Overview of TrueOS 18.03 reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kstoneman · 2018-05-07 18:38 This is a good writeup. I had the same problems with Lumina and with security that the author noted when I tried TrueOS recently and also back when it was called PC-BSD. I keep hoping that they'll get their act together, but as the years roll past, I'm beginning to think that their philosophy is at the root of the problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- user_not_permitted · 2018-05-09 21:27 I agree - good summary of my experience also. But out of curiosity - what do you mean by “their philosophy” being at the root of the problem? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kstoneman · 2018-05-10 01:53 I really want to love this project. They have many appealing ideas: making it easy for people new to BSDs get up and running with an easy installer, graphical tools, better package management, better hardware support, ZFS support, even the Lumina desktop. After following them off and on for maybe a decade, it seems like Kris and the others may have gotten a little off-track, focusing more energy on marketing the name change and working to present an appealing image without fixing some of the more troublesome bugs. It mostly works, but the breakages are annoying and sometimes showstoppers. I can't remember the specific bugs that made me stop trying, but it was a difficult enough problem to make me try something else. I have been distro-hopping in the Linuces again for a while. Artix blew up openrc after the last update, so I tried a bunch of non-systemd distros again this week. Minor annoying bugs with each of them, so back to Manjaro for now. I briefly considered installing TrueOS, but the memory was painful enough that I skipped it. I don't remember anything specific, just that it was painful within the last six months. I have been running OpenBSD as my daily driver for seven or eight years now. There are a handful of things that I use another system for, so I usually either have two laptops or a desktop and a laptop or a dual-boot laptop (current scenario) to have access to those things. (For example, Google maps will only let me have the "lite" version on OpenBSD, and sometimes I just need Google maps, so Linux it is.) So, to get to the point finally: I think by "their philosophy," I really mean that they are willing to make changes that break things without going back to fix them immediately when someone points it out, and I think that has to do with some idea that "making it easy" doesn't always mean "making it correct." It's probably my bias after dealing with OpenBSD for all these years, but I really, really like stuff to work, and if it doesn't, I really like it when the project says, "It's too much trouble to try to make that work right now, so we're removing it." Come to think of it, my impression is that the Linux distros I tend to like also "just work," though I never feel like their nearly as "correct" as OpenBSD. TrueOS *seems* like it should be a project that "just works," but the reality is that there are lots of little breakages and annoyances that get in the way of that. I don't find that surprising considering that it's built on FreeBSD, which is generally less concerned with security and correctness and more concerned with competing for its share of the server market. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Hinulog · 2018-05-10 04:54 The 18.03 release is pretty good. Yes it's not perfect but it's usable. Its only a small team so patience is necessary. When they hit critical mass & attract a bigger team papercuts will be fixed quicker. They're in the top 10 on distrowatch these days... whho'da thunk a BSD would be there? I'm just delighted to be far, far away from the horror of systemd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- techsnapp · 2018-05-10 05:37 Good post here. As someone who also uses openBSD on a daily basis, but not as long as you, I agree with much of what you wrote. OpenBSD is quite stable, even when running daily snapshots. It's actually quite amazing how busy the developers stay and how few things break. To be fair, openBSD doesn't have a bug tracking system, so we don't exactly know what's been reported over the years and not fixed. For example, I have a laptop with a non-supported wifi card on openBSD, but it works fine with trueOS. Fortunately it's an easy fix - use an external wifi dongle. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kstoneman · 2018-05-10 19:07 I might have to try it. I'm running a systemd linux right now for DRM stuff because the non-systemd distros I've tried have annoyances without easy fixes. Artix seems like the most promising, but recently broke openrc with an update so it wasn't bootable. Rather than mess with it, I just put Manjaro on that partition. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kstoneman · 2018-05-10 19:09 [They just got a couple more hardware devs! ](http://undeadly.org/cgi?action=article;sid=20180506235838) Hopefully they will be able to get more wifi cards working soon. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-05-10 19:09 [removed] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Hinulog · 2018-05-11 04:04 Manjaro would be my most recommended Linux distro. Those guys are really nailing it. Full disclosure : TrueOS is a frozen in Amber six monthly snapshot. My experiments with using the FreeBSD ports to get newer version of Firefox on it did not end well lol!