Is "HugsBSD" a real operating system, or just a joke? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 11:46 Lunduke mentioned it on his show, but I can't find much outside the github page. CONCLUSION: I'm giving up on BSD now, and I respectfully suggest others consider doing the same. There's a word for people who can't peacefully allow others to hold opinions different than their own, but I can't quite remember it right now. As far as I can tell, *BSD is cannibalizing its user base and pushing newcomers away as hard as possible. I don't need the bullshit. I just need an operating system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2018-03-08 12:01 it's more of a safe space for highly sensitive white dudes who like using FreeBSD, but believe the evil Jews\^WWomen\^WGeorge Soros\^W\^WSocial Justice Warriors have taken over the project in an attempt to control their minds. not even joking ---------------------------------------------------------------------- monotux · 2018-03-08 12:10 The recent trainwreck\^Wdiscussion on r/freebsd has been a bit...well entitled. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 12:10 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 12:11 Because war is peace and freedom is slavery, right? Wanting EVERYONE to be free to be who they are and say what they mean even when you disagree with them, while contributing our time and energy to projects we love, equates to those you see as highly sensitive, paranoid, sexist, racist, anti-Semitic, white men, wanting a safe space? I simply can't imagine the kinds of mental gymnastics you had to perform to reach that conclusion, but it's good to know we can have a dialog about these things ;-). EDIT: I think I might understand, but please correct me if I'm wrong: from your perspective, anyone who object to the new CoC is doing so because they're hateful bigots who want to treat people disrespectfully, and not because, as I would put it, they value people's freedom of speech and expression more than the feelings of, as I would put it, the perpetually offended? On the off chance that I did understand but my words were badly chosen, feel free to reply in your own words. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 12:20 Can you tell me if HugsBSD is a real operating system or not? I need an operating system, not a flamewar. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 12:33 Not a clue sorry. All I know about Hugs is what's written on GitHub, and they feel nice. I use OpenBSD for pretty much everything. So far there's been less of this nonsense over there. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 12:46 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-03-08 12:48 Doesn't matter. If you want a BSD system, install FreeBSD and be done with it. Or OpenBSD or NetBSD if you prefer. Otherwise, no one cares. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2018-03-08 12:58 Dragonfly is pretty damn neat. don't count it out. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2018-03-08 12:58 it's a FreeBSD-copy safe space. again, I'm not joking. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 13:07 Again, perhaps you could explain how speaking out against the imposition of safe spaces though rigid codes of conduct and prescribed punishments, forced on the community from on-high, equates to wanting a safe space? I'm not joking. What you're saying is about as close to Orwellian doublespeak as I've ever seen anyone come! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Xerxero · 2018-03-08 13:53 Guess it’s a github fork with no developers and couple of changed lines. A gimmick and not much more. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 13:54 ***It's a joke***, though not a terribly good one. This is literally all that needs to be said about it, though some people seem to want to try their best to inject more toxicity and make this another flame war. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 14:48 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 14:49 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 16:48 > inject more toxicity Sweet Jesus ;-) I think you have cause and effect mixed up. It was the FreeBSD Core team that injected all this toxicity, with their CoC. And "flame wars" are the expected result. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KinterVonHurin · 2018-03-08 17:05 It is just FreeBSD the repos are sync'd every 10 hours the difference is that it doesn't apply the CoC. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KinterVonHurin · 2018-03-08 17:06 Dragonfly is also the only one I've been able to install at all in the last year (both OpenBSD and FreeBSD fail to boot from a USB and fail to install in a VM.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KinterVonHurin · 2018-03-08 17:07 You aren't joking you're just an idiot ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 17:08 > I think you have cause and effect mixed up. It was the FreeBSD Core team that injected all this toxicity, with their CoC. No, I didn't. There have been multiple injections of toxicity, from all different groups. Toxic actions generating toxic responses, ad infinitum. A lot of different people need to pull themselves together and cut it out. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 17:20 Ok. What caused all of this if not the CoC? I'm not denying that there's been a whole load of shit since the new CoC was released, much of it unfortunate, but it's hard to point to a similar level of drama on this topic prior. Cause, meet effect. Patient zero. FreeBSD Core is not innocent in all of this (but then who is at this point?) Am I alone in hoping they'd let go of all this politics and go back to the old CoC, or an acceptable new-new CoC? How does rolling over help anything? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 17:51 I actually think that, outside the context of the political toxicity, the mere word play is pretty clever. That's not a good reason for me to adopt it as an operating system though. I've always admired FreeBSD from the outside, strictly for its technical accomplishments. The communit\(y\|ies\) of users and developers is something I've yet to understand. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 17:52 That's not something I wanted to assume without asking. Thanks. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 17:56 Does that mean there is no serious effort to make HugsBSD its own operating system independent of FreeBSD? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Wileydj · 2018-03-08 18:27 Aight, I tried. I'm not a BSD user, but I've been interested for a while. I'm unsubscribing from this sub for now. If folks can't get on board with due diligence, being inclusive and attempting to make every day implicit social norms explicit rules, I'm not into it. Later. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KinterVonHurin · 2018-03-08 18:35 As time goes on (so long as contributions keep up) it will slowly but surely become it's own thing. Since the fork is only a couple weeks old it's still the exact same OS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 18:39 I didn't say anything about rolling over. > Am I alone in hoping they'd let go of all this politics and... No, you're not alone, but crap rhetoric like "HugsBSD", "patient zero", and "FreeBSD Core is not innocent" is just going to cause people to dig in their heels. If you want this fixed or improved, you need FreeBSD Core's cooperation. Why start by alienating them by focusing on blame and fault? It's counterproductive. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 18:42 > the mere word play is pretty clever You'll have to point out the clever wordplay to me. I'm not seeing it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2018-03-08 18:46 Please discipline me. I would love to see all the paranoid idiocy being spewed about the CoC come to life Protip: it wont ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 18:48 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 18:48 I don't have to do anything asshole. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 18:51 I'm giving up on BSD now, and I respectfully suggest others consider doing the same. There's a word for people who can't peacefully allow others to hold opinions different than their own, but I can't quite remember it right now. As far as I can tell, *BSD is cannibalizing its user base and pushing newcomers away as hard as possible. I don't need the bullshit. I just need and operating system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 18:57 > Does that mean there is no serious effort to make HugsBSD its own operating system independent of FreeBSD? Correct. AFAIK, this is not a fork by anyone with the technical competence to maintain or improve it. It's just a political statement made by someone who's only shown a tiny time commitment and proven basic technical competence with git. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 18:57 No, fuckit I give up. I just wanted to ask a few questions to learn more about the various BSD operating systems, but I got shit on for it. No matter how good this family of operating systems is technically, the hostile user community will kill it eventually. I don't need the headaches of being involved while that's happening. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 19:04 > I don't have to do anything asshole. Asshole? That came out of nowhere. Are you mad that your probably feigned ignorance of HugsBSD didn't trigger the discussion you wanted? And just so you know, I've written against the new CoC. However, a lot of other people who've written against it, probably including yourself, aren't doing that position any favors. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KinterVonHurin · 2018-03-08 19:08 Sorry to hear that but protip: reddit is not a good place to ask questions because it runs almost entirely on groupthink (this is why despite the clear backlash against the recent CoC on FreeBSD, the posters in this sub appear to be in complete denial about any backlash and attribute it to trolls instead.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-08 19:12 You're right about Reddit. If you'd like to direct me to a more newbie friendly place I may consider it after a month or two. I need time to forget this experience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 19:16 How do you propose that we get FreeBSD Core's cooperation in this matter? Reading some of the discussion, including the leaked emails, they seem to have made up their mind. At which point I have to wonder what mechanisms are available to hold them to account? I guess I could email conduct@ but since the judge is now presiding over his own trail I doubt I'd get a better response than anyone else. We seem to be missing a few checks and balances here and playing by their rules until we get tired, decide it's not worth the fight and just accept their rules, doesn't seem like a useful tactic to me. They can and will just keep driving the wedge deeper, censoring dissenting voices, and pretending that all the reasonable people agree with them (and by extension, those that don't agree are "unreasonable". More on that later). So what do we do about it? "Don't alienate the tyrants or they're not going to listen to you", has NEVER worked. I'm open to having my mind changed and I'm not advocating screaming and shouting but I'm also not happy to just be silent while reading claims that the reason people (like me) aren't happy about this move is because they (we) are "highly sensitive white dudes who [....] believe the evil Jews, Women, George Soros and The Social Justice Warrior's have taken over the project in an attempt to control their (our) minds", or as I read it, because they (we) are overly sensitive, paranoid, sexiest, racist, anti-Semitic, White men. Mmmmmm. Ok. There perfectly valid reasons (practical and philosophical) not be happy with the new CoC or the way it was imposed on the community by decree, but it seems we can't do anything about it. Calling out such statements doesn't result in a civil discussion of the matter if there is any discussion at all. Because it's toxic. There's plenty of ranting but no justifications. Get with the program or shut up is the message I'm getting. Well ok then. I won't be using FreeBSD. I won't contribute. And I won't donate. That makes me very very sad but I can't think of anything else that I can do? Will that make a difference? I highly doubt it... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 19:27 > I just need and operating system. There's always Plan 9 I supposed ;-). I've heard some nice things about void Linux (started by an ex NetBSD guy) and Alpine, but I'm reluctant to go that route, because, well, GNU and Linux, but needs must. I'm currently using OpenBSD for pretty much everything in my personal and professional life and have been for the past couple of years but there was a time when FreeBSD served that purpose. It's a fantastic system. It's just a shame that they've decided to take a political stance and they seem hell-bent on carrying it to the height of lunacy. I guess I'll just donate more to the OpenBSD project. I can't support this. Edit: I'm yet to really try DragonFlyBSD. Maybe that's an option for you? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 19:39 > At which point I have to wonder what mechanisms are available to hold them to account? Since neither of us our committers, the only mechanism is forwarding convincing arguments *that take into account their perspective and assume they're acting in good faith*. The only possible success is a *win-win compromise*. No one's going to successfully bully them into totally backing down and handing you precisely what you want. > I guess I could email conduct@ but since the judge is now presiding over his own trail I doubt I'd get a better response than anyone else. You could, but make sure it's something that you'd read and at least consider if you were in their shoes. It'd probably make sense to email core@ and cc conduct@. Speak to concerns that you think they'd share or at least be sympathetic to. An example is "how we can make the CoC better." I swear, judging my many of the public missives I've seen, too many people opposed to this new CoC would open such a message with: "Benno, you slimy villain, stop politicizing the project with your SJW ideas!!" Maybe not you, but definitely others. > I'm open to having my mind changed and I'm not advocating screaming and shouting but I'm also not happy to just be silent while reading that the reason people (like me) aren't happy about this move is because they (we) are "highly sensitive white dudes who needs[....] believe the evil Jews, Women, George Soros, Social Justice Warrior's have taken over the project in an attempt to control their (our) minds", or as I understand it, because they (we) are highly sensitive, paranoid, sexiest, racist, anti-Semitic white men. Then show that they're wrong and engaging in foolish stereotyping. Act classy and dispute those characterizations. Point out how they're unfair, strawmen, etc. Or downvote and move on. Or respond with an eyeroll. There are a lot of different options that are fine. > Get with the program or shut up is the message I'm getting. And those messages are usually coming from stupid people who aren't in any positions of power themselves either. For instance, the claim the CoC is "just about not being an asshole," is pretty easy to take apart when you note "being an asshole" is a very subjective thing so they really said nothing because they left all the meaning unspecified. Maybe bring up a one of the "perfectly valid reasons (practical and philosophical)" to oppose some aspect of it. Also remember, we're talking about the FreeBSD CoC, not feminism or transgender rights or anything like that. I've seen a lot of people get derailed into arguing about political topics and then saying something stupid. In all these cases, though, you shoot yourself in the foot as soon as you let in stuff like overblown rhetoric, name calling, shibboleths like "SJW," or villain narratives, etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 20:19 HugsBSD could never realistically be counted as one of the various BSD operating systems, and there was never anything to be learned about it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 20:36 It seems to be a matter of deep-felt belief, and if history is anything to go by, I doubt that reasoned argument will help. Despite 20+ years of evidence to the contrary Core now seem (from my third- party outsider perspective) to believe that in order for people to play together they have to think the same, and you need to outline exactly what is and isn't allowed, to an even more ludicrous degree than in society at large. Okay, I disagree. We can talk about the value of freedom of speech for resolving conflicts and arriving at consensus but if they don't want to hear it they won't. Their presumption here seems to be precisely that (to greater or lesser degrees) certain groups of people are bigoted, nasty and oppressive by their very nature, and that without a firm boot on the throat, chaos will ensue. I don't know how you argue with that. It's not true but if you really, really, really believe that then no amount of evidence or reason will ever change anything. A case in point, that beautiful little piece of statistics, "the gender pay gap" (as abused constantly by the BBC), defined simply as the difference between the average annual income of all men in some sample group and the average annual income of all women in some sample group... it doesn't take into account anything. Not level of education. Not industry. No time in employment. Not position. Not even hours worked. Not the holidays taken. Not benefits received. Nothing at all. It does not and cannot be understood to measure what it purports to be measuring, and this has been argued ad nauseam. It's easy to explain. It cannot be denied. There are numerous academic studies completely debunking this. But, mystery of mysteries, even after it's been explained people still believe they're literally receiving N cents on the dollar more/less than coworkers of the opposite gender for the same work... it shows a complete ignorance of statistics but they believe it none the less. And these aren't stupid people... So, how does one argue with that? By which I mean, how does one overturn someone's deepest held beliefs? Baring in mind there are still people saying the earth is flat and who will never be convinced otherwise... I understand what you're saying and I find it to be a positively enlightened approach to the problems we're experiencing. It's hard to reconcile with my experiences. I love it. It's great. I really wish there were more people like you in the world! You've convinced me. But how do you convince people who will not or cannot be convinced? Sincere question! And maybe it's a dumb question, but if you wouldn't mind I'd love to hear your opinion. I don't think it's a matter of argument... I think we just withdraw our support until they're ready to deal with reality. They're saying "if you want to play with us then here are the rules". So we vote with our feet. Sorry, those rules are not acceptable. Why would I put years of my life into something knowing that you can oust me on a whim because I have a different opinion about some things that have nothing at all to do with the project, it's aims, my role, or it's operation. What I "want" is that we accept that we have differences of opinion and realize that it's not the end of the world. We've happily played together for 20+ years without such decrees. Let's continue doing that. Let's not ostracize people because of politics. There's a word for that... and it's the opposite of what Core claim to want... (Hence my reference to doublespeak.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 20:48 > So, how does one argue with that? By which I mean, how does one overturn someone's deepest held beliefs? Baring in mind there are still people saying the earth is flat and who will never be convinced... There a lot of big, probably false assumptions in this statement. Whose "deepest held beliefs?" Do you even know that person? > I think we just withdraw our support until they're ready to deal with reality. The reality is that your support doesn't matter and no one will miss it. > What I "want" is that we accept that we have differences of opinion and realize that it's not the end of the world. .... Let's not ostracize people because we're different. You might be able that, if you identify what's achievable and focus on that. If you keep daydreaming about heroes and villains, you probably won't. > There's a word for that... and it's the opposite of what Core claim to want... I think your conception of Core is probably a strawman, and even if it isn't Core isn't the entire project. They're not the politburo standing committee (e.g. the only people with real power and accountable to no one). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 21:11 With due respect, is it an implicit social norm that (I know this sounds ludicrous but bear with me here) before giving someone a \*hug\* you must first get their explicit consent, or face punishment, not by a jury of your peers but by those people who imposed their rules upon you, with no requirement of evidence or due process? What about your right to face your accuser(s)? It seems like everyone has forgotten the principals of Common Law; that we as a society make and give power to the rules which govern us, and don't just accept decrees from on high... Tyranny is, by definition, being subject to arbitrary judgment. We fixed that a thousand years ago. Why are we now seemingly intent on throwing the baby out with the bathwater? These are not structures we should accept lightly. People's livelihoods (their lives) depend on this stuff! If I was a FreeBSD developer working for a third party and you took away my commit bit because you say that someone has complained about something I said on Twitter some years back, which may or may not have been so controversial at the time, what am I to do about it? Who do I go to for redress? Do we really want to accept the implication that we're guilty until proven innocent? We're all grown-ups here and presumably we all function fairly well in society; the FreeBSD project is 20+ years old at this point and while it's seen it's fair share of disagreements its mostly worked out for everyone. Why "fix" what isn't broken? Why should we want or need to make implicit social norms explicit? We leave them implicit in society... Somewhere deep down we know that when you prescribe everything in such detail then, whether you like it or not, you eschew the flexibility (the nuance and understanding) that is necessary for dealing with people in society... That wisdom, from a bygone age, is slowly washing away... I'm all for inclusivity and acceptance, but that is not what this does. In practice, all it achieves is to make people walk on egg- shells and allow a small group of people to punish or ostracize others for having a difference of opinion. So what if I happen to think a good *hug* from time to time is swell, that I hate deviled eggs, and don't agree with same-sex marriage but I have no problem with civil-partnership; all thoughts and opinions that have the potential to get me banned from contributing to FreeBSD under their new [Geek Feminism] CoC. Can you honestly look me in the eye and tell me that it's in the name of "inclusivity" that you wish to exclude people with different opinions? Because frankly: that seems ludicrous to me. Especially considering the very real effects that such actions could have on the lives of real people. But hey, later :-). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dlyund · 2018-03-08 21:27 > There a lot of big, probably false assumptions in this statement. Whose "deepest held beliefs?" Do you even know that person? Abstractly, do you accept that there are people who will not be swayed by any amount of evidence, or reasoned argument? I'm curious, separate from the issue with Core (or whatever you want to call the group of people that believes in and put forward this Geek Feminism CoC), how do you deal with people who have power over you (directly or indirectly), but will not listen? It just seems to me that if I simply don't care, you can talk until your blue in the face (or the hand) and it won't make an ounce of difference. I'm not saying I have a solution but do you accept that that's a problem with "stay calm and keep arguing rationally"? > The reality is that your support doesn't matter and no one will miss it. You're absolutely right. > I think your conception of Core is probably a strawman, and even if it isn't Core isn't the entire project. They're not the politburo standing committee (e.g. the only people with real power and accountable to no one). Fair point. But they do have the power to impose CoCs on the community, and they can presumably back up those rules if you don't fall in line? Otherwise, where are the teeth in all this? If there are no teeth then great, we can just ignore all this nonsense! :-) I don't know, you're probably right. Thank you for your time and patience, and an interesting discussion! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2018-03-08 21:30 > As far as I can tell, *BSD is cannibalizing its user base and pushing newcomers away as hard as possible. There are a few bad users on the internet who are pushing people away from BSD. The rest of us just ignore them. I don't know anything about "HugsBSD". I wouldn't stop using Firefox if some random idiot with a GitHub account forked "Hugsfox". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 21:45 Fuck the FreeBSD core team, and fuck FreeBSD. I'm out. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 21:51 > Abstractly, do you accept that there are people who will not be swayed by any amount of evidence, or reasoned argument? To be frank: fuck abstractions, especially abstract people. You're dealing with *real* people who are a lot more complicated. The abstractions you put on them will only trip you up. > how do you deal with people who have power over you (directly or indirectly), but will not listen? This is demonstrably not the case here, so it's moot. > Fair point. But they do have the power to impose CoCs on the community, and they can presumably back up those rules if you don't fall in line? Otherwise, where are the teeth in all this? I think your assessment of the dynamics here is wrong. For one, the core team is accountable to the committers. We're also not privy to all the inside information needed to make an accurate assessment. That point needs to be underlined. > Thank you for your time and patience, and an interesting discussion! Thank you as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 22:11 Good for you. The "SJWs" applaud you for making them look kind and reasonable. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 23:02 Are you an imbecile? I was a potential new user of FreeBSD and then I saw this whole shitty, condescending, and dictatorial attitude by self-appointed royalty, and it totally put me off. Enjoy wallowing in your passive -aggressive filth while your community dies slowly and painfully. You deserve no better. I'm off to a community that cares about technology more than debating the merits and demerits of virtual hugs. Bejasus, talk about living in a bubble. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 23:03 > Are you an imbecile? I was a potential new user of FreeBSD and then I saw this whole shitty, condescending, and dictatorial attitude by self-appointed royalty, and it totally put me off. Enjoy wallowing in your passive -aggressive filth while your community dies slowly and painfully. You deserve no better. I'm off to a community that cares about technology more than debating the merits and demerits of virtual hugs. Bejasus, talk about living in a bubble. What, exactly, did you hope to accomplish with that comment? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-08 23:13 Does it have to "accomplish" anything? Boy, you are delusional. Go out into the real world a bit more. It's good for you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 23:22 So you were just pissing into the wind because it felt good? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- doxavg · 2018-03-08 23:34 Can someone please tell me how the fuck FreeBSD became "BSD"??? That's like calling Ubuntu Linux "Linux", it's idiotic. If CoC loving FreeBSD isn't good enough for you because "drama", I suggest visiting one of the other projects that are mostly or completely unrelated and just as technically awesome. The whole drama over a CoC is retarded unless you happen to be one of the few that actually contribute to the project and may have a reason to care. As an end user, choose the project that suits your technical requirements and move on. Now if you'll excuse me, my popcorn is burning and my toaster is finished compiling. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-03-08 23:45 > you need FreeBSD Core's cooperation Not in the long term no... Because either core will be reelected, in which case it's clear that the majority wanted the CoC in which case it's just time to leave and watch the ship burn from afar... Or the current core will be ejected because of it. Either way, core's cooperation is not at all needed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-08 23:52 ...or the current Core reacts to the situation because it's a garbage fire they didn't want. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-03-08 23:53 Right... But you claimed that we NEEDED core's cooperation... And that's just evidently not the case. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-03-09 00:03 That's not quite how it works. Even if you're a user, and choosing based entirely on the technical aspect. You're also choosing based on the technical aspect of the future. That means that even end users, are affected by this CoC because it affects the outcome of the project in the long run. So it's just outright false to claim that it only affects the developers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- doxavg · 2018-03-09 00:50 I choose what's right for me, right now, with a view towards the immediate future, not what's right for me in the unforeseeable future. The CoC doesn't affect the immediate future of FreeBSD, although the politics surrounding it does have the potential to affect funding as well as developers deciding if they want to stay or go, which can affect the long term future. I'm also not standing up server farms, so what I have concerns about is completely different than someone who is about to build the next hotmail.com. I'd still choose FreeBSD for that project however, in spite of the politics and drama. If anyone can point me to FreeBSD Core developers leaving in droves over the CoC, then I'll pronounce FreeBSD dead and lean more heavily on the other BSDs, or *gasp* (sorry /r/BSD, I hang both ways) choose linux if it makes more sense to. If you think the CoC is a good thing, then FreeBSD now has two pluses going for it, if you think it's a bad thing, you can still rely on the operating system for it's technical merits. Personally, I'm not sure I really care (commenting here more over the equation of BSD to FreeBSD than the CoC). That they felt they needed one, speaks volumes about both the sensitivity of people today as well as the lack of empathy. It's not a FreeBSD issue, it's a societal issue and it extends to every nook and cranny. It's disappointing, hopefully Humans 2.0 are a better species. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-03-09 00:58 And if you only plan for the next 6 months, good for you. The vast vast majority of users make decisions for OSes for much MUCH longer time frames than that. Usually for the lifespan of the computer it's being installed on since OS choice often also influence the choice of hardware. But you having the time to invest to redo your install every so often or at least plan to redo it every so often, is completely and utterly irrelevant to the vast amount of users who do not have that much free time on their hands that they don't know what to do with... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 01:27 I suppose that's true. I get what you were saying now. But I still think that it's not right to write off the core team and the project just yet. In any case, trying to influence it and get its cooperation is a good short term goal. There's no gain in alienating it. If it's truly intransigent, that will be shown over time and make a stronger case that it should be replaced. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-03-09 01:41 I don't think anyone is writing off the entirety of Core. But any rational person would have already written off people like Benno after his sexist and racist rant... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 3G6A5W338E · 2018-03-09 02:37 For a real and mature FreeBSD fork, look at Dragonfly. https://www.dragonflybsd.org/presentations/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2018-03-09 05:13 It's a great operating system. All business, no bullshit. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2018-03-09 05:16 I'm going to write a review of HugsBSD pretty soon. Stay tuned, bro. There will be lots of touching and backrubs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- GuinansEyebrows · 2018-03-09 06:32 void is great. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-09 07:22 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Cathy_Newman · 2018-03-09 07:57 While it may be normal for you to discriminate based on gender or race, many other people try to avoid this. I’d certainly not establish discrimination as a rule. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 15:37 >fuck abstractions, especially abstract people. You're dealing with real people who are a lot more complicated. The abstractions you put on them will only trip you up. As someone with a deep background in personality psychology research, I have to plainly disagree here, as /u/dlyund is presenting a form of mindset[1] that actually *is* fairly common and not merely a theoretical construct, whether (s)he knows it or not. And quite frankly, I find it insulting to the people who dedicate their lives researching how people work whenever someone makes an 'appeal to complexity' like this, as if we're all completely unique individuals that cannot be understood without getting to *deeply know* them personally first, because the science is just plainly not that simple. It's a shame, because I've largely agreed with your positions otherwise. EDIT: I should probably clarify that [1] isn't a singular trait or pattern, but rather a family of traits and behavioral patterns that lead to similar outcomes. The literature on this is quite verbose and technical, so it's tricky to compress and translate it into plain English without this turning into a whole essay, so I'll have to leave it at that for now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 15:54 >Also remember, we're talking about the FreeBSD CoC, not feminism or transgender rights or anything like that. I've seen a lot of people get derailed into arguing about political topics and then saying something stupid. >In all these cases, though, you shoot yourself in the foot as soon as you let in stuff like overblown rhetoric, name calling, shibboleths like "SJW," or villain narratives, etc. are you suggesting that there are no external political factors involved in the motivations behind these sorts of CoCs, or simply that these factors shouldn't be used as arguments against them? legitimate question. also, at what point does pointing out a connection to external political phenomena become "overblown rhetoric" as opposed to just filling in historical context? I ask only because I find that often, merely pointing out connections to prior political movements is enough to get labeled as "rhetoric" regardless of how informative that added context actually is, simply because there seems to be no objectively neutral way of talking about contemporary politics in the current social climate where everyone seems to immediately assume the least charitable interpretation possible. This applies just as much to people who get offended by virtual hugs as it does to people who deride anyone who uses the term "SJW", it's just an unfortunately really common trend on all sides. Even though I don't like the term "SJW" myself either, it is one of the very few labels with a lot mindshare that unambiguously refer to a very specific niche political movement that exists. Unlike many of the labels surrounding this CoC discussion, it does not refer to a race/gender/orientation, but rather to a political platform, much like "Jacobin" did during the French revolution. Granted, it tends to get tossed around carelessly a lot, but then what political affiliation doesn't? So even though I wish there were a better name for it (that isn't surrounded by *even more* stigma/misunderstanding), I don't think advocating for shutting down all discussion or reference to it is productive, namely because there aren't very many other ways to refer to that concept, and a lot of relevant context is given by talking about it. It'd be like trying to talk about the American political system and it's policies without referring to any of it's actual political parties. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-09 15:55 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2018-03-09 16:25 They will come for that next. Stand strong and be ready to punish them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 17:02 >I'm reluctant to go that route, because, well, GNU and Linux, but needs must. I sympathize completely, though if you want as close of a BSD-like experience in linux land as possible, I highly recommend checking out [Crux](https://crux.nu/) and Slackware/[Salix](https://www.salixos.org/) with [sbotools](https://pink-mist.github.io/sbotools/). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 3G6A5W338E · 2018-03-09 17:13 They wouldn't stand a chance in dfly. About as unlikely as openbsd. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chalbersma · 2018-03-09 17:19 Can I get a TLDR? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- unused_alias · 2018-03-09 17:26 Random bsd-curious dude notices there are multiple os-es in the bsd family and decides to ask in a public forum about a mysterious outlier because he doesn't want to waste effort on jokes and drama. Question thread is immediately dv-ed to hell and polluted with jokes and drama. Great first impression. Don't expect me to read any replies. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 17:27 You missed my point. I'm not saying that everyone's an irreducibly unique and complex individual that can only be understood by deep individual knowledge. What I was trying to say is if you focus too much on your personality abstractions, e.g. >> people who will not be swayed by any amount of evidence, or reasoned argument ...you'll likely trip yourself up because you're likely to keep your head in the clouds and miss facts on the ground that don't fit your abstraction. Also, if you're engaging more with your own abstraction and less with the person you talking to the disconnect shows as a weakness in argument. This is how strawmen are formed. This causes non- sequiturs. I also suspect that this disconnect is *more* visible to more neutral observers and *less* visible to more biased ones. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chalbersma · 2018-03-09 17:48 Well now I just have more questions.... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 18:39 > are you suggesting that there are no external political factors involved in the motivations behind these sorts of CoCs, or simply that these factors shouldn't be used as arguments against them? legitimate question. No. What I'm saying is: what's your goal, to fight the political battle or fix the CoC? I think those goals are in tension with each other, and you're not going to win your political battle on /r/FreeBSD or in the FreeBSD mailing lists. It's the wrong venue. I'm not saying you should pretend like the political and ideological influences on the CoC don't exist, but how you bring them up should be subordinated to the goal of improving the CoC. > Even though I don't like the term "SJW" myself either, it is one of the very few labels with a lot mindshare that unambiguously refer to a very specific niche political movement that exists. It's a shibboleth and you *instantly lose a lot of people* when you deploy it. It was a lazy label in the first place, but now it's corrupted beyond redemption. You can thank the word-salad spewing idiots for that. You also don't need a *label* with "a lot of mindshare," you need the ability to clearly describe the behaviors and ideas you're talking about and be understood. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 18:45 >. What I was trying to say is if you focus too much on your personality abstractions ... you'll likely trip yourself up because you're likely to keep your head in the clouds and miss facts on the ground that don't fit your abstraction. It's a tricky divide there between the useful abstractions and unhelpful "abstractions", because it really depends heavily on what the classifications actually are, and what the actual audience is. The reason I felt the need to respond is in fact because a lot of times, abstractions (even like the ones you quoted) can actually be really helpful tools that can help guide communication better. In this case in particular, it may seem like a roadblock to suggest some people cannot be argued with reasonably, however I'd view it more as a creativity boosting tool suggesting that perhaps there's another way around the mountain besides directly climbing it. Where I'd argue attempting to gain substantial support for any non-predominant idea on a public forum is akin "directly climbing up the mountain". Not to suggest that nobody should attempt it of course, but I'd argue this form of more nuanced, persuasive argumentation is probably best dissipated through more focused channels, such as blogs, videos, and mailing lists. Public forums (and especially vote-based ones) seem to me like some of the least impactful places for trying to have productive discussion, as there's just a lot of self-reenforcing crowd-mentality involved, and it's really difficult to get any kind of point across when you're not 100% with the predominant positions there. Not to take away from any of your efforts, it's just my personal experience as someone who's dedicated a lot of his life studying psychology. Should consider putting up an anonymous blog post somewhere if you're up for it, as it can be surprising how much more effective posting a few links here and there can be to get a message across. Secondly, I feel compelled to point out the irony of us having a meta discussion about abstracting people, which is itself an "abstraction" that doesn't directly affect the current issue ;). It's just really impossible to say whether any given abstraction is adequate or not without referring to a specific person or subset of people. As much as I would like there to be simple universal principles of effective communication, experience and research has taught me that the only thing that's safely reliable in that domain, is to minimize projecting things about ourselves onto our audiences, and just learning to adapt to dealing with the wildly differing mindsets of others. >if you're engaging more with your own abstraction and less with the person you talking to the disconnect shows as a weakness in argument. As I mentioned above, it kind of depends on the abstraction. Abstractions can in fact lead to strawmen as you suggested, but they can also bring you closer to empathizing with your detractors more than you ever thought possible. It's not really reliable to assume this is bad as a steadfast rule, since even seemingly 'negative' abstractions can be productive sometimes, while seemingly 'positive' abstractions can be counter-productive at other times. It's a rather nuanced issue. > I also suspect that this disconnect is more visible to more neutral observers and less visible to more biased ones. Agreed completely. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 19:07 > Where I'd argue attempting to gain substantial support for any non- predominant idea on a public forum is akin "directly climbing up the mountain". Not to suggest that nobody should attempt it of course, but I'd argue this form of more nuanced, persuasive argumentation is probably best dissipated through more focused channels, such as blogs and mailing lists. AFAIK the only discussion on the CoC is occurring: 1. Internal FreeBSD mailing lists 2. For a short time in a Hacker News thread 3. Here 4. Probably twitter, but fuck that No one's going to give a shit if I write a blog. Also the interactivity of a forum is helpful for getting out of your own head. > and it's really difficult to get any kind of point across when you're not 100% with the predominant positions there. I think a lot of that's a side effect of too much labeling and the polarization it fuels. There are places that are too much of a circlejerk to bother, but this doesn't seem to be one of them. > It's a tricky divide there between the useful abstractions and unhelpful "abstractions", because it really depends heavily on what the classifications actually are, and what the actual audience is. ... > Secondly, I feel compelled to point out the irony of us having a meta discussion about abstracting people, which is itself an "abstraction" that doesn't directly affect the current issue ;). It's just really impossible to say whether any given abstraction is adequate or not without referring to a specific person or subset of people. I'm not opposed to abstractions in general, just when they're used for the people you're presently interacting with. They're also unwise if there's too much ideological difference, or too much *assumed* ideological similarity, because they're a barrier to creating common ground for communication. Abstractions are only useful in that case if they're shared, and even that requires a little verification. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 19:41 > what's your goal, to fight the political battle or fix the CoC? Fair enough, point taken. I can see how the goals are in tension with each other, however there is still a high likelihood of overlap, which makes the situation complicated, and I don't know of any realistic solutions for that unfortunately. > You also don't need a label with "a lot of mindshare," you need the ability to clearly describe the behaviors and ideas you're talking about and be understood. Not that I disagree, however that quickly leads you to writing/referencing [entire books](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show /27793.Explaining_Postmodernism) when dealing with matters as complex as these. And frankly, I can't blame people for finding that impractical compared to just using shorthand labels, especially since most people just immediately ignore any argument that involves a wall- of-text or relies on any kind of long book to explain its argument. It's unfortunate, but I'm just trying to stay realistic here. This is why I highlighted that the whole issue of "the least charitable interpretation being assumed" is a communication barrier here in the context of contemporary politics, because I doubt many would make similar arguments about using the label "Jacobin" instead of fully elaborating the political stance every time when talking about 18th century France. I understand *why* this is the case mind you, I'm just making it explicit that emotional reactionary forces are at play here, and that it isn't objectively about label use being inherently bad. >you instantly lose a lot of people when you deploy it. This is true, but you cannot please all people all the time, and everyone's going to make different choices about who they feel comfortable pissing off. We don't have to agree with everything everyone says when making similar arguments obviously, but it seems easier for things to get derailed and dilute the argument even more, when we start aggressively debating who we should or shouldn't be pissing off in such situations, since it's almost certain a consensus is never going to be reached about that. Sometimes [worse is better](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worse_is_better), other times it's not, but I'm not comfortable making a judgement call to decide which time it is with regards to that just yet. >It was a lazy label in the first place, but now it's corrupted beyond redemption. Agreed, but a lot of the alternatives aren't much better either unfortunately, either because they're just instantly reaction-inducing (e.g. "cultural marxists"/"leftists"), confusing (e.g. "[third-wave] feminists"), or just too obscure (e.g. "post-modernists"). And again, while it would be *ideal* to not rely on labels so heavily, the alternative is cumbersome and exhausting enough to sufficiently many people, to ensure that it's going to continue happening anyway whether we like it or not. And I just don't feel comfortable advocating for the silencing of well meaning people that want to contribute something to the discussion, and simply don't have the time to write up a whole novel about the issue every time it's brought up. *I* may choose to write walls of text to clarify my stances, but I don't think I have the right to request that of everyone wanting to something to say about it, regardless of how bad and idiotic as some peoples' opinions may come out sounding as a result. Part of the entire reason I'm not in favor of this CoC in the first place, is because I'm deeply against the idea of any form of compelled speech. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 20:04 >No one's going to give a shit if I write a blog. Not at the onset, no. However, there is a benefit to having an argument presented somewhere more "permanent" than some ephemeral forum comment. It may get less traffic for a while, but it actually has higher odds of collecting more attention overall in the long term, and thus a higher likelihood of getting more traction. This is assuming that you'd submit it to relevant subreddits, and link it where appropriate instead of having it just sit there of course. But don't underestimate the [power of small influencers](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13542853-trust-me-i- m-lying). Even that Lunduke character managed to make a reasonably sized impact with his videos even though they have relatively few (< 15k) views, so who knows. Public opinion is filled with lots of little butterfly effects like that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 21:33 > Not that I disagree, however that quickly leads you to writing/referencing entire books when dealing with matters as complex as these. And frankly, I can't blame people for finding that impractical compared to just using shorthand labels You don't solve that problem by using terms like "SJW." All the problems I mentioned above still apply, but I can add another: by using the label you're implicitly referencing all the walls of text you read on the label, without providing any way to access them. Labels are only useful if you and your interlocutor are using them consistently, and even then there's a danger of a descent into sloppy thinking. > especially since most people just immediately ignore any argument that involves a wall-of-text or relies on any kind of long book to explain its argument. It's unfortunate, but I'm just trying to stay realistic here. > about using the label "Jacobin" instead of fully elaborating the political stance every time What you have to do is distill your description down to the most essential points you need and let the rest unfold in the conversation. It's a mistake to "fully elaborate." You do seem to have a tendency towards walls of text. > This is true, but you cannot please all people all the time, and everyone's going to make different choices about who they feel comfortable pissing off. When you use shibboleths like "SJW," I think it's a safe approximation that you're at least annoying everyone who doesn't already agree with you, and probably pissing off a good fraction too. It's pissing into the wind. > Sometimes worse is better That is a misapplication of the idea. You're not releasing software into the marketplace. Also, usually worse is just worse. You also seem to value "completeness" above all else, which is counter to both design philosophies. > Agreed, but a lot of the alternatives aren't much better either unfortunately, either because they're just instantly reaction-inducing (e.g. "cultural marxists"/"leftists"), confusing (e.g. "[third-wave] feminists"), or just too obscure (e.g. "post-modernists"). And again, while it would be ideal to not rely on labels so heavily, the alternative is cumbersome and exhausting enough to sufficiently many people, to ensure that it's going to continue happening anyway whether we like it or not. And I just don't feel comfortable advocating for the silencing of well meaning people that want to contribute something to the discussion, and simply don't have the time to write up a whole novel about the issue every time it's brought up. I may choose to write walls of text to clarify my stances, but I don't think I have the right to request that of everyone wanting to something to say about it, regardless of how bad and idiotic as some peoples' opinions may come out sounding as a result. False choice, there are more options than sloppy and/or stupid labels and cumbersome walls of text. To make an analogy: show someone a room instead of hand-waving at the whole edifice or trying to walk them through its blueprints. > Part of the entire reason I'm not in favor of this CoC in the first place, is because I'm deeply against the idea of any form of compelled speech. Ok, great, you're deeply against something. What are you for and why should I care? How is that relevant to the development of an open source operating system? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-09 21:37 Some stuff is ephemeral, like this controversy. This shit ain't for the ages. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-09 23:06 > by using the label you're implicitly referencing all the walls of text you read on the label, without providing any way to access them. I don't understand this argument. One of the *benefits* of unique labels, is that they're easily searchable. By giving someone a label they might not have heard before, you're presenting them the opportunity to research it on their own and form their own conclusions about it. The label might still be shit, but imagine if "freebsd" was called "berkley patches for the unix operating system that later developed into it's own full operating system". Clearly, "FreeBSD" is a lot more accessible. Ideally you'd give readers both the label and description, so you don't *force* them to actually go out of their way and google things, but not giving any form of keyword to search for at all actively deprives them of getting a lot of additional context that may be of interest to them. > there's a danger of a descent into sloppy thinking. Yes it's a danger, but it's not a guarantee. Each argument should be evaluated individually on it's own merits, not based on whether it uses certain taboo words or not. > You do seem to have a tendency towards walls of text. Guilty as charged. My background is as an academic, and I acknowledge the trade-offs that come with this style, but still deliberately choose to present my arguments this way for a reason. > I think it's a safe approximation that you're at least annoying everyone who doesn't already agree with you, and probably pissing off a good fraction too. It's pissing into the wind. Once again, you're not wrong. But so what? It's an individual's prerogative to use whatever inane terminology they like. Let people piss away their efforts with their poor word choices. There is more than one way to skin a cat, and there are more than enough people trying to skin cats at the moment to drown out the poor performers. >That is a misapplication of the idea. You're not releasing software into the marketplace. The intention behind it was to be an analogy, or simile if you like. I referenced it because this is a subreddit that would most likely be familiar with the concept already, and would be able to re-use some intuitions about it, even if not directly applied to software. To assume I was using it literally is quite a disingenuous interpretation. >You also seem to value "completeness" above all else To be fair, you also seem to value "completeness", not just in the sense of describing which particular ideologies you're debating against, but also in the sense of trying to direct how all the arguments against them should go. I'm not going to argue this is a bad thing, but it is something to keep in mind. > False choice, there are more options than sloppy and/or stupid labels and cumbersome walls of text. To make an analogy: show someone a room instead of hand-waving at the whole edifice or trying to walk them through its blueprints. Correct about the false choice, however in the real world, a lot of house tours involve all 3 of those components: walking through the room *while* hand-waving, and occasionally referring to blueprints here and there. My arguments are not *against* walking through rooms, or *for* the showing of blueprints, they are against the full-stop black-and-white opposition of hand-waving that doesn't take into account the circumstances in which it happens. Someone can have still have a perfectly sound argument while making reference to labels here and there, and you seem to be for throwing out the baby with the bath water because it carries the risk of alienating people. I'm of the mind that people aren't as fragile creatures as you're painting them out to be, and can handle reading content with questionable labels in it while still reaching their own conclusions. Otherwise, schools would've banned reading Huck Finn years ago. > What are you for and why should I care? How is that relevant to the development of an open source operating system? I took the trouble to elaborate on a lot of ideas already, and you're (seemingly knowingly, based on your response) prodding me for yet another wall of text that you seem to find counter-productive? Oy :P. Some ideas and arguments cannot be condensed to small unambiguous snippets of text without begging for misunderstanding. We might as well just continue talking past each other at that point. So ultimately it's probably better if we just agree to disagree. I don't believe your debates here are helping/harming the project any more than the voices you claim are actively hindering your efforts, and I was only trying to communicate clearly and in good faith the reasons why that would be the case, and attempted to resonate that directly with /u/freebsd_user, not to some arbitrary audience of freebsd users in general. However if my words are going to be misconstrued, there's no benefit for me to continue spending energy here. I've attempted to be the most charitable I could be with my interpretations of your words, and quite frankly I'm not seeing that reciprocated very much, so I'd rather cut my losses and move on. Good discussion while it lasted. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wannabehax0r · 2018-03-10 03:01 ❄️❤️❄️❤️❄️❤️❄️❤️❄️❤️❄️ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-03-10 05:46 >> by using the label you're implicitly referencing all the walls of text you read on the label, without providing any way to access them. > I don't understand this argument. One of the benefits of unique labels, is that they're easily searchable. Their search gives them 10,000 walls of text. Which ones? Who knows, but probably not the ones you intended. Maybe they happen on ones that say SJWs are really just people with empathy and find that convincing. Maybe they only read the a few of the 9,000 of those walls of text that are batshit insane or downright embarrassing, and form a poor opinion of you via the association. That's the benefit? Maybe when you're talking about some scientific jargon with a good Wikipedia page, but not this stuff. > By giving someone a label they might not have heard before, By now you can assume they've all heard of "SJWs" and "cultural marxism", and probably have an opinion about the type of people who use those terms. > you're presenting them the opportunity to research it on their own and form their own conclusions about it. Why would they bother digging around in those 10,000 walls of text just to try to make sense of a shibboleth you used like "SJW" in a random internet comment or blog? That comment or blog is not some great revelation, no one is going to care that much to spend the time. That's why you need to accurately and concisely describe the specific idea you're commenting on, *in your comment*. The idea's right there when they need it. > The label might still be shit, but imagine if "freebsd" was called "berkley patches for the unix operating system that later developed into it's own full operating system". Not at all what we're talking about here. To recap: 1. Not good to label your interlocutor, since you're not speaking with the strawman in your head. Best not tempt that mistake. 2. Not good to use vague shibboleth-labels like "SJW." Invites other counterproductive labels (e.g. "gamergator"). They're shit terms anyway with no good agreed-upon definitions (among other things). Realistically, you're never commenting on the edifice (and if you are, you're probably not saying anything of value), so just describe the relevant part, *which shouldn't be hard or take too much text.* > Each argument should be evaluated individually on it's own merits, not based on whether it uses certain taboo words or not. Good luck with that. > There is more than one way to skin a cat, and there are more than enough people trying to skin cats at the moment to drown out the poor performers. My sense is the poor performers dominate. > but also in the sense of trying to direct how all the arguments against them should go Just pointing out things that work poorly. > they are against the full-stop black-and-white opposition of hand- waving that doesn't take into account the circumstances in which it happens. [Hand waving](http://www.dictionary.com/browse/hand--waving?s=t). The key word is "insubstantial." > Someone can have still have a perfectly sound argument while making reference to labels here and there, and you seem to be for throwing out the baby with the bath water because it carries the risk of alienating people. I'm talking specifically about terms like SJW and the like. They're ungodly miasmas of straw-men, shibboleth, and hate-objects. Make your perfectly sound arguments, but say what you mean rather than using them if you want anyone to listen. >>> Part of the entire reason I'm not in favor of this CoC in the first place, is because I'm deeply against the idea of any form of compelled speech. >> What are you for and why should I care? How is that relevant to the development of an open source operating system? > I took the trouble to elaborate on a lot of ideas already, and you're (seemingly knowingly, based on your response) prodding me for yet another wall of text that you seem to find counter-productive? Those are questions everyone asks when you state your beliefs, and especially when you just state that you're against something. You didn't answer them when you introduced your political opinions to me. I'm not prodding you for more more walls of text. I actually wish you'd write less text that's more to the point, then I wouldn't need to skim so much. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- orubyqncnyrubefr · 2018-03-11 12:52 I hope you're right! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- orubyqncnyrubefr · 2018-03-11 12:54 This reads like a post from n-gate. Good one. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- orubyqncnyrubefr · 2018-03-11 12:55 I hope these are consensual. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-03-13 00:00 If we want an operating system written by white (and a few Asian) men, with no social justice bullshit, we can just use OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-03-13 00:03 You need to get the right image to boot from USB on a UEFI system with OpenBSD. In my experience DragonFly supports modern hardware much better, although the OpenBSD userland is certainly nicer. FreeBSD is almost useless as a desktop system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Cobbleking32486 · 2018-03-14 16:42 Yep, it's real. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Shadowh4wk · 2018-03-16 06:03 Late reply at this point, but I just wanted to say that your arguments on this thread are civil and on-point, and this one in particular was beautifully stated. If more people were as eloquent as you were in this thread, I think the perceived need for a restrictive CoC wouldn't exist. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tidux · 2018-04-02 17:08 Bye fag.