OpenBSD Passes 300,000 Commits reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pouar · 2014-10-19 20:14 The Linux kernel alone somehow has more commits than all of OpenBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pouar · 2014-10-19 20:17 Although most of the code is optional and can be disabled at compile- time. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- pouar · 2014-10-19 21:58 Not really sure why I'm being downvoted. I'm just pointing out the fact that the Linux kernel is ridiculously huge. Which could be a problem. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- theGeekPirate · 2014-10-20 05:25 Thanks to all the developers who made it happen! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- janizary · 2014-10-20 07:31 I assume it is because it is entirely irrelevant. Like saying, "Linux is more popular than OpenBSD," or, "Linux has more developers than OpenBSD." True, but really has nothing to do with anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2014-10-20 11:31 Because the Linux kernel - at least its repository - is four (?) years older and doesn't have quality management, so there's a lot of "commit, fix for commit, fix for fix for commit" commits. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2014-10-20 11:32 On the interwebz, no one hears your irony. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- oxychromaticdynamite · 2014-10-21 10:00 However the Linux repo is only the Kernel, while the OpenBSD repo is the kernel and the rest of the system and userland etc. Linux has over 400k commits to just the kernel, while OpenBSD's 300k commits are spread between the kernel and everything else. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Athaba · 2014-10-22 17:57 Well a lot of software in OpenBSD too is independently developed and then just updated from one release to another. Also the development style simply changes the amount of commits a lot. I know projects with small codebases having thousands of commits in and others having way less in weeks. That's actually a trend, unrelated to Operating System development if you have smaller contexts that you can go into, either because the project is rather small (functionality/code wise) or because there are lots of tiny individual, independent modules with not so stable APIs there are way more commits. The latter thing is true for Linux in my opinion. It has lots of tiny, many say unneeded things, often things that just happen to be in the code base but could be somewhere else and people change them a lot, because they won't break anything. But even more it's a community thing. There are communities where people commit a lot and ones where people commit mainly big stuff. One last thing is that you simply tend to commit more often when using Git, compared to CVS, which is used by OpenBSD. At least for what I have seen so far. Does anyone have a chart of how Linux commits changed from pre-git era to git era? I'd be really interested.