The story behind FreeBSD's new code of conduct reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 09:14 Still sucks. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2018-02-26 09:24 The whole talk itself is very good. There was a lot of public problems in FreeBSD, and having a Code of Conduct is necessary because we've seen that "act like adults" doesn't mean anyone will actually act like a adult. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dom_89 · 2018-02-26 10:18 Hopefully as the years go by open source projects will learn how to keep nutcases like this from inflicting tremendous harm like that which has been done to FreeBSD's reputation. You have talented people completely focused on tech while nuts like this secretly work in the background to hijack the project with their toxic ideologies. It's the same problem you have with law enforcement where you attract EXACTLY the wrong type of people to the position. At least with law enforcement there is some level of screening. But with open source there is absolutely nothing to keep the nutcases from hijacking a project. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dom_89 · 2018-02-26 10:33 The only 'public problem' in the past few years in the FreeBSD project was Colin Percival's vile harassing Randi Harper attacking an innocent developer for wrong think. So don't you lecture this community about having to be told to act like adults. Or pretend that FreeBSD doesn't have a wonderful and well written CoC. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- HardesSteel · 2018-02-26 10:35 He has turned FreeBSD into the laughingstock of the open source world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 10:37 Poettering: "Hold my beer." ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2018-02-26 10:38 I will lecture "this community", because I am part of it. I also support the FreeBSD CoC. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ValeriJendau · 2018-02-26 10:39 I knew I wasn't the only one who has kept thinking: Linux: systemd fiasco FreeBSD: toxic SJW CoC fiasco ---------------------------------------------------------------------- dom_89 · 2018-02-26 10:50 Benno Rice right now still follow the toxic harasser Randi Harper. Let's make it absolutely clear why FreeBSD has been turned into the laughing stock of the open source community: * The only real case of serious harassment was from Randi Harper attacking an innocent FreeBSD developer for wrong think * Randi Harper was thankfully finally kicked from any association with FreeBSD * Benno Rice has been secretly working behind the scenes to force this toxic SJW CoC on the community * Benno Rice FOLLOWS Randi Harper You can't make this crap up. There is a reason people all over the development world are laughing in disgust at what an absolute joke FreeBSD has become. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2018-02-26 10:53 >You can't make this crap up. Except, you did. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RLMansworth · 2018-02-26 10:56 I honestly thought you were joking. I just checked Benno Rice's twitter and he really is following Randi Harper. I don't know what to say. Absolutely sickening. If there is anyone in the FreeBSD community who doesn't know who this disgusting person is and her history of harassment, please google her name. The fact that anyone in the FreeBSD community would be following her is bad. The person responsible for this awful CoC fiasco following a well known harasser is deeply problematic. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 11:04 > Benno Rice right now still follow the toxic harasser Randi Harper. I suspect lower expectations. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 11:06 > The fact that anyone in the FreeBSD community would be following her is bad. Depends on their motivation. Does she still try to buy her merits with sex? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 11:12 I wonder if lecturing "this community" who never requested that already violates the "no harassment" part of the CoC. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NiceUnderstanding · 2018-02-26 11:50 I found the IRC logs he mentioned that were leaked: https://archive.is/9KGyX This whole thing has been very eye-opening for me. I had no idea FreeBSD developers were involved with such social disorder. They don't fit the image I had of them at all. I also found an interview with Randi, where she specifically says she's furious about the geek feminism wiki, and that there's no problem with needing more women in open source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Xrrlhvs9vE > People are so defensive now, I mean you can't crack a joke, you can't make any statements without worrying, 'Is somebody going to be offended?' -- Randi Harper (2010) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 12:10 2015.06.22 20:44:25 <@xmj> Grow up. 2015.06.22 20:44:30 < randi> you grow up, you piece of shit. Classy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-02-26 13:08 The only people who think that are people on forums. Tech people, the vast majority of those who use FreeBSD, are just doing their jobs and worry about the technology, not these people with personal issues. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-02-26 13:09 FreeBSD has not changed at all. The only thing that's changed is this piece of paper and those who care about it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NiceUnderstanding · 2018-02-26 13:20 I'm worried about it, because their inability to manage people in an organized manner has already resulted in talented developers losing commit access. These social disabilities affect the code I depend on for my business. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-02-26 13:30 I understand when one reads about people leaving due to these words, I'm only aware of two, but I think and hope they will come to their senses and miss the work they did and take back what they worked on. Some of their work has been absorbed by others already. I hope they come to their senses and realize how little anyone cares about this and nothing, technically, will change with FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-26 13:43 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-26 13:45 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 13:47 I surely hope they will contribute to a project where technological expertise is actually worth a dime. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- apancetta · 2018-02-26 13:50 to see where /u/dom_89 is coming from, try [reading his older comment history](http://archive.is/YMsz2). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poops34 · 2018-02-26 14:50 And now the KiA people are over here trolling away. NiceUnderstanding, 4 day old account. apancetta, 4 day old account. ValeriJendau, 8 day old account. RLMansworth, 8 day old account. HardesSteel, 11 day old account. newmechanicalkeyboar, 14 day old account. and dom_89 who's never posted on a BSD related subreddit till the CoC and is a frequent KiA poster. Get a life woman haters. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-02-26 15:25 Thank you for your important contribution to the discussion at hand. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 15:40 Randi is far from innocent. She's literally a cancer on the project and uses the name making everything and everyone look bad with all her insanity. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 15:44 That ship sailed as time moved forward. (age++) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- masta · 2018-02-26 17:08 Thick skin > safe space ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NerdVsGeek · 2018-02-26 17:25 Just because they're new accounts doesn't make them trolls. Perhaps they feel strongly and wish to speak out, but due to this CoC they're afraid to risk their main accounts which they may have used extensively and it'd be easy for someone to dox them? Unfortunately, it's difficult to tell the genuine from the bad with this. For the record, I suspect some of those accounts are what you describe but I disagree with your demonizing all of them as 'woman haters'. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poops34 · 2018-02-26 17:59 [When](https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7y43fk/censorship_on_ rfreebsd/) a [post](https://www.freebsd.org/internal/code-of- conduct.html) in /r/FreeBSD gets hundreds of comments in a single day in a relatively inactive sub, it's full of trolls. The vast majority of the FreeBSD community still communicates via the lists or the forums. I'm not sure what you mean by "dox them". The CoC doesn't apply here, this is reddit. And I shouldn't say woman haters, perhaps scared angry white males. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 18:37 ...citation needed ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NerdVsGeek · 2018-02-26 18:38 Scared, for certain. It's enough for me to reconsidering joining the project to the point of traveling to conferences and such on my own dime. I'll give this CoC a year or so before I commit any of my money (e.g. 5-6k/year) for travel expenses. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 18:47 https://encyclopediadramatica.rs/Randi_Harper ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 18:47 Troll for 3 days... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 18:49 Nice troll account ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 18:51 The fact you link that site says it all... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 18:55 Truth sucks doesn't it? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-26 18:58 zb might still maintain a fork of sektie-undermydesk-freebsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 18:59 This is the truth about obama based on the shit "source" you linked >Barack Jesus✡ (/b'rɑːk jee:zuhs/), the immortal God-Emperor of Blackkind, was the first reptilian president and was the last leading idol of the liberal world and consumerist media from 2008~2016.  Try again you shill... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 19:01 Is that you Randi? I just noticed you're the only troll here pushing your agenda. Hahah. Nice job downvoting everyone. Idiot. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 19:02 Hahaha. God the memories...the flashbacks... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avatar4d · 2018-02-26 19:05 Peter, from what I see, most folks expressing legitimate discourse regarding the new CoC, myself included, are not against FreeBSD having a CoC per se. Rather, we have problems around the specific language used. It could be boiled down into a simpler format that provides equal treatment to all without virtue signal to specific people. Note: I just upped my monthly donations to OBSD by routing former FBSD allocated funds due to this so hoping it isn't adopted there too. I really like OpenBSD better overall anyway (you do amazing work!) so would be more torn up about stopping contributions there, but I have other initiatives that I support and will divert again if needed. I am sure my contribution isn't going to make or break the project so I don't say that as a threat, but just indicating that I (and I am sure others) do not intend to support something financially that I do not agree with philosophically. I doubt that should be a surprise to anyone though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 19:22 Those are just facts... If your source to convince people who don't trust you (because why would they?) is encyclopedia dramatica then you can fuck right off. For obvious reasons... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 19:24 Would you like some meth? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ciny · 2018-02-26 19:34 Aaaw a loser is browsing my comment history. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 19:43 Nope. Just making fun of Randi, but you just fessed up to it like an idiot. Apparently you and Randi both have similar tastes. Hahahaha. What a goldmine! Are you sure you're not one of her many personalities? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-26 19:47 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-26 19:58 http://catb.org/jargon/html/H/ha-ha-only-serious.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-26 20:53 When Core (or anyone) makes a controversial decision, take a step back, breathe, and remember their [motivations are pure.](https://pics.onsizzle.com/do-it-for-the-lulz-what-do-you-do- it-21382416.png) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NiceUnderstanding · 2018-02-26 20:55 I've used FreeBSD for over 20 years. I'm not involved in any social drama online. I don't use Twitter, and don't know about these other subreddits people mention. I don't know what that has to do with the video I shared. It stands alone, regardless of who posts it. But I can tell you that the latest issue in `/usr/ports/UPDATING` regards nextcloud. You can verify using `head`, but if it shows something different you'll need to `portsnap fetch update` first. Actually, I last did that yesterday I think, so maybe it's changed since then. If you don't like things I write, maybe you want to `ipfw deny all from me to you via reddit`. Don't forget to `check-state`, but maybe you use pf, not ipfw. Good enough? I made this account specifically to post about this code of conduct issue. I'm not attacking anyone, and I see the story behind what's going on. But I see it as a problem, and if people like Benno just want to pretend everyone like me are trolls, then I hope we can elect other people who aren't involved in any social drama or politics that don't belong in FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- teresko · 2018-02-26 21:13 Ehh .. couldn't FreeBSD handle it the same way as ~~PCBSD~~ TrueOS did? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-26 21:26 ipfw? ewww...why?!?!? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- haroldp · 2018-02-26 21:30 I probably have this wrong because I generally tune out at the first sound of drama, but... Isn't the missing part of this (generally fair) history that cperciva@ was Randi's mentor on the project and being generally supportive of her in this struggle and wrote and delivered the original Code of Conduct for FreeBSD? And on one hand, a lot of nerds didn't like getting a CoC at all, and on the other hand the CoC was extremely pro- nerd, using words like "meritocracy" and that was kind of the last straw for Randi, so she wandered off? It seemed like cperciva@ got flack from both sides but quietly... this was us getting an absolutely reasonable CoC for FreeBSD that preserved the ideals of FreeBSD, preemptively put a lid on any future gratuitously shitty behavior, and yet wasn't full of the political horseshit that has really damaged other projects that got an overly- restrictive CoC. Please let me know if I have that wrong. Seems like an important part of missing history if we are talking about adding the popular buzzwords into the CoC now. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-26 22:19 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- apancetta · 2018-02-26 22:28 don't bundle me with that crap. I am a woman and a very active contributor. I delete my account every few months so people can't easily read my entire comment history as soon as they figure out who I am, especially now that posting on BSD subreddits means people realize who I am in about 2 posts. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-26 22:34 Maybe he has a lot of traffic to filter. Syntax is not everything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-26 22:44 Unlike FreeBSD, OpenBSD is not a democracy. It's run by Theo, and he probably is the last person to ever want a code of conduct that could be used to push him out, again, from a project he founded. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poops34 · 2018-02-26 22:58 If you've been a 20 year user then you realize you need to be a committer to vote for core. I'm not a committer but I do know the new CoC was talked about extensively on -developers, and the current core team implemented it, not just Benno. I find it a bit ridiculous, but mostly irrelevant. The majority of the committers however seem to be fine with it and seem to feel it was needed. The drama involved is still revolving around Randi Harper who isn't even involved with the project anymore. I don't really have an opinion on her as I've only talked to her a few times on IRC and I don't twitter either. I do know people from r/KotakuInAction/gamergate absolutely hates her and actively posted to the mailing lists and the official forums just to troll, and events involving her certainly were part of the reason why the previous CoC was put in place. Sorry if I was rash, but I'm simply over these threads, and a more proper forum would have been on the official channels - the forums or the lists. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- poops34 · 2018-02-26 23:00 I'm not sure why people finding out who you are is a bad thing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cacatl · 2018-02-26 23:18 Sometimes benevolent dictators are better than pseudo-corporate bodies at leading a project. OpenBSD, DragonflyBSD, and even Linux have clearer goals than FreeBSD does. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 00:02 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 00:04 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 00:07 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 00:07 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avatar4d · 2018-02-27 00:14 I must have missed my ballot for voting in the democratic FreeBSD system to approve the CoC ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-27 00:23 On the other hand, FreeBSD's confusion-by-committee approach is the truest spiritual successor to commercial Unices. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-27 00:25 Why did god give women legs? So they can get to the kitchen and then to the bedroom. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-27 00:25 What is it about white males that scare you fam? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-27 00:29 The BSD CoC is what happens when you let feminazi SJWs take over a project my dude. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zachsandberg · 2018-02-27 00:46 >Get a life woman haters. In the world of discourse we call this an ad hominem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zachsandberg · 2018-02-27 00:48 >You basically just stalked us. Why do you support a CoC you wouldn't want to live by elsewhere? You don't think that authoritarians are just going to let you have the *wrong opinions* and not do anything about it, right? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zachsandberg · 2018-02-27 01:18 >scared angry white males. I love it when people try and diminish an argument using a person's skin color as a pejorative. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zachsandberg · 2018-02-27 01:30 This is a stupid and needlessly offensive thing to post here. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-27 01:48 Hey fam, it is called a joke. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-27 01:59 Meh, shes a well known troll that caught Milo's attention. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 02:09 FreeBSD committers elect the core team AFAIK. It's not a Swiss-like direct democracy where they have a referendum on important things, it's more like representative democracy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 02:31 It shows how hypocritical some of the people who support this CoC are. In fact, it's noteworthy that it only mentions "systemic oppression" (which makes it OK to disparage "angry white males" since they are supposedly the "oppressor") and protects every attribute you can think of (race, religion, sex, religious beliefs, etc.) but not political beliefs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 02:32 Cool it, dude. Not everyone believes in god. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-02-27 03:12 Not true. In a representative democracy, still have certain requirements, such as that the elected are to follow the wishes of their constituents. They are there to represent their constituents, NOT their own agenda, no matter how much "in their best interest" they perceive their actions to be for those constituents. Basically, as a representative, you simply DO NOT DO stuff because "it's good for them". You do stuff because, and ONLY because, your constituents want it, or rather, because you believe that is what your constituents want. That's one of the pillars of representative democracy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-02-27 03:18 1. The post hit r/all 2. The sub is only inactive because there's very little of interest to comment on. It's not inactive in that there's no readers. When something that clearly was of interest to comment on, it was obvious to everyone it was going to get a lot of comments... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 03:28 Right. Is that how it works in practice though? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- apancetta · 2018-02-27 03:33 I used to split my online and offline lives, and severely self-censor myself "offline", where things "actually matter". online I'd be openly speaking about everything. the blurring of the lines is uncomfortable. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-02-27 03:36 Yes. Because politicians care about getting reelected. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 03:42 In many cases there are term limits. If you are an American President, have already received the Peace Nobel prize and cannot be re-elected because it's your second term, why should you care about anything? In fact, frequent elections create a bias toward short-term policies, but I guess that's a bit of an off-topic debate. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 03:47 /u/poops34 we used anonymity or funny pseudonyms so we can have frank, open discussions like we could have in a bar. The difference is, if we say something a bit stupid or controversial in a bar discussion with friends or coworkers, it will be forgotten. If you write something stupid or controversial online, it will be dug up sometimes 10 or 20 years later, despite you being an entirely different person then. In fact, even the liberals who use their real-name because their political opinions are entirely aligned with the current status quo should be careful. Today they fire people from their job for having the wrong opinions, but if all their own opinions are archived online forever, the same thing might happen to them in the future. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-02-27 03:56 You have one misconception there though. You're not a constituent of the POTUS. You don't actually elect the POTUS. You elect electors, whom you're a constituent of, and they and the house of representatives elect the POTUS and neither have any term limits. And have different election dates exactly to prevent the very thing you talk of because they have the power to also remove the POTUS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-02-27 04:47 > If you've been a 20 year user then you realize you need to be a committer to vote for core. That's bullshit. In what world must a long time user be necessarily familiar with bureaucratic project minutiae? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- qubes-ist · 2018-02-27 06:10 New account. Had to retire the old one over bad opsec potentially compromising anonymity. But... I'm on your side. And you might even see me around for a while. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avatar4d · 2018-02-27 06:33 Oh so a small group within a larger community granted authority to elect a smaller group to govern all of the community is a representative democracy? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-27 06:40 Well, that small group is the group of committers; a remnant of the meritocratic origin of FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-27 09:35 but ipfw is not nearly as elegant as pf... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avatar4d · 2018-02-27 17:24 That may be, but it doesn't appear to fit the definition of either a democracy or a representative democracy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LysanderSporker · 2018-02-27 18:58 Of course it's political. So is doing nothing. Doing nothing, after all, is complicity with the status quo. Everything's political. So the question is, do we push a positive political agenda or a shitty one? FreeBSD, to their credit, chose the former. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 19:04 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LysanderSporker · 2018-02-27 20:19 No, they all push political agendas too. Again, "doing nothing" towards ensuring equitable treatment of marginalized voices is a political agenda, because it's complicity with the status quo. That you can't be bothered to make the intellectual effort necessary to grasp this, doesn't make it false. It just makes you intellectually lazy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-27 20:35 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-27 21:21 In a democracy, the legislators work hard to get elected. Whereas core members are often coerced into accepting election against their better judgement. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2018-02-27 21:28 Sometimes, worse is better. ^^^except ^^^for ^^^sendmail ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avatar4d · 2018-02-28 01:21 Facts, literal facts are down voted. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wannabehax0r · 2018-02-28 03:28 Given all the moaning and complaining on this issue its obvious there isn't enough thick skin to go around ---------------------------------------------------------------------- masta · 2018-02-28 03:38 I would not draw the same conclusion, but just the same thanks! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- masta · 2018-02-28 03:48 Hi there. Probably late by now, but I do ask that you be polite. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- throwawace_ · 2018-02-28 04:02 *slaps knee* hilarious ---------------------------------------------------------------------- throwawace_ · 2018-02-28 04:09 If I look at someone’s tweets on a twitter thread, I’m not stalking them. That’s part of how discovery works on twitter. If I see people making claims on reddit, and I look at their posts, I am not stalking them. That’s how reading works on reddit. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- EtherMan · 2018-02-28 04:39 Hi there. Probably late by now, but asking people to be polite, when your own mods are not, is kind of disingenuous. Especially considering the very comment you're replying to, IS being polite... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freebsd_user · 2018-02-28 04:43 > Of course it's political. > > So is doing nothing. Doing nothing, after all, is complicity with the status quo. > > Everything's political. > > So the question is, do we push a positive political agenda or a shitty one? This is a BS line of reasoning used to try to pull people into political battles and force them to pick a side. It incorrectly casts the world as an "either you're with us or against us" dichotomy to falsely remove any middle ground or space for people to just do their own thing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-28 04:52 Haha. But outside of the downvotes...why? Like...is there an advantage to ipfw over pf? I thought we had evolved to pf? Is the gas on? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-02-28 06:29 IPFW has more features and better performance. PF is nice to configure. PF is fine in most cases, unless you are running an ISP or a 10G network. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DHermit · 2018-02-28 11:20 I just read the Code of Conduct and I can't find anything bad with it. I don't know how it was before, but what exactly is the problem with it? I don't see anything beyond specific cases of "be excellent to each other". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-02-28 12:25 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NiceUnderstanding · 2018-02-28 14:10 Colin banned me. Go here: https://www.reddit.com/r/FreeBSD_OS/ ---- It takes sides in a heated cultural battle. Did you pay attention to Google firing James Damore? The new FreeBSD code of conduct basically says, "We side with Google in the firing of James Damore, and we will do the same to you". There's an ideology that has been spreading, and is associated with liberals, feminists, LGBT kinds of groups. They have this idea that society is structured to oppress people who are not middle-class heterosexual white males. They believe that there needs to be 50% females in tech projects, with an equal mix of races, or else there's evil systemic oppression, and it's a white-boys' club where they enjoy unfair privileges of power while others suffer. Benno is a member of that ideological subculture, and he's transforming FreeBSD from a neutral organization into one that aligns itself with the specific ideology he identifies with. It feels good and righteous for him, but not us. We don't identify with that group, and so from our perspective, it feels like if some Mormons wrote a code of conduct using Mormon terminology, that promotes their specific beliefs, which have nothing to do with software. We already have a long history of culture in personal computing, and it does not fit with this new ideology. Our culture is more libertarian or anarchistic, and does not like those battles between liberals and conservatives. We just want to focus on code, and technology. The old ideology behind the code of conduct was more like what Linus believes, which is that the burden is on you to not be offended, not on me not to offend you. > Those in the FreeBSD community should have a right to be free from hate speech, harassment and abuse, **but not a right not to be offended.** That was deleted, and Benno said, "There were a few problems with it, one of them being, there's a push in some codes of conduct to try and say, as well as don't offend people they also try and say don't get offended, and one of the main objectives of this one was to resolutely point out that **it's not your job not to get offended**, it's your job to do your best not to offend people". He also said that it's designed to make a "safe space", and offense is subjective so if anyone is offended even if you didn't intend to offend, it's still a valid problem that they can report you for. The old code of conduct said that "FreeBSD is a meritocracy", but Benno said that's wrong, because he believes that the system is rigged against minorities, so we can't judge based on merit since they're at a disadvantage. He said that FreeBSD has a lot of white males, and not many females or people of color, and the safe space is for them to feel better about participating, because the goal is diversity, not merit and value from your code. Those aren't his ideas, they're part of that ideology shared by many, including those who fired James Damore. It's a very heated debate, and FreeBSD changed sides, where they're alienating many of their contributors. It's not easy to see all this, because it's written between the lines. It's in the choice of terms used, and how the code of conduct is taken from the "Geek Feminism wiki", and the speeches given by Benno. It's like when a town gets a new sheriff, and he believes he's doing good saying, "There's going to be changes around here", where he goes around "cleaning things up". He believes he's putting things into order. But really he might be confused about how things truly work, and is just causing problems for the local residents. FreeBSD doesn't have a problem, but Benno believes there is one, so he's causing problems trying to fix it. He said it himself, "Leadership is hard". Except it isn't. It's only hard for low-level programmers who are playing politics, pretending they're at the top of a pseudo-corporate organization, and letting it go to their head. Programmers cause problems when they try to write code to fix social problems with what feels logical to them. That's not how people work. They probably don't fully even understand why there's such public backlash. There was a joke about them banning hugs, and Benno was on [YouTube](https://youtu.be/GfZyrQmAM7o?t=21m19s) "clearing things up", but they don't seem to understand why people are upset. It's not hugs. It's really interesting to watch, because it looks like autistic people trying to figure out things they have an obvious disability in being able to begin to process, and there's nobody there who excels at managing people. They're low-level programmers, and might be geniuses with operating systems, but that doesn't translate to social systems. They have some brainwashed members, who are pushing their political ideologies onto the group. If you look around, you'll see a lot of developers and people involved with open source who are offensive, and have no social tact. Benno is saying they're terrible people and need to be punished if they can't be tamed. But that's one of the big reasons why some people are involved in open source to begin with. Benno is being hypocritical, because he's saying he wants inclusiveness and to protect minorities, as he attacks them. It goes along with conditions like autism, and personality disorders, where some people have a real mental impairment where they cannot be anything but offensive, because they don't work right with social stuff. Should they be punished and excluded from an open project? I don't think so. Their code of conduct specifically mentions neurodiversity, but they're singling out a certain type of neurodiversity and saying that's excluded. It isn't fair. It isn't right. It's a divisive and bigoted kind of stance, and they're siding with what they like, without recognizing that there's other kinds of aspies and sociopathic people out there who can code, but aren't polite. Linus would tell them to fuck off, but Benno wants to believe that they're different and better than Linux, where FreeBSD is the place for "safe spaces", that welcomes the liberal feminist gender-queer community. It's offensive to people like me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fragbot · 2018-02-28 15:55 Watching that and reading the IRC logs below, it's clear to me that Randi Harper scooting off elsewhere improved the FreeBSD environment. With that clarity, it's amazing they'd change the CoC in an attempt to keep people who act like her associated with the project. This is a textbook example of hard cases making bad law. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- archlinuxmydude · 2018-02-28 16:00 Me neither fam. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-02-28 18:48 Really? I've never really paid attention to it. Figured it's old and crappy. Clearly I need to do some reading. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2018-03-01 05:26 ipfw has far better performance for some workloads. The pf fork in FreeBSD isn't especially active and lags behind the syntax and feature set of OpenBSD's pf. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-03-01 05:30 Better workloads like what? Any examples? I'm wrapping my head around it ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2018-03-01 05:43 [Olivier Cochard-Labbé publishes extensive performance testing results on github](https://github.com/ocochard/netbenches). E.g., here's forwarding performance on 2x12 core system: https://githu b.com/ocochard/netbenches/blob/master/Xeon_E5-2650-2x12Cores- Mellanox_ConnectX-4/forwarding-pf- ipfw/results/fbsd12.r328085.BSDRP/README.md . Note that ipfw absolutely dominates. [Here's forwarding performance on more embedded hardware](https://gith ub.com/ocochard/netbenches/blob/master/Atom_C2558_4Cores- Intel_i350/forwarding-pf-ipfw/results/fbsd11.1-yandex/README.md). ipfw still leads, although the margin is smaller. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2018-03-01 06:02 Niiice. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-03-02 01:00 This comment should seriously be stickied. I haven't even seen anyone else mention the part about the CoC being hypocritical against programmers who lack social skills, which is a really good point. And besides, why should anyone in FreeBSD care about whether something is offensive or not? The mascot is a FREAKING DEVIL! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-03-02 01:16 Luckily we still have 2 more BSD's left! (Yeah I know, there's also DragonflyBSD as well as smaller BSD's) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-03-02 01:19 Also the people who contribute money and code to it, cause I've seen quite a few people switch over to OpenBSD already. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 3G6A5W338E · 2018-03-02 09:57 Dragonfly perhaps. Matt had good reason for forking. Their SMP design, the one FreeBSD rejected to adopt Linux-like fine-grained locks, is the better one. And their network stack already benchmarks better than both Linux and FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-03-02 12:13 I've seen far more switch from Linux to FreeBSD. At any point in time, you can always find someone who's done something about anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-03-02 12:25 To be honest, so have I, but that was mostly due to systemd. Keep in mind that the CoC issue barely occurred 2 weeks ago AFAIK. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- justbouncinman · 2018-03-02 12:42 Give it another two weeks and it will barely be mentioned anywhere anymore. It's just internet excitement no one cares about. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-03-02 13:07 I wouldn't be surprised if this happens, but then again, distributions come and go from the spotlight over time. Politics have also screwed up smaller software projects in the past (OpenELEC->LibreELEC, ffmpeg->libav, and maybe mplayer1->mplayer2/mpv come to mind). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Valmar33 · 2018-03-02 14:47 Excellently said! I'm glad that people like Linus are level-headed. Benno... how did he convince the other FreeBSD maintainers that his ridiculous and divisive CoC was necessary?! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-03-02 19:41 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RandomKraut · 2018-03-03 02:35 It's in the nature of these quarrels on "social" networks, that there are terrible and toxic people on both ends. Gamer gate .. wow computer games serious business. FreeBSD should have told anyone involved to go play immature meta game wars on twitter and get lost. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- losthalo7 · 2018-03-03 17:54 Sufficiently advanced political correctness is indistinguishable from sarcasm. (Erik Naggum) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- losthalo7 · 2018-03-03 18:14 You make a good point regarding autism and personality disorders, since tech has been a haven for many who struggle with those issues and have aptitude for the field. Another take on the subject of taking or not taking offense: "A written text has no power to abuse you. It is a dead string of bits that needs an interpreter before it has any meaning. That interpreter is you, and you have to accept responsibility for your interpretation. If you fail to do this, you will believe that other people said what you interpreted it to mean, and it becomes impossible for anyone to show you that you interpreted it wrongly." (Erik Naggum) It's one thing if someone is directly attacking you, lying about you, directing hatred at you, etc. It's another if someone merely says something you disagree with or think is offensive. We've become almost unable to separate the two lately and it's not working out well for human society, it's dividing us and preventing us from working on real problems. The answer to bad speech (barring outright hatred or inciting immediate violence) is more speech so that things get sorted out. We have to have faith in one another that we're basically decent people most of us and we all want the world to get better. We need to get over being offended so much and preventing offense and begin talking to one another and more importantly *listening* to one another. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Cathy_Newman · 2018-03-03 23:28 Yup. She’s been raking in fortune from Patreon and her supposed “non- profit”. The funny thing about her little organization is that she decided against filing for 501c3 status, which made her soliciting for donations illegal in some states. Her antics are very well documented. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- CaptnMeowMix · 2018-03-04 04:20 > ensuring equitable treatment of marginalized voices First of all, that is definitively **not** what most of these movements and CoCs are doing. They are eliminating *actual* equality of treatment and replacing it with "equality" of outcome. And if you disagree with me, guess what? I'm a minority with a "marginalized voice" as well, and you'd effectively be oppressing me by doing so. (that is how it works right?) Second of all, this "doing nothing is political" mindset is pure [radicalized rhetoric](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRTrgFkyPW4) that actively discourages cooperation, and it doesn't actually help anyone that it claims to help. Source: me, someone who would fall under the category of people all these movements naively think they're "helping". ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kernigh · 2018-03-04 04:43 > FreeBSD... welcomes the liberal feminist gender-queer community I'm fine with open source projects that have liberal feminist gender- queer authors. > It goes along with conditions like autism, and personality disorders, where some people have a real mental impairment where they cannot be anything but offensive, because they don't work right with social stuff.... Their code of conduct specifically mentions neurodiversity, but they're singling out a certain type of neurodiversity and saying that's excluded. Autism is not the same as bad conduct. A project can exclude people who have bad conduct and still include people with autism or weak social skills. Suppose that I get a commit bit in a project like FreeBSD. Suppose that I act very stupid and do all of the following: - My commits break features, device drivers, hardware platforms that I don't use. I break things faster than others can fix them, but I say that I'm smart and others are stupid. - I get in the way of other authors. If someone is working on a big change, I reindent that code so they can't merge their diff. - I ignore the project's code style. Project uses 8-space tab, I use 4. Project lines up case labels with the switch, I indent my case labels. - I make commit wars. I commit something, someone undoes it, I commit it again, someone undoes it, and so on. - I argue a lot about octal versus hexadecimal literals, or the name of a new command, or what color to paint the bike shed. - I use a lot of obscene words. I believe that I can win arguments by using the most offensive language. I want to be right because the other person is a "f---" or a "s---", not because of the code. - I harass other authors so they will leave the project and get out of my way. I create several sockpuppets on Reddit, Twitter, IRC, and the mailing lists. These sockpuppets post insults against other authors, without any real information about the quality of their work. I want the whole internet to know that my victims are losers. - In an argument, I compare another committer with people who believe in the Holocaust. The other committers are now offended that I denied the Holocaust, but I tell them that they don't have a right to be offended. I blame them for being offended! If I'm not literally denying the Holocaust, I'm doing something almost as stupid. Suppose that I then claim to have autism. I believe that I can be rude to everyone because of autism. I believe that I can be offensive without limit, that I have no obligation to fix my behavior, because autism means having no social skills, which is the same thing as using my social skills to harass everyone. This isn't about the real symptoms of autism; it's about me using the word "autism" to justify my bad conduct. Now, if I did the above, then the project should expel me (whether or not the project has a code of conduct) and ignore me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Cathy_Newman · 2018-03-09 08:36 Maybe the governance needs to be reviewed. It makes sense for committees to elect people responsible for setting the technical direction and driving adoption. The CoC is entirely divorced from tech, so why wouldn’t users - sometimes also financial supporters - have a say in this kind of decision. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- -__-_--__--_ · 2023-12-06 01:51 And now,6 years later?