Why do you use (or contribute to) BSD, rather than Linux? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-07-30 22:44 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- veritasserum · 2018-07-30 22:45 Historical inertia ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ketralnis · 2018-07-30 23:02 * https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD/search?q=linux&restrict_sr=on * https://old.reddit.com/r/BSD/search?q=%22why%22&restrict_sr=on ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2018-07-30 23:17 I always support technical superiority. Otherwise I would just use Windows. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LocalRefuse · 2018-07-30 23:28 I like it more ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-07-30 23:44 I wanted a Unix with decent man pages. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rectagonal · 2018-07-30 23:45 In general Ive grown to really like the UNIX way of doing things and in some respects it feels as if BSD keeps it's eye on those sensibilities a bit better. Or sometimes it feels a bit like GNU/Linux is more willing to compromise these sensibilities a bit more for other goals. I also think with GNU/Linux there is oftentimes a big disconnect between maintainers or those who steer distributions and the developers of the large components that make up GNU/Linux. Often making things feel like the tail is wagging the dog, or parts of the ecosystem are at odds. The more holistic approach of BSD has grown to appeal after making do with years of the other. Also by and large the documentation is better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2018-07-31 00:40 By accident -- I had trouble looking for a Linux distro for a PowerPC Macintosh, so I used OpenBSD/macppc instead. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deux3xmachina · 2018-07-31 02:14 Primarily because I think the devs of DragonFly BSD and HardenedBSD in particular have some really cool ideas and well made systems. So I've been using them as my primary workstation OS for a few years now, and am giving back to them as I'm able. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- geeohgeegeeoh · 2018-07-31 03:43 Learned behaviour favours faster outcome from familiar processes. Sure, I could learn how to drive systemd or the replacement for ifconfig, but.. to what benefit? I regret the slowness BBR is taking to emerge in bsd. I regret how long it's taking graphics or ceph or database tuning or a native build of chrome not chromium. Equally, I regret how long it's taken Linux to get zfs to the same level it's on bsd. Mainly it's muscle memory. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- haroldp · 2018-07-31 03:51 jails zfs ports man hier init bsd 2 clause   ^(I like linux fine too though) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wee-tod-did · 2018-07-31 04:38 it's not linux. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thenovum · 2018-07-31 04:50 Do you run it with a desktop? Ive got a G5 just sitting ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2018-07-31 05:43 I went from Linux to FreeBSD. It has a very good structure, it has a huge amount of packages and it's rock stable. Occasionally, I try out Linux and I am more and more confused with the system. Things do not work like I expect them to work. Linux distributions ignore POLA (policy of least astonishment). They add Google DNS as fallback, they use randomized MACs for wireless interfaces as default. Then there is systemd that introduces nondeterminism. There are sometimes surprises on boot up and shutdown. *And they are silently ignored!!*. I also couldn't make Debian unmount /var cleanly. This is a basic function. I found out later that this is because of my home on encfs. encfs made also the system unreasonably slow. This costs me hours to days. And after weeks I still don't have a usable system. I also tried ZFS on Linux. I love ZFS. I realized, I don't love it on Linux, because it's not native. Try to make it boot from ZFS and you'll know what I mean. I went back to FreeBSD of course. I enjoy my proper defaults. And thanks God, I have all my *config and *stat commands back again! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Chapo_Rouge · 2018-07-31 05:55 One of the coolest feature is the way the upgrades are handled, I don't know you but being able to do an upgrade with `make -j 3 buildworld` `make -j 3 buildkernel` `make installkernel` `make installworld` `make upgrade` `reboot` ... is pretty damn sweet ! FreeBSD binary upgrades are also pretty smooth. I run DragonFlyBSD for HAMMER and FreeBSD as HTPC because it's rock solid ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gshrikant · 2018-07-31 06:16 Simpler code (OpenBSD) and semantics. I use both and I find the OpenBSD (and by extension, NetBSD) kernel easier to read and poke around. The rate of development on Linux is way too fast and it is somewhat harder to get a foot in the door if you're not doing it as part of your job. BSDs are evolving at a more deliberate pace and the community is still mostly individual volunteers which makes them easier to get involved in. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mloiterman · 2018-07-31 07:01 https://www.freebsd.org/doc/handbook/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bit_of_hope · 2018-07-31 07:51 Por que no los dos? There are things to be learned in less common systems. NetBSD's /usr/pkg filesystem separation is handy. OpenBSD shows the value of an opinionated system with premium placed on simplicity and correctness. Were it not for FreeBSD, Junos wouldn't exist and I'd have to endure Cisco at work. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thedeadslow · 2018-07-31 07:57 This can't not be stressed enough. When I switch to Linux, I read a ton of manpages, which actually teached me something. They had been a source of knowledge about the tool, the integration into the system and, more often than less, the specific quirks, which had to be considered. Today, if you get an output on --help, you are a lucky human being. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-07-31 08:47 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DamienCouderc · 2018-07-31 09:25 Used Linux first (Yggdrasil, Slackware) then fallen in love with OpenBSD because everything was like I thought it should be. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2018-07-31 10:52 Debian might have trouble keeping up with package versions, but one policy I really admire them for is their mandate for man pages. On Debian, every tool has a man page. If the software doesn't come with a man page, the maintainer has to write one. That's a really good policy. Incidentally, something similar is the reason why UNIX got good documentation in the first place. Back when UNIX was a research project at Bell Labs, all the team members could write their own programs and place them in `/usr/bin`. To prevent cruft from accumulating, a rule was instituted: if you add a program to `/usr/bin`, it has to have a man page. If you change the program, the man page has to grow. This rule was checked by means of a shell script which would delete offending programs. Unsurprisingly, all tools had excellent documentation soon. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2018-07-31 10:53 `encfs` is a kludge. Plus it's a FUSE file system so it can't be fast, no matter what. Use real disk encryption instead. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2018-07-31 10:59 I left Linux for FreeBSD because systemd was forced on me. I grew to enjoy FreeBSD because it's just so much more coherent than the average Linux distribution. While Linux is a patchwork of a zillion small projects, each of which believes that it is the sole bearers of the truth and are unwilling to smooth out their idiosyncraticies, you can really see how FreeBSD is one large project designed with common design rules and standards. Every tool works largely the same and follows the same design patterns. Everything is designed to interact and just works. Everything is documented with man pages, most importantly including device drivers (Linux is terrible in this regard). And I haven't even started with ZFS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- robbak · 2018-07-31 11:04 Yes, I mean - 'systemd'. The very name states that it is something that simply should not be. You just don't klumph everything a system does under one pid. And the only argument I heard for it is, "look how complex apache's rc script is?" Um, yeah, so? I'm sure they'll make their systemd whatever-it-is compex too, because that's what they like. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fyoory · 2018-07-31 12:57 FUSE is rather silly isnt it? Everyones relying on it for permformance these days without reading the history books about FUSE being a SLOW, USERLAND Filesystem, which in linux kernel speak means the most expensive filesystem operation you can do. Go ahead, setup a fuse system, crank up a 1GB file and xfer it and watch your top iowait soar. Now put that into production doing that 10x a second. Meanwhile do something else intensive and observe. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2018-07-31 12:59 FUSE is just a terrible design. It might be a fun project to devise something similar without the terrible performance problems. I know that NetBSD has a similar interface, but I've never used it. The worst part about fuse is that it's not really documented. File systems must fulfill a shitload of invariants to work as expected towards programs. Fuse documents none of these. It doesn't even say what error codes to return and what cases to handle. It took me ages to figure out how exactly (not) Fuse handles permissions because there is absolutely no documentation about that. It's infuriating. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-07-31 13:28 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- daemonpenguin · 2018-07-31 15:52 I contribute more to FreeBSD because the barrier is so low to entry. I can whip up a port or patch and submit it to the bug tracker and it'll likely get accepted. With most Linux distros it's a pain to find the right mailing list or the proper guide or the right git project. Many projects require mentorship, etc. I don't want to read 20 pages of a mission statement and e-mail five people to ask if they'll let me into their club just to submit a one page patch. FreeBSD let's me just do the work and "drop it off" to be committed if it looks good to a core dev. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xenepa · 2018-07-31 16:07 I used to, for jails, pf and zfs. Now, all of this and more is existing in linux sooo.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xenepa · 2018-07-31 16:10 So how's that ZFS on OpenBSD, NetBSD and Dragonfly? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-31 16:36 https://old.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7xapx2/freebsds_new_geek_fem inismbased_code_of_conduct/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deux3xmachina · 2018-07-31 16:55 When did Linux get jails or pf? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xenepa · 2018-07-31 16:57 Not the same, just comparable. lxc and nftables. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qci · 2018-07-31 17:16 I thought it would be similar to pefs on FreeBSD. pefs did not introduce much penalty, AFAIR. Most time I'm using geli. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 2016-679 · 2018-07-31 20:38 half a year ago I wanted to get the adventure in computing again, next to being able to make a very basic installation with only the parts I really need. after a week I completely switched from Fedora (27) Linux to FreeBSD and I never regretted it. stability, documentation and forum help are outstanding. FreeBSD makes me do more with less CPU and RAM, which starts to count on a ten year old machine... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Jethro_Tell · 2018-07-31 22:30 just talking to a friend about this the other day. It's a power hog, .55kw/h, but, you get a full on functional desktop, plenty of power for OpenBSD and no known/unknown intel speculation bugs. It's not the worst choice at the moment. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-07-31 22:38 **One reason: [the license](http://copyfree.org)!** Restrictively licensed software (ex. GPL) is NOT "free software". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NicheArchitecture · 2018-07-31 22:39 Unfortunately, there are speculation bugs on ppc. Only the G3 and Sawtooth G4 are immune to spectre :( https://tenfourfox.blogspot.com/2018/01/more-about-spectre-and- powerpc-or-why.html https://tenfourfox.blogspot.com/2018/01/is-powerpc-susceptible-to- spectre-yep.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NicheArchitecture · 2018-07-31 22:41 ZFS is cancer. I don't want half the Solaris Kernel imported (and a kludge of non free software) cluttering up my beautiful OS! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-08-01 00:06 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lbmn · 2018-08-01 00:14 You are operating under the communist definition of "freedom". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-08-01 00:27 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NicheArchitecture · 2018-08-01 01:50 Because Linux made me want to reconsider my choice of profession. OpenBSD was the only OS that actually made sense to me. I love the continuity and clean, minimalist design philosophy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- thenovum · 2018-08-01 04:52 What kinda gfx adapter is recommended. Or does both brands work? G5 is a good machine for the cold winters her in Sweden. Hmm interesting about specter, i thought the G5 wasn't affected. Maybe its time to get a G4 also.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-08-01 15:18 GNU/Linux is a mess. Go ahead and try to use the documentation for Ubuntu 12 on Ubuntu 14. Or 14 on 16, or 16 on 18. Or Red Hat on CentOS, or CentOS 5 documentation for CentOS6. Even when the documentation says it's for CentOS 6, there's no certainty that the thing documented will even work on CentOS 6. Keeping up with it is a full time thing. If you're in to that kind of thing, great. Some people like to overclock and have forgotten what they're going to do with the extra 20% of performance they might get. They don't care that their systems aren't necessarily stable for more than a few hours at a time. Overclocking is the destination, not a step along the way. Likewise, GNU/Linux is great if you don't mind a messy, inconsistent system where lots of software has issues coexisting with other software. It's slowly becoming a Windows desktop where installing, then removing software can still leave the system in a different state than if the software had never come along in the first place. Their solutions are containerization and virtualization. So, in essence, they're promoting the idea that every somewhat complex piece of software should have its own container / virtual machine, and therefore its own OS. BSD, on the other hand, is more traditional. If software changes the base OS in ways that can't be reverted, it's broken. Likewise, if software can't coexist with other software, it's broken. This is why ports and pkgsrc are projects which require tons of work - it's not trivial to overcome the sloppy practices that kids are learning these days with GNU/Linux. Don't even get me started with systemd... Let's just say that the documentation doesn't match actual usage, and half the time systemd is the issue, not the software we're trying to get systemd to run. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- johnklos · 2018-08-01 15:23 You do realize that the United States is not a democracy, right? It's not even close. Your analogy fits, though - BSD is more about a number of closer to equal actors working together and compromising, like the EU, and the GNU/Linux world is more about big money and famous / popular people making decisions by fiat, like the United States where money wins over the will of the people a majority of the time. Most popular GNU/Linux distros now are businesses. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-08-01 17:33 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2018-08-01 21:09 I have an old PowerBook5,4 (G4, 1333 MHz) that boots Mac OS X or OpenBSD/macppc. Back in 2010, this machine ran OpenBSD with cwm as desktop and Firefox as web browser. In 2010, I switched to a faster machine with OpenBSD/amd64. In 2018, you can't run Firefox on OpenBSD/macppc. My PowerBook5,4 now has a snapshot from 2018 of OpenBSD/macppc with Xfce as desktop and NetSurf as web browser. OpenBSD's [dfs(4)](https://man.openbsd.org/dfs) and [radeondrm(4)](https://man.openbsd.org/radeondrm) didn't exist in 2010 but are working now, so the machine runs faster now. Without dfs(4), the cpu was stuck at half speed (666 MHz). Now, I can use `apmd -A` with dfs(4) to reach full speed (1333 MHz). Without radeondrm(4), OpenGL used slow software rendering. Now, OpenGL has hardware acceleration. - OpenBSD can't sleep or hibernate any macppc machine. - OpenBSD is bad with nVidia graphics -- you might have only 256 colors with [vgafb(4)](https://man.openbsd.org/vgafb) and [wsfb(4)](https://man.openbsd.org/wsfb). - OpenBSD can't adjust the fans on some macppc models. My PowerBook5,4 seems to have hardware fan control, but other models may have fans stuck at full speed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FUZxxl · 2018-08-01 22:27 `pefs` is implemented in the kernel, so it's a bit faster than `encfs` and doesn't suffer from the inherent serialisation FUSE file systems have. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vvelox · 2018-08-02 08:44 Sane sound and init system. GEOM is sweet. It beats every other disk system subsystem hands down. Makes life so much easier. Ports very much as a sweet software selection to choose from. Much saner kernel directory layout. It is developed as a whole OS instead of very piecemeal, so it is more consistent. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- annadane · 2018-08-08 03:41 http://0pointer.de/blog/projects/the-biggest-myths.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jfaodc13 · 2018-08-18 14:48 BSD just makes sense. It follow conventions that go back \~40 years, and its code base goes back that far too. Parts of it, anyway. Linux likes to do its own thing, rather than learn from other OSes. This results in Linux making mistakes with problems which are already solved in other OSes. Linux DOES NOT audit its kernel. I have researched for 5 years for one complete audit of any Linux kernel version, but it doesn't exist. Many people believe it happens, but I cannot find one single documented proof of it. And no one to date has been able to present me with any proof. The closest I have ever seen is coverity which has scanned 13,913,948 lines over 12 years, which means over many kernel version. The kernel is much larger than 13,913,948 lines of code. --> [https://scan.coverity.com/projects/linux](https://scan.coverity.c om/projects/linux) If you look at the companies and governments who contribute code to the Linux kernel, audits should be top priority. Also, the license. GPL3 is a very obtuse and restrictive license, despite claiming to defend freedom. GPL supporters tend to be fanatical and angry, rather than logical and inclusive. This causes rifts in open source. If you want some good insight of what Linux does wrong, listen to Bryan Cantrill in this episode of BSD NOW --> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6XQUciI- Sc](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6XQUciI-Sc)