Does anyone run OpenBSD as a desktop (ie not a server)? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bharath_g · 2018-01-12 06:13 I do on my primary laptop and it has been a very good experience. Almost everything worked without tweaking anything including suspend. I think openbsd is a much better choice for personal computers than freebsd. Freebsd setup experience just does not feel that polished. As long as your hardware is supported by openbsd, you should have a very good experience with using it on your desktop/laptop ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2018-01-12 06:45 @bcallah Brian Callahan do . He replied in telegram BSD group :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kweisar · 2018-01-12 06:48 I used to run it on my desktop for about a year. My only issues were lack of software, driver support for my GPU, and slowdown when a huge chunk of memory gets freed. Everything about it feels polished and it almost feels fun to use compared to other Unix OSs. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DHermit · 2018-01-12 07:05 The one thing that stops me from using OpenBSD is the missing ZFS support ... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- geheimnisse · 2018-01-12 07:11 I did for several years. Just recently migrated to a homogeneous FreeBSD environment (well, my tower and my laptop. RPi runs raspbian). I've had a couple of Thinkpads - T420 and X240. OpenBSD runs phenomenally on them. Today I only use OpenBSD on my VPS (thanks RamNode) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2018-01-12 08:51 I run OpenBSD on my desktop at work, and on my laptop(s). I'm quite happy with them, and are constantly adding new features to make things work better. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-01-12 10:01 I ran OpenBSD on my secondary laptop before I got a new one which is still about to get WiFi firmware on BSD. My experience is that OpenBSD is probably the smoothest possible desktop system I've ever come across: It does *exactly* what I *expect* it to. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Nanosleep · 2018-01-12 12:43 I run it on my ultraportable laptop (little celeron netbook with intel graphics). Very happy with it, but I'm not sure I'd be able to take the plunge with it full-time on my workstation. I think once I feel like vmm has come along far enough, I'll give it a fair shot. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Chapo_Rouge · 2018-01-12 13:48 I run a desktop VM, works well ! Binary patches sure are appreciated :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- balle23 · 2018-01-12 13:57 I have a OpenBSD desktop in a vm at work and run it on a laptop at home. On both I am using openbox as window manager. I have noted all things learned in a wiki located at http://balu- wiki.readthedocs.io/en/latest/security/openbsd.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------- gumnos · 2018-01-12 15:56 Given the lower-end specs of my netbooks, OpenBSD's low system requirements really let me make better use of them. My only issue has been the rubbish onboard BCM wifi chips. Managed to replace one with an Atheros chipset card and it's much less troublesome now. The other is wired or offline. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mansaber · 2018-01-12 19:06 I have to run Void Linux on the desktop for nvidia support, but I've always used OpenBSD on my ThinkPads. It's a great secure mobile laptop os as long as you've got hardware thats not brand new ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jggimi · 2018-01-12 19:11 I've been running it on a desktop/laptop for about 15 years. Very happy with its simplicity, elegance, and ease of use. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pyvpx · 2018-01-12 21:42 I've run it natively as my laptop OS for nearly a decade now. with a dual booting OS X spurt for a couple years. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2018-01-12 23:03 Most/all of the OpenBSD devs do. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- X7spyWqcRY · 2018-01-13 02:11 The ZFS codebase is utterly enormous. I think it's more likely that OpenBSD will take HAMMER from DragonflyBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2018-01-13 13:22 BTW anyone interested : small reminder, we are playing quake 2 today at 20:00 UTC - feel free to join #openbsd-gaming on Freenode if you want to participate by @mulandee ---------------------------------------------------------------------- slainthejabberwock · 2018-01-13 14:24 Recommended reading: https://www.tedunangst.com/flak/post/ZFS-on- OpenBSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- VampyrBit · 2018-01-13 14:54 I used to run OpenBSD on my 2in1 laptop and loved it, worked amazing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- yourhelpfulfriend · 2018-01-13 17:54 I run OpenBSD exclusively on both my laptops. I do run Debian on my desktop, but solely for the larger package selection and Nvidia support. But since I tend to invest my time in software that I can also use on my laptops, Debian's larger set of packages doesn't mean so much to me anymore. If or when I get an AMD video paddle I would strongly consider switching my desktop to OpenBSD as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Anonymous_Mentat · 2018-01-13 21:25 I wish the DragonFlyBSD guys would have worked with OpenBSD instead of starting Yet-Another-BSD back in the days... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- X7spyWqcRY · 2018-01-13 21:33 I think it's fine to split. All the BSDs have different goals and focuses. Dragonfly is all about parallelism and performance, not security or simplicity. HAMMER is still in development so it's not ready for OpenBSD anyway. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sijuogeorge · 2018-01-14 04:05 I use OpenBSD and DragonflyBSD as desktop.use fvwm2 as window manager ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UninsuredGibran · 2018-01-14 10:02 No way this was going to happen. Matt's plan was to take a hammer (hu hu), break all the walls and rebuild all the kernel, pretty much by himself, to do single-system image. No way he could have done that in OpenBSD, due to different cultures and priorities. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tidux · 2018-01-17 07:06 Upsides: simplicty, clarity, stability, ease of installation/upgrades, works with most FOSS applications. The more the web moves away from proprietary plugins, the easier it is to do "normie" things on relatively obscure OSes. Sndio "just works" in a way that ALSA and OSS struggled with for years and PulseAudio is only now approaching. Downsides: if you ever need to run third party binaries, you'll need to keep Linux or Windows around. Performance and driver support lag Linux in particular for desktop workloads. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tidux · 2018-01-19 20:03 HAMMER is actually done. HAMMER2 is the one with the fancy ZFS-like features that's still in development. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- strngsvlmstng96 · 2018-01-22 03:58 Any examples of its predictable behavior? I guess I can see how not involving stuff like systemd would make certain tasks simper, in theory, but I'm not sure what exactly ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2018-01-22 07:50 systemd is a good example: there is no can-do-all application on OpenBSD, and applications which come close (Apache) are gradually replaced by such which don't (OpenBSD httpd). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- chocolate-labia · 2018-01-23 04:28 that sounds awesome. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NicheArchitecture · 2018-01-27 19:03 Yes, posting this from an OpenBSD XFCE desktop running latest Firefox thanks to Landry! When I first moved to an all open source desktop, I chose Ubuntu as that is what my school ran exclusively. It ran alright, but I abuse my computers. One of my biggest issues was that Ubuntu wouldn't free memory properly. If I were to get the machine swapping, the only way to recover my performance and free memory would be to reboot. I shouldn't have to reboot my machine after only grepping 20GB of log files. I found myself using OpenBSD more and more, as I found it to 'just work' for me, for a long time. I need a desktop that I can shithammer for months at a time without it locking up, or having some "critical" security patch desperately needing a reboot to install. A lot of people bitch and moan about lack of "insert modern file system of the day here" and kvetch that they NEED their favorite filesytem to make the transition. I can tell you, that nothing comes close to FFS with softdep in my humble opinion. The number of times that I have nuked ext4 or xfs filesystems through no fault of my own is terrifying. A perfect example of this is a CentOS box I set up to serve as a movie NAS / Backup server. It had dual Xeons, ECC ram, the works (It was a box I pulled from my production stack to use for myself). After only 100 days of uptime (spent mostly idle save for streaming a few seasons of cartoons) I decided to patch and reboot, only to have the machine freeze, shit the bed, and become unbootable. The boot/OS partition was completely mangled and unmountable. Thank goodness I had a separate home partition. Another example is my last Ubuntu desktop, after ~30 days of uptime, I returned to my desk to find the screen frozen and unresponsive, and I was unable to drop to shell as the keyboard was unresponsive as well. My only option was a hard reset. Again, thank goodness I had a separate home partition as the other file systems were unmountable. I then had to go through the sphincter clenching process of manually recovering my encrypted home partition. The moral of the story here is, OpenBSD is the most rock solid desktop I’ve ever encountered. The other day I had to sift through hundreds of GB of text with grep/perl on my desktop, and sure as can be, OpenBSD freed my memory appropriately with zero issues. This machine has been up over 40 days, currently has well over 100 Firefox tabs open, regularly has to swap while doing retarded amounts of text processing, file transfers, network I/O and audio/video processing and it doesn’t skip a beat. That’s my 2 cents ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-01-28 07:04 Dammit, I need to remember to join this group, although I'm a Slackware user. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jaypatelani · 2018-01-28 07:05 All are welcome ;) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-01-28 07:05 Did you stick with the stock .fvwm2rc? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2018-01-28 07:08 [deleted] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bonemaster69 · 2018-01-28 07:10 =] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rufwoof · 2018-05-27 12:46 Yes, solely now. Was dual booting Debian and OpenBSD but decided not to upgrade Debian from Jessie to Stretch and reclaimed the disk space to have OpenBSD solely \(baremetal full disk\). For home server \(old celeron single core as a httpd and file server\) \- just OpenBSD base. For desktop, base plus jwm and pcmanfm \(using pcmanfm \-\-desktop for the desktop\). In addition to that firefox\-esr, libreoffice, kdenlive, audacity, vlc as my major application set, along with other smaller programs such as osmo for notes/diary/calendar, mtpaint for image editing ...etc. For me OpenBSD works great as a desktop, rendering kdenlive videos for instance just works, rather than tending to crash under Debian. I install binaries only and use mtier's openup to keep things updated. Three accounts, root \(that I only ever run from cli\), user \- that is a member of wheel and operator groups and beneath which I store all my docs/data, and userid firefox that I use as my usual boot to desktop for browsing ...etc. and that is only a member of its own group and where it can't access files under /home/user, so all my data/docs are secure/isolated from the browser user.