logo, and foldable sounds cool but not sure i would use it (more likely a distraction and more likely to break), this combined with $\~1000, which is okay but not for a plastic laptop i don't think you read my post (i don't care about ssd/ram/etc.) i see and understand that a lot of people like thinkpads, just not my cuppa tea. xxx ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localhostdotdev · 2019-05-17 20:51 thanks for the link to list, i definitely want to screen and internet to work :D i move quite a lot so can't have a static computer (couldn't work in trains, planes, coffee shops and couldn't move it from office to home) (edit: oof would be easier to have actual computer names :D, will look for that) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localhostdotdev · 2019-05-17 20:54 i'm looking for something minimalistic, i don't play games, i don't do heavy stuff with gpu/machine learning etc., i use servers for machine- intensive tasks (like storing gigabytes/terabytes in a database, etc.) someone linked to the hardware list, so i will look at those, maybe choosing a very simple machine could make it likely to be supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2019-05-17 21:05 If it's a laptop, further considerations apply. I recommend you to check if that exact model you plan to buy has been used successfully with FreeBSD before. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2019-05-17 21:40 Then look at Elitebook 2570p ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CuBeRJAN3 · 2019-05-17 21:42 > Too many ports How is that a bad thing? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- woogeroo · 2019-05-17 22:54 Too many ports? Who cares, what’s the difference? Foldable? Not too sure what you mean by this. If you don’t want RAM or SSD upgraded, don’t upgrade them from stock. You can get a great used Thinkpad from a few years ago from like $200 that is perfect for your use case. I have no idea what you expect to find with 1GHz/500MB ram in a laptop form factor similar to a MacBook. Buy a used MacBook from a few years ago maybe. If you run FreeBSD and want decent out of the box hardware support your choices are limited. You can spend an insane amount of time trying to get things working well on a random machine, or pick something well supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nick_storm · 2019-05-18 12:09 Can't speak to the other BSDs, but OpenBSD is minimal and simple. Minimalism is one of their tenets. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-05-18 13:25 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2019-05-19 03:09 Each BSD has different versions of packages. I run OpenBSD; [the list of packages for OpenBSD 6.5 amd64](https://cdn.openbsd.org/pub/OpenBSD/6.5/packages/amd64/) includes 2 Chromium-based browsers (chromium 73.0.3683.86 and iridium 2018.11.71) and a few WebKit browsers (luakit 2.1, midori 8.0, otter- browser 0.9.94, surf 2.0, vimb 3.3.0). Node.js is in the node 10.15.0 package. There won't be newer packages until OpenBSD 6.6, about 6 months from now. ([The unstable packages for OpenBSD-current](https:// cdn.openbsd.org/pub/OpenBSD/snapshots/packages/amd64/) don't run on 6.5, and sometimes not even on -current.) My Android tablet gets the latest Chrome from Google Play, but my OpenBSD desktop has a months- old Chromium, and [an unofficial package of Firefox](https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-ports-cvs&m=155713656524528&w=2) that fixes the add-on bug. I tried to find packages for other BSDs: [NetBSD amd64 8.0 2019Q1](htt p://cdn.netbsd.org/pub/pkgsrc/packages/NetBSD/amd64/8.0_2019Q1/All/) doesn't have Chromium. [FreeBSD 12 amd64](https://pkg.freebsd.org/FreeBSD:12:amd64/latest/All/) has many packages (including multiple versions of Node). [DragonFly 5.6 x86:64] (https://avalon.dragonflybsd.org/dports/dragonfly:5.6:x86:64/LATEST/Al l/) has older versions of what FreeBSD has. [TrueOS amd64](https://pkg.trueos.org/pkg/freebsd- pkgbase/FreeBSD%3A13%3Aamd64/latest/All/) looks close to what FreeBSD has. In my experience, some parts of OpenBSD don't work out of the box. It disables [apmd(8)](https://man.openbsd.org/apmd) by default; I use [rcctl(8)](https://man.openbsd.org/rcctl) to enable `apmd -A`, which adjusts my cpu speed to save power, and allows me to sleep `zzz` and hibernate `ZZZ` my amd64 desktop. The datasize-cur in [login.conf(5)](https://man.openbsd.org/login.conf) is too low and causes web browsers and some games to run out of memory; I raised my datasize-cur to 3G. After I pkg\_add(1)ed xfce, I needed to write a shell script in \~/.xsession to start xfce instead of the default fvwm. My OpenBSD machines use an Ethernet wire, but other people get stuck with wi-fi: OpenBSD tries to download some wi-fi firmware, but can't use wi-fi to download it. My newest OpenBSD machine is 8 years old (from 2010), so I don't know how BSD runs on newer hardware. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2019-05-25 09:30 For real keyboard layout - ThinkPad X220/T420/T420s/T520/W520 - depending on your USB 3.0 and physical size needs. ​ These ThinkPad \*20 will work with ALL BSDs well. ​ * X220 with i7 has USB 3.0 and up to 1366x768. * T420s has USB 3.0 and up to 1600x900. * W520 has USB 3.0. * T520 and W520 are available with FullHD 1920x1080 screen. * X220 is available with IPS screen (also 1366x768). * T420 and T520 does not have USB 3.0 in any option. * Its possible to get T520 with Quad Core CPU - its has the same cooling as W520. ​ If you want newer options, then ThinkPad X1 Carbon 5th and 6th Generations work well with FreeBSD but dunno about other BSDs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vermaden · 2019-05-25 09:32 >TrueOS Stay away from TrueOS, use stock FreeBSD.