Will NetBSD play well to being dual booted with Windows (XP)? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-19 15:33 Hi all! I might dual boot NetBSD with Windows on my current PC simply to get used to using BSD (or any *nix OS in the matter), I already have some free partitions, will NetBSD play well in a dual boot with Windows? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2018-07-19 15:54 Yes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-19 16:10 What sort of bootloader will it use? GRUB, LILO, Windows' boot loader or another bootloader I haven't heard of it? Will NetBSD or Windows be prioritized upon boot? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rectagonal · 2018-07-19 16:26 While NetBSD doesn't support lilo or grub, you can use Grub or Lilo to do this yes. NetBSD has it's own built in bootloader which can do this. Check out the NetBSD man pages for mbr, installboot, fdisk and multiboot for more information. (It may not seem obvious coming from a non-netbsd world but fdisk is actually used to setup the entries in the native bootmanager. The multiboot man page will have some info for booting NetBSD with unsupported bootloaders.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-19 18:27 Why are you still using Windows XP? It hasn't been supported for four years and you can't get a reasonably supported browser on it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-19 19:50 >Why are you still using Windows XP? Hardware limitations + a lot of newer Windows versions suck >and you can't get a reasonably supported browser on it. I use a modified version of the latest Pale Moon beta (released 3 months ago), that's about as supported as it gets. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2018-07-20 04:08 You might want to dual boot *BSD + ReactOS :) or any application that can run on Wine? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 08:59 ReactOS doesn't play well with dual boots, it killed my XP installation so that's that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 17:14 > Hardware limitations + a lot of newer Windows versions suck Then I'm going to be blunt -- you need to get a new computer or switch full time to BSD or Linux. If it's a hardware limitation, your computer is pushing 15 years old at the minimum. XP is a security risk now, and it always will be. Shit, an RPi is more powerful. >I use a modified version of the latest Pale Moon beta (released 3 months ago), that's about as supported as it gets. "As supported as it gets" means actual support. PaleMoon discontinued XP support over a year ago. Using some unofficial port is putting lipstick on a pig. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 17:41 >Shit, an RPi is more powerful. No it isn't. The CPU is quite a bit more powerful on the RPi, but the GPU capabilities- The RPi's GPU capabilities are similar to that of the original Xbox. Not very good. The GPU I use (ATI Radeon HD X1650 Pro) is A LOT more powerful than the RPi's GPU. I've also probably got more RAM than an RPi does, and I've got expansion buses. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 17:57 If your computer is so damned ancient that it won't even run Windows 7 properly, then yes, an RPi is more powerful. CPU have come a long way in the past ten years. I would also be very surprised if that GPU was more powerful. That's a 12 year old AGP video card. AGP is dogshit slow compared to PCIe and modern onboard video. As far as your expansion goes, at this point it's obsolete. If you're using AGP video, it's almost certain you don't have PCIe, which all modern card expansion uses. Sure, you can hunt down the older equipment, but it's going to be bottlenecked. Trying to do anything with XP at this point is pissing into the wind while putting lipstick on a pig. Especially when off lease business class mini towers with Sandy Bridge or more recent processors can be had for under $200. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 18:04 The RPi's CPU is described as "Ten times as powerful as a 350mhz Pentium II", the CPU I use is probably 5-6 times as powerful as a Pentium II (could be more) and like I said, the GPU of the RPi is said to be as good as the original Xbox's GPU- it is definitely less powerful than what I've got. Also, my PC would run Windows 7 almost certainly just fine, but XP will run a lot faster than 7 on it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 18:09 Sauce on your quotes for the CPU and GPU? I would highly doubt that XP is any meaningfully faster than 7. XP has dogshit Multithreading support, a non functional 64 bit version (effectively capping you to 4GB of RAM), and old API. If you're so hell bent on having a Windows install on such an ancient computer, 7 is the only effective option...at least until 2020, at which point I'm sure you'll still be insisting on keeping an old pile around. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 18:13 I don't actually remember where those quotes are from... I know they're there, somewhere. My mobo maxes out at 3gb (DDR limitations, I have 2.5gb) and as my CPU isn't 64-bit, and only has 1 thread a lot of the problems you mentioned are non-issues. I have actually tried trimmed down Windows Vista and by god... it was a horror to use. Keeping well clear of later Windows versions for now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 18:24 Then they mean nothing if you can't cite them. Even if you did manage to, I would bet that they're talking about the original model -- not the Raspberry Pi 3 that's out now. If you only have one thread that's all the more reason to replace. Dual cores were common by 2006. Even the RPi3 has four. And if you're using DDR1 and it's 32-bit, that means you're using the 20 year old Pentium 4 architecture, a complete dogshit one even at the time. Best case you're using an Athlon XP, which still has the same issues. Having 2.5gb of RAM there is meaningless over the Pi's lesser amount when it's so slow and the CPU only has one thread to utilize for getting information from the RAM. Here's my advice to you: Get an offlease refurb desktop like this: htt p://www.microcenter.com/product/507818/OptiPlex_3010_Desktop_Computer_ Refurbished This is many times more powerful than what you're running, can run Windows 7 if you're that stubborn, and will run BSD/Linux far better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 18:29 >Best case you're using an Athlon XP, You're damn right I do use an Athlon XP. Well, technically a Sempron but it's essentially a rebranded Athlon XP 2200+ >Here's my advice to you: Get an offlease refurb desktop like this: ht tp://www.microcenter.com/product/507818/OptiPlex_3010_Desktop_Computer _Refurbished I simply don't have the monetary flexibility to be able to get something like that. I do have a machine which I use as a reserved machine for games, an OEM Packard Bell with an Athlon 64 however as I much prefer customs to OEMs, and web browsing is actually faster on the Athlon XP (Vista vs. optimized XP). I enjoy hardware freedom and that's something that I really can't get with OEMs. Don't worry, I do have upgrade plans for late 2019 when I will *hopefully* be able to afford some parts made in the last decade. I'm talking a Radeon HD 6970, 12gb of DDR3, and an FX-8320. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 18:37 The RPi is faster than your Sempron. Even if we were to imagine for a moment that a core was just the same, it'd still be light-years beyond because it has four cores and significantly faster memory. While I can appreciate the money issues, you're simply horribly misinformed on just how much your old hardware is worse than new hardware and you seem to be wilfully glossing over how bad of an idea it is to run XP now. And as for your proposed build, don't do it. Piledriver was a bad architecture. It uses a lot of power for little benefits. Get a quad core Ryzen if you're doing a build. They get extremely cheap very often, and theres a series with an integrated GPU that's more powerful than the 6970 you plan on. You are doing yourself zero favors by constantly buying not only bad hardware, but hardware that wasn't great when it was released. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 19:21 I'd prefer not to have PSP. I am aware the CPU is slower (on my machine)- but I'm fairly sure the GPU is better. The FX-8320 was the first non-shit FX CPU- I'm aware that the FX-6300 sucked balls but I know the FX-8320 is better than the FX-6300. Further, no an iGPU is almost certainly a lot slower than a Radeon 6970. It's important to remember the Radeon HD 6970 is roughly as fast as a 960ti, faster in some areas- I don't think there are any iGPUs as fast as the 960ti, do correct me if I'm wrong. There's also the benefits of discrete vs. integrated, RAM included. As well as the fact that DDR4 is extremely expensive, I don't like the sound of using Ryzen. Plus, I'd be forced to use Windows 10 if I were going to run Windows and I'd rather get sodomized by a cactus than do that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 19:47 > I'd prefer not to have PSP. Something like that is a fact of life with any modern core. You're deliberately being foolish to get any construction cores. They're hot, use ridiculous amounts of power, have terrible single threaded performance, and more. >I'm aware that the FX-6300 sucked balls but I know the FX-8320 is better than the FX-6300. They're the exact same architecture. The only difference is that 8xxx series are quad cores and 6xxx are tri cores. They clock the same, have the same amounts of cache, and single core performance is the same. >Further, no an iGPU is almost certainly a lot slower than a Radeon 6970. The 6970 is pretty old and lacks DX12 and Vulkan support, in addition to acceleration of new codecs like VP9. The new Ryzens have Vega based GPU's. Furthermore, if you're using something as old as you are, discrete graphics are completely worthless to you. Even if it is a small amount more powerful, it's just sucking up power unless you're actually playing demanding games. >As well as the fact that DDR4 is extremely expensive RAM is expensive. DDR3 is only going to get worse as time goes on. >Plus, I'd be forced to use Windows 10 if I were going to run Windows and I'd rather get sodomized by a cactus than do that. I'm going to be completely honest -- you're being neurotic and irrational on a lot of things. You're paranoid about a PSP that can be mostly disabled (only active for an initial bootstrap, then disabled and the OS turns off the driver), but you still continue to run Windows at all. If you're that concerned, just ditch it entirely and go full Linux or BSD. If you're using XP, I highly doubt there's anything you can't run on these modern systems. And even if there was some obscure app, I would bet it would work in WINE, or at worst case, a VM. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- letterafterl14 · 2018-07-20 19:55 >Then get Haswell or something without it. You're deliberately being foolish to get any construction cores. ALL Haswell boards have iME, which is basically the same thing as PSP. >The 6970 is pretty old and lacks DX12 and Vulkan support, in addition to acceleration of new codecs like VP9. The new Ryzens have Vega based GPU's. Furthermore, if you're using something as old as you are, discrete graphics are completely worthless to you. Even if it is a small amount more powerful, it's just sucking up power unless you're actually playing demanding games. I don't really care for DX12, actually as a matter of fact I don't think I've played any DX10 games, definitely not any DX11 let alone DX12. Besides, very few games actually require it. Also, coming from my heart, fuck VP9. Just another standard put in place by Google which murders older hardware, I'll use H264-ify thank you. >RAM is expensive. DDR3 is only going to get worse as time goes on. DDR4 is expensive. You can thank Hynix and Samsung for that. DDR3 is just fine and a lot cheaper. >If you're that concerned, just ditch it entirely and go full Linux or BSD. I acknowledge I will have to do that eventually, hence why I'm *sortof* learning how to use BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JQuilty · 2018-07-20 20:12 > ALL Haswell boards have iME, which is basically the same thing as PSP. I edited it, but I repeat -- this is a fact of life for anything decent. You are being an utter fool by buying construction cores. Ryzen also has the ability to mostly turn it off, where it's only active to boostrap the CPU. >I don't really care for DX12, actually as a matter of fact I don't think I've played any DX10 games, definitely not any DX11 let alone DX12 So in other words, you have no need for anything high end. Ergo, a discrete GPU is useless for your needs. >Also, coming from my heart, fuck VP9. Just another standard put in place by Google which murders older hardware, I'll use H264-ify thank you. Again, we go back to you being neurotic and inconsistent. VP9 is fully open source, put under a license that allows anyone to use it as long as they don't sue for patents. You go on about freedom, yet piss on a cutting edge performance open source codec and promote a less efficient, proprietary codec. And your "I'll use H264-ify thank you" is complete and utter ignorance -- VP9/VP8 don't work as well on Youtube because...wait for it....your GPU lacks hardware acceleration for them. You're also only hurting yourself since VP9 has way better compression than H.264. You're using probably twice (or more) the bandwidth vs VP9 if you continue to use it on a new build. And you're just being dumb with the "murders older hardware". The same fucking thing happened when H.264 became common over divx. Is it any shock to you that codecs require acceleration? Or that more effective compression requires more compute power? You praise H.264, which isn't a competitor to VP9. VP9's competitor is HEVC/H.265, which like VP8 vs VP9, requires way more computational power to transcode. It's not because they're mustache twirling villains that want to fuck with your old hardware, it's because effective compression needs more power than your 20 year old junk pile. You're blindly hating Google when they did both open source and the world in general a huge favor by buying On2 and open sourcing VP8, then keeping that up with VP9. And doing it yet again with AV1, which merges what was going to be VP10, Cisco's Thor, and Mozilla's Daala -- all under a completely free license. And it will be used by Youtube, Netflix, Amazon/Twitch, and even Apple has now joined AOMedia. If you're this pissed over VP9 you're going to die of an aneurysm as AV1 is rolling out, since everyone is using it and Google probably won't be apt to pay for H.264 licensing much longer, switching Youtube over entirely to AV1/VP8. >DDR4 is expensive. You can thank Hynix and Samsung for that. DDR3 is just fine and a lot cheaper. DDR3 is significantly slower and prices are rising as time goes on since it's not made any more. This is, quite frankly, a very dumb reason to stay with DDR3. By the time you build, you're going to be talking a few dollars in price. Your comments are identical to people complaining about DDR3 being expensive in 2012. >I acknowledge I will have to do that eventually, hence why I'm sortof learning how to use BSD. So rip that band-aid off. You're only making yourself worse off by continuing to use Windows. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ander_bsd · 2018-07-27 18:44 Try Haiku ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LeGauchiste · 2018-08-19 12:44 Buddy it sounds like you work at McDonalds, on good days when they need an extra worker and your phone number is there. You do understand, in most of modern (western styled) world if you had any friends they'd simply give you a better computer than that, that they don't use. Hell I have at home 3 or 4 laptops I think, all working and in good condition (only one with it's Nvidia card dead, so running on Intel card), that I don't use because they are old to me and I don't need them, or I use them rarely. I know it's off topic, but you are planning a budget for end of 2019 for investment of 50$ or so. McDonalds it is.