*BSD on laptops reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- guynan · 2016-10-26 10:26 Do many of you use BSD on your laptops or do you use it exclusively on your desktop machines? If the former, how is your experience with it? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazuoKuroi · 2016-10-26 10:32 Used FreeBSD on both. It works well assuming you have the right hardware, I recommend Thinkpads with either Nvidia or Intel cards. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2016-10-26 10:35 I have been using OpenBSD on my laptops since 2003. Right now, my main laptop is a Thinkpad x250. Everything except for bluetooth and the mini-dp port work fine. Many OpenBSD devs have been natively running on our own laptops for many many years, and we've figured out many of the subtle bugs that only exist after long periods of use. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2016-10-26 10:59 Been using OpenBSD on a ThinkPad T60, switched to NetBSD, both run awesome. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- obligatory_bsdpost · 2016-10-26 11:44 Yep, I put my favourite OS on all the hardware I can get my hands on. With NetBSD and a Dell Inspiron n4030, I've had a lot of issues overall. My remaining issues are: Broadcom wifi just wasn't happening (the FreeBSD driver won't do for it either) so I bought a replacement card, and resume makes my touchpad not work. Buying new hardware is always a rough start with some issues, but any fix I've needed was committed - dogfooding works! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DamienCouderc · 2016-10-26 11:48 Hello ! If my memory is good enough i must have used OpenBSD on all my laptops since 2002. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- scratsayshi · 2016-10-26 12:21 Could you please mention the latest models of those laptops? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- earlof711 · 2016-10-26 12:39 What are your preferred tools for managing wifi connections? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2016-10-26 13:29 ifconfig, mg, sh /etc/netstart iwm0 No, I'm not kidding. I have a list of wifi networks I connect to, and comment and un-comment based on where I am. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2016-10-26 13:30 I'm also (very very slowly) working on a solution to automatically select a wifi network if you already know of them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2016-10-26 13:36 I've been running FreeBSD on a laptop for a decade. The first was a Compaq. The latest is a Dell Inspiron 1540(?). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bsd_lore · 2016-10-26 13:46 I am using FreeBSD 11-RELEASE on a Thinkpad w541 with great satisfaction. I use KDE as main DE. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- moviuro · 2016-10-26 14:56 Doesn't `wpa_supplicant(8)` already do that? You'll still have to configure DHCP or static IP given where you are though, but everything has DHCP now (I guess...?) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- obligatory_bsdpost · 2016-10-26 15:23 OpenBSD put WPA in their kernel, and people don't use wpa_supplicant normally. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Zebba_Odirnapal · 2016-10-26 15:43 Once had an old Hitachi laptop, over a decade ago. Had some issues getting OpenBSD to run, which resulted in a one-line kernel tweak (later a patch) thanks to some devs hanging out on IRC. I'm still not a kernel hacker, but it was a pretty neat experience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BumpitySnook · 2016-10-26 15:56 I'm using FreeBSD on a laptop. It's an older ThinkPad X230 (Sandybridge?) so graphics just work. Wifi is 802.11 and just works. No major complaints. FreeBSD's got Haswell graphics support, but nothing newer in-tree yet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zmyrgel · 2016-10-26 17:15 I've run OpenBSD on my laptops. Currently running it on my Thinkpad T430s and it works just fine. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kenmoore134 · 2016-10-26 17:23 I use TrueOS on a bunch of laptops. Mostly Lenovos (T 400 & 500 series, x1 carbons, etc) + a random assortment of netbooks and asus/hp laptops. TrueOS has up through skylake intel support, so most laptops just work in my experience. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LyndonSlewidge · 2016-10-26 19:28 OpenBSD runs on my work laptop. It's been a very enjoyable experience, and I've been using it since OpenBSD 5.6. Almost everything runs beautifully. The only issue I have is that the internal wireless is Broadcom. The bwi driver which leverages bwi- firmware can be spotty, which if you know Broadcom should be completely understandable. Stick to the good wifi chipsets and you'll be golden. For OpenBSD pay attention to supported GPUs as well (there's no binary driver for nVidia on OpenBSD for instance). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- drdaffey · 2016-10-26 23:00 I'm running FreeBSD on an x201 Thinkpad: zfs + geli encryption tripple-booting with Debian and Windows 7. No issues. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kmetadata · 2016-10-26 23:11 I only run it in a VM. I tried running PC-BSD 9.1 on a 2013 Toshiba laptop. It ran like crap, halve the time it did not boot and the times it did it had major issues. Wifi did not work, the resoltuion was wrong, I could not even see any linux partitons and I could not do any networking. IT took hours to load and at one time I had recored it. I would leave at school at 7 and come home at 5 and it would not be done booting off the DVD. It sucked, I have heard it has gotten better, I would only put BSD on a server it is not stable enough for desktop use, let alone a laptop. You will have a better time haveing Haiku work, and unlike PC-BSD it worked. I had no issues with Haiku or React OS. Yet the so called "True OS" could not even do that. If you run it do it with a level one hyperviser, DON'T PUT YOUR DIALY DRIVER AT RISK. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kmetadata · 2016-10-26 23:14 that is like giving a laptop HIV since 2003. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ahhyes · 2016-10-27 00:39 X230 is Ivybridge. I only know that as I've been looking at buying one recently. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jggimi · 2016-10-27 02:07 I've been using OpenBSD on laptops for about 13 years. Many different makes and models. At the moment, I am using a Thinkpad X220 and everything Just Works (tm), including the fingerprint reader. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UnaClocker · 2016-10-27 05:00 OpenBSD is pretty well immune to viruses. Windows is akin to HIV, judging by the number of viruses and malware it has suffered since 2003. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jeremiahs_bullfrog · 2016-10-27 14:01 Last time I used FreeBSD on my laptop, suspend/resume, battery monitoring and changing screen brightness didn't work, and this was with a T-SHIRT series Thinkpad. No dedicated graphics, just an Intel CPU. Any tips on which model works with the above? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazuoKuroi · 2016-10-27 14:14 x230 running 11 worked fine for suspend, battery, and brightness. You will have to do what I did for battery and write a script which probes ACPI on a cron. I don't have the script but it shouldn't be too hard to do. I would avoid running consolekit and GNOME/KDE or some other fatass DE if I were you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jeremiahs_bullfrog · 2016-10-27 16:05 Is your recommendation about GNOME/KDE something specific to FreeBSD or laptops? I typically run GNOME, but I'm comfortable with tiling WMs and may try out Lumina. My last attempt was with FreeBSD 10, so maybe things have improved in the suspend/resume area. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kenmoore134 · 2016-10-27 20:12 You realize PC-BSD 9.1 is ancient history right? TrueOS was originally going to be PC-PSD 11.0, but we changed the name due to all the foundational differences from PC-BSD 10.3. TrueOS is a "very" different system from PC-BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- strngsvlmstng96 · 2016-10-27 21:30 That's how all great programming things start. One line at a time! :D ---------------------------------------------------------------------- strngsvlmstng96 · 2016-10-27 21:31 troll detected ---------------------------------------------------------------------- KazuoKuroi · 2016-10-27 23:56 Bloated DEs have to rely on outdated dependencies since Linux is systemd dependent essentially now, unless you want a broken package manager. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kmetadata · 2016-10-28 16:13 no, it is not.It is PC-BSD with out a GUI. 9.1 is still supported. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kenmoore134 · 2016-10-28 17:22 Wow.... You realize it's not 2013 anymore right? Even PC-BSD 10.3 is reaching it's end-of-life within the next couple months.... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- guidok · 2016-10-29 13:30 I've been researching this (running BSD on a laptop) as well. Gravitating towards either TrueOS or DragonFlyBSD. Both *seem* to have good support for modern Intel processors (Skylake). But shelling out $$$s only to find things not working is somewhat scary. The Dell Precision 5000 series looks okay for running TrueOS or DragonFlyBSD. Love to see it confirmed beforehand though. Anybody experience with recent 5000 models and these BSDs? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2016-10-29 15:41 Thinkpad T-530, bought ~ late 2013 I think. I do have a Linux partition just because "why not".... but for all intents and purposes FreeBSD has become my only system, and I've been happy with it. Suspend/Resume - works perfectly, consistent and reliable. All I had to do was add a line in /etc/sysctl.conf to suspend when the lid is closed. Wireless - I replaced the original Realtek (fucking horrible across the board) with an Intel 6205 Taylor Peak wireless card which works great, using the iwn0 driver. FreeBSD consistently has the best network performance I've ever had on any OS. Intel HD4000 graphics - works fine for my purposes, I really don't know shit about graphics cards though. I use PS4 for games, not this laptop. I don't think it handles some of the stuff required for a full featured gnome-type setup, but I don't really care. You've got all the basics - transparency and basic animations. Touchpad/Trackpoint - good, but not excellent. I can't enable the synaptics driver without losing all functionality with the trackpoint, but using the plain mouse driver with a few tweaks is sufficient. All features work fine, just without some nice touches like coasting. Overall it's great for me. It doesn't have all the turn-key features of Linux, but those "conveniences" come at a high price. 9.9/10. Would recommend. PS: Also, I've been able to find all the software I've wanted or needed in pkg or ports. This is very specific to individual needs, of course. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2016-10-29 15:52 > Many OpenBSD devs have been natively running on our own laptops for many many years, and we've figured out many of the subtle bugs that only exist after long periods of use. And we <3 y'all for this! :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2016-10-29 15:54 LOL Ok, funny. Untrue but +1 anyway. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- tinytimstoothbrush · 2016-10-29 16:00 I've run FreeBSD and OpenBSD on my x230 and both work very well including suspend, wireless etc. etc. OpenBSD probably runs a bit better as I had to do almost no configuration for everything to work. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BtcVersus · 2016-10-29 17:47 Why did you switch? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2016-10-29 18:06 No particular reason, OpenBSD works really well out of the box. I just wanted to see how NetBSD works. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BtcVersus · 2016-10-29 18:39 That is a perfect reason, thank you. :-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2016-10-29 18:49 Enjoy. :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DamienCouderc · 2016-10-29 21:17 I actually use an Asus X73B. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2016-10-30 15:01 Speaking from my own experience, using a 2013 model T530 with Intel 6205 wireless and HD4000 graphics.... Over the last couple of years, support has improved for suspend/resume and touchpad features, which had been my main headaches. On current 11.0 RELEASE both of these things work great. With power monitoring and fn keys, things are always fairly hit-or-miss for me. Admittedly I don't find these all that important, but they are nice to have. **fn keys / buttons:** * Screen brightness adjustment works (fn+F8/F9) * The "mute volume" key works, but the up/down volume adjustment keys don't. * backlight key (fn+spacebar) works. Battery status monitoring with xfce4-power-manager has worked when I've tried, but I don't regularly need or use it. If I need to check the status I use hwstat which can be installed from packages. From what I recall, Intel Ivy Bridge (HD4000) graphics is the most recent card that reliably works. Regarding desktop environments, I generally agree with what /u/KazuoKuroi is saying. You *can* use gnome, but you'll have to manually deal with a lot of things that are designed with Linux in mind. Not impossible or difficult, just not convenient. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MaskedCoward · 2016-10-30 15:09 KDE4? Or do you build Plasma 5? I've been wondering how Plasma 5 is going to fare on FreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- bsd_lore · 2016-10-30 15:53 KDE4. The FreeBSD KDE team is working bringing in Plasma 5, and I'd rather use from packages. I like KDE4 very much and I can wait for Plasma 5. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jeremiahs_bullfrog · 2016-10-30 17:37 Maybe I'll have to give my laptop another shot. Unfortunately, as I use my laptop when away from home, I need the battery indicator and screen to work. I'll check out `hwmon`; if it works, I can shim something together. I've used, and liked, tiling WMs like xMonad and i3, so I'd probably use one of those. As long as I can get graphics acceleration, ^screen brightness, suspend/resume and battery state checking working, I could switch to FreeBSD (I don't need sound and can get a wireless card, etc). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- twattock · 2016-10-31 01:04 Using FreeBSD 10.3 on an old Dell Inspiron as a DLNA server for my children, it's as solid as a rock and the only thing I really have to do with it is add more space... how times change as a kid I got a rental VHS tape from the video shop if I was well behaved! I remember my father accidentally renting me Conan the Barbarian when I was 10, oh lordy my mother wasn't pleased... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- freudDidNOTHINGwrong · 2016-10-31 05:50 What T laptop was it? I have managed to make everything from screen- brightness to nVIDIA Optimus to the audio switching between headphone and speakers to work on a W530, and on a T410 I don't recall needing to do anything at all. Let me know and I am sure I can tackle it. If there is one thing I cannot abide, it is FreeBSD not functioning to top spec on a ThinkPad. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jeremiahs_bullfrog · 2016-10-31 05:54 It was a T430 with upgraded screen, and I tried FreeBSD 10.1 IIRC. I spilled some water on it last year and haven't tried using it since, but I'll dig it out and see if I can get FreeBSD 11 working on it nicely. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- krishna · 2016-10-31 06:40 NetBSD 7 on an older Dell E6230 - 3rd-gen i5, RAM maxed with an SSD. X, wireless, touchpad, sound and suspend/resume all work. Battery life is the only downside (1.5-3 hours depending on the use) but it works for me as a time box.