UNIX and BSD Discord/Matrix Servers reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 04:04 Hey there. My friend has started running a discord server for BSD and UNIX discussion, with an emphasis on new users who may not want to use IRC or who prefer discord or Matrix. The Matrix address: #bsd-unix-group:matrix.org The Discord Invite: https://discord.gg/nYjvXyc Join if you're into these kinds of chat. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- TotesMessenger · 2019-04-03 04:22 I'm a bot, *bleep*, *bloop*. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit: - [/r/freebsd] [UNIX and BSD Discord\/Matrix Servers](https://www.redd it.com/r/freebsd/comments/b8terp/unix_and_bsd_discordmatrix_servers/) - [/r/netbsd] [UNIX and BSD Discord\/Matrix Servers](https://www.reddi t.com/r/NetBSD/comments/b8tlkw/unix_and_bsd_discordmatrix_servers/) - [/r/unix] [UNIX and BSD Discord\/Matrix Servers](https://www.reddit. com/r/unix/comments/b8ti57/unix_and_bsd_discordmatrix_servers/)  *^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^\([Info](/r/TotesMessenger) ^/ ^[Contact](/message/compose?to=/r/TotesMessenger))* ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2019-04-03 04:37 There is also #bsd:matrix.org and telegram : https://t.me/unitedbsd both are bridged :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 14:24 Not a fan of fragmenting the community like this. IRC isn’t hard to use and has long been a official method of communication alongside mailing lists. And unlike Discord or Telegram, IRC is actually decentralized and not proprietary. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- w0lrah · 2019-04-03 15:28 Matrix is also decentralized and not proprietary. The problems with IRC basically come down to two things, IMO: 1. No standard support for formatting or rich content. 2. No sane support for multiple devices. I realize that in a *nix group there'll be a lot of old-school types who think #1 is a good thing, but it's not if you want to keep your community growing. Being able to paste a block of code in to the channel and have it come through sanely is a good thing. Being able to post images and have people see them without requiring a click through is a good thing. Link previews are good things. Et cetera. Also there's nothing stopping you from configuring your client to not show these things, in which case you can have the same old classic IRC experience you prefer. As far as #2 goes, yes of course there are solutions that people use. Bouncers, running a text-mode client in a screen/tmux session, and so on, but those do not provide the same shared state experience you get with the modern rich chat protocols. If I'm switching between a desktop, a laptop, and a phone while wanting to stay in the same conversations the closest I can get with IRC is something like Quassel. Now Quassel is open source and great to use most of the time, but if you look in to its network protocol it's not pretty. Alternative clients are unlikely. Matrix solves both of these issues quite well IMO. It provides the kind of experience people used to Slack or Discord like, but in a standardized, decentralized, self-hostable way. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 15:30 Strawman. I didn’t mention Matrix at all. I’m perfectly fine with Matrix and am trialing Riot.im at the moment. Don’t make blind assumptions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- w0lrah · 2019-04-03 15:44 It's not a blind assumption when it's half of what this thread is about. I agree that Discord is silly (if you're going to use a proprietary service, why use the one intended for gamers rather than the one intended for productivity?) but your response didn't specify in any way that you were only talking about it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 15:53 Point taken. I concede that a position, if nuanced, should be clarified for everyone’s sake, especially on the internet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 16:36 Discord attracts young people. There's roughly 250,000 regular IRC users, but Discord has millions of users. If you don't want to tap into young people that's fine, but don't expect people to go back to stone age protocols on their own when alternatives exist. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 16:38 We bridged discord to the Matrix chatroom so that way we have options for both kinds of people. Discord is huge, and attracts young people. The admin of the discord even runs an IRIX discord, and he has over 200 regular users a day. Not huge, but IRC is sadly on the decline. And the hope is to eventually push people to matrix and other clients while providing accessibility and migration ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 16:55 I like how you just ignored the points made about decentralization and the downsides of gated communities in order to advance your own agenda. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 17:16 Lolwut? I made three arguments mate that were respectful and useful: 1. Discord has a larger userbase. This is undeniable. 2. IRC is primitive and has far less regular users 3. Matrix is federated and designed to bridge communities like this anyways. So again, what is worth insulting me over? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 17:29 No one’s insulted you. Resorting to hyperbole really doesn’t help your case at all, with another example being your referring to IRC as a stone-age protocol. Furthermore you still don’t address the fact that these are not officially affiliated with any of the BSDs, which will confuse incoming new users as to where to get official help and communications from. Again, you completely ignore how this fragments the community when there has already been a long-established precedent for where to engage with others: IRC, the forums and the mailing lists. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 17:31 I still fail to see any issues with this. What you're saying is elitist and gatekeeping. And with that I think we have nothing more to discuss. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- quanell · 2019-04-03 17:33 Funny, you’re the one that wants to move people into your own gated community, by definition making you a gatekeeper. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ahandle · 2019-04-03 17:53 What's this? A Flying Bridge? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-03 18:41 It's a chatroom for BSD and UNIX users that is bridged between Matrix and Discord. It offers a lot of benefits over IRC, namely because it supports: * Text-formatting, including code-snippets * Image/gif embedding * Video embedding * Music * Voice chat ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ahandle · 2019-04-03 18:45 GTFOOHWT ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-04-04 06:08 I love reading messages (history) when I come back online. However irc is dead easy to setup on terminal. ZNC is bit complicated set setup for me and IRC Cloud is paid service. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-04-04 06:11 IRC is for 1337 people. Upstream developers directly poke there ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LiberalMasochist · 2019-04-11 15:32 Just use screen from a VPS, or run a bot to log history. Does discord even work on freebsd? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-04-11 15:49 No. But it doesn't matter as long as I can use bridge via matrix everywhere (@appservice-irc:matrix.org for irc for example). Now I can connect discord via bridge, telegram, IRC servers, other matrix channels etc without a single connection drop, with full encryption, chat logs stored remotely (encrypted on private chats optionally), runs even on browsers. All we need is an irc client and a volunteer to host a log server. We are BSD people, not Linux newbies. Newbies don't do these, we can. Right? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ReservoirPenguin · 2019-04-22 15:31 I don't use X-Window system, does this discord program work in a terminal? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazenoIgnis · 2019-04-25 03:58 The main client doesn't. Some of the third party ones do. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- s_w_eek · 2019-05-02 00:24 I don't think this is fragmenting the community.... Some people just don't care for irc and would rather not use it. Now there is an alternative set of applications for those people.