Is there an advantage of using bsd over linux? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kiwi_birds · 2018-09-15 18:03 Hi! I'm a distro hopper and I have windows installed and I'm thinking of trying bsd, specifically freebsd 11. Is there an advantage of using it over Linux in terms of "work"? (I don't really have a job, I just make dumb little code in C and other languages) I'm still going to install freebsd but I'd like to know! :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- celibidaque · 2018-09-15 18:25 No systemd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kiwi_birds · 2018-09-15 18:27 Why? I used it all the time on linux ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Volt · 2018-09-15 18:49 No, it's a matter of preference. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- msbic · 2018-09-15 18:52 I am a hobbyist, not an advanced user, so from my pov - Things don't change rapidly (from a user perspective). Most of what I learned 10-12 years ago is still relevant. - You have 1-2 filesystems, a single sound subsystem. - Strict separation between the system and 3-rd party software. - Both open and free installations are minimal, no bloat. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- losthalo7 · 2018-09-15 19:06 Rather than play out a discussion on it here, you should giggle for the reasons why some don't like systemd if you're curious. Not being tied to systemd was a factor in why I recently switched over to NetBSD from Debian. The real question is what you need out of an OS (and why you're not out researching that on your own rather than just asking vague questions here). I do like for example that NetBSD leaves /usr/local/ for your own use since I occasionally compile things from source. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlangille · 2018-09-15 19:22 What I do like is ZFS, poudriere, jails, and pkg. I can use poudriere to build my own packages, with the configuration items I select. It uses the FreeBSD provided ports tree, but build when I say. Patch gets issued, I can update the systems immediately. Poudriere can use zfs and jails to full potential to build new packages in parallel, not [necessarily] serially. ZFS is a great filesystem (yeah, you got that on Linux too), and jails are great way to virtualize stuff. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 7yearlurkernowposter · 2018-09-15 19:42 Things are built to last instead of the wheel being reinvented weekly. There are downsides to this as well but a lot of us are looking for a more traditional Unix. Really it’s personal preference, most of us probably have a Linux install somewhere at work or home as well, I just find BSD to be a more pleasing experience especially with the documentation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- X7spyWqcRY · 2018-09-15 19:48 BSD man pages are excellent. Coming from Linux you have to train yourself to read the docs instead of just immediately googling everything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2018-09-15 20:12 Yes. Also add the FreeBSD ports collection. It's why I use FreeBSD. Then there are also beadm and pf. I'd like to add that booting BSDs is nice. Every stage allows you to inspect the situation and you don't have this hacky squashfs thing that introduces a redundant point of failure with a second Linux distribution. Also BSDs allow you to mount filesystems as you like with a few constraints only. If you're an admin and don't want to get a heart attack when there are problems, choose a BSD, because you'll a be able to analyze the situation in almost every case, while using the system under inspection. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-09-15 20:24 In general, the BSDs are cleaner and much more consistent than the GNU/Linux distros. Therefore, it all depends on what you want to do. That would determine whether the cleanliness and consistency would be beneficial to you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2018-09-15 20:31 Makes your beard thicker and more gray. Kidding aside, BSD is a collection of 4 operating systems designed from top down as full OS's. Linux is generally a mixture of a kernel and the userland of the failed GNU Herd. BSD is Copyfree, Linux is Copyleft. BSD is a UNIX, Linux is a UNIX Like. In general, since one's a UNIX and the other is a UNIX Like, they run pretty much the same software and do the same things. Linux however, being a UNIX-Like has slowly gone down their own path of software that only works on Linux. Not to mention all the closed sourced stuff written for it. When it comes to "work". You're not going to notice much difference between the two if you're using FOSS stuff. They're both essentially the same. When it comes to maintenance, I find a fully designed OS to be much easier to use than 250+ distros all using different user lands which are not consistent with each other, consistent on the system, etc. TLDR. BSD's are much better organized. Linux is more chaotic. Both essentially do the same thing if you stick to FOSS code and away from Linux specific monstrosities like SystemD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-09-15 20:33 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- YouCanIfYou · 2018-09-15 20:55 From underlying philosophy to documentation and file structure, "BSDs are cleaner and more consistent" is no joke--see [a code comparison](https://gist.github.com/fogus/1094067). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ScrambledAuroras · 2018-09-15 21:25 An overclocking regression on Arch Linux, Xubuntu, and other distros is currently present for a few motherboards, and I couldn't figure out what was causing it on my workstation. BSDs don't do that though, FreeBSD actually lets you overclock. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2018-09-15 21:40 FreeBSD performs better at networking than Linux does. It's one of the reasons Netflix uses it for all their video delivery. The BSDs are more concerned with engineering than popularity, playing games, or gaining market share from Windows. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tzsz · 2018-09-15 21:54 How does NetBSD perform as a Debian replacement? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-15 22:49 No GPLv3 in the OS is the main advantage for me. The licenses are very permissive, in general. There are many things that aren't as well supported, though. I know there's a hypervisor but it's pretty new. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- losthalo7 · 2018-09-15 23:07 Performance-wise I'm not seeing a big difference. I didn't have any problems with Debian, it's a very solid OS. I'd used it for over a decade, but I didn't want to transition to using systemd or jump through hoops on every system upgrade to continue using SysV init. I'd had access to a NetBSD system at [SDF](https://sdf.org/) for a long time on a shell account and liked it and decided to try it as my desktop OS. I once again know what all of the processes running in 'top' are whereas Linux has been proliferating the processes that have to run just to boot. It's like a breath of fresh air, basically. The question really is what you need your OS to do, and what your preferences are. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Volt · 2018-09-16 00:09 I'm not sure stuff like that really matters to a distro hopper though ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 00:34 No ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 00:35 No gpl is why bsds are dying ---------------------------------------------------------------------- _my_name_is_earl_ · 2018-09-16 00:56 > cleaner and much more consistent What does that mean and why does it matter for the user? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- twizmwazin · 2018-09-16 01:19 Less, more straightforward code means there is a significantly lower chance of a security vulnerability. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 01:56 By your (non)logic all non-copyleft projects would be dying, and copyleft would dominate the free software ecosystem. But **the very opposite is happening in reality!** The [market share](https://blog.github.com/2015-03-09-open-source-license-usage- on-github-com/) of [copyfree](http://copyfree.org) (permissive) licenses continues to grow. Some examples in various software categories... BSD-licensed Chromium (in many distributions) took over the Internets, reducing Firefox to 5% [market share](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browser_market_share). All popular FLOSS Web servers have been permissive (Apache, Nginx) from the beginning. Only Oracle's Java is the last [popular](https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/) programming language with only restrictively-licensed implementations, while permissive languages like Go, Python, Rust, Haskell, etc are growing the fastest. Same for newest popular text editors: Atom, VScode, IntelliJ Community Edition, etc. LLVM is gaining on GCC. Zsh is gaining on bash. PostgreSQL and SQLite are gaining on MySQL. Etc. The real reason why Linux was successful ***DESPITE*** copyleft: BSDs were not freed from AT&T lawsuits until 1994, and Linux went viral in the year prior. The kernel is the most difficult piece of software to replace, so the industry became addicted. Linux remained the most popular open source option, gaining many leader advantages like billions of dollars in support from IBM, Oracle, and now even Microsoft. But, despite lacking those billions of dollars, the BSDs are doing just fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 02:06 False, as other commentators have demonstrated. You might not care about the criteria where BSDs are at an advantage, but that doesn't mean those criteria don't exist. I'm a philosopher, and to me software freedom and my [rejection of restrictive licenses](http://copyfree.org) trumps everything else. Linux tries to be a jack-of-all-trades in a single codebase (from embedded / IoT to laptops to mainframes and supercomputers), and that adds on tremendous complexity. Projects like OpenBSD and DragonFlyBSD focus on more narrow goals. I think OpenBSD has always been ahead of Linux in security and correctness, and that DragonFlyBSD will soon surpass it in amd64 performance as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 02:08 Check out the [Copyfree Initiative](http://copyfree.org) for other people who appreciate license freedom. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 02:19 So you thing ultimate freedom is good everywhere? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ahandle · 2018-09-16 02:24 [init](https://www.freebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?query=init&sektion=8&manpat h=freebsd-release-ports) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 02:34 Liniers said himself, gpl is the reason, bed became a whore project that got forked too many times ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-16 02:37 The lawyers at work won't let me use GPL code in my projects, so, yeah. I understand why Linux uses GPL and it makes sense to me but it also makes it harder for me to use. And I really don't think BSDs are dying. MacOS is doing quite well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2018-09-16 02:44 No. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vvelox · 2018-09-16 02:53 There is a lot less time needed to be spent configuring stuff as you don't need to deal with the half assery that is the shitty defaults and distros trying to manage stuff. Outside of that it all depends on what BSD you are using. Speaking in regards to FreeBSD... It has a actually easy to work with and good disk sub system. ZFS on it is great with no weird ass non- standard "features" that will make your pool unportable. A firewall that does not suck ass. Sane network management(no half assedly maintained ifconfig command or badly through out ip command). Software RAID that is actually good. And lots of other fun bits. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 02:54 I would say yes, donations are shrinking no lagging behind on Current technologies almost 0 support from vendors ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-09-16 02:54 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2018-09-16 02:56 In that case, the BSDs are far more stable than almost all Linux distros and he would really appreciate that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 03:09 That's an over-generalization. I offer an alternative to [Richard Stallman](http://stallman.org)'s free software philosophy. He sees businesses and free market capitalism as an evil, vindicates copyright (which copyleft depends on), and puts a lot of faith in centralized government. I believe that, if he had the power, he would continue expanding GPL with further restrictions and impositions (SJW CoCs, all power to Mommy Government, all right-wingers are Nazis, etc). I see FLOSS as a free market phenomenon that shares ecosystems with proprietary businesses for mutual benefit, and requires nothing from government force (including no regulation of ISPs). I question automagical implicit contracts and intellectual property in general (read [Kinsella](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephan_Kinsella) for a right-libertarian perspective on IP). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- annadane · 2018-09-16 03:18 My irritation with FreeBSD - and OpenBSD barely works thanks to the clusterfuck that is Nvidia - is how hard it is to set up a simple desktop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Silbern_ · 2018-09-16 03:50 Mac OS is not a BSD at all. It uses the userland and that's it, and even then the versions tend to be quite old. The kernel is the XNU Mach kernel iirc, and as a microkernel, it functions quite differently to Linux or the BSD's monolithic one. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Silbern_ · 2018-09-16 03:54 Hard compared to Linux in general, or hard compared to for example Ubuntu or OpenSUSE? Arch and Debian have very similar install processes to FreeBSD...? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- annadane · 2018-09-16 04:01 I just felt there was a lot of futzing around with things that were easier in Linux. Maybe one day I'll sit down and read the manual more thoroughly ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marmulak · 2018-09-16 04:27 For me FreeBSD is a pleasure to use. I'm no stranger to Linux and I have a favorite distro, but I often go for BSD when I can because I usually find it easier to manage, more lightweight and simple, but just as powerful. In other words, it's most convenient. As they say, the system is clean and stable. I first learned how to really admin and manage a unix-based system with FreeBSD when I was a teen. Prior to that I had used Linux for a couple years but hardly learned anything except how to use wizards to set things up. (And they'd get set up wrong, too.) BSD isn't as much of a pain in the ass to customize. Tweak and tinker all you want. It's perfect for someone who wants to learn more about system administration. You can do all kinds of stuff on it too... lots of software available. Not as much software and hardware support as Linux, but it really holds its own compared to like 99% of all OS's. Also don't forget GNU/Linux is essentially based on the fundamental Unix design, which is what BSD literally is. Personally I think it'll help you grow as a person. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marmulak · 2018-09-16 04:35 I don't know how it is now but once you learn how to install the video driver and set up X then it gets really easy. Take you like five minutes ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-16 05:02 IMHO an OS is a userland and a kernel and running a BSD userland with another kernel doesn't make it not BSD anymore. Mach is derived from BSD code originally. It's probably a distant cousin of the current BSD kernels at this point but it's still in the family. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-09-16 05:07 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-16 05:21 BSDs as general operating systems are not popular (except macOS). But we see other projects build on top of it all the time, and that stuff is everywhere. FreeNAS and pfSense are probably the most popular examples. The BRAND is not doing so hot, but the code is all over the place and people rely on it every day. A lot of the backbone internet infrastructure also uses BSDs. There are enough businesses with a vested interest to keep development going. It doesn't have feature parity with Linux, but people don't use it for the same stuff they use Linux for. We also see NetBSD and Dragonfly in a lot of embedded devices. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marmulak · 2018-09-16 05:35 This is an awful lot of bullshit about Richard Stallman and the GPL. The importance of copyleft is that it ensures the quality of open source and free software because it stops the abusive tactic of forking open source projects and then closing them. Businesses abuse BSD-style licesning to get free development, but they will not return their own code contributions to the community, so it is a take-only and give-nothing relationship which is bad for the user (you). GPL/copyleft was a clever innovation that established a give-and-take relationship that was mutually beneificial for everybody. Then you get all these idiots claiming BSD license is "more free" when if it wasn't for the GPL you wouldn't even have quality open source software today. Even BSD systems were developed with heavy dependence on GNU software, or by people who could not have learned how to do it had GNU software not existed. The GPL is not anti-business. In fact, Stallman encouraged selling GPL software and other viable business models. Lots of businesses have been built around free software. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xerxero · 2018-09-16 06:07 Why? I do find the binary driver work fine with xorg. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- HaleyStarshine · 2018-09-16 09:10 BSD is absolutely not Unix as it is not certified per the SUS. It's just as Unix-like as Linux. Solaris and MacOS on the other hand... /u/pink_echoes to the rescue. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-16 09:51 Wrong... if only people made proper researches instead of simply making assertions accompanied by 'iirc', where 'iirc' mainly consists of rumors. So it's not rare to bump across 'macOS is Mach' or 'macOS is FreeBSD' without evidence at hand. Both satements are wrong XNU is an hybrid kernel born from Mach 3.2 and kBSD4.3 Unix Reno (albeit those have been later replaced by True64 OSFMK and kFreeBSD portions respectively); the [BSD part](https://opensource.apple.com/source/xnu/xnu-1504.3.12/bsd/kern/) is neither secondary [nor negligible](https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd- advocacy/2008-August/003674.html) at all, as it provides the POSIX API, handles syscalls and memory allocation, kernel loader, init, filesystem hierarchy, MAC and crypto frameworks, user/group ids and permissions, VFS, IPC, TCP stack and networking protos, UFS, HFS, NFS, FAT and other FSs support, audit subsystem, FS-independent journaling, randomization... It's by these components and its *BSD userland that Darwin is SUS -compliant and [registered Unix](https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3632.htm). DragonflyBSD has an hybrid kernel too; this doesn't make it less Unix than others ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pink_echoes · 2018-09-16 10:46 It has a Unix lineage though in contrast to Linux (however quite much of old Unix code is purged now due to copyright issues). Technically though it is indeed a descendant of old Unix. But yes, it's not UNIX©/POSIX-certified. OTOH there are systems that are certified by the SUS but do not share any history or code with the original Unices. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 11:26 Doesn't seem too well, shame, well that's why I prefer the gpl which sacrifices some individual freedom for a bigger society freedom ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 11:44 The GPL gives me a more important freedom, freedom for all of us as humans, it doesn't give me complete individual freedom, but that sacrifice make us free as a society ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FrontMeringue · 2018-09-16 12:22 for my developer self, I really like that the entire OS's source code is easily available and easy to build. I have inspected and modified random parts as I desire. I also build all my packages from source (with debuginfo, and leaving the work directories), so really, I have nothing holding me back from diving into why a problem happens if I so desire. It's very satisfying. everything is 20 seconds from a sprinkle of debug printfs to see if my guess is right. from X, to kernel, to ld.so. In linux doing all of this is hard, I had trouble producing a working kernel from the latest git. First trying with the default config, then with the distro config, both had problems. I tried to update rtld, but it was to a newer version that enabled some security mitigation that conflicted with the rest of my builds. I have a lot less confidence to make changes, but maybe it will come with time. That and ctrl-T, everyone who BSD'd for a while will leave these phantom ctrl+T on linux and get disappointed at no answer. Which process is hanging? what is it doing now? one of the 200 opened processes is the one that's running. Linux does have better support in everything though. I keep having to add support for things I want on netbsd. But hopefully everyone afterwards won't have to. And it keeps me busy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poshpotdllr · 2018-09-16 13:22 dafuq? gpl is why linux is dying ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 13:38 Linux dying now that's a joke ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poshpotdllr · 2018-09-16 13:50 most common OS is netbsd/minix (every x86 cpu for 10 years) followed by darwin bsd (ios/osx) followed by freebsd (juniper, netapp, citrix, etc) followed by linux (android, hipsters). youre on crack. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-16 13:58 Right https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems Like how bad donations are dying code is poor? Etc ---------------------------------------------------------------------- HelperBot_ · 2018-09-16 13:59 Non-Mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems *** ^HelperBot ^v1.1 ^/r/HelperBot_ ^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Please ^message ^/u/swim1929 ^with ^any ^feedback ^and/or ^hate. ^Counter: ^212439 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poshpotdllr · 2018-09-16 14:04 >Right https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems this article is written by idiots that dont count most computers. they think a computer is a web server software or a cell phone only. >Like how bad donations are dying unlike linux, bsd is free. people are assholes. get over it. > code is poor? Etc only poor code in bsd land is freebsd because of linux compatibility layer and openness to gpl. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- HelperBot_ · 2018-09-16 14:04 Non-Mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems *** ^HelperBot ^v1.1 ^/r/HelperBot_ ^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Please ^message ^/u/swim1929 ^with ^any ^feedback ^and/or ^hate. ^Counter: ^212444 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2018-09-16 14:14 Of course *BSD's are not UNIX certified. If memory serves me certification is outrageously expensive and serves very little purpose for a non-commerical operating system. It doesn't mean they couldn't pass the test process. It just means it they haven't paid Austin Group / The Open Group for their seal of approval. https://web.archive.org/w eb/20131223025351/http://www.freebsd.org/projects/c99/ As you can see in the link, FreeBSD was not too far off way back in 2002. I doubt it took steps backwards since then. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DonovanNagel · 2018-09-16 15:17 Wow. Good to see this comparison. And all equally functional? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DonovanNagel · 2018-09-16 15:21 NVIDIA on OpenBSD you are correct. But getting a desktop up and running, totally false. Both FreeBSD and OpenBSD are leaps and bounds easier and faster than most Linux distributions. OpenBSD works out of the box. FreeBSD is dead simple - install xorg and a desktop, xinit. Bam. Why is that so hard? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- random_fucktuation · 2018-09-16 15:52 Similar question, I don't know C at all. Why is the UNIXv5 implementation of echo so simple compared with later implementations on later OSes... ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-09-16 18:58 [removed] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-16 20:58 Why do you always have to react like that on this forum and can't keep a civil debate? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-16 21:00 Dragonfly on embedded? Since when? It only supports x86_64 and is designed to run on multiple cores, large SSDs, high physical RAM and lot of swap. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-16 21:16 BSDs look like serious Operating Systems, they somehow return the kind of experience which things like macOS, Solaris or even Windows can give: something 'finished', tidy, united, coherent, consistent and tightly -integrated, designed bottom to top with clear goals. Linux has this peculiarity of feeling like a messy whole of redundant components developed by different projects with different phylosophylies and goals in mind, wrapped togerlther around the same kernel ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 21:45 Translating what you said from Communistspeak to English: > GPL uses legalese restrictions backed by government violence to force people to do what I want. That's not "free as in freedom"! Only open source software that is either "public domain" or has an inconsequential "just don't sue me" license [(whitelisted by the Copyfree Initiative)](http://copyfree.org/standard/licenses) is genuinely free. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EnigmaticHam · 2018-09-16 22:45 The BSDs are more coherent, consistent and reliable even than GNU/Linux. The result for the end user is a more stable system that behaves predictably and works the way you expect. This allows you to hack and slash the system more than a Linux machine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- U-1F574 · 2018-09-16 23:01 No they are not all equally functional. I mean, they are in the sense they print text, but unix one is nowhere near as configurable as the GNU one. Also the freebsd one draws in more libraries than any other. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- U-1F574 · 2018-09-16 23:05 Backwards compatibility with old scripts mostly, and new features. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-16 23:47 > This is an awful lot of bullshit about Richard Stallman and the GPL. s/bullshit/facts/ > The importance of copyleft is that it ensures the quality of open source and free software because it stops the abusive tactic of forking open source projects and then closing them. [Again](https://www.reddit.com/r/BSD/comments/9g3jxt/is_there_an_advan tage_of_using_bsd_over_linux/e61x2z5/), that communist talking point is entirely counterfactual. *"Open source would be succeeding faster if the GPL didn't make lots of people nervous about adopting it." [--esr](https://linux.slashdot.org/story/05/07/01/1210258/we-dont- need-the-gpl-anymore)* The reality is that copyleft has done nothing but hurt the free software movement, as is evidenced by the success of non-copyleft genuinely free software, which is [slowly gaining the upper hand](https://redmonk.com/dberkholz/2013/04/02/quantifying-the-shift- toward-permissive-licensing/) as GPL loses popularity in every market segment. Linux and Java are the only remaining copyleft market-leading success stories, due to their exceptional momentum and billionaire sugar daddies like Oracle and IBM, but sooner or later freer alternatives will replace them too. All of Java's top competitors are permissively licensed, and the most promising new kernel projects like [Redox OS](https://www.redox-os.org/) and [Fuchsia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia) are too. Millions of people, including myself, do not contribute to free software because of the communist ideology with which people like Stallman have poisoned its culture. > Businesses abuse BSD-style licesning to get free development, but they will not return their own code contributions to the community, so it is a take-only and give-nothing relationship which is bad for the user (you). Yet another clearly counterfactual communist talking point. Free software is a natural market phenomenon that does not require viral licenses or government force. Businesses have voluntarily contributed a huge fraction of the best open source software that exists today. No one forced Microsoft to release .NET, VScode, etc (all under permissive licenses). Apple contributed to large parts of the FreeBSD ecosystem, including LLVM. Billions of client devices have standardized on Chromium and other BSD-licensed libraries from Google, including WebM video. And they contribute to FLOSS ecosystems in many other ways as well. Businesses contribute the lion's share of funds to the [FreeBSD Foundation](https://www.freebsdfoundation.org/donors/#!) and every other major FLOSS project out there (including initiatives like Google's "20% time" and "Summer of Code"). And of course businesses employ programmers who then have the money to pursue FLOSS work in their spare time. And of course businesses pay taxes and make voluntary grants that fund university R&D, which is where a lot of FLOSS innovation comes from. Etc, etc, etc. It is impossible to just create a closed fork of a free project and make money from it without adding any value - everyone would just use the free version instead. Closed-forked products like the Apple userland, [PlayStation OS](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PlayStation_4_system_software), [EnterpriseDB](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EnterpriseDB), [etc](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_products_based_on_FreeBSD) all add value and only add more eyeballs, ideas, and contributions to the FLOSS projects they started from. > GPL/copyleft was a clever innovation that established a give-and- take relationship that was mutually beneificial for everybody. The "give-and-take relationship" of free information sharing is as old as human speech. Copyleft is not an "innovation", it's just copyright. In many ways it is more evil than the proprietary licenses / EULA's because it misuses the word "freedom". If you want to hold a gun to people's head and dictate what they can do with your 1s and 0s, then don't call it "free"! > Then you get all these idiots claiming BSD license is "more free" when if it wasn't for the GPL you wouldn't even have quality open source software today. BSD license is objectively more free. Restriction, which is what GPL adds, is the opposite of freedom. You are free to argue that people shouldn't be free, and should be forced to do what you want - but don't call it freedom! And, just so you know, the people you're insulting as "idiots" include some of the greatest free software developers of all time, including Theo de Raadt [(OpenBSD)](https://www.openbsd.org/policy.html), [Eric S Raymond](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_S._Raymond), Rob Pike (Go), etc, etc, etc. A very trollish thing to say in r/BSD! I avoid GPL software like a plague. If it had never existed, we would have more genuinely free software in its place. > Even BSD systems were developed with heavy dependence on GNU software, or by people who could not have learned how to do it had GNU software not existed. True. So what? Stallman has fooled a lot of people into a false dichotomy between copyleft and proprietary software. No one is denying that GNU has made significant technical contributions - and so did Microsoft, and, heck, [even Nazi Germany](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Konrad_Zuse). This does not help you in your argument for copyleft. Zuse didn't necessarily need the Nazis, and GCC didn't necessarily need GPL. Unix has always been a bazaar with different components coming from different places and under different licenses. The GNU project started working on top of proprietary Unix in 1984 (some Orwellian irony here), and it finally got a viable kernel with Linux in 1991-93, while BSD systems only became free in 1994. Naturally BSDs used some restrictively licensed components to avoid reinventing the wheel, just like GNU programmers originally used proprietary Unix components. But some non-copyleft projects existed even before GNU. GNU/Linux has used tons of non-copyleft code, including things like X11. BSDs had to use components like GCC in the bad old days, but fortunately freer alternatives are now available. A pure Unix system that is 100% free from restrictive licenses is our goal, and it has already been pretty functional for quite some time. Once, as a thought experiment, I wanted to see if I can set up Linux From Scratch without any copyfree components, and found it impossible. > The GPL is not anti-business. In fact, Stallman encouraged selling GPL software and other viable business models. Lots of businesses have been built around free software. Everyone knows where [Stallman](http://stallman.org) stands politically. Him not behaving like a commissar during the Red Terror of the Russian Civil War (because times and circumstances are very different) doesn't make him a champion of business freedom. The point remains that GPL is anti-business compared to copyfree licenses like BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-17 01:02 If you care about free software, avoid buying "clusterfuck" hardware. Read the BSD wiki (ex [laptops](https://wiki.freebsd.org/Laptops), [graphics cards](https://wiki.freebsd.org/Graphics), etc). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-17 01:07 Linux is not "dying". But someday it will. And so will BSD. I don't mean dying as going away completely, but losing market share to something new. An operating system where many design decisions were made for the hardware economies of the 1970s, written in an unsafe language, cannot remain popular forever. New operating systems that will someday replace Linux and BSD could already be among us: Redox? Fuchsia? Haiku? Or maybe it'll be something entirely new - only time will tell. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mgladiethor · 2018-09-17 02:04 Are you truly free? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poshpotdllr · 2018-09-17 11:05 >Linux is not "dying". But someday it will. And so will BSD. linux is a dead horse that keeps telling itself everything is ok by looking at microsoft. bsd is on a rapid growth path. this is because the GPL is shit. >I don't mean dying as going away completely, like linux and microsoft? they will die. >but losing market share to something new. bsd has been steadily gaining market share for 40 years. no end in sight. >An operating system where many design decisions were made for the hardware economies of the 1970s, written in an unsafe language, cannot remain popular forever. this is a horseshit statement. in the future OS's will be written in ASM and things will move towards low level programming >New operating systems that will someday replace Linux and BSD could already be among us: Redox? Fuchsia? Haiku? Or maybe it'll be something entirely new - only time will tell. only a noob would say this. the OS that wins in the long run is the one with the best ideals from a scientific perspective, and in that arena bsd has no competition at all (except freebsd which is a bit of an abomination and i would put it on par with linux). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poshpotdllr · 2018-09-17 11:17 why does everybody argue with my tone despite the fact that i am obviously and objectively correct in my statements? YOU KNOW I AM RIGHT. BOW YOUR HEAD IN SUBMISSION AND MOVE ALONG. THE PROPHET HAS SPOKEN. there is no value in polite ignorance at the expense of truth. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- aedinius · 2018-09-17 12:29 There is a distro of Linux that is UNIX-certified. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- HaleyStarshine · 2018-09-17 12:54 Tell me more. Also, sources. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- aedinius · 2018-09-17 13:00 [Inspur K-UX](https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/) is certified UNIX, based on [RHEL](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inspur_K-UX) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- WikiTextBot · 2018-09-17 13:00 **Inspur K-UX** Inspur K-UX is a Linux distribution based on Red Hat Enterprise Linux produced by Inspur, a Chinese multinational company specializing in information technology. Inspur K-UX 2.0 and 3.0 for x86-64 are officially certified as UNIX systems by The Open Group. *** ^[ [^PM](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=kittens_from_space) ^| [^Exclude ^me](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=WikiTextBot&me ssage=Excludeme&subject=Excludeme) ^| [^Exclude ^from ^subreddit](https://np.reddit.com/r/BSD/about/banned) ^| [^FAQ ^/ ^Information](https://np.reddit.com/r/WikiTextBot/wiki/index) ^| [^Source](https://github.com/kittenswolf/WikiTextBot) ^] ^Downvote ^to ^remove ^| ^v0.28 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- varshitbhat · 2018-09-17 14:17 GPL helps against software exploitation ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-09-17 16:33 We're not talking about certification here. We're talking about OS families and how one is much closer to Unix than the other. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-09-17 16:49 It matters because when you configure your OS and write scripts to do things in your OS, you have to change and practically rewrite those scripts every time there's a major version change in GNU/Linux. Take Ubuntu for example - stuff that works in Ubuntu 12 doesn't work in 14, and what you learned in 14 suddenly is different in 16, and the differences between 16 and 18 are crazy, and the documentation for 18 doesn't even match the OS they shipped! It's a big, big, unmaintainable mess. If you only care about running software as a regular user, and if that software depends very little or not at all on any special configuration of the OS, then it wouldn't matter to you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-09-17 17:58 All of which are cheap these days. There are a number of x86_64 SoC boards out there these days based on Atom, Jaguar, or Bobcat. For example, PCEngines and Minnowboard are both popular low-power x86 boards. Intel Atom (e.g. Braswell, Airmont, Silvermont, Goldmont) are all x86-64 with multiple cores, low power (<10 Watts), and are cheap to purchase. Also, HAMMER wants at least 60GB these days. However, a 120GB SSD retails for about $30 USD (which means it's wholesale is probably closer to $15 USD). Most embedded systems use 512 MB to 1GB of RAM, with 2GB being on the high-end. So RAM prices aren't going to be that expensive either. So I can see this as being a true statement (albeit, unexpected). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-17 20:14 All proprietary appliances built on FreeBSD do contribute code back though ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-17 20:16 Cool, seems like I had been left behind and fooled by wrong assumptions based on a past which is no longer reality ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marmulak · 2018-09-17 20:26 Perhaps not all but those that do should be commended ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-17 20:52 Well, your right. Thanks Apple, Juniper, Netflix, Apache, NetApp, iXsystems I guess; I know there's truth in your words, I'm not against GPL,but I think there's pros and cons in both copyleft (stft/strong) and permissive licenses. Regarding the latter, I think in most cases it's interest for a corporation to contribute code back to the open source project whose code it built its proprietary appliance on: the open source base will gain reliability, larger userbase, donations,bug reports, and draw new developers attention, the dev team in charge of maintaining it will focus on other matters rather than re-implementing the same feature that the company developed for its custom appliance, while the new code will have the chance to be tested and patched. In this case contributing back it's convenient. Now, what about those who take and give nothing in return? I think Sony with its PS4 OS wouldn't have much to contribute back to FreeBSD, I mean anything which is convenient opening: would be Sony code of any use? No one can tell, but I guess it largely wouldn't. To be usable it should be consistent with FreeBSD phylosophy an goals; example: iXsystems ported OpenRC to FreeBSD (TrueOS, etc..), why hasn't FreeBSD took those patches and adopted it too yet? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-18 18:17 OpenBSD with a modern-ish HD radeon/intel: - fw_update - syspatch - pkg_add gnome - less /usr/local/share/doc/pkg-readmes/gnome* - follow the instructions - reboot ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fragbot · 2018-09-18 20:01 My shortlist: * useful man pages. I've never seen a Linux distro that was anywhere close to as well-documented. * coherent design. Since they control kernel and user space, they can have a tighter integration. * more willing to go slowly (in my experience, NetBSD is particularly this way) and go without something for a bit if the implementation will be a boat anchor later. To be fair, Linux might be more this way if it didn't have practically infinite dev resources. * I've used jails on FreeBSD and containers (well, Docker) on Linux/OSX. As a long-time Unix person, jails made more sense to me. That said, I'm guessing Docker will be more orchestratable just due to the imbalance in development resources. * For certain use cases (a giant file store with a ridiculous number of inodes that was amenable to block compression), ZFS worked far better than the Linux offerings do (yes, I know ZFS can run on Linux; no, I wouldn't trust it as it's kind of an afterthought). * In my experience, the BSDs work harder to remain POSIX-compliant. While most people wouldn't value this, I hate seeing, say, bashisms in shell scripts or some yahoo using GNU sed's *in-place* option. * *kqueue* is an amazing piece of work that, while not standard, I still think Torvalds missed the boat on. To be able to unify your kernel events across a single syscall (inotify, dnotify, and epoll would've never happened) and get rid of the "pipe hack" for signal handling (ugh; I just read that Linux has another syscall--signalfd-- to handle this problem) would have just been better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-19 11:48 ESR is a bit of an idiot. About RMS and communism, that's bullshit. Support is capitalism based, and even if the OS is GPL'ed, tech support calls are pretty expensive. Just look at RHEL. And I say that by using OpenBSD on the desktop. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-19 12:24 Stallman is not a communist. You know shit about communism. First, in communism there are several branches, from the Soviets (and even the Soviet hated Stalin on the civil approach, not as a war commander) to a more socialdemocrat ones. Being said that, in a Soviet country they would be no GPL at all. All state code would be a highly secret under a death penalty for treason, leaving the civil code as a strict non-profit code, something the GPL forbids, beacuse it leaves one freedom out. Your speech is typical of the American uneducated jerk, understanding politics as something either black on white, with no degrees of thinking. RMS falls under progressive left, at least on social behaviour, and he advocated a full shared knowledge for humanity. Yes, the GPL is restrictive, I'd prefer ISC or MIT instead of that, but, please, do not even try comparing polar opposite ideologies when the GPL falls under a neocon basis clearly, stablishing an obligatory knowledge sharing for everyone so any folk in the home can have a success. Basically a proper American Dream, ensuring that even your neighbour can work and develop technology. How can be that even close to communism? Ironically, Microsoft's corpo propietary license with monolithic designs reminds me a lot of a Soviet bureaucracy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wafflePower1 · 2018-09-19 14:42 You're installing FreeBSD. You will install linux emulation. Why not just cut the middleman - FreeBSD - and go straight to Linux? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FrontMeringue · 2018-09-19 19:01 > the greatest free software developers of all time, including Theo de Raadt (OpenBSD), Eric S Raymond, Rob Pike (Go), etc, etc, etc. wtf, esr being mentioned alongside reasonable people. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-20 21:48 > Stallman is not a communist. Welcome to the Internet. Proponents of free market capitalism (such as myself) call all people who advocate for greater government intervention "commies". This is because calling them "people whose possibly-well-intentioned political ideas push in the direction of less individual and economic freedom, and therefore greater government force" is just too long. [Read this.](http://www.libertyzone.com/Communist-Manifesto- Planks.html) Political norms have been shifting in the bigger- government direction for a very long time, and no one even notices how many communist ideas have be become mainstream. If you believe in Federally-regulated public schools, you are a commie. Deal with it. And RMS [makes it very clear](https://duckduckgo.com/?q=obama+site%3Astallman.org&ia=web) that he's several light-years to the left of even Obama. > You know shit about communism. I was [born](https://archive.fo/jt9z1) in the Soviet Union, and I've spent most of my life reading (including many books you can't get in English). I can identify all 37 flavors of communist shit by taste alone (so to speak). > First, in communism there are several branches, from the Soviets (and even the Soviet hated Stalin on the civil approach, not as a war commander) to a more socialdemocrat ones. They are all commies and should all go jump into the same giant woodchipper feet first. > Being said that, in a Soviet country they would be no GPL at all. The Soviet Union was created by naive "benevolent" commies (like my grandfather), who very much resembled Stallman in their ideology. It of course wasn't run by those same commies, because their ideas were absolutely out of touch with reality, and more practical commies filled the competence vacuum in a blood-bath that killed millions of people. The Stalins get the blame, but the Stallmans are the underlying cause. GPL is a tool of injecting commie control through copyright laws. It is a toothpick of a tool compared to the chainsaw that Stallman would wield if he had actual political power, and he would be quickly replaced by less principled commies with much more powerful weapons. In a Soviet country there would probably be a [Union of Soviet Programmers](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_of_Soviet_Writers), controlled by the party. Releasing the source code probably won't be a major goal, but there would be a lot more restrictions. Samizdat software that doesn't fit the desired ideology would be repressed. > Your speech is typical of the American uneducated jerk, understanding politics as something either black on white, with no degrees of thinking. That's a great argument against democracy. Maybe there's hope for you yet. Go read [Hans-Hermann Hoppe](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans- Hermann_Hoppe) and other right-libertarians. Stephan Kinsella is especially important for understanding [opposition to IP](https://mises.org/library/against-intellectual-property-0) (like GPL). > RMS falls under progressive left, at least on social behaviour Using better-sounding propaganda words like "progressive" or "liberal" instead of commie doesn't change the substance. > and he advocated a full shared knowledge for humanity. So do I. But all that RMS has actually contributed to human knowledge is copyleft - that is a defense of government force. > I'd prefer ISC or MIT instead of that [...] Awesome. > [...] but, please, do not even try comparing polar opposite ideologies when the GPL falls under a neocon basis clearly, stablishing an obligatory knowledge sharing for everyone so any folk in the home can have a success. Compiler failure: too many grammatical problems, cannot compute. > Basically a proper American Dream, ensuring that even your neighbour can work and develop technology. How can be that even close to communism? If I violate GPL (as civil disobedience, of course), then I will get summoned to court. If I refuse to go, then I will get more angry letters and eventually a knock on the door to serve me legal papers. And if I refuse to comply, police will be dispatched to arrest me. And if I don't surrender, I will be shot. Don't confuse ends and means. Benevolent ends **never** justify unethical means (like government force). Since most people fail to understand this, all evil things now come wrapped in benevolence as a disguise. > Ironically, Microsoft's corpo propietary license with monolithic designs reminds me a lot of a Soviet bureaucracy. I don't like Microsoft, and therefore I don't use any of their products. *Everyone knows Microsoft is not free software.* Anyone who drinks their poisoned koolaid is responsible for their own choices. Avoiding proprietary software was becoming very easy (at least until Microsoft acquired GitHub). But so-called "free software" poisoned with licenses is a serious philosophical problem that free software / content ecosystems need to overcome. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-20 21:50 > that he's several light-years to the left of even Obama. And half of Europe, and trust me: Spain is not nearly as Communist as the USSR. Being born in the middle, I can acknowledge that both extremes (Soviet extremism shifting from pure economics to social control) to neocon AKA "Law of the Jungle, the fittest survives and that weak dies", are bad. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-20 22:56 > And half of Europe, and trust me: Spain is not nearly as Communist as the USSR. I think the [Index of Economic Freedom](https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking) is the best approximation we have for quantifying the degree of "how communist" a nation is. USSR would range from North Korea (1930s) to Cuba (1980s). Although USA is homogenized by the Federal government, different states also have different degrees of freedom, as quantified [here](https://www.freedominthe50states.org/economic). > Being born in the middle, I can acknowledge that both extremes (Soviet extremism shifting from pure economics to social control) to neocon AKA "Law of the Jungle, the fittest survives and that weak dies", are bad. You are using words incorrectly. [NeoCons](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoconservatism) do not represent the opposite of communism, [right- libertarians](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right-libertarianism) like myself do. [My "Tent City" activism](http://www.ronpaulforums.com/showthread.php?417696-The- Libertarian-Solution-To-End-Homelessness) was directed at the question of what should happen to the poorest people in a free market: cheap living, voluntary charity, NGO privatization of "public land", cottage industries, and mutual aid. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-20 23:05 You were like a pendulum, you shited from one extreme to the polar opposite. Good luck with roads, firefighters, police, healthcare... I don't wanna know how could you get basic stuff like vaccines. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-20 23:33 > You were like a pendulum, you shited from one extreme to the polar opposite. I have no idea what you're talking about. It's very well documented via online forums that I've been a tax resister since 2004 and a right-libertarian since 2006. > Good luck with roads, firefighters, police, healthcare... Pure free market [("anarcho-") capitalism](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism) is in practice most likely to result in small local [jurisdictions of voluntary governance](http://www.stephankinsella.com/2010/05/hoppe-on- covenant-communities/), where residents vote with their feet. r/Seasteading is most likely to come first, and then local secession movements within places like r/FreeStateProject. And then I'll build [something like this](http://libman.org/img/bak/20180906-Libmania5.jpg)... All running OpenBSD! ;-) Existing micro-nations like Monaco are doing just fine on roads, firefighters, etc. What I want is a million Monacos (maybe some as large as Singapore) competing for brains and capital. That's just to explain what a non-commie world would look like. You're free to stay in your giant nation-state, but you will eventually run short of competent people to tax... > I don't wanna know how could you get basic stuff like vaccines. Vaccines is indeed one of the most complicated questions. Some jurisdictions would require them, not sure what to do about those that don't (and how important that is). But that's very far off-topic. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-21 00:25 I mean, your approach is as utopic as the USSR. Without a basic state, your community could be crushed down by bigger fish ;) An state built on cooperative factories with minimal taxes (healthcare, roads, firefighters), would be pretty far more suited. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-21 00:30 >homosexuality Funny how you ensemble in the end the worst of Stalin shit ;) That's why puristanism is shit, and religion should be purged. Doesn't matter being from the Orthodox people or the Evangelist one. All of them are irrational mental illnessess. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-21 00:51 > I mean, your approach is as utopic as the USSR. Free market in governance is as anti-USSR as you can get. Marx and Lenin dictated what is to be done for desired outcomes, and failed miserably. Free market "anarcho-" capitalism is the "I know that I know nothing" and the scientific method applied to politics. There are no prescribed outcomes, only freedom of choice. I don't know what a good society looks like. I don't even know what kind of a society I want to live in. People will experiment and choose. There will be many mistakes, and the marketplace will learn from those mistakes. > Without a basic state, your community could be crushed down by bigger fish ;) This is exactly why libertarianism hasn't existed before the 21st century - all precursors have been forcefully crushed by more centralized and aggressive invaders. But, in the 21st century, "the camera is the new gun". Killing peaceful secessionists who use Gandhi tactics makes governments look bad, even to the "normies". And so, in the end, we will win. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-09-21 00:56 > ". And so, in the end, we will win. Now they control the media. You are an OpenBSD user, so am I, so we know perfectly what will happen with those faked videos created with neural networks. Ironically, journalists being bent to the money instead of some old ethics wont give a shit about the truth being faked and everything will continue as usual. That's why I am in the midle ground: someone will put the shit out there because politics are not polar. State federalism, European healthcare, science founding and secularism with no tax ever being sent to maintain religions is the true future. That with personal freedoms, OFC; not a social shithole like the USSR which was pretty much a cult instead of an economic theory. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 4d656761466167676f74 · 2018-09-21 17:35 >Not to mention all the closed sourced stuff written for it. Given that the PS3 and PS4 run a custom version of NetBSD, I'm not sure that Linux has more closed source software than BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2018-09-21 23:41 > > Not to mention all the closed sourced stuff written for it. > Given that the PS3 and PS4 run a custom version of NetBSD, I'm not sure that Linux has more closed source software than BSD. OrbisOS (PS4) is based off FreeBSD 9, not NetBSD. The OP is asking about advantage of BSD in "work" related tasks. So obviously we're not talking about closed entertainment systems. We're talking about desktops/servers. As such, Linux has a significant amount closed source things for these tasks. For example, Skype, Steam, VMware Workstation, drivers, and firmware, etc. Does he need to use Maya? He can in Linux, he can't in *BSD. This is the sort of "work" related stuff we're talking about. But if you want to be pedantic about it, sure *BSD is in several game consoles. Linux, the kernel, on the other hand is in a majority of phones. Android has significantly more closed source programs than Playstation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- markkrj · 2018-09-23 22:46 I for one don't think the phrase "BSD is a Unix, Linux is a Unix- like" imply that one is closer to Unix than the other, but rather that one is Unix and the other is not. If both are Unix like, he should rephrase it... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-09-23 23:49 We, meaning most computer geeks of the world, don't care one bit about something being certified. Standing on that as a technicality is not really relevant to this discussion. Instead, we're making generalizations about Unix and Unix-like OSes, not about certified or non-certified OSes. BSD is a Unix, and is in some ways more true to Unix than some of the Unix "certified" OSes. Is BSD Unix? Absolutely. Can anyone call it that and be correct? Yes, with the only exception being when talking about Unix certification. Is GNU/Linux Unix? Absolutely not. Can anyone call it Unix and be correct? No. Even if it's Unix certified, you can only call it Unix certified. Calling a Unix certified GNU/Linux distro Unix is still incorrect. The certification just means it does enough stuff the way it's expected to do those things. Do we all know what we're talking about when we say Unix-like? Yes. GNU/Linux is moving away from that, though. Many of the large recent changes are decidedly in the opposite direction of being Unix-like. Is BSD more Unix-like than GNU/Linux? Absolutely. There is no confusion here, even though /u/HaleyStarshine would like to think otherwise. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-25 10:17 MacOS users don't even know they are using *BSD. That is trash system with weird graphics && bloat && inefficiency. Do not defame *BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CommonMisspellingBot · 2018-09-25 10:17 Hey, maheshhegde, just a quick heads-up: **wierd** is actually spelled **weird**. You can remember it by **e before i**. Have a nice day! ^^^^The ^^^^parent ^^^^commenter ^^^^can ^^^^reply ^^^^with ^^^^'delete' ^^^^to ^^^^delete ^^^^this ^^^^comment. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-25 10:27 Just being fascinated with "language safety" hype? These systems neither are secure nor have much features. Especially fuchsia is Google's design trash made to get out of GPL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-25 10:29 delete ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-25 17:17 lol this is why I don't hang out in FOSS subs. The people are terrible. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-09-26 00:48 > Just being fascinated with "language safety" hype? How is it "hype"? When I use a more type-safe and memory-safe language, I shoot myself in the foot a lot less often. Maybe you're a super-genius immune to all mistakes, but most programmers are not. > These systems neither are secure You need a more complete explanation of your argument here, especially since you're comparing ripe apples to apple seeds... > nor have much features. Yet. > Especially fuchsia is Google's design trash made to get out of GPL. If we can *get out of GPL* without putting all Stallmanites in death camps, I'll consider it a moral victory. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NerdVsGeek · 2018-09-26 01:08 None of my FreeBSD machines use a non-GENERIC kernel and I leave the Linux syscalls emulation out of the kernel, its not even compiled as a module. I have one Linux system in my house and it's because I prefer a UNIX- like desktop to run a few proprietary apps and I don't want to pay for a Mac. Think on the irony. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-26 09:11 The design philosophies behind these systems are hype. I think haiku may have chance. But fuchsia totally sucks -- it is just a hype on UX. Redox OS, too, there is not much reason except promoting rust and stupid "microkernel" philosophies. The better thing you may expect from these languages is rewrite of currently working OSes in them. By the way, millions of man years of work is poured for enriching and securing popular OSes. A new kid on the block **uses a relatively secure language** does not mean **it is relatively secure** -- they are different things anyway. And there is not much reason to hate GPL. It is just because of GPL why Microsoft and oracle etc.. could not make Linux parts effectively proprietary and compete against FLOSS. They have advantage of money, and their software still continues to suck for good -- that's due to GPL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-26 10:10 You are acting like steve balmer lol :) FOSS software is usually created by scientific people and you business minded crap continues to be furious about it. BTW, macos is pretty inefficient and bloated -- carries only some virtues of parent projects. Linux / BSD community can make a better OS of that kind which is faster and takes much less disk space. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-26 17:28 If scientists wrote FOSS OS code it would all be written in Scala and half-broken. Scientists are terrible programmers. FOSS is written mostly by business people. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-27 03:45 Your understanding is terrible. I am talking about computer scientists. Also, business people write terrible code. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-27 16:20 Heh you're adorable. Have you ever read LMKL? Taken a look at people's email addresses? You know how they all have company names as the second half of their email address? *That means they work for a company.* ---------------------------------------------------------------------- maheshhegde · 2018-09-28 09:36 "Work for company" is different from "business people". Business ppl are crap when it comes to software so they use windows. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cheeseboythrowaway · 2018-09-28 16:37 I'm realizing I got sucked into an argument with a 12 year old. Well played. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Obvguy · 2018-09-30 06:55 I've a desktop with old intel 2nd gen core i3 and 6GB of DDR3 RAM. Which BSD has the best hardware support and will work fine in this desktop? Last time, I've tried FreeBSD was in 2010 or so. Can I get latest Firefox quantum with BSD ports? Also, which one has latest packages? TrueOS or FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Pan_opticom · 2018-10-04 17:07 Take GhostBSD, yes you get the newest firefox no problems ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Losraio2 · 2018-10-08 10:02 A small portion of the problems that Linux has to solve. I think there's a clear winner here. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tuccx · 2019-02-19 14:52 what's wrong with systemd? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VENTDEV · 2019-02-19 23:07 Talk about necro-posting on a dead horse topic. Here you go: http://lmgtfy.com/?s=d&q=Arguements+against+systemd First result you should get is this: http://without- systemd.org/wiki/index.php/Arguments_against_systemd Third result you should get is this: http://without- systemd.org/wiki/index.php/List_of_systemd-critical_webpages Have fun. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2019-03-06 13:35 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- codevil · 2019-03-12 15:34 That last sentence is an incredible value proposition. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ReservoirPenguin · 2022-12-15 15:27 Both are UNIX-like. The distinction between UNIX-like and UNIX is entirely due AT&T enforcing it's copyrights. Also, back in the days people bought commercial UNIX workstations like SGI to mostly run commercial applications, does it mean IRIX was somehow inferiors to BSD? :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2022-12-15 17:12 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ReservoirPenguin · 2022-12-15 17:29 To anyone who used UNIX in the 80-90s Linux would feel infinitely more familiar and UNIX-like that BSD. We bought SystemV workstations and first thing we did we installed GNU tools on them. SysV ran on anything from 8086 to the fastest RISC, every software and hardware vendor had their own SysV version. BSD, well it ran on a VAX at Berkeley. SunOS was the only BSD derived commercial system and even SUN abandoned it in favor of SysV Solaris. To a UNIX user any modern BSD would feel alien and un-UNIX like