KFreeBSD port is in danger of being dropped from Debian Jessie reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- nbca · 2014-09-30 12:23 >The factor that gives us greatest concern is the human resources available to the port. If there isn't enough people interested in maintaining the port, it makes a lot of sense to drop it. I don't think the platform ever really got off its feet in the first place, has anyone here used it for anything successfully? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rhabarba · 2014-09-30 12:27 Why not use the original FreeBSD then anyway? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- earlof711 · 2014-09-30 12:52 I have 15 years experience as a Debian user. I now run a nearly exclusively FreeBSD farm. I love both projects. I have 0 interest in mixing them together. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- diyorgasms · 2014-09-30 12:55 I did not realize that this port had so few people working on it. However, I could see the writing on the wall when Debian switched to systemd, since that has its tendrils all in the Linux kernel. I'm not sure how the kFreeBSD team resolved that. Maybe they just stayed on sysvinit? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- byuu · 2014-09-30 13:08 The project always felt like the worst of both worlds, I'd never even considered running it. And Debian's awful handling of systemd just made that all the more certain. BSD was never really suited to distro forks anyway. There's only two ways to start a legitimate BSD in my book: 1) you start from the original 386BSD (that ship sailed two decades ago); or 2) you get kicked out of the core team for your polarizing views and in return spin off your own fork of said distribution. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2014-09-30 13:59 This always felt like a bad idea to me. I'm kind glad to see people have the opportunity to spend their free time in (hopefully) more interesting pursuits. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [deleted] · 2014-09-30 16:31 They both have their advantages and use cases. Mixing them really brings absolutely no benifit either way. I think it's a cool project and am sad to see it go. But really it serves no purpose. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- minimim · 2014-09-30 19:13 Are you referring to the discussion? Or do you have technical concerns about systemd on debian? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fwaggle · 2014-09-30 23:10 I would rather have a Linux kernel with a BSD userland than the other way around, so I've never really seen the point in kFreeBSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- kev009 · 2014-10-01 05:05 This might have been a reasonable tradeoff to manage a userland (especially kFreeBSD jails) for conservative users that can't handle a rolling release. With poudriere and pkgng, it seems less scary these days though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- localtoast · 2014-10-01 11:07 > 2) you get kicked out of the core team for your polarizing views and in return spin off your own fork of said distribution. [fedora tipping intensifies] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- espero · 2014-10-11 19:40 For Science, innovation and corner cases, it's somewhat important. It's already proved to be semi-possible, but I guess it's okay if it needs to go. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- espero · 2014-10-11 19:42 Yeah. I really wish DragonFlyBSD would get some more traction. Anyone tried actually using it for anything? I love reading about it, and I have even developed a little on it, but I don't know if anyone in the real world even knows it exists. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- earlof711 · 2014-10-11 22:36 What does it facilitate that FreeBSD doesn't? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- espero · 2014-10-12 07:24 There was this time when there were software patent murmurs over the Linux kernel... Some of the big software houses were going to sue Linux (not sure who they would target) to Kingdom come. So someone began work swapping out the kernel and got quite far. I think the effort is worthwhile There's always Gentoobsd and archbsd ---------------------------------------------------------------------- iio7 · 2014-10-13 01:25 I have been using Debian for about 20 years, both on servers and desktops. I have been using FreeBSD for about half that. Both systems are fantastic each on its own. kFreeBSD makes little since today, especially with the new and improved pkg tool. Since systemd I am going almost exclusively to FreeBSD and OpenBSD.