AMDGPU reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2018-09-03 22:57 I have RX 460 2GB and what BSD should I choose for gaming? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MrThugger · 2018-09-04 06:02 You should probably use FreeBSD, NetBSD updated their amdgpu driver to the latest version recently but I don't know if there are many videogames available on NetBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-04 11:24 I'm quite confident RX 460 is supported on every *BSD (regarding NetBSD, only on -current); better to leave this to an AMD GPU user though. FreeBSD has largest games and emulators availability in repo (albeit a few emulators available in OpenBSD are not in FreeBSD and vice versa),including for example up to date Xonotic and OpenTomb. FreeBSD and NetBSD have Wine and Linux compat layer; the latter allows playing some FOSS clients for Linux, like those for UT, Unreal, Doom3, Quake IV, Neverwinter, Return to Castle Wolfenstein, Enemy Territory, Dwarf Fortress. Several old games successfully run in wine, like Half Life, Hitman, Age of Empires 1-3, Rome/Medieval 2 Total War, Deus Ex, Starcraft. The TrueOS guys reported even running Skyrim and Mass Effect on Steam through Wine. Depending on the game, you may have to tweak with wine/winetricks a bit, so be prepared to get your hands dirty Both implementations are more mature and up to date in FreeBSD, but work acceptably on NetBSD too. DragonflyBSD and OpenBSD have neither of the 2, but Dragonfly's games repo width is close to FreeBSD's. OpenBSD and NetBSD have a comparable variety of games in repo, but OpenBSD is well known to maintain some clients extremely well, due to a little community of free-time OpenBSD gamers (see #openbsd-gaming IRC on Freenode), so that they always work out of the box and give less trouble than in the other BSDs. That's the case for example of the various Quake 1-3 clients. FreeBSD and DragonflyBSD have the best performance, while OpenBSD has the worst. The difference is not so evident and significant when applied to a laptop launching lightweight game clients , but it exists and won't pass totally unnoticed. If you have low RAM (~2gb) don't use ZFS on FreeBSD or HAMMER on Dragonfly, or you'll kill performance, rather use FFSv2. If you want to play on BSD on older hardware (e.g. 32bit, 1 Gb RAM,which is perfectly feasible), in this case NetBSD will return the best performance ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gldisater · 2018-09-04 12:39 TrueOS ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Borg_10501 · 2018-09-04 14:09 OpenBSD has no plans to import amdgpu due to the size of the code. https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-misc&m=152465462030464&w=2 > I have no plans regarding amdgpu. > Most people seem to be interested from the point of view of polaris/vega which are not supported in linux 4.4. Ignoring the parts of the shared drm/ttm code that would have to be updated the latest drivers/gpu/drm/amd in linux has over 1.5 million lines of code. Which is multiple times larger than the complete OpenBSD kernel source... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2018-09-04 17:30 NetBSD has amdgpu? Doesn't say anything about supporting it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- floatboth · 2018-09-04 21:23 Of course FreeBSD, we even have Vulkan working :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- illumosguy · 2018-09-05 01:49 A couple of weeks ago, Taylor Campbell announced on tech-x11 mailing list,that he had updated the DRM/KMS drivers to versions found in Linux 4.4, this should, *teorically*, include amdgpu,extend i915 support to Kaby Lake and and nouveau support to 10xx series ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2018-09-05 16:34 RX460 is supported from Linux 4.10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2018-09-07 01:37 There is [a post in tech-x11 listing amdgpu cards in NetBSD- current](https://mail- index.netbsd.org/tech-x11/2018/08/29/msg001873.html). Some have a driver, some don't. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paspie · 2018-09-10 11:57 The sooner Radeon cards can switch to the generic modesetting driver, the sooner GCNv3+ cards can become usable on OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wafflePower1 · 2018-09-19 14:55 > BSD for gaming? whew lad ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Maccraft123 · 2018-09-19 18:14 Only "radeon(kms)" driver is ported ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fondleear · 2018-12-23 00:24 > FreeBSD Trueos was the only one i tried that booted to a desktop gui from "usb live" I have an AMD RX560 card. I installed it but sadly the "boot loader" was missing from my multi- boot win10/linux setup. So i was stuck with trueos sitting on a partition but no way to get into it. Might have been uefi's fault which does cause a lot of issues with various installs. Having a 3g dongle for my net connection probably doesn't help as it's only useful once i have a desktop gui. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbroly884 · 2019-02-28 23:12 freebsd is the only one even remotely close to being a 'gaming' os the rest are completely useless in that regard ​